Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by readthenotes1 on Saturday February 18, 2023 @09:56AM
(#34847335)
Tldr:
Accounting violations are widespread: in an average year, 41% of companies misrepresent their financial reports, even when we ignore simple clerical errors. Fortunately, securities fraud is less pervasive. In an average year, 10% of all large public corporations commit (alleged) securities fraud...
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by dccoolgai on Saturday February 18, 2023 @09:56AM
(#34847337)
IMO the demise of modern journalism presents an absolutely enormous opportunity for the few people with the right skills: If this is even close to true (66% of corp fraud undetected) imagine if you could get even a couple researchers to detect more of it using publicly available information. Set up a massive short position on that company and fire off press releases on a slow Newsday to share what you found with the public. I actually knew some professional researchers and talked to them about this once. I'm too lazy to actually put it together but pretty sure it's a viable idea.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by dccoolgai on Saturday February 18, 2023 @10:39AM
(#34847654)
I think you have to be an "insider" to qualify as a whistleblower. NAL, but I think if you were gonna do this you'd have to be squeaky clean using only public data. Otherwise it's textbook insider trading.
I literally started screaming with joy like a lunatic at my phone in the middle of the street.
Turns out... even an obvious obvious obvious fraud can keep going like
wile coyote for prolonged periods of time. Do not friggin recommend.
I also have been trading the Turkish lira for over a year. Also do not recommend as they flat out cheat and gaslight on.. frankly historical scales.. as well as get foreign currency under the table from fellow despots.
If you're wondering what the hell would possessed me: at some point they started making schemes like "citizens it is your patriotic duty to sell us your gold jewelry so we may smelt it, we will give you a great price promise" -- the list of shenanigans got so long and comical and the central bank balance sheets so iffy I couldn't help myself.
Being correct directionally is not nearly enough. Be very careful. This Adani thing mostly bounced back already, unless you're willing to be very patient as it unfurls over literal years you very easily could lose money despite being right.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by sokoloff on Saturday February 18, 2023 @11:51AM
(#34848367)
I also directly shorted $NKLA shares. There was no realistic way they were going to make post-SPAC buyers money, but I also didn’t know if it would take 3 months or 3 years to unwind.
I remember being unable to sleep wondering if the audience at his events were all hired actors. But then they couldn't be as that is a conspiracy involving too many people. Looking online he had actual fans and true believers and they were basically illiterate people gambling he is the next Elon, absolutely nothing would phase them.
The journalists interviewing him clearly had no idea about the difference between a gas powered and a hydrogen vehicle. And neither did he as he would steer the conversation into folksy directions whenever anything remotely technical came up.
I did a lot of soul searching and accepted that this is the stupidest time line and the emperor really is naked. And this time I caught his tiny wiener flapping in the wind in time. It was just beyond obvious.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by lordnacho on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:37PM
(#34848934)
Maybe I've listened to too many CNBC interviews, to me he sounds like any other exec? "Blah blah everything is going great, we need capital but it's going great".
Just a totally bland exec call, standard for that station.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by recuter on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:58PM
(#34849866)
> Maybe I've listened to too many CNBC interviews, to me he sounds like any other exec? "Blah blah everything is going great, we need capital but it's going great".
> Just a totally bland exec call, standard for that station.
Yes it almost makes your eyes glaze over. By design. But you see ,unlike an actual exec at an actual real company at this point in time he is burning cash and literally has nothing to sell and nothing to show.
If you listen carefully to his explanation of when he plans to actually show something and sell things -- you will note that it is... complete... gibberish..
> But also keep in mind it is essentially an advertising segment.
Absolutely. And what is he advertising at this point in time? :)
Imagine he was talking about a super sonic long distance electric VTOL plane instead of hydrogen trucks.
"We have no debt and plenty of money in the bank and these things are going to roll off the factory line next year just as soon as we figure out the PR with our customers as the timelines are tricky. Meanwhile we can't show you anything. Please buy my stock."
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by alfor on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:08PM
(#34848556)
Same here.
I thought it was so obvious and then called out publicly and exposed.
It doesn’t matter. I think that as long as the right people in the media are greased it doesn't enter the mass consciousness.
If you look at the mass media, you will see that the actors on the news will show emotions around certain subjects, they will make a grind or a disgusted face while talking about a problem at a company or a political movement. That is what change people mind when repeated many times.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by tablespoon on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:32PM
(#34848876)
> This video (from a shadow banned account) show how the media talk with one voice. https://youtu.be/ZggCipbiHwE
That was that Sinclair media thing. The fact that they have independent teams serving many smaller markets gave it away. If (say) CNN were to do the same thing, they could probably reach an even bigger audience with one guy reading the script, which can't be exposed with a supercut.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by dccoolgai on Saturday February 18, 2023 @04:00PM
(#34851042)
Exactly. You wouldn't do "obvious fraud" with this setup: you would do "things that aren't obvious but a couple good researchers could prove". You don't even need to scare everyone out of the security, just do enough to make a few big players go "ooh, I didn't know _that_".
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by eurasiantiger on Sunday February 19, 2023 @12:19PM
(#34859595)
> the country is run by clueless mobsters
This is the correct take. The world is nowadays largely owned and operated by various criminal organisations that rake in more cash in a month than entire nations do in a year. Thank you, prohibition.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by chewz on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:21PM
(#34848726)
> Set up a massive short position on that company and fire off press releases on a slow Newsday to share what you found with the public.
How naive... No One would listen... [1]
> No One Would Listen is the thrilling story of how the Harry Markopolos, a little-known number cruncher from a Boston equity derivatives firm, and his investigative team uncovered Bernie Madoff's scam years before it made headlines, and how they desperately tried to warn the government, the industry, and the financial press.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by taeric on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:20PM
(#34849451)
My gut is that it is more likely that 66% of fraud being undetected is more along the lines of "mistakes are easy to make and often ignored." That is, for it to be fraud, intent matters. More, for it to be substantial and actually a problem, value matters.
Consider, is it employee theft if they take a notepad home? I'd wager not. Now, if they empty out the supply closet? Almost certainly yes.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by bsenftner on Saturday February 18, 2023 @10:04AM
(#34847396)
Now let's a similar study on employment fraud: mischaracterizing employees as salaried is omnipresent in the corporate world. That is just the tippy tippy top of that iceberg.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by analog31 on Saturday February 18, 2023 @10:42AM
(#34847683)
If an employee is classified as "exempt," (aka, "salaried") then they are exempt from being paid overtime. There were recently a few articles on an increase in the number of workers being given artificial "manager" titles, to put them in the exempt category.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by danaris on Saturday February 18, 2023 @11:11AM
(#34847954)
To be clear, "exempt" and "salaried" are not synonymous, even though they are very commonly treated as such.
It is perfectly possible to be a salaried employee, and to be eligible for overtime.
My interpretation: Companies just hate doing that, because it means trusting the employees to accurately report when they work overtime who are not regularly reporting their hours.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by analog31 on Sunday February 19, 2023 @02:04PM
(#34860674)
The way it's worked for me is that I've been asked to report my hours when the information is being used to track how my time was divided among different projects. The ostensible purposes were to show that each project was receiving the its allocated share of resources. A secondary purpose was to see if anybody was being overworked -- for instance it could be used as evidence to justify hiring another person.
But we were told in no uncertain terms that we were not counting our hours. I'm sure the legal department had approved all of the verbiage and procedures.
I never personally measured my work in hours, and a lot of workers simply reported hours that precisely matched their project allocations, or copy-pasted from one week to the next. My present job doesn't have any of that.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by vba616 on Sunday February 19, 2023 @04:54PM
(#34862246)
Some companies who do that have both salaried and overtime eligible hourly employees who are otherwise in the same type of position. Or they did at different points in time.
So the meaning of saying that it is not counting hours is as clear as mud.
It also extends to more than one industry. Not just, say, corporate litigation.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by vba616 on Sunday February 19, 2023 @03:01AM
(#34855514)
My first office job was hourly, and paid overtime. For a short time, there was so much work we were allowed to do as much overtime as we liked. After a while we were told no overtime without permission, and then we were all changed (ostensibly) to exempt and salaried, but nobody said anything about us being "managers".
Now I am salaried, and am not allowed to put in overtime on my own initiative, but I am eligible for it if requested. The next salary grade up, union rules allow unpaid overtime.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by monero-xmr on Saturday February 18, 2023 @10:10AM
(#34847438)
Every executive I know (public or private) discusses everything remotely sensitive over voice or Signal now. Sending anything over email is insane given the number of lawsuits going. Just look at the recent layoffs at big tech - class actions everywhere. You aren’t going to detect corporate fraud very easily.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by ccooffee on Saturday February 18, 2023 @11:59AM
(#34848459)
This is my experience as well. The higher-ups slap "privileged" on nearly all emails, even when they have nothing to do with soliciting legal advice (e.g. a company-wide email about internal policy changes). I wish I'd hear stories about a company being sued, and during discovery opposing counsel finds the erroneous "privileged" markings, then the judge drops a hammer or something. I cannot imagine that happening. The most I can see is the judge appointing a special master to review everything marked privileged, but even that seems unlikely.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by taeric on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:21PM
(#34848731)
Would love a link. I don't mind when folks on lists say "we should be more deliberate discussing this, please move it to another channel." I get really annoyed when they do the above, though.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by vinay_ys on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:45PM
(#34849032)
Also, remember the corporate lawyers are there to protect the corporate, not the individual. Usually the individual gets fed to the wolves when push comes to shove.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by stuckinhell on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:35PM
(#34848907)
True, also the idea of "secure data enclaves" is something executives I work with are pushing for very hard.
Basically a secure dropbox where they can share important information about the company aka layoffs plans and unpopular ways to make money without worrying about some tech activist in the company leaking that information.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by wongarsu on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:19PM
(#34849431)
I imagine it's similar to digital data rooms used for due dilligence, M&A, etc.: no obvious print or download option, and personalized watermarks that allow you to track who took the screenshot (an when/where it was taken).
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by stuckinhell on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:52PM
(#34849120)
Not exactly sure, because its a buzzword right now.
If I had to guess infrastructure that's under a completely different ownership than the rest of company, under an extremely tight audit control.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by remote_phone on Saturday February 18, 2023 @10:17AM
(#34847486)
This “paper” is shit.
They get the most basic function of auditing wrong. Auditors are taught from the beginning that they do not look for fraud. You should not expect auditors to detect fraud. My wife is in finance and I have a dozen Big 4 auditors as friends. This is one of the basic things hammered into every auditor from day one. Auditors do not look for fraud.
If they happen to find fraud they need to report it. But they don’t go into an audit looking for fraud.
Second, using restatements as a measure of fraud is stupid. restatements can happen for a bunch of reasons, the least of which are fraud. Very often people make mistakes and thats why every company has a tolerance of error called materiality. Sometimes errors aren’t detected for many quarters and would cause a restatement.
As well the auditing rules leave room for interpretation. There is always dynamic tension between the accounting team of a company vs the auditors. The fact that a company and auditors gets things wrong and then for this to be classified as “fraud” is stupid. It’s most often times not fraud. Sometimes the audit partner changes and their opinion is vastly different from the previous partner which causes a lot of regurgitation of the financials and likely a reevaluation of the contract. But the audit partner doesn’t want to lose her job or go to jail so I think for the most part having strict laws and tough punishments is very motivating for auditors.
That said, I worked for a company that got shut down for true fraud. The cfo and ceo lied about sales in order to make their numbers. They both went to jail but this is the most basic fraud and they went to jail for a long time.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by denton-scratch on Saturday February 18, 2023 @10:36AM
(#34847634)
> Auditors are taught from the beginning that they do not look for fraud.
To be fair, the authors defined fraud very loosely.
"As we explain in Section 2, we use the term “fraud” loosely, since what we measure is some form of misconduct or alleged fraud."
Auditors are expected only to certify that a company's accounts are a "true and accurate" representation of the company's financial position. Corporate fraud is fantastically expensive to investigate and prosecute; fraud trials sometimes last years, and some fail simply because jurors died of old age.
If you don't prosecute crimes, then you are encouraging them; I imagine the incidence of fraud is much greater than the authors estimate.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by hef19898 on Saturday February 18, 2023 @02:13PM
(#34850043)
Compliance to rules and regulations, as well as sufficient internal controls. If you, say, make up bank accounts and fake the account statements an auditor, say, EY, might just acceot those at face value. Until your company, say Wirecard, is forced by external pressire from short sellers and the FT, to conduct another audit from another auditor and everything falls appart.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by LatteLazy on Saturday February 18, 2023 @05:17PM
(#34851677)
Auditing is checking someone added up the numbers right and put the right things in the right columns.
Auditing is not actually checking the money exists or the transactions were real or the products paid for were really delivered etc.
If I say Acme Inc received 2$ in revenue and spent 1$ in costs, it's cash on hand should go up 1$. If I get that right, I pass that bit of the audit. Whether acme actually got paid or not or even exists is not the auditors problem: just 2-1=1.
Re:How pervasive is corporate fraud?
by vorpalhex on Saturday February 18, 2023 @10:28AM
(#34847571)
This is a terrible paper and I suspect it's going to fail to be reproduced. That won't stop it from being quoted heavily.
> In our experiment, the sample of firms under enhanced scrutiny is the set of Arthur Andersen (AA) clients after the AA demise following the Enron scandal.
Their initial data sets (2) indicate that detected fraud is in the realm of 2-5%, and they then hypothesis from Enron clients that the actual fraud rate is astronomically high, by abusing a statistical model.
They are using an outlier to form statistical representations on the whole.
Good piece on Netflix about her and the short position she took
When Hindenburg published this gem: https://hindenburgresearch.com/nikola/
I literally started screaming with joy like a lunatic at my phone in the middle of the street.
Turns out... even an obvious obvious obvious fraud can keep going like wile coyote for prolonged periods of time. Do not friggin recommend.
I also have been trading the Turkish lira for over a year. Also do not recommend as they flat out cheat and gaslight on.. frankly historical scales.. as well as get foreign currency under the table from fellow despots.
If you're wondering what the hell would possessed me: at some point they started making schemes like "citizens it is your patriotic duty to sell us your gold jewelry so we may smelt it, we will give you a great price promise" -- the list of shenanigans got so long and comical and the central bank balance sheets so iffy I couldn't help myself.
Being correct directionally is not nearly enough. Be very careful. This Adani thing mostly bounced back already, unless you're willing to be very patient as it unfurls over literal years you very easily could lose money despite being right.
I think there's a famous saying about that: "the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent."
Here is a random CNBC clip, look at these absolute lunatics: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NYBj83HttG4
I remember being unable to sleep wondering if the audience at his events were all hired actors. But then they couldn't be as that is a conspiracy involving too many people. Looking online he had actual fans and true believers and they were basically illiterate people gambling he is the next Elon, absolutely nothing would phase them.
The journalists interviewing him clearly had no idea about the difference between a gas powered and a hydrogen vehicle. And neither did he as he would steer the conversation into folksy directions whenever anything remotely technical came up.
I did a lot of soul searching and accepted that this is the stupidest time line and the emperor really is naked. And this time I caught his tiny wiener flapping in the wind in time. It was just beyond obvious.
And the market cap kept rising and rising!
Just a totally bland exec call, standard for that station.
Yes it almost makes your eyes glaze over. By design. But you see ,unlike an actual exec at an actual real company at this point in time he is burning cash and literally has nothing to sell and nothing to show.
If you listen carefully to his explanation of when he plans to actually show something and sell things -- you will note that it is... complete... gibberish..
> But also keep in mind it is essentially an advertising segment.
Absolutely. And what is he advertising at this point in time? :)
Imagine he was talking about a super sonic long distance electric VTOL plane instead of hydrogen trucks.
"We have no debt and plenty of money in the bank and these things are going to roll off the factory line next year just as soon as we figure out the PR with our customers as the timelines are tricky. Meanwhile we can't show you anything. Please buy my stock."
I thought it was so obvious and then called out publicly and exposed.
It doesn’t matter. I think that as long as the right people in the media are greased it doesn't enter the mass consciousness.
If you look at the mass media, you will see that the actors on the news will show emotions around certain subjects, they will make a grind or a disgusted face while talking about a problem at a company or a political movement. That is what change people mind when repeated many times.
This video (from a shadow banned account) show how the media talk with one voice. https://youtu.be/ZggCipbiHwE
That was that Sinclair media thing. The fact that they have independent teams serving many smaller markets gave it away. If (say) CNN were to do the same thing, they could probably reach an even bigger audience with one guy reading the script, which can't be exposed with a supercut.
You're not betting just on whether they did a mistake, you're betting on when will they realize it.
This is the correct take. The world is nowadays largely owned and operated by various criminal organisations that rake in more cash in a month than entire nations do in a year. Thank you, prohibition.
How naive... No One would listen... [1]
> No One Would Listen is the thrilling story of how the Harry Markopolos, a little-known number cruncher from a Boston equity derivatives firm, and his investigative team uncovered Bernie Madoff's scam years before it made headlines, and how they desperately tried to warn the government, the industry, and the financial press.
[1] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/7740121-no-one-would-lis...
Consider, is it employee theft if they take a notepad home? I'd wager not. Now, if they empty out the supply closet? Almost certainly yes.
https://www.businessinsider.com/companies-may-give-fake-mana...
Edit: See comment below about "salaried." Thanks.
It is perfectly possible to be a salaried employee, and to be eligible for overtime.
My interpretation: Companies just hate doing that, because it means trusting the employees to accurately report when they work overtime who are not regularly reporting their hours.
But we were told in no uncertain terms that we were not counting our hours. I'm sure the legal department had approved all of the verbiage and procedures.
I never personally measured my work in hours, and a lot of workers simply reported hours that precisely matched their project allocations, or copy-pasted from one week to the next. My present job doesn't have any of that.
So the meaning of saying that it is not counting hours is as clear as mud.
It also extends to more than one industry. Not just, say, corporate litigation.
Now I am salaried, and am not allowed to put in overtime on my own initiative, but I am eligible for it if requested. The next salary grade up, union rules allow unpaid overtime.
Rules for thee, but not for me.
Basically a secure dropbox where they can share important information about the company aka layoffs plans and unpopular ways to make money without worrying about some tech activist in the company leaking that information.
how does it work then?
if you share, then they can always take a picture/screenshoot/record their screen
They get the most basic function of auditing wrong. Auditors are taught from the beginning that they do not look for fraud. You should not expect auditors to detect fraud. My wife is in finance and I have a dozen Big 4 auditors as friends. This is one of the basic things hammered into every auditor from day one. Auditors do not look for fraud.
If they happen to find fraud they need to report it. But they don’t go into an audit looking for fraud.
Second, using restatements as a measure of fraud is stupid. restatements can happen for a bunch of reasons, the least of which are fraud. Very often people make mistakes and thats why every company has a tolerance of error called materiality. Sometimes errors aren’t detected for many quarters and would cause a restatement.
As well the auditing rules leave room for interpretation. There is always dynamic tension between the accounting team of a company vs the auditors. The fact that a company and auditors gets things wrong and then for this to be classified as “fraud” is stupid. It’s most often times not fraud. Sometimes the audit partner changes and their opinion is vastly different from the previous partner which causes a lot of regurgitation of the financials and likely a reevaluation of the contract. But the audit partner doesn’t want to lose her job or go to jail so I think for the most part having strict laws and tough punishments is very motivating for auditors.
That said, I worked for a company that got shut down for true fraud. The cfo and ceo lied about sales in order to make their numbers. They both went to jail but this is the most basic fraud and they went to jail for a long time.
To be fair, the authors defined fraud very loosely.
"As we explain in Section 2, we use the term “fraud” loosely, since what we measure is some form of misconduct or alleged fraud."
Auditors are expected only to certify that a company's accounts are a "true and accurate" representation of the company's financial position. Corporate fraud is fantastically expensive to investigate and prosecute; fraud trials sometimes last years, and some fail simply because jurors died of old age.
If you don't prosecute crimes, then you are encouraging them; I imagine the incidence of fraud is much greater than the authors estimate.
Auditing is not actually checking the money exists or the transactions were real or the products paid for were really delivered etc.
If I say Acme Inc received 2$ in revenue and spent 1$ in costs, it's cash on hand should go up 1$. If I get that right, I pass that bit of the audit. Whether acme actually got paid or not or even exists is not the auditors problem: just 2-1=1.
> In our experiment, the sample of firms under enhanced scrutiny is the set of Arthur Andersen (AA) clients after the AA demise following the Enron scandal.
Their initial data sets (2) indicate that detected fraud is in the realm of 2-5%, and they then hypothesis from Enron clients that the actual fraud rate is astronomically high, by abusing a statistical model.
They are using an outlier to form statistical representations on the whole.