News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by grardb on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @05:07AM (#35148922)
Pardon if this is a stupid question, but I think I must be missing something. How is all of this different from turning WiFi off?
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by mrtksn on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @05:29AM (#35149050)
The difference is that it includes the initial installation process too. So the idea is that since online services are deeply embedded into the OS, what happens if you don't have an internet connection?

A few years back there was this issue of MacOS apps launching with a delay because the OS was checking with Appe if you are allowed to use the app. IIRC, this was just a bug.

Also, you won't be able to use iOS without an initial internet connection.

This creates a curiosity on how usable a Mac is without internet. As it turns out, it's pretty usable.

Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by pathartl on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:26AM (#35153025)
> A few years back there was this issue of MacOS apps launching with a delay because the OS was checking with Appe if you are allowed to use the app. IIRC, this was just a bug.

If you're talking about Nov 2021 when Apple's Gatekeeper servers went down, apps weren't just delayed, they were unable to be opened _at all_ unless you blocked DNS requests to the server or completely disabled your internet connection.

I believe the only apps that were allowed to be opened were the built in macOS apps. Why this verification is done on every single load is completely beyond me. After this and the whole iPhone 7 radio debacle I won't be buying their products for a long time.

Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by mrtksn on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:31AM (#35153123)
What’s the iPhone 7 radio debacle?
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by pathartl on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @01:11PM (#35154791)
The iPhone 7 had a flaw in its assembly where the radio IC was not epoxied to the PCB correctly. Overtime due to heat stress the chip would get fractures in its solder joints and the phone would lose the ability to get on cell networks.

I took my 7 to the Apple store in 2019 with this issue after giving it to my SO. I was told by the store rep that it was an issue with "the third party manufacturer" (Qualcomm) but Apple would do the repair for free. I learned from some independent repair communities that this was actually a really common issue and Apple was doing some silent recalls.

Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by less_less on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:44AM (#35153384)
> If you're talking about Nov 2021 when Apple's Gatekeeper servers went down, apps weren't just delayed, they were unable to be opened _at all_ unless you blocked DNS requests to the server or completely disabled your internet connection.

IIRC, Gatekeeper responses are cached for some amount of time for each app, so most people were still able to launch a given app. But yeah, you'd have to disable DNS or internet if you were unlucky and the cache had expired.

Apple's failure inspired me to research compressed CRLs. These don't have the same privacy problems as OCSP, and they work offline. As far as I can tell they would be a good replacement for OCSP here (and also in most cases on the web) but I don't know how one could convince them to roll them out.

Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by lapcat on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:52AM (#35153518)
It was November 2020, and at the time, OCSP responses were only cached for 5 minutes, so most people weren't actually able to launch apps. After the incident, Apple increased the cache period to half a day.
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by pathartl on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @01:14PM (#35154835)
Ah yeah, I had the year off. At the time it knocked out my SO's entire company for a couple of hours.
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by whywhywhywhy on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:42AM (#35153343)
> A few years back there was this issue of MacOS apps launching with a delay because the OS was checking with Appe if you are allowed to use the app. IIRC, this was just a bug

Convinced this is why Spotlight is so janky on iOS lately and you’ll be just staring at a blank list while searching for a local app.

Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by simondotau on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @05:22AM (#35149014)
It isn’t. The how is provided for the sake of reader curiosity; it is ancillary to the analysis performed in this article.
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by personjerry on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @05:42AM (#35149157)
The difference is that this article is an advertisement for the app they're selling.
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by janfoeh on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @05:59AM (#35149292)
That is a pretty accusatory comment, given that the _freeware_ program mentioned is linked for download _right in TFA_.
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by fsflover on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:43AM (#35150562)
Freeware is not the same as free software. You can use the former for a bait and switch.
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by jamesfmilne on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:01AM (#35149303)
They're not selling it, the app is free.
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by favaq on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:57AM (#35149614)
They are not selling it currently. Once they have enough downloads and people who rely on the app on a daily basis, who knows.
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by sharikous on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:36AM (#35149919)
Too cynical. The author is one of the best experts on macOS (on the level of Jonathan Levin) and their utilities are geared towards understanding the OS, not so much as really doing something commercially viable
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by fsflover on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:45AM (#35150580)
If it was free software, you would be right.
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by Sporktacular on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @09:17AM (#35150954)
He is right because it is free.

Maybe not free in the geek bugbear sense, but in the sense that the real world actually uses, especially in a discussion about cost.

Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by fsflover on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:08AM (#35152720)
Windows is also effectively free for, e.g., students. Then, the students are hooked and have to pay for it later (including paying with their private data). Same for some other well-known services from Google.
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by lapcat on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @01:04PM (#35154669)
May I ask, FSF lover, with https://fsf.org in the "about" of your profile, why exactly you're commenting multiple times in a submission specifically about Apple Mac?

To me it feels like you're just evangelizing, with no particular relevance to the subject at hand. Yeah, we get it, Mac is not "free" software as defined by the FSF.

Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by fsflover on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @09:23AM (#35167966)
> we get it

It's not a news to you and, perhaps, many others. However, people saying "He is right because it is free" do not seem to understand the difference between freeware and free software. I did not reply to the article; I replied to one particular comment, which was wrong in my opinion. You can call it "evangelizing" if you want, but knowledge of this difference can (in principle) save one from being trapped in the future.

Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by lapcat on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @09:36AM (#35168121)
> I did not reply to the article; I replied to one particular comment

You replied to two separate comments (not including this one). One of your replies was (rightly) flagged dead.

The entire thread was misconceived. All of the accusations of advertising and bait and switch were completely lacking in evidence or justification. Howard Oakley isn't ever going to "trap" anyone, regardless of whether his software is "free" under your strict definition.

Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by fsflover on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @09:42AM (#35168198)
I did not accuse anyone. I said that it was in principle possible to use freeware as bait and switch.
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by lapcat on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @09:57AM (#35168409)
> I did not accuse anyone.

I didn't say you did. You didn't start the misconceived thread, you just participated in it.

> I said that it was in principle possible to use freeware as bait and switch.

That's completely unhelpful though. We're not talking about "in principle" or "in general". Some commenters here were accusing the article author, Howard Oakley, of using his article for advertising of his software. And you added fuel to that fire.

The "in principle" possibility is irrelevant to this submission unless you're specifically suggesting that Howard would actually do it. And that would amount to a personal accusation.

Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by Sporktacular on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:23PM (#35170696)
I'm aware of both meanings. The discussion was with regard to cost. The software in question is free in that sense, which is the sense that virtually everyone would interpret.

But not FS types, who have had many years to adopt a less ambiguous word to differentiate free as in speech vs. beer. Open, Libre etc. can be used but they insist on trying to unnecessarily reclaim the word. Seemingly just to make a point.

Okay, we get it. But no one cares about the axe you're grinding. You guys need to pick your battles and move on.

Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by saagarjha on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:30AM (#35194932)
> The author is one of the best experts on macOS (on the level of Jonathan Levin)

Jonathan Levin is far more careful about verifying what he writes.

Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by bilekas on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:06AM (#35149680)
This assumes too much and isn't really fair to.
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by franzkappa on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:12AM (#35149718)
Just check the website and you’ll know. The website is well respected in the Mac world and their utilities are free since forever

edit typos

Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by WesolyKubeczek on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:13AM (#35150237)
Dr Oakley is making his software for way too many years for such model to be feasible. Had he been relying for one of his apps to become a unicorn, he’d probably have gone broke by now.

The „business model” you are speculating about is second in its insanity only to making MIT-or-more-permissive open source software with an expectation that a multibillion corporation picking it up for its own use will share profits with the author in a sudden ethic attack.

Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by whywhywhywhy on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:54AM (#35153554)
People are allowed to be paid for their work and no one is forcing you to read the article.
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by lapcat on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:44AM (#35149990)
Absolutely wrong. Howard is a retired doctor. And all of his Mac software (https://eclecticlight.co/downloads/) is free.

Also, Howard has been blogging about the Mac and making free apps available for many years. He's not suddenly going to pivot.

Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by ChrisMarshallNY on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:16AM (#35150260)
Wow. Google Twain "Remove All Doubt".
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by vinaypai on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:55AM (#35150074)
"I turned my WiFi off and nothing surprising happened" wouldn't make it to the front page of HN.
Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by lapcat on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:43AM (#35150554)
The author blogs almost every day about the Mac on his years-old Mac-oriented blog. The author doesn't write for HN readers, nor did he submit his blog post to HN.

Why do the worst HN comments always rise to the top?

Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by joshuaissac on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:51AM (#35150660)
> The author doesn't write for HN readers, nor did he submit his blog post to HN.

It does not follow from the GP comment's claim that the author must be writing for HN readers. There may be many articles written by many people about how the Mac works without a network connection, but this one happened to be the one to be posted to HN and make it to the front page because it has traits that are in line with what HN wants to read.

Re:Using a Mac without a network connection by lapcat on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:57AM (#35150727)
> It does not follow from the GP comment's claim that the author must be writing for HN readers.

It seemed clear to me that the comment was a snide remark suggesting that the article was clickbait. Much like some of the other snide remarks on this submission, such as the sibling comment "The difference is that this article is an advertisement for the app they're selling." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35149157