News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Friday February 17, 2023 @04:27PM (#34840798)
With all due respect, in a discussion about Seymour Hersh's credibility, his soundness of mind should be a valid criticism.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by dang on Friday February 17, 2023 @05:57PM (#34841762)
What you did was against the rules regardless of who you're talking about. It's not a borderline call.

Maybe you don't owe disagreeable elderly journalists better, but you owe this community better if you're participating in it.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Friday February 17, 2023 @06:01PM (#34841790)
Is there a respectful way of suggesting a journalist is too senile to be reliable?
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by tptacek on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:40PM (#34843633)
Yes. For starters, if you had kept "senility" out of it, and just made your case based on what he'd actually reported, you wouldn't have made it so easy for the thread to devolve into a referendum on "ad hominem" arguments. His age and "soundness of mind" --- which you don't know anything about --- has nothing to do with this situation.

On the off chance that getting this feedback from someone on "the same side" as your argument is helpful, that is.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:57AM (#34844345)
Well, I don't know if you noticed, but the part of the thread I responded to was already about discussing Mr Hersh's trustworthiness. And on the contrary, his soundness of mind has everything to do with this.

I would love to discuss the merits of the evidence presented by Mr Hersh. Too bad he hasn't given any! We just have to take him at his word because apparently he's credible and we have to pretend that octogenarians are just as mentally present as the rest of us. Anyone calling this an ad hominem doesn't know what the fallacy even means - it's not attacking the person instead of the argument if the person is the argument in the first place.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by dang on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:20AM (#34844470)
You could start by editing out swipes, as the site guidelines request. By what logic did you think it was ok to post nastiness like "He's clearly cuckoo for cocoa puffs" and, worse, "time to send him to the nursing home"? That's an outright slur. Please don't do such things on HN.

As tptacek correctly pointed out, it also discredits your argument, so it would also be in your interest to edit out. Either way, though, we need you to stop posting flamebait and/or snark to this site.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Saturday February 18, 2023 @02:05AM (#34844701)
Well, I can't really edit that anymore as it's been too long. And I simply used a bit of colourful language to describe relevant points to a discussion of Mr Hersh's trustworthiness: he is senile and old.

Now, if you think 'The man is 85, he gets basic facts wrong in his articles, he takes a single anonymous source's word as gospel, and either won't do fact checking or fails to do so competently. He is senile and old.' is acceptable, I will stick to such less colourful language in the future.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by pvg on Saturday February 18, 2023 @02:59AM (#34844958)
The whole point is that namecalling/internet diagnosis is not acceptable. You can't 'it's just colourful language' your way out of that.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Saturday February 18, 2023 @10:21AM (#34847516)
As I've said elsewhere, the question of whether or not Mr Hersh possesses a sound mind is relevant to the matter as the discussion was already revolving around whether or not he's a trustworthy figure in journalism. And again, this story is based entirely around his credibility in the first place, so there's really no other place for this discussion to end up.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by pvg on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:17PM (#34849412)
the question of whether or not Mr Hersh possesses a sound mind is relevant

It's not. It's just a rationalization for the name calling. No attempt to elevate it into some reasoned point about the article is going to make it not-name calling.

there's really no other place for this discussion to end up.

Whatever the place is, it's just not here because you just can't go 'story I don't believe' -> 'mentally deficient person'. It's a completely straightforward thing to not do.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:54PM (#34849832)
I haven't said it's not name calling, but only that it is not an ad hominem, as the very thing in question is Mr Hersh's credibility.

Is it wrong to suggest someone who has made a number of outlandish claims in recent years and is quite elderly is suffering from a degraded mental state, as we all know is wont to happen to the elderly?

If, say, Linus Pauling published in the 90s something along the lines of 'I've discovered the secret to immortality, and no, I won't provide any verifiable evidence for it, you just have to trust me' after decades of passing off Vitamin C as a cure for cancer, and everybody was saying 'well Linus Pauling is one of the greatest biochemists of our time, he's won the Nobel Prize', is it out of bounds to say, well, maybe at one point, but the man is 90 now and clearly lost his marbles some years ago?

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by pvg on Sunday February 19, 2023 @01:34AM (#34855092)
Is it wrong to suggest someone who has made a number of outlandish claims in recent years and is quite elderly is suffering from a degraded mental state, as we all know is wont to happen to the elderly?

That's not actually the thing you are getting all this flak for - we don't have to decide or agree if it's 'wrong' on some broad scale or whether or not it constitutes a logical fallacy. It's corrosive to the notion of a (however imperfect and irritating) internet forum that aims for interestingness and curious conversation. Which is why it's in the written guidelines, the reams of mod comments, the mod-scolding you got earlier. Globally wrong or not, you can't do it on HN because it would kill HN.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Sunday February 19, 2023 @02:36PM (#34861004)
Well, perhaps an Internet forum that aims for interestingness and curious conversation should also aim for the intellectual honesty of admitting that the mental faculties of individuals diminish as they age.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by dang on Saturday February 18, 2023 @08:07AM (#34846640)
No, you can't attack someone by putting them down as "senile and old" here. Doing it because you disagree with someone is particularly distasteful.

Please don't do the putdown/name-calling/slur thing on HN at all. You can make your substantive points without any of that.

(Edit: I see pvg already made this point, and I don't mean to pile on, but maybe it's important for a moderator to make this clear.)

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Saturday February 18, 2023 @10:15AM (#34847472)
I didn't do it because I disagreed, I did it because the 'trustworthiness' of Mr Hersh is the very thing in question, and a discussion about a story based entirely off of his word and credibility alone had no other way of ending up. Again, I would love to argue on the merits of the evidence Mr Hersh has presented - but too bad he hasn't given any! Where else could this discussion end up other than whether or not Mr Hersh is credible?

It is not an ad hominem when the entire basis of an argument is 'so-and-so says so'. Well, I think so-and-so is full of shit; why isn't that a valid point of inquiry?