News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by BlueTankEngine on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:07AM (#34892220)
In my experience talking to semiconductors folks, ARM is just not a concern anymore. The future is RISC-V, and ARM is already being seen as legacy tech. ARM's progress in the server space has stalled, the ARM Windows ecosystem is dead, Android has laid the groundwork for a move to RISC-V, and ARM has never and will never touch the desktop market.
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by pnpnp on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:10AM (#34892242)
> ARM has never and will never touch the desktop market

That’s a bold statement as I type all day on an M1 Mac. My FT100 company just made the leap to them as dev machines.

Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by r00fus on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:15AM (#34892274)
My company has entire teams and regions that do NOT buy PCs and only Mac laptop for employees. Started with the M-series.
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by feanaro on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @04:40AM (#34893536)
I think you mean "Do not buy Windows computers". Macs are also PCs.
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by 314 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @07:27AM (#34894546)
To be fair that whole boat sailed with the "I'm a mac he is PC" series of adverts.
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by feanaro on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @05:15PM (#34903722)
Ah, I'm not in the US so I avoided those ads.
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by BlueTankEngine on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:49AM (#34892481)
It proves my point beautifully when the only response to my comment is someone saying "bUt DonT YoU KNow M1 Mac CoMeS IN DESKTOP FORMAT, I'm very intelligent." Obviously I was referring to Linux/Windows workstations, but if everyone was smart enough to pick up on that I wouldn't be paid as much as I am :(
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by silisili on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @02:31AM (#34892735)
> It proves my point beautifully when the only response to my comment

Your comment was beyond ignorant, and wrong. Most folks here are too smart, or busy, to reply to such nonsense. I am neither.

ARM is by far the most shipped and used arch every year. AMZ is even going in heavier on it. It's not legacy tech at all. So a person decided to show you how wrong you were, by listing what's probably the most impressive chip in all of our lifetimes, and it's guess what, ARM.

> Obviously I was referring to Linux/Windows workstations

The creator of Linux is using an ARM machine as a workstation today, AFAIK.

> if everyone was smart enough to pick up on that I wouldn't be paid as much as I am

If you're making more than a burger flipper at Wendy's, the world just isn't fair.

Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by ksec on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @03:55AM (#34893259)
The unwritten rule of HN: You do not criticise The Rusted Holy Grail and the Riscy Silver Bullet.
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by 314 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @07:28AM (#34894557)
ssshhhhhh, the Rust Evangelism Squad will hear you.
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by monocasa on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @04:18AM (#34893404)
The one viable server ARM CPU core is now tied up in a Qualcomm-ARM legal spat and probably won't see the light of day and made it pretty clear to anyone not grandfathered in like Apple that it's not worth designing your own ARM core. ARM itself has been hemorrhaging employees both because of better offers from Apple and the RISC-V stealths, and because since the SoftBank push to get their money back has simply been a worse and worse place to work. Their ability to execute is extremely compromised.

Because if the long tail of the hardware industry, the writing can be on the wall long before it's clear based on what you can go out and buy off a shelf today.

Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by klelatti on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @05:26AM (#34893823)
I get it that you want RISC-V to succeed - so do I - and to advocate for it but I really don’t understand why it needs this sort of comment about Arm. I see exaggerated criticism of the Arm ISA elsewhere from people who ought to know better too - it’s really CISC, it’s 5000 pages vs 2 for RISC-V etc. It’s just not necessary.
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by monocasa on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @06:48AM (#34894322)
I mean, nothing I said is exaggerated here. ARM doesn't even have a viable server core that can compete with x86 even as vaporware. SoftBank ruins everything they touch, and is super focused at the moment on stealing from Peter to pay Paul to get something out of the upcoming ARM IPO since their attempt to sell it off to Nvidia fell through. The rumor is they've been cutting R&D funding hard to get temporarily boost profitability. If anything this is more a dig at how vulture capitalism ruins productive companies.

As an aside, ARM has always been a hybrid CISC/RISC core. It has nothing to do with the number of instructions, but the fact that not having an I$ on the ARM1 forced it to have microcoded instructions to mainly to support LDM/STM. That's not a dig at ARM. It's a valid design; particularly at that gate count.

Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by klelatti on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @10:45AM (#34897372)
You jumped in in support of a comment that said Arm is ‘legacy’ tech. You said they don’t ‘even have a viable server core’. They are ‘haemorrhaging’ staff. Softbank have ‘ruined’ them.

Sounds more apocalyptic than exaggerated tbh.

I still don’t know why you think this is necessary.

Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by monocasa on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @02:03PM (#34900906)
I guess I don't see why you think it's necessary to not criticize them.
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by mort96 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @02:51AM (#34892865)
The M1/M2 Macs run Linux pretty well. It's not perfect yet, but perfectly usable (especially as a desktop machine!) and support is improving every day.

I believe you're trying to move goalposts to avoid admitting you're wrong.

Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by Xixi on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:33AM (#34892377)
If RISC-V support by Microsoft is as bad as it has been for ARM, then I'm afraid RISC-V will never touch the desktop market, at all. Contrary to ARM, which is being pushed there with great success by Apple. Server-wise of course it's a different story...
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by BlueTankEngine on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:54AM (#34892517)
If great success to you is that they put the M1 and M2 in a tower, I don't know what to tell you. Intel, AMD, and the x86 industrial complex don't care in the slightest what instruction set your Mac runs
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by swores on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @04:49AM (#34893596)
Might I suggest taking a step back, re-reading your first comment and all the replies under it, and asking yourself "is it possible I might not be 100% correct, and maybe other opinions have enough merit to be worth considering why people aren't agreeing with me, rather than just changing my argument to make sure I'm still the winner of this thread"?
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by Xixi on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @09:14AM (#34895810)
I’m not sure I expressed my point clearly. It wasn’t quite about Apple. So I will reformulate it here: the fate of any instruction set on the desktop is primarily decided by Microsoft.

Do you have any information that Microsoft is planning to support RISC-V at least as well as x86/x64? (That is to say, not with something like Windows RT, or Windows CE)

That would be tremendously good news, I shall add.

Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by klelatti on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:50AM (#34892485)
Graviton, M1/M2, Ampere etc but I’m sure you’ll be able to explain why Arm is seen as ‘legacy’ tech when billions of smartphones are being shipped every year with Arm CPUs.
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by BlueTankEngine on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @02:06AM (#34892572)
Oh look, you named 4 areas where ARM development has already peaked. Hyperscalers are already looking to evolve from ARM in the near future, just look at how much attention Ventana got at RISC-V Summit. M1/M2 are Apple ecosystem specific phenomenon that haven't inspired any copycat products. Ampere has been a massive disappointment to everyone in the industry, see the fact that Nuvia had their entire business dead-to-rights pre-acquisition. ARM simply isnt at the cutting edge of the semiconductor industry anymore. Just because Apple and Qualcomm use it to great effect doesn't mean ARM is making any major innovative strides relative to the competition.
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by klelatti on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @02:24AM (#34892684)
> ARM simply isnt at the cutting edge of the semiconductor industry anymore.

What you really mean is Arm isn’t the hot new thing anymore. Well it hasn’t been that for 20 years. Meanwhile billions of arm devices in leading edge nodes are being shipped. Oh well.

Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by datadeft on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @05:05AM (#34893685)
> Hyperscalers are already looking to evolve from ARM

citation needed

https://www.theregister.com/2023/02/08/5_percent_cloud_arm/

"5% of the cloud now runs on Arm as chip designer plans 2023 IPO"

5% does not seems to me as a position that you want to change to something else.

ARM in every day computing outside of mobile phones and SBCs is just getting started as I see it.

Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by Dalewyn on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @02:03AM (#34892561)
>The future is RISC-V

I hope this never comes to pass, because a RISC-V future is a Chinese future.

A Chinese future will not be kind to western ideals that most of us hold dear.

Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by mort96 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @02:58AM (#34892920)
Huh? China has licenses for both the x86_64 and ARM ISAs. WhT about RISC-V makes it an advantage for Chinese companies?
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by Dalewyn on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @03:56AM (#34893265)
RISC-V is free and open as in libre, by contrast to x86 and ARM which must be licensed from Intel/AMD and ARM and are thus subject to potential western economic sanctions.

Now, yes, China will just espionage and kangaroo court their way through and around such legalities anyway, but nonetheless RISC-V is less effort for more reward for China if it becomes at least on par with x86 and ARM.

Put more basically, it's a matter of national security. China can have an entire RISC-V ecosystem indigenously, unlike x86 and ARM.

Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by mort96 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @05:10AM (#34893725)
Can Zhaoxin's x86 license, or the various Chinese companies's ARM licenses, just be revoked?
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by Dalewyn on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @08:18AM (#34894973)
If the US and/or UK place sanctions on exporting microprocessor technologies to China then that's that. Intel/AMD and ARM are subject to US and UK laws and regulations respectively.

RISC-V by contrast is much, much harder for any given country to regulate because of its free and open nature. At most the US and UK can embargo individual developments made within their jurisdictions, but they can't regulate the entire architecture. RISC-V doesn't have a kill switch named Intel/AMD or ARM.

Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by ksec on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @03:59AM (#34893278)
China has licenses for x86-64 “designs” and ARM’s design. Not the ISA. Although “ARM China” is probably enough for them.
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by sudosysgen on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @04:46AM (#34893576)
They have access to VIA's x86 license. They have entered a deal to use it for their domestic designs and have been doing so for 10 years now.
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by mort96 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @05:13AM (#34893747)
Really? No Chinese company has the ARM architecture license? That's honestly a bit surprising if true
Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by cameron_b on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @09:11AM (#34895735)
ARM China is a wildly different animal than ARM. They went rogue a few years back and though SoftBank/ARM did a lot to get things back in line, it still shows up like this:

https://www.reuters.com/technology/arm-china-says-its-ousted...

Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by shaunsingh0207 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:42PM (#34900528)
I'm loving it. I used cheap risc-v boards for several of my projects, most notably a GD32V in my keyboard. The equivalent stm boards weren't too expensive, mostly in the 10-20$ range, but weren't as easily available (and 10$ is still 3x the price of the chinese risc board)

Though the rp2040 has largely ended my cheap risc-v addiction

Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by ksec on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @03:52AM (#34893242)
>In my experience talking to semiconductors folks,

Most, if not all SemiCoductor “folks” I know are very pragmatic. As in how a Real Engineer should be, unlike software engineers. And in my experience, only HN and the Internet are suggesting ARM is dead. Everything will be RISC-V.

Re:AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency by adql on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @08:39AM (#34895243)
Yup, difference to the engineer is minuscule.

It's getting traction coz chip companies don't want to pay ARM for licensing, not because it is particularly better at something.