Some don't, but a phone does.
Google has purged 32-bit apps from the official Android app store, but as I understand it the Chinese OEMs that ship un-Googled AOSP ROMs with their own app stores haven't been as aggressive about moving to 64-bit.
M1 has 16 billion of them
AMD is below 10 billion
it's not that expensive
it's a tradeoff, you lose something there, you gain somewhere else.
x86 has a more complex decoder exactly because it was less powerful and had to save on computing power and energy consumption, not being a mainframe.
First of all, when you downclock anything, you're going to gain efficiency. If Apple downclocks M1, it can get even more efficient.
Second, most of these tests use Cinebench, which is highly optimized for x86, not ARM instructions. Geekbench should be used instead.
Third, the M1 is a SoC. Everything is on it. Everything is efficiently connected directly inside the chip.
AMD’s latest parts are actually quite close to M1/M2 in computing efficiency when clocked down to more conservative power targets.
They crank the power consumption of their desktop CPUs deep into the diminishing returns region because benchmarks sell desktop chips. You can go into the BIOS and set a considerably lower TDP limit and barely lose much performance.
Where they struggle is in idle power. The chiplet design has been great for yields but it consumes a lot of baseline power at idle. M1/M2 have extremely efficient integration and can idle at negligible power levels, which is great for laptop battery life.
At any rate, using single points to compare energy efficiency isn't a good comparison, unless either the performance or power consumption of the data points comparable. Like, the M1's little cores are 3-5x even more efficient when operating in an incomparable power class, and Apple's own marketing graphs show the M1's max efficiency is also well below its max performance [1]
Those perf/power curves are the basis of actually useful comparisons; has anyone plotted some outside of marketing materials? It might even be possible under Asahi.
[1] https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2021/10/introducing-m1-pro-an...
I can’t be bothered to chase down an actual comparison, but usually you’ll see something along those lines if you compare the benchmarks for the top tier chip with a slightly lower tier 65w equivalent.
Below 100w it’s more linear, but that might depend on undercoating and the like as well.
Every notebookcheck.net review. For example https://www.notebookcheck.net/AMD-Ryzen-7-6800U-Efficiency-R...
They also do the same to a lot more laptops they test.
Look at the multi-core results, Zen3+ comes pretty close.
Also the single thread result shows what GP said: AMD CPU drains too much power at idle.
See more: https://www.reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/pitid6/eli5_why_d...
Albeit for later releases this is less true since most customers have switched to GPUs...
It doesn't. As far as I know, everything is translated from x86 to ARM instructions - not direct ARM optimization.
Cinema4D is a niche software within a niche. Even Cinema4D users don't typically use CPU renderer. They use the GPU renderer.
The reason Cinebench became so popular is because AMD and Intel promote it heavily in their marketing to get nerds to buy high core count CPUs that they don't need.
What should I be buying to not have to ask myself that question?
idle means the computer is turned on, a Mac on idle consumes less power than an x86 on idle, they both consume ~zero in deep sleep.
We just stare at an article in a web browser. We look at a text document. We type a bit in the document. An app is doing an HTTP request. The CPU is doing nothing basically.
Once in a while it has to redraw something, do some intense processing of an image or text, but it takes seconds.
It's the 99% in idling that counts and there most laptop CPU's suck.
Even when watching a video the CPU is not (should not be) doing much as there are HW co-processors for MPEG-4 decoding built in.
It's quite embarrassing how AMD and Intel have screwed up honestly.
ASUS UL30A-X5
Really an excellent computer, ran linux great (games didn't really exist yet though), and with tuning was coming in under 10W if the display brightness was turned down. First time I was able to get through flights without the system running dead.
I think in this case what's going on is that temperature rises increase resistance in a chip and therefore cause lower efficiency. If you can keep it cool, you can keep it more efficient. The move seems like a necessary one, a computer as powerful as that UL30A is probably inside the phone if you turn off the radio and display, that thing still had a giant battery and only lasted 10-12 hours.
I've seen AMD do some pretty impressive things, I wouldn't count them out. They're at least willing to attempt to compete on price.
The benefit of ARM is scale of multitasking due to not requiring the same kind of lock states that Intel's architecture requires, and can additionally scale much better than only one physical+virtual core pair.
I guess the only thing that's holding back ARM is Microsoft, as laptops are expected to run an desktop OS that people are comfortable with. Windows RT wasn't really a serious desktop OS and rather a joke made only for some IoT enterprises instead of end-users.
I wish there was more serious hardware than the standard broadcom or MediaTek chips, I'd definitely want some of that...be it as a mini ATX desktop/server format (e.g. as a competitor to Intel NUC or Mac Mini) or as a laptop.
With the ongoing energy crisis something like solar powered servers would be so much more feasible than with x86 hardware.
The high power ARM cores aren’t that small. If you took the M2 and scaled it up to 256 cores, it would be almost 7 square inches. You can’t just scale a chip like that, though, so the interconnects would consume a huge amount of space as well. It would also consume over 1000W.
The latest ARM chips are great, but some times I think the perception has shifted too far past the reality.
The actual cores are about .6/2.3 mm², and local interconnects and L2 roughly double that.
So with just those parts, 256 P-cores would be about 1.5 square inches, and 256 E-cores would be about half a square inch. And in practical terms you can fabricate a die that's a bit more than a square inch.
Of course it wouldn't use 1000 watts. When you light up that many cores at once you use them at lower power. And I doubt a 256 core design would have all that many P cores either.
As a rough estimate, you could take the 120mm² M1 chip, add 28 more P-cores with 110mm², 220 more E-cores with 300mm², 128 more MB of L3 cache with 60mm², 100mm² of miscellaneous interconnects, and still be on par with a high end GPU.
That sounds doable but is pushing it. A 128 core die, though, has nothing stopping it except market fit.
And the memory controllers aren't that big on the die. You could include a bunch more on a 128 core model.
Source: https://www.anandtech.com/show/16979/the-ampere-altra-max-re...
It's not Microsoft holding it back. It's Qualcomm.
Apart from their very latest SOC (designed by a bunch of ex-Apple employees, no less) their CPUs have are significantly worse than x86 in terms of general performance and have persistently lagged 4 years behind Apple in terms of performance (3 years behind x86). They sell for the same price per unit as x86 CPUs do, so there aren't very many OEMs that take them up on the offer given the added expense of having to design a completely different mainboard for a particular chassis.
As such, x86 is the only game in town if you're buying a non-Apple machine; Qualcomm's products aren't cheaper and perform much worse outside of having more batter life. Sure, Qualcomm owns Nuvia now, but that acquisition will still take some time to bear fruit.
It might be a very long time considering Arm is suing to get Qualcomm to destroy Nuvia's work.
I have no idea what you mean by this. The only x86 feature I can think of that might qualify as a 'lock state' is a bus lock that happens when an atomic read-modify-write operation is split over two cache lines. That has a very simple solution ('don't do that'--you have no reason to), and anyway, one can imagine more efficient implementation strategies
> can additionally scale much better than only one physical+virtual core pair
I have no idea what you mean by this either. Wider hyperthreading? It can be worthwhile for some workloads (and e.g. some ibm cpus have 4-way hyperthreading), but is not a panacea; there are tradeoffs involved.
Let's get real here, most things can't be parallelised at all. We must strive for better single core performance.
These days I only see a single core loaded up to 100% when I grep through a big directory or when I encounter a bug in some software.
Most of the time, it's either all cores are equally idling or equally doing something heavy (like building a big project).
That’s a bold statement as I type all day on an M1 Mac. My FT100 company just made the leap to them as dev machines.
Your comment was beyond ignorant, and wrong. Most folks here are too smart, or busy, to reply to such nonsense. I am neither.
ARM is by far the most shipped and used arch every year. AMZ is even going in heavier on it. It's not legacy tech at all. So a person decided to show you how wrong you were, by listing what's probably the most impressive chip in all of our lifetimes, and it's guess what, ARM.
> Obviously I was referring to Linux/Windows workstations
The creator of Linux is using an ARM machine as a workstation today, AFAIK.
> if everyone was smart enough to pick up on that I wouldn't be paid as much as I am
If you're making more than a burger flipper at Wendy's, the world just isn't fair.
Because if the long tail of the hardware industry, the writing can be on the wall long before it's clear based on what you can go out and buy off a shelf today.
As an aside, ARM has always been a hybrid CISC/RISC core. It has nothing to do with the number of instructions, but the fact that not having an I$ on the ARM1 forced it to have microcoded instructions to mainly to support LDM/STM. That's not a dig at ARM. It's a valid design; particularly at that gate count.
Sounds more apocalyptic than exaggerated tbh.
I still don’t know why you think this is necessary.
I believe you're trying to move goalposts to avoid admitting you're wrong.
Do you have any information that Microsoft is planning to support RISC-V at least as well as x86/x64? (That is to say, not with something like Windows RT, or Windows CE)
That would be tremendously good news, I shall add.
What you really mean is Arm isn’t the hot new thing anymore. Well it hasn’t been that for 20 years. Meanwhile billions of arm devices in leading edge nodes are being shipped. Oh well.
citation needed
https://www.theregister.com/2023/02/08/5_percent_cloud_arm/
"5% of the cloud now runs on Arm as chip designer plans 2023 IPO"
5% does not seems to me as a position that you want to change to something else.
ARM in every day computing outside of mobile phones and SBCs is just getting started as I see it.
I hope this never comes to pass, because a RISC-V future is a Chinese future.
A Chinese future will not be kind to western ideals that most of us hold dear.
Now, yes, China will just espionage and kangaroo court their way through and around such legalities anyway, but nonetheless RISC-V is less effort for more reward for China if it becomes at least on par with x86 and ARM.
Put more basically, it's a matter of national security. China can have an entire RISC-V ecosystem indigenously, unlike x86 and ARM.
RISC-V by contrast is much, much harder for any given country to regulate because of its free and open nature. At most the US and UK can embargo individual developments made within their jurisdictions, but they can't regulate the entire architecture. RISC-V doesn't have a kill switch named Intel/AMD or ARM.
https://www.reuters.com/technology/arm-china-says-its-ousted...
Though the rp2040 has largely ended my cheap risc-v addiction
Most, if not all SemiCoductor “folks” I know are very pragmatic. As in how a Real Engineer should be, unlike software engineers. And in my experience, only HN and the Internet are suggesting ARM is dead. Everything will be RISC-V.
It's getting traction coz chip companies don't want to pay ARM for licensing, not because it is particularly better at something.
30 Years ago I don't think the compute power of a modern phone chip was available at any price, even in super computers.
On a tangential note, there are economists who think this increase in compute is somehow an increase in one of their measures - I don't recall which one. I disagree, because with that logic we all have trillion dollar tech in our pocket. Making a better product over time is expected, it's not some kind of increase in output.
It's an Apples to ThinkingMachine Oranges comparison but CPU-Benchmark[1] ranks the Apple A16 Bionic used in the latest iPhones, its GPU - in the "iGPU - FP32 Performance (Single-precision GFLOPS)" section - at 2000 GFlop/s.
GadgetVersus[3] reports a GeekBench score of the A16 Bionic at 279.8 GFlop/s. - SGEMM test of matrix multiplication, it seems.
AnandTech[4] was reporting the A15 architecture ARMv7 came in at 6.1 GFlops in the "GeekBench 3 - Floating Point Performance" table, SGEMM MT test result, in 2015.
[1] https://www.top500.org/lists/top500/1993/06/
[2] https://cpu-benchmark.org/cpu/apple-a16-bionic/
[3] https://gadgetversus.com/processor/apple-a15-bionic-gflops-p...
[4] https://www.anandtech.com/show/8718/the-samsung-galaxy-note-...
The amount of processing power available in a modern smartphone is truly mind-boggling. I'd love to see a chart showing the chip cost and energy cost of the power on an M1 chip in each previou syear. I would guess that 30+ years ago you'd be in the millions of dollars and watts of power but that's just a guess.
As we see from the modern M1/M2 Macbooks, these lower TDP SoCs are more than capable of running a computer for most people for most things. The need for an Intel or AMD CPU is shrinking. It's still there and very real but the waters are rising.