News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by londons_explore on Sunday February 19, 2023 @09:09AM (#34857674)
If you add DRM video playback to the fingerprint, it is pretty much impossible to fake...

Either they have a real TPM with a real nvidia graphics card able to decrypt content with a real serial number... Or they don't...

If one graphics card or TPM serial number starts acting bot-like, you can ban just that one.

Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by azalemeth on Sunday February 19, 2023 @09:22AM (#34857771)
I browse with DRM disabled. Every time it gives me a notification about it, I view it as a "hah, fingerprinting avoided!" signal.

Sites that use it get my anti-traffic. I don't buy, support, or condone DRM'd media and I actively disable EME on every browser I come across...

Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by nine_k on Sunday February 19, 2023 @09:54AM (#34858052)
Good for you.

There are sites that commercially distribute DRMed video content; say, Netflix. They have a large audience, and they care, whether me and you like it or not.

Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by andrewmackrodt on Sunday February 19, 2023 @10:33AM (#34858411)
Using Netflix as the example, Widevine L1 has very limited support on the desktop, i.e. Microsoft Edge on Windows and Safari on macOS.

All other configurations use L3 which is a shared key, e.g. provided by ChromeCDM as it runs entirely on the CPU - which is why Netflix content also works under Linux, albeit L3 is limited to 720p (or 1080p with browser extensions).

Given Chrome's massive browser market share, I'm not sure whether enabling DRM adds anything meaningful to the fingerprint - i.e. I don't think it's possible to revoke an L3 key without pushing out a new version of the CDM to all users of that browser, as has happened once before with Chrome.

Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by onion2k on Sunday February 19, 2023 @10:01AM (#34858115)
What use case is there for accessing DRM video content using a headless browser?
Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by sebzim4500 on Sunday February 19, 2023 @10:18AM (#34858268)
Automated downloading of the content, I assume.
Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by lupire on Sunday February 19, 2023 @09:59AM (#34858101)
How much of that audience is watching on a device without a video card? Almost none.
Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by nine_k on Sunday February 19, 2023 @10:15AM (#34858245)
AFAICT, the server can avoid serving the DRMed content until the browser proves it has a legitimate DRM-respecting playback capability, which is designed to be hard to feign. That is, unless something like [1] is correctly implemented in the headless mode, DRM content won't be available anyway.

Am I missing anything?

[1]: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Navigator/r...

Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by azalemeth on Sunday February 19, 2023 @02:57PM (#34861206)
I've never used Netflix (or other streaming sites like them) because of the DRM. Youtube manages to prove that a streaming model can be very, very profitable without it at all, as does BBC iPlayer.
Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by charcircuit on Sunday February 19, 2023 @07:54PM (#34863650)
YouTube uses DRM for licensed content like TV shows
Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by 2h on Sunday February 19, 2023 @09:57AM (#34858086)
> I don't buy, support, or condone DRM'd media

this is good, but it would also be helpful if you supported the anti DRM movement. Some people have developed ways to get around certain DRM such was Widevine, from dumping your own CDM to Widevine proxy. Just ignoring the problem is not going to make it go away. Over the last two years DRM use for streaming content has increased significantly. If you want to really help, I would look into contributing code to these projects, or donations.

Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by lupire on Sunday February 19, 2023 @10:06AM (#34858156)
Why is stealing content so important to you?

DRM has no affect on content you and your friends create without DRM. I don't want to deal with a Kickstarter to prefund all revenue, for each and every video I want to watch.

Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by rwmj on Sunday February 19, 2023 @10:35AM (#34858420)
Even as someone who isn't in the slightest interested in unauthorised copying of content, watching videos on anything which isn't VLC on my laptop is such a PITA that I never do it.
Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by theyeenzbeanz on Sunday February 19, 2023 @10:22AM (#34858302)
We don’t want to deal with having to be forced into having specific hardware, operating systems, and browsers to watch content we paid for. I’ve had perfectly good monitors that were before HDCP was a thing, and these sites gimp the quality or outright refuse to play media because the monitor didn’t have some bogus technology.
Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by jimmydorry on Sunday February 19, 2023 @11:16AM (#34858824)
DRM has a huge impact on what I consume. For example only being able to watch Netflix at 720p due to running a *nix distro.
Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by ViViDboarder on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @11:46AM (#34883307)
I'm not seeing how that doesn't help support DRM?

It does nothing to dissuade content gatekeepers from employing restrictive DRM on their sites.

Anti-DRM would be avoiding anything that gives money to those that employ DRM to incentivize the removal of the DRM. Frankly, flat out piracy (streaming ripped content) is more likely to result in the removal of DRM than making it appear that the DRM is working well for the provider.

Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by notatoad on Sunday February 19, 2023 @10:51PM (#34864738)
i love the contrast in these comments. on the one hand you have all the people arguing that headless chrome is unethical because websites need to be able to block bot traffic, and on the other you have actual humans saying they try as hard as they can to behave like a bot.
Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by pritambaral on Monday February 20, 2023 @02:36AM (#34865939)
> ... actual humans saying they try as hard as they can to behave like a bot.

Blaming humans for desiring privacy is bad. No one here is "trying to behave like a bot".

Exaggerated example: "Oh, you don't want to show me, a random stranger on the internet, your ID? You are behaving like a crook!"

Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by notatoad on Monday February 20, 2023 @01:13PM (#34870881)
i'm not blaming people for wanting privacy. i'm just saying that if you value privacy, you can't also value blocking bots, because in order to block a bot you have to collect enough information to violate the real people's desire for privacy.

and there seems to be significant overlap between the people who think enabling bots is morally wrong, and people who think fingerprinting is morally wrong. if you value privacy, you have to value privacy for all web users even before you've collected enough data to determine whether that web user is a real person or not.

Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by jefftk on Sunday February 19, 2023 @09:23AM (#34857781)
> If one graphics card or TPM serial number starts acting bot-like, you can ban just that one.

I don't think you can get the serial number, though?

(And if there was an API for this it wouldn't be a passive one, which makes it inapplicable for fingerprinting)

Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by redox99 on Sunday February 19, 2023 @09:14AM (#34857716)
I don't believe DRM fingerprinting is used in the wild. Firefox shows when DRM is being used (like Netflix) and I've never seen it used outside that.
Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by ffpip on Sunday February 19, 2023 @09:45AM (#34857971)
Reddit's website uses DRM for fingerprinting - https://iter.ca/post/reddit-whiteops/
Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by redox99 on Sunday February 19, 2023 @10:10AM (#34858196)
Maybe they changed their mind on that, because it does not show me any DRM usage as of now.
Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by 323 on Sunday February 19, 2023 @09:27AM (#34857806)
Can you report back the TPM serial number to the webserver?

If so, why isn't this used as an immutable ever-cookie that can't be deleted?

Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by t0mas88 on Sunday February 19, 2023 @12:59PM (#34860034)
You can't, the parent comment has combined a few real world possible things into an impossible combination.
Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by xnx on Sunday February 19, 2023 @09:15AM (#34857724)
How does this work? Wouldn't a lot of real user-agents not have this capability and therefore not be able to be fingerprinted and banned in this way?
Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by beagle3 on Sunday February 19, 2023 @09:16AM (#34857729)
Also shutting out a lot of older and weird devices (internet fridges, dumb smart tvs, and more, many Linux and bsd users) who can’t play DRM.

Some sites won’t care, but for some this will be too high a price for avoiding headless bots.

Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by sarnowski on Sunday February 19, 2023 @09:51AM (#34858030)
TPMs do not reveal a unique serial number or similar identifier by design for privacy reasons.

A TPM can attest that some measurements were done with it and it can attest that it comes from vendor X. You can block an entire vendor if they don’t behave but not individual TPMs via remote attestation.

You can use a scheme in which you can set up an „identity“ on first use and then on next use authenticate the same identity. But that identity is kinda per use case.

Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by melvyn2 on Sunday February 19, 2023 @01:21PM (#34860273)
I was under the impression that the EK could be used to identify individual TPMs- why can’t it?
Re:New headless Chrome has been released and has a near-perf... by RobotToaster on Sunday February 19, 2023 @11:51AM (#34859245)
Why couldn't they just use a software TPM?