News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yellen says government will help SVB depositors but rules... by mrcwinn on Sunday March 12, 2023 @09:55AM (#35120047)
Good. Investors like Ackman and Cuban seem so concerned about payroll for tech workers.

The truth is that the vast majority of this cash was dry powder for acquisitions, staying liquid for new new investments, fresh VC money for advertising.

Isn’t it these same folks who remind us all the time that most startups fail? Why bail out an entire bank when 99% of its startup depositors wouldn’t have made it anyway?

If anything, taxpayers should be able to sit at the front of a new cap table with preferred position, like any other entity providing a bridge. But at that idea, I am sure they’d warn of government interference.

Re:Yellen says government will help SVB depositors but rules... by nipponese on Sunday March 12, 2023 @10:40AM (#35120559)
I guess that’s true if you are a Roku or a Roblox, but how can you say that about sub-50 person company still trying to find its footing?
Re:Yellen says government will help SVB depositors but rules... by lotsofpulp on Sunday March 12, 2023 @10:48AM (#35120646)
The same thing people tell 22 year olds trying to find their footing who invested in the wrong degree.
Re:Yellen says government will help SVB depositors but rules... by nipponese on Sunday March 12, 2023 @11:10AM (#35120933)
Depositing money in a bank is not supposed to be an investment with associated risk.

Yes there may be an interest yield and services rendered, but these customers were not greedily looking for a sizable return.

Re:Yellen says government will help SVB depositors but rules... by ffggffggj on Sunday March 12, 2023 @11:19AM (#35121071)
There are literally stickers on the doors of every bank explaining that depositing money beyond $250,000 incurs risk.

These naive smol bean founders don’t struggle to figure out the most tax advantageous way to get paid, let’s not pretend they’re too stupid to read a huge sticker.

Re:Yellen says government will help SVB depositors but rules... by nipponese on Sunday March 12, 2023 @12:13PM (#35121912)
You're not wrong, but the purpose of "moral hazard" is to punish risky investments.

What are you trying to punish here? Founders who didn't want to waste time messing around with multiple banks?

Re:Yellen says government will help SVB depositors but rules... by ffggffggj on Sunday March 12, 2023 @12:29PM (#35122148)
The VCs who advised them to behave this way, if you ask me. In my ideal resolution, the government does their own valuation of the startups, rescues in excess of insurance the ones that seem promising, and proportionally takes the VC equity in these companies that got special rescue consideration. If the investment is getting bailed out, the VCs who started this mess shouldn’t get their equity returns. They can invest again in the next round if they really believe their convictions.

Practically, the VCs should have made some bridge loans to solve the short term problems while we wait to see what comes out of receivership. Some did, and good on them for sticking with it in the hard times.

Re:Yellen says government will help SVB depositors but rules... by nipponese on Sunday March 12, 2023 @01:37PM (#35123285)
Interesting perspective, but the flip side is you're rewarding VC who encouraged the run on the bank.
Re:Yellen says government will help SVB depositors but rules... by rolldat777 on Sunday March 12, 2023 @07:53PM (#35128403)
All investments have risk. This is one of the risks associated with meager yields - very rare but possible wipe out. If depositors were always guaranteed then what would prevent high-risk banks that promise huge yields but ultimately just rely on govt backstopping when they go under. Who pays the cost in that case? Even 'guaranteed' investments like cash or treasuries are not guaranteed, there are failure modes.
Re:Yellen says government will help SVB depositors but rules... by lotsofpulp on Sunday March 12, 2023 @11:19AM (#35121082)
> Depositing money in a bank is not supposed to be an investment with associated risk.

Says who? Why do all the signs in a bank specify $250k then?

What if the 22 year olds also thought that when they borrowed money to get their degree?

Re:Yellen says government will help SVB depositors but rules... by berkle4455 on Sunday March 12, 2023 @11:23AM (#35121123)
Roblox has $150M at SVB out of their $3000M cash position. They’re completely fine.
Re:Yellen says government will help SVB depositors but rules... by chipgap98 on Sunday March 12, 2023 @10:08AM (#35120195)
> The truth is that the vast majority of this cash was dry powder for acquisitions, staying liquid for new new investments, fresh VC money for advertising

Any sources for this? This seems like an opinion with nothing backing it up.

> Isn’t it these same folks who remind us all the time that most startups fail?

There is a big difference between a single startup being able to fail at any time and many of them failing all at once.

Re:Yellen says government will help SVB depositors but rules... by colinmorelli on Sunday March 12, 2023 @05:49PM (#35126728)
There's also a big difference between a startup failing because it doesn't deliver a product that people want and will pay for, and a startup failing because of "random chance" (in quotes because I can't prove that bank choice is a random distribution among startups, but it's not clear that it's a proxy for quality of founder or company)
Re:Yellen says government will help SVB depositors but rules... by skwirl on Sunday March 12, 2023 @10:14AM (#35120281)
> Investors like Ackman and Cuban seem so concerned about payroll for tech workers.

They weren’t calling for a bailout of SVB. They were calling for protection of depositors, which is what Yellen is trying to make happen.

Re:Yellen says government will help SVB depositors but rules... by aodin on Sunday March 12, 2023 @11:28AM (#35121192)
Both Ackman and Cuban have called for measures beyond "protection of depositors".

Ackman: "What should the FDIC do? @FDICgov to guarantee all bank deposits by Sunday night before Asia open and call a time out. Run a process to recapitalize @SVB_Financial while managing liquidation of UST and MBS portfolios ... Equity holders pre-recap are wiped out, bond holders are protected." [1]

Cuban: "The Fed should IMMEDIATELY buy all the securities/debt the bank owns at near par, which should be enough to cover most deposits. Any losses paid for in equity and new debt from the new bank or whoever buys it. The Fed knew this was a risk. They should own it" [2]

In a following tweet, Cuban claimed "this isn't a bailout" [3]. Their tweets, like many of the comments here, seem to be arguing the semantics of a "bailout". However, both Ackman and Cuban are calling for financial assistance from the Fed, which is absolutely a bailout, if only "partial".

[1] https://twitter.com/BillAckman/status/1634694924707807236

[2] https://twitter.com/mcuban/status/1634416692301373442

[3] https://twitter.com/mcuban/status/1634418925331968007

Re:Yellen says government will help SVB depositors but rules... by mgfist on Sunday March 12, 2023 @10:02AM (#35120131)
> Good. Investors like Ackman and Cuban seem so concerned about payroll for tech workers.

? The truth is that the vast majority of this cash was dry powder for acquisitions, staying liquid for new new investments, fresh VC money for advertising.

You seem confused. The "cash" you're talking about here is the deposited cash, which Yellen is saying will get funded. I think you're confusing that with bank equity.

Re:Yellen says government will help SVB depositors but rules... by SkyPuncher on Sunday March 12, 2023 @10:09AM (#35120207)
Cash flow is currently the issue for many businesses.

They literally cannot afford to pay people on Monday if their deposits are not returned.