News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by cs702 on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:22PM (#35137900)
Everyone now knows that SVB's depositors will be bailed out by the federal government, but SVB's shareholders will not. Given that SVB's losses exceed its equity capital, it's likely that SVB shareholders will get... nothing. By implication, the common stock of all other banks in a similar situation are also worth... nothing.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by spywaregorilla on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:33PM (#35138096)
Why would there be a run on other banks if depositors are confident they'll be protected though?
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by vsareto on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:38PM (#35138185)
Baseless speculation, but I wouldn't be surprised if some withdrawals are just moving money around to spread risk. High confidence, but high withdrawals?
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by danielmarkbruce on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:43PM (#35139434)
Lots of people are doing exactly this.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by postalrat on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:38PM (#35138203)
Whats the upside for the risk, no matter how small?
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by readthenotes1 on Monday March 13, 2023 @04:52PM (#35142394)
alleviating the risk in having to manage piddling amounts of money in multiple Banks.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by tempsy on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:36PM (#35138160)
a “run” can simply be a wake up call to wealthy people with hundreds of thousands or millions in some 0% earning checking account to funnel that money into a money market or t-bills earnings 4-5%.

that would alone create some outflow even if the reason is not panic

Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by jliptzin on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:59PM (#35138603)
I happened to check what my citibank savings account pays these days...0.12% interest. Not that I keep any significant amount of money there, anyway. I would if they would pay remotely close to competitive interest rates, but I guess they're banking on most people being too dumb to realize that they can get 4-5% more on their money if they take 5 min to open an account elsewhere.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by kortilla on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:12PM (#35138859)
Some banks are even offering the better rate if you open a different account with the same bank. They are definitely depending on people not noticing.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by garyfirestorm on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:07PM (#35138761)
Couple of weeks ago I opened a Citi High Yield Savings account ~3.5% interest rate. Took less than 30 seconds to open the account.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by hypothesis on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:06PM (#35138732)
Might as well buy treasuries with higher rates and tax benefits. Should not take much longer to setup…
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by jaywalk on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:31PM (#35139205)
I have a checking account that pays 0.1% APY. Savings account is at 3.6% APY. You are getting screwed.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by arbuge on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:30PM (#35139197)
That dynamic, known as cash sorting, had already been going on for several months, and appeared to be stabilizing.

If anything, I think the events of the last few days could reduce it somewhat. Better to have your funds safe earning little in a Big 4 bank than somewhere else with higher rates but now perceived to be risky.

Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by tempsy on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:46PM (#35139495)
no bank is safer than lending directly to the US government at higher rates than what they can offer
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by arbuge on Monday March 13, 2023 @02:36PM (#35140336)
It's an alternative but that doesn't give you all the flexibility and features a bank account does.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by vkou on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:43PM (#35138293)
There doesn't need to be a run, a bank will be closed by FDIC if it is insolvent.

And in SVB's case, a very small amount of withdrawals was enough to trigger insolvency. (As it forced the bank to sell, and thereby mark-to-market it's long-term treasuries.)

Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by biscottigelato on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:11PM (#35138836)
SVB had $45B withdrawals on their $175B deposit base. That is not a small amount of withdrawals.

JPM has $500B of cash and cash equivalents on their $3T deposit base. Of which only ~$34B is in actual cash. Even JPM would fall (without Fed backstop) if JPM had that much withdrawals as a percentage of deposit.

Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by vkou on Monday March 13, 2023 @02:22PM (#35140102)
> SVB had $45B withdrawals on their $175B deposit base. That is not a small amount of withdrawals.

Almost all of those withdrawals happened after the bank was insolvent.

SVB had to sell all of their available securities to cover day-to-day customer withdrawals (The problem with being the bank of choice for startups is that they aren't making any money, aren't getting any new investments, but are still spending money.)

The bank run started after SVB started dipping into its underwater long-term securities, and borrowing money, and doing emergency fundraising.

A more diversified bank (Like any of the big four) would avoid this problem, because their regular day-to-day activity would be a ~net-zero balance of withdrawals and deposits. SVB was uniquely vulnerable because of its undiversified customer base, where normal customer activity pushed it towards insolvency.

Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by notch898a on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:50PM (#35138435)
FDIC only has a reserve ratio of under 2%.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by downrightmike on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:55PM (#35138531)
Why wait for something to get given back when you can take it back right now? Dealing with insurance is always a bitch, especially if they have to pay. They'll drag it out years.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by lxgr on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:59PM (#35138606)
The entire point of FDIC and similar insurances is to make insured funds available within days.

If depositors could/had to wait years, there wouldn‘t be a need for insurance anymore in this case.

Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by rcme on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:06PM (#35138734)
I think the point still stands: why keep your money in a bank known to be insolvent? What is the upside? Especially if you already have an account at a bigger bank.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by credit_guy on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:14PM (#35138887)
Not a lot of upside, but on the other hand you don't have to deal with all the hassle to switch banks. Even as a private person, I don't relish the idea of switching my bank. I have quite a number of autopayments set up. My salary also goes automatically in my bank account. If I switch it would take me days to set up everything again. I imagine a small/medium company would go through this, but times 100. If you are short on manpower (and who isn't nowadays?), then you have better things to do.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by behrlich on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:21PM (#35139009)
The upside is that the bank you keep your money in doesn’t go out of business. Why keep your money there in the first place if you don’t get some kind of service you like from the bank?

I feel the exact opposite as you. Now that essentially 100% of deposits are guaranteed indefinitely, there is only downside to withdrawing.

Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by luckylion on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:16PM (#35138923)
For the same reason people went to SVB in the first place: better deals. JP Morgan won't give you the same below-market home-financing deals in return for you working with them exclusively at your startup.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by herpderperator on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:05PM (#35138729)
If it were your hard-earned money saved up over the course of years or decades, would you risk seeing if the theory works in practice?
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by notch898a on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:06PM (#35138733)
It's not clear what was meant by "other banks" above. If "other banks" means a large percentage of all of them, the FDIC doesn't have the cash on hand. Sure there may be appropriations from somewhere else, but that could take awhile.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by jastanton on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:24PM (#35137943)
I'm not very financially literate. How does SVB shareholders getting nothing translate to shareholders of all other banks being in the same situation?
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by nickvanw on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:27PM (#35137999)
SVB shares are worth $0 because there was a run on the bank and the US Government did not step in to save the bank, only the depositors.

If the same thing happens to other banks - everyone withdraws, they shut down and the government steps in - the assumption is that their equity will eventually be worth $0 too. So, everyone sells at >$0.

It's not going to be all banks, though.

Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by realce on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:47PM (#35138366)
I see it as a haircut for newly discovered risk
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by mullingitover on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:11PM (#35138833)
> SVB shares are worth $0 because there was a run on the bank and the US Government did not step in to save the bank, only the depositors.

And there was a bank run because the investors panicked and caused the share price to plummet. Depositors saw stock plummeting, got nervous and pulled out. If this type of thing spreads to other banks we'll have a bad time.

Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by disgruntledphd2 on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:28PM (#35139145)
Hence, the US government stepping in to ensure both depositors are made whole, and (more importantly) saying that the banks can redeem their underwater treasury bills at par (up to some limit under some circumstances obviously).
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by mullingitover on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:38PM (#35139340)
Hopefully this isn't too little, too late. There are already a few regional banks with share prices getting hammered in the market this morning regardless of the intervention.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by dragonwriter on Monday March 13, 2023 @05:37PM (#35143161)
> SVB shares are worth $0 because there was a run on the bank and the US Government did not step in to save the bank, only the depositors.

It also simultaneously stepped in to preemptively save similarly-situated [0] banks, though.

[0] to the condition SVB was in which led ultimately to the bank run.

Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by cs702 on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:26PM (#35137990)
You misread my comment: I mean all other banks that happen to be (i.e., put themselves) in the same situation.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by nevir on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:24PM (#35137932)
...and if they demonstrate less risky behavior, their stock should (hopefully) become valuable again.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by nostromo on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:32PM (#35138082)
SVB definitely mismanaged risk.

But I don’t think people realize that no bank could have 25% (and counting) of deposits withdrawn in a day and survive.

If they had still been allowing withdrawals on Friday that number would be much much higher.

Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by partiallypro on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:24PM (#35137938)
Most community banks aren't in a similar situation though. This is mostly caused by panic, not reality. If people didn't panic about SVB eating a loss, even it wouldn't have likely failed. Now people are not using logic and causing panic across the board. Mostly caused by VC tech bros going around stirring up things in a hope to get a bailout. That's why the Fed/Treasury/FDIC stepped in this morning to hopefully instill confidence.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by newsclues on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:30PM (#35138043)
"Most community banks aren't in a similar situation though. This is mostly caused by panic, not reality." Nothing prevents panic from overriding reality at other banks.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by partiallypro on Monday March 13, 2023 @12:49PM (#35138410)
Of course, but the underlying books aren't the same, the SVB problem was fairly unique. Once the panic is over, most all other regional banks will be fine. The only way they will fail is if the mob creates additional panic for either a false perception or a political gain (bailout.) That's basically what happened on Friday.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by ImHereToVote on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:26PM (#35139107)
Isn't the fact that people are panicking part of the reality of the situation? Or do we exclude human behaviour from financial calculations. Am I stupid for predicting other people will panic?
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by mellosouls on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:04PM (#35138699)
This is mostly caused by panic, not reality. If people didn't panic about SVB eating a loss, even it wouldn't have likely failed

That's not "reality" though. The phenomenon of people "panicking" (ie acting sensibly when their savings are at risk and getting them out while they still can) is a fundamental part of the crisis-process of any bank when it is badly managed.

Saying "well if people just ignored history and group psychology and hope nothing bad will happen and risk all their savings by doing nothing, then nothing bad will happen" just isn't remotely realistic.

Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by Msw242 on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:28PM (#35139157)
They just want to blame the users
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by JumpCrisscross on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:25PM (#35139090)
> people didn't panic about SVB eating a loss, even it wouldn't have likely failed

Silvergate, SVB and Signature were insolvent. This wasn't a fire sale prompting a decline in their asset values, i.e. classic illiquidity. It was their assets being worth less than their liabilities. If it were purely a liquidity issue, they could have borrowed at the Fed's discount window. (As First Republic appears to be doing.)

Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by danielvf on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:29PM (#35139177)
SVB was literally insolvent though. Not only that, but they couldn't put together a rescue stock sale - it fell through. This was not a bank run caused by panic, but a run caused by an already failed, insolvent institution.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by maxerickson on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:06PM (#35138744)
Seems like there won't be that many banks with such large average account sizes (which is probably one component of being in a similar situation). First Republic touts their large average account sizes though.
Re:Plunge in Regional Bank Stocks Triggers Spate of Trading ... by sanderjd on Monday March 13, 2023 @01:26PM (#35139119)
But one of the new facilities announced yesterday is designed to keep that from happening to the other banks... If they have this liquidity problem due to long-term bonds, they can now turn those into cash for a year without paying interest.