News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by ad404b8a372f2b9 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @06:45PM (#34828445)
When you qualify Hersh as one of journalism's least trustworthy figures, it's impossible to take the rest of your comment at face value.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by kurthr on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:09PM (#34828709)
Well, in the last decade he's kinda blown it with multiple claims in Syria. Statements that are either unbelievable, undocumented and easily could be (like building locations), or basically falsified have really brought down his trust. Even if he's just getting bad information rather than coming from a particular angle, his readers deserve better vetting of the material. At some point it feels like he's being driven by narrative more than facts that's a problem, and hanging out with Bashir Al Assad doesn't help to get the "real" story. Also note that Assad does have a particularly aligned geo-political supporter these days, who's directly involved.

   https://www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v35/n24/seymour-m.-hersh/whose-sarin
   https://www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v38/n01/seymour-m.-hersh/military-to-military
   https://www.bellingcat.com/news/mena/2017/06/25/will-get-fooled-seymour-hersh-welt-khan-sheikhoun-chemical-attack/
   https://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/magazine/whatever-happened-to-seymour-hersh
There's no such thing as a chlorine bomb- "Chlorine is just a gas. It's not a chemical warfare weapon. You smell it, you run away." - Seymore Hersh

Tell that to soldiers in WWI.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by Mizza on Thursday February 16, 2023 @08:03PM (#34829260)
Bellingcat is a way for UK/US spies to launder intelligence, a bootleg Wikileaks that won't challenge domestic power structures. I wouldn't point to them if I wanted my point to be taken seriously.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by ninjagoo on Thursday February 16, 2023 @09:01PM (#34829722)
> I wouldn't point to them if I wanted my point to be taken seriously.

Bellingcat have a significant proven track record [1] and have won significant awards for their reporting, including the Investigative Reporting Award from the European Press Prize [2]. Do you have evidence for your counter-claim that they should not be taken seriously?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bellingcat#Notable_cases [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bellingcat#Awards

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by halothane on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:35AM (#34835100)
I'll just leave this here. Take your time. https://twitter.com/aaronjmate/status/1374782087321034755
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by halothane on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:25AM (#34834983)
Seems like the Bellingcat Tik-Toker team is busy at their keyboard from the looks of some of the comments in this thread! Gone are the days when HN would present evidence that could be debated without ad hominem attacks. Groups like Bellingcat and Team Jorge have done what they meant to do - sow confusion and disinformation. MILDEC at work.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by halothane on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:05AM (#34831011)
Haha, Bellingcat is your source vs a Pulitzer Prize journalist who may have fallen out of favor with a particular crowd, and you want the comment to be taken seriously? Not all us drink Koolaid. Here's a link to your link - about Brown Moses, an unemployed man from Leicester, England (https://www.cjr.org/business_of_news/bellingcat_brown_moses....)
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by kurthr on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:52AM (#34831284)
Good idea, judge based only on the name of the source, completely captured by narrative and unable to make decisions based any measurable facts they present. Pick a football team and cheer them to victory for surely that's the right way to understand the world, the economy, and geopolitics!

Don't read anything from the London Review of Books either since you might not agree with them. It's scary to hear new things.

I'll note that you didn't dispute that chlorine gas was used (eg in Yepres and many other times) and killed thousands in the great war nor that Seymour said it couldn't (there's video). Do you like it when your team slaughters innocents? Tryout Kiwi Farms.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by halothane on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:20AM (#34834916)
>>>>Good idea, judge based only on the name of the source, completely captured by narrative and unable to make decisions based any measurable facts they present. Pick a football team and cheer them to victory for surely that's the right way to understand the world, the economy, and geopolitics! Lots of words, but nothing that adds to the discussion that the source of your "new things" is a bunch of Tik-Tokers doing armchair analysis. Here's another description of your trusted sources - "Brown Moses aka Eliot Higgins, is the founder of an online collective called Bellingcat that picks apart conspiracy theories and investigates war crimes and hate crimes using clues from the Internet." Wow, how amazing that we can now understand the world, the economy, and geopolitics from sitting in our gaming chair using clues from the internet. Yah, let's dispute about chlorine gas in the "great war" since you and I are experts at chemical warfare and we both have access to proven, evidence-based reliable data aka Bellingcat and London Review of Books!
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by kurthr on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:23PM (#34837497)
When you're JAQing off the use of chlorine gas in WWI and comparing LRoB to TikTok, ZyclonB and the holocaust are nearby. Since you use the internet I guess you can't know anything, LOL!
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by halothane on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:39AM (#34835139)
Go ahead, pick your football team and cheer them on. Here's the ball. Some scary new things as you said ;) https://twitter.com/aaronjmate/status/1374782087321034755
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by eduction on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:03PM (#34828646)
I completely agree. He has a Pulitzer Prize, five Polk awards, two national magazine awards. Broke My Lai, Abu Ghraib, and exposed the Israeli nuclear program.

He is easily the most accomplished journalist for several generations.

That doesn’t automatically mean this story is right but to dismiss him in emotional and inaccurate terms doesn’t speak to a rational, evidence-based interpretation of the facts.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by XorNot on Thursday February 16, 2023 @08:05PM (#34829280)
Seymour Hersh has also gone off the deep end lately. Some current examples[1]:

* the Osama bin Laden raid was faked in a conspiracy with Pakistan and he was actually captured in 2006

* much of the US special forces is controlled by secret members of Opus Dei

* that the US military flew Iranian terrorists to Nevada for training

* the 2013 chemical weapons attack in Syria was a "false flag" staged by the government of Turkey

Being right decades ago doesn't somehow absolve you of having to have verifiable sources and evidence when you go on to make numerous other claims that don't happen and no one can verify.

[1] https://www.vox.com/2015/5/11/8584473/seymour-hersh-osama-bi...

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by maybelsyrup on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:49AM (#34831265)
We live in a world where the CIA has a heart attack gun [1], a presidential administration faked evidence of WMD to go to war in Iraq, the CDC conducted secret medical torture on black men with syphilis, and the Pentagon sent JFK proposals to justify a war on Cuba by conducting false flag terrorist attacks against American civilians [2]. (JFK rejected them, apparently.)

So I read a list like yours, and read you scoffing at the implausibility of any of those things, and I remember just how different we all can be.

[1] https://www.military.com/video/guns/pistols/cias-secret-hear...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Northwoods

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by XorNot on Friday February 17, 2023 @02:07AM (#34831726)
Yes and you know what all those things have in common? Actual evidence which corresponds to real events, and multiple sources confirming that they happened.

What Hersh's suppositions have is a stunning lack of verifiable evidence and observably factually incorrect assertions (as in the case of his articles on Nordstream).

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by maybelsyrup on Friday February 17, 2023 @02:19AM (#34831809)
Saying someone's claims don't (yet) have the kind of evidence you demand is pretty different from calling someone crazy (and in so doing implying that those claims are not worth the consideration of the sane).

The only thing your bullet points were doing is suggesting "look at the delusions of this maniac! He can't be trusted because of them". But because the completely insane shit in my list turned out to be true, Hersh's sorts of claims are at least as plausible as the insane shit I listed in my reply. (And in the case of the first two, they were labeled by bienpensants of all kinds as proof that the claimant was certifiably nuts or at least unworthy of Serious Attention ... until the day they were shown to be true.)

All I'm saying is that, given the factual record of conspiracy and sociopathy on the part of the world's powerful, something like "2013 chemical weapons attack in Syria was a "false flag" staged by the government of Turkey" can't easily be used to dismiss someone as nuts. Not enough evidence? Sure, whatever (but let's wait a decade or two). Crazy though? Nope.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by XorNot on Friday February 17, 2023 @02:41AM (#34831959)
Over 10 years. It's one thing to have a story out there no one can prove, it's quite another to have been continuously publishing things you can't prove and which no one else can find any evidence of despite looking.

There are multiple factual claims about verifiable vessels, planes and movements being made and none of them are true.

All your saying is, despite obvious factual inconsistencies in the parts of the story which should be publicly verifiable, you've already got a conclusion you like. Which is what everyone's doing because the real big secret is "it was Russia" is a boring conclusion that doesn't move clicks.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by maybelsyrup on Friday February 17, 2023 @04:37PM (#34840899)
> you've already got a conclusion you like

> the real big secret is "it was Russia"

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by tptacek on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:09PM (#34842788)
Yes. The previous comment is also problematic. It does not follow from Hersh being one Smiths song short of a mixtape that the opposite of his conclusions are true. It's indicative of how all these discussions happen: points made to impeach Hersh's conclusions are analyzed as if they are arguments for the purity of US foreign policy. Hersh might be "right" that the US is behind the pipeline attack! But that doesn't matter if he got there by guessing. The real question is: can we learn anything from the story he told, and the answer to that seems, pretty convincingly, to be "only that his sources are fabulists".

It would be handy if you could conclude things like "whatever Hersh said, the opposite is true" from his stories! His journalism would be super valuable if that was the case. You'd just read it and draw the opposite conclusions. But you can't do that, because his stories (at least since 2006) are unmoored from reality.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by maybelsyrup on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:22AM (#34844483)
>points made to impeach Hersh's conclusions are analyzed as if they are arguments for the purity of US foreign policy

They're not about purity. They're arguments that US fp is fundamentally well intentioned and transparent even when -- shucks -- it gets things wrong. A sort of clumsy and oafish but ultimately benign labrador retriever.

And it's correct to analyze them this way, because that's what they are. For whatever factual case they may be trying to make, these arguments are too pervasive, and appear too quickly after stories like these, in too anxious and defensive a tone, to be anything at their core but emotional responses to perceived threats to closely held, orthodox worldviews -- ones that deny that Our Side is consistently and secretly up to Real Evil in the world, and that to suggest otherwise in too bold a way is "unmoored from reality". It's always asserted that the points are about facts, but with human beings it's never only that.

It's okay, is the thing -- I get it. I do it myself. We all (HN types, anyway) do: we're by and large Knowledge Workers with Fancy Degrees and Big Salaries, maybe even a blog or a Twitter, and society rewards and praises us for being so knowing. So when Johnny GED comes along asking about conspiracy theories, we raise our chins just so, smirk benevolently, and proclaim that such talk is out of bounds: this stuff is crazy. And if it's some cantankerous old guy with (gasp) a claim or two about the world today, even better: look at this walking artifact. He lost it in 2006.

With respect to this topic, the irony is that this behavior -- Snopes as personality type, let's call it -- prevents people from wading into the strongest argument for skepticism about Hersh, one that's held long before his alleged mid-aughts wash-out: that his anonymous sources, members of the American security state to a man, regularly use the 20th Century's Greatest Journalist to advance their agendas by feeding him Juicy Truths, Half-Truths, or Untruths. In plainer English, that he's a shill, witting or unwitting, of this or that CIA caporegime with this or that need to get something out there. So this

> his sources are fabulists

and this

> unmoored from reality

are not only the defensive putting on airs of articulate urban types with bachelor's degrees, they stop a hair too short of saying or asking or probing something really important and necessary about how power still works in this country: a semi-hidden system of factions of the American power elite consistently and systematically attempt, with varying degrees of success, to manage public thought in ways that advance their (varying, often competing, often unknowable) interests by exerting influence or control over the media, especially the trusted media. And we're not allowed to know about it, we'll likely never find out the true extent of it, and the behavior is immunized by the public itself: the hard right will call you unpatriotic for bringing it up, and centrists with New Yorker subscriptions will call you a kook. But from Mockingbird to Ken Dilanian, this is the world we live in -- has it gotten Hersh too?

So if

> the real question is: can we learn anything from the story he told?

then the answer's definitely yes, and it doesn't even matter all that much if he's right or wrong. Though maybe we'll know in 20 years.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by dralley on Thursday February 16, 2023 @06:51PM (#34828508)
I think you have to separate Hersh pre-2010 and Hersh after-2010. He was once one of the greatest journalists in the world, but the last decade he has been putting out poorly-sourced, falsifiable garbage.

Watch the interview he gave the other day (mentioned in this article) and tell me you walk away from it with more confidence that he's fully "there" as a journalist. He goes on a tangent about how Ukraine is doomed and Zelenskiy is killing his own people by resisting, even though 90% of the country is in favor of fighting to regain the occupied territory.

He also doubles down on the ship being, specifically, the ALTA (and not any other ship), but the ALTA has been sitting in a scrap yard for 6 months.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by honkler on Thursday February 16, 2023 @06:59PM (#34828599)
More likely that you developed a tribalistic bias in the last decade (Trump, election interference, vaxxine, and now Ukraine). So obviously you don't like his journalism.

Also noticed same dynamic at play with Glenn Greenwald, Matt Taibbi, Edward snowden who were loved back then, but then were hated for a sniff of center right political stance.

Ofcourse when you play the tribalistic game, Whistleblowers become your enemy, and 3 letter agencies your friends. Funny how psychology works.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by pvg on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:11PM (#34828727)
Hersh stopped working within journalistic organizations, with their editors, fact-checkers, second-sourcing, etc - the organizations in which all his previous and more credible and verifiable work was done. That's a concrete fact, not 'tribalistic bias'. There's no basis whatsoever for you to attribute skepticism of recent Hersh to it, it's just namecalling.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by pphysch on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:49PM (#34829105)
According to Hersh, he still does due diligence with editors and fact checking. He just doesn't have the brand sponsorships anymore.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:53PM (#34829159)
And yet, somehow his work ends up error-laden and full of holes. Funny how that works out.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by pphysch on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:56PM (#34829185)
That's just not true. A handful of bloggers have nitpicked at it using publicly available information. All of Hersh's big stories received the same initial response of derision, going back to My Lai half a century ago [1].

Hersh, believe him or not, is not relying on publicly available information, but confidential sources.

[1] - https://mobile.twitter.com/MarkAmesExiled/status/16262796968...

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Thursday February 16, 2023 @08:07PM (#34829300)
'Chlorine is just a gas. It's not a chemical warfare weapon. You smell it, you run away.'

Sure sounds like the words of somebody who isn't going senile!

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by graeme on Thursday February 16, 2023 @09:10PM (#34829791)
There’s a difference between:

1. Convincing an editor to run your ideas under their masthead

2. Paying someone to edit your work, and running your ideas under your own masthead

A newspaper is more than a brand. They put their reputation on the line when they publish.

(You can make a good argument that many newspapers have trashed their own reputations, but that doesn’t negate the argument. When you self publish, you have no one vouching for you. Furthermore if you don’t like an editor or fact checker you can fire them)

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by zmgsabst on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:28PM (#34830365)
Except that it’s legacy media who has eviscerated their reputation in the past decade.

Eg, CNN has a lower viewership in the “key demo” than large YouTube news channels.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by jrsj on Thursday February 16, 2023 @11:03PM (#34830600)
Even if he wanted to work within those journalistic organizations and everything he said was true, they wouldn’t publish it. There’s really no other option for him at this point.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by pvg on Friday February 17, 2023 @02:28AM (#34831870)
The fact they didn't want to work with him, after many years of him dropping huge bombshells they published, the literal foundation of his reputation, says more about his later work than than theirs, no? It's strange to claim his inability to find publishers for his non-verifiable work somehow confirms its credibility.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mturmon on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:17PM (#34828780)
You're jumping to a conclusion here -- sometimes the journalist does change.

Plenty of political journalists go off the deep end at some point in their career. (Prof.) Mark Crispin Miller used to write well-researched essays on the culture of TV, now he believes that Sandy Hook was likely staged and that the standard explanation for 9/11 isn't true. Christopher Hitchens made a significant swerve to the right later in his career.

Many colleagues and former friends of Matt Taibbi and Glenn Greenwald feel the same way about what they have done.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by honkler on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:24PM (#34828864)
> now he believes that Sandy Hook was likely staged and that the standard explanation for 9/11 isn't true

No lies detected.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by nkozyra on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:43PM (#34829066)
Gross
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by zmgsabst on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:31PM (#34830384)
Those last two examples indicate you have a tribalistic bias though:

Matt Taibbi and Glenn Greenwald changed their politics which you’re implying impacts their credibility because their friends (fellow members of your tribe) said mean things about that.

Further, why is Christopher Hitchens changing his politics relevant to a discussion about journalist credibility — and even mixed into a paragraph about hoaxes?

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mturmon on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:24PM (#34843195)
> why is Christopher Hitchens changing his politics relevant to a discussion about journalist credibility...?

Because, unfortunately to those who admired him, Christopher Hitchens allowed his disgust for Islamic fundamentalism to lead him to credulously advocate for a war that turned out to be based on a series of lies? Lies that he partly saw through, but that he decided to ignore in service of what for him was the larger good?

It's an instructive episode.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mturmon on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @12:56PM (#34884340)
Self-replying to point out a more well-informed take on Seymour Hersh's recent writing: https://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/whats-the-story-with-se...
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:33PM (#34828942)
He has a fanciful tale about how the raid on Osama bin Laden was actually staged by Pakistani intelligence, who were presumably happy to play the part of incompetent dupes. I assume Stanley Kubrick directed the raid on a sound stage.

The man is 85, he gets basic facts wrong in his articles, he takes a single anonymous source's word as gospel, and either won't do fact checking or fails to do so competently. He's clearly cuckoo for cocoa puffs at this point. Time to send him to the nursing home.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by halothane on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:22AM (#34831102)
Nice! Love how you threw in the age factor there Buster. Yep, Seymour sure got his basic facts wrong during the Vietnam War, Watergate scandal, Abu Ghraib and more. I'd rather have him report on our state of the world than Brown Moses's team of Tik Tok experts or for that matter Team Jorge, unless you are one of them?
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:32AM (#34831170)
I threw in the age factor because it's a fact that people's mental faculties diminish as they age.

And the Pakistani staged Bin Laden raid, Opus Dei in the USMC, and the Turks using chemical weapons in Syria? How convenient that everything that doesn't corroborate his fairy tales is just more proof of the cover up.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by halothane on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:49AM (#34834594)
First it was age, now its "fairy tales"! There's a pattern in comments that are meant to be debated based on facts and evidence vs ad hominem comments subtly designed to slander the individual. You know where you stand. :)
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:25AM (#34834980)
What is presented without evidence may be dismissed without evidence.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by dang on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:48AM (#34835985)
Can you please not (a) post in the flamewar style to HN, or (b) use HN for political flamewar? You're breaking the site guidelines badly here.

We don't need you to change your views but we do need you to present them thoughtfully and respectfully, if you want to participate here.

If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site to heart, we'd be grateful.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by halothane on Friday February 17, 2023 @03:27PM (#34840081)
Got it. That's not the intent, but have to call out the comment preceding mine which is ad hominem and insulting individuals without providing any substance for discussion.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by dang on Friday February 17, 2023 @03:46PM (#34840308)
I didn't see that comment. I've responded now. We don't always read the threads sequentially.

But in any case, other commenters breaking the rules doesn't make it ok for you to break them. (I don't mean you personally there, I mean any of us.) That's just a recipe for a downward spiral (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...). Also, you broke them in several places, not just that one.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by dang on Friday February 17, 2023 @03:44PM (#34840287)
Personal attacks and name-calling are not allowed here. We ban accounts that do that sort of thing, so please don't, regardless of how wrong someone is or you feel they are.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Friday February 17, 2023 @04:27PM (#34840798)
With all due respect, in a discussion about Seymour Hersh's credibility, his soundness of mind should be a valid criticism.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by dang on Friday February 17, 2023 @05:57PM (#34841762)
What you did was against the rules regardless of who you're talking about. It's not a borderline call.

Maybe you don't owe disagreeable elderly journalists better, but you owe this community better if you're participating in it.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Friday February 17, 2023 @06:01PM (#34841790)
Is there a respectful way of suggesting a journalist is too senile to be reliable?
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by tptacek on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:40PM (#34843633)
Yes. For starters, if you had kept "senility" out of it, and just made your case based on what he'd actually reported, you wouldn't have made it so easy for the thread to devolve into a referendum on "ad hominem" arguments. His age and "soundness of mind" --- which you don't know anything about --- has nothing to do with this situation.

On the off chance that getting this feedback from someone on "the same side" as your argument is helpful, that is.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:57AM (#34844345)
Well, I don't know if you noticed, but the part of the thread I responded to was already about discussing Mr Hersh's trustworthiness. And on the contrary, his soundness of mind has everything to do with this.

I would love to discuss the merits of the evidence presented by Mr Hersh. Too bad he hasn't given any! We just have to take him at his word because apparently he's credible and we have to pretend that octogenarians are just as mentally present as the rest of us. Anyone calling this an ad hominem doesn't know what the fallacy even means - it's not attacking the person instead of the argument if the person is the argument in the first place.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by dang on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:20AM (#34844470)
You could start by editing out swipes, as the site guidelines request. By what logic did you think it was ok to post nastiness like "He's clearly cuckoo for cocoa puffs" and, worse, "time to send him to the nursing home"? That's an outright slur. Please don't do such things on HN.

As tptacek correctly pointed out, it also discredits your argument, so it would also be in your interest to edit out. Either way, though, we need you to stop posting flamebait and/or snark to this site.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Saturday February 18, 2023 @02:05AM (#34844701)
Well, I can't really edit that anymore as it's been too long. And I simply used a bit of colourful language to describe relevant points to a discussion of Mr Hersh's trustworthiness: he is senile and old.

Now, if you think 'The man is 85, he gets basic facts wrong in his articles, he takes a single anonymous source's word as gospel, and either won't do fact checking or fails to do so competently. He is senile and old.' is acceptable, I will stick to such less colourful language in the future.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by pvg on Saturday February 18, 2023 @02:59AM (#34844958)
The whole point is that namecalling/internet diagnosis is not acceptable. You can't 'it's just colourful language' your way out of that.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Saturday February 18, 2023 @10:21AM (#34847516)
As I've said elsewhere, the question of whether or not Mr Hersh possesses a sound mind is relevant to the matter as the discussion was already revolving around whether or not he's a trustworthy figure in journalism. And again, this story is based entirely around his credibility in the first place, so there's really no other place for this discussion to end up.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by pvg on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:17PM (#34849412)
the question of whether or not Mr Hersh possesses a sound mind is relevant

It's not. It's just a rationalization for the name calling. No attempt to elevate it into some reasoned point about the article is going to make it not-name calling.

there's really no other place for this discussion to end up.

Whatever the place is, it's just not here because you just can't go 'story I don't believe' -> 'mentally deficient person'. It's a completely straightforward thing to not do.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:54PM (#34849832)
I haven't said it's not name calling, but only that it is not an ad hominem, as the very thing in question is Mr Hersh's credibility.

Is it wrong to suggest someone who has made a number of outlandish claims in recent years and is quite elderly is suffering from a degraded mental state, as we all know is wont to happen to the elderly?

If, say, Linus Pauling published in the 90s something along the lines of 'I've discovered the secret to immortality, and no, I won't provide any verifiable evidence for it, you just have to trust me' after decades of passing off Vitamin C as a cure for cancer, and everybody was saying 'well Linus Pauling is one of the greatest biochemists of our time, he's won the Nobel Prize', is it out of bounds to say, well, maybe at one point, but the man is 90 now and clearly lost his marbles some years ago?

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by pvg on Sunday February 19, 2023 @01:34AM (#34855092)
Is it wrong to suggest someone who has made a number of outlandish claims in recent years and is quite elderly is suffering from a degraded mental state, as we all know is wont to happen to the elderly?

That's not actually the thing you are getting all this flak for - we don't have to decide or agree if it's 'wrong' on some broad scale or whether or not it constitutes a logical fallacy. It's corrosive to the notion of a (however imperfect and irritating) internet forum that aims for interestingness and curious conversation. Which is why it's in the written guidelines, the reams of mod comments, the mod-scolding you got earlier. Globally wrong or not, you can't do it on HN because it would kill HN.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Sunday February 19, 2023 @02:36PM (#34861004)
Well, perhaps an Internet forum that aims for interestingness and curious conversation should also aim for the intellectual honesty of admitting that the mental faculties of individuals diminish as they age.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by dang on Saturday February 18, 2023 @08:07AM (#34846640)
No, you can't attack someone by putting them down as "senile and old" here. Doing it because you disagree with someone is particularly distasteful.

Please don't do the putdown/name-calling/slur thing on HN at all. You can make your substantive points without any of that.

(Edit: I see pvg already made this point, and I don't mean to pile on, but maybe it's important for a moderator to make this clear.)

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Saturday February 18, 2023 @10:15AM (#34847472)
I didn't do it because I disagreed, I did it because the 'trustworthiness' of Mr Hersh is the very thing in question, and a discussion about a story based entirely off of his word and credibility alone had no other way of ending up. Again, I would love to argue on the merits of the evidence Mr Hersh has presented - but too bad he hasn't given any! Where else could this discussion end up other than whether or not Mr Hersh is credible?

It is not an ad hominem when the entire basis of an argument is 'so-and-so says so'. Well, I think so-and-so is full of shit; why isn't that a valid point of inquiry?

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by tptacek on Thursday February 16, 2023 @09:46PM (#34830061)
If you're stuck in a time tube and perceive the world as it was in 2005, Hersh is one of the more important journalists in the world. I don't deny that. I only deny that the Jews are attempting to start WW3 in Iran, that Opus Dei runs USSOCOM, that the US faked the UBL raid in Pakistan (and in fact the ISI had UBL for years prior), and that Syria's Sarin attacks on their own people were faked by the US. Oh, also that the US got the Norwegian Navy to put a minesweeper in the Baltic Sea as a diving platform for US divers to blow up a pipeline that wasn't shipping any gas to Germany.

If you're still in 2005, I have great news for you: you've got one more amazing season of the Wire ahead of you, and 5 whole seasons of a show called Breaking Bad --- take my word on this, it's going to be amazing. You can skip The Wire S5 though.