News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by dmix on Thursday February 16, 2023 @02:50PM (#34824751)
If someone was feeding Hersh false information why would they reference the Alta class? Assuming it was some Intel op or some insider, did they just google some Norwegian navy ships that could plausibly fit the picture? Or did Hersh draw that connection himself?

Hersh has been criticized for listening to cranks. Maybe some Intel officer (or adjacent gov/military worker) heard some rumours internally but there was comparmentalization or operational security protecting the details, and then tried to piece it together themselves, before leaking it to Hersh.

If it is false it's worth asking why and who would care to push these angles.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by tptacek on Thursday February 16, 2023 @02:52PM (#34824795)
Presumably it's for the same reasons that people gave him faulty technical information about Sarin gas in his debunked Syria story, or whatever weird details he was fed about the notion that the Osama bin Laden raid never happened, or the idea that USSOCOM is secretly controlled by a sect within the Vatican. Because he'll run with it, and people pay attention to him.

People troll all the time on the Internet; why would we assume they wouldn't troll everywhere else too?

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by rjsw on Thursday February 16, 2023 @02:55PM (#34824863)
I didn't think he claimed that the OBL raid never happened, just that the backstory about how he was found was wrong.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by tptacek on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:00PM (#34824969)
It's above the fold on his LRB story: he claims that Pakistani ISI captured bin Laden, not the US.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by rjsw on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:57PM (#34825995)
... and then the US staged a raid to pick him up from the ISI.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Thursday February 16, 2023 @04:03PM (#34826105)
And it was directed by Stanley Kubrick.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by Convolutional on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:14PM (#34828747)
As bin Laden was holed up 800 yards from the Pakistan Military Academy, it seems more likely that he was captured by ISI and/or the Pakistani army, as opposed to trying to hide from them there.

ISI dealt with bin Laden in the 1980s, and has good intelligence in the region bin Laden had been rumored to be holed up in.

It takes more of a leap of faith to believe bin Laden was hiding from the Pakistan military/industrial apparatus 800 yards from the Pakistan Military Academy, then that some high officials knew he was there.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mannerheim on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:52PM (#34829145)
I can believe Pakistani intelligence knew where he was the whole time.

I don't believe they cut some deal to stage a raid where they came off looking like total morons for purported military aid that never came.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by dmix on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:01PM (#34824999)
I'd still give Hersh the benefit of the doubt he's not just listening to some internet troll type person. There has to be some reputation at play here for him to take it seriously. The odds are high it's someone connected to the US or NATO govs. At least you'd assume so. As another commenter mentioned, he claimed he used to the same fact checkers used by The New Yorker.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by tptacek on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:05PM (#34825071)
I would not give him the benefit of the doubt, and I have a hard time understanding why anybody would; there is more than ample reason to doubt any story he runs. I can't imagine a credible source working with him, so far has the presumption of accuracy been shifted on his work over the last 10 years. That's why a famous journalist is reduced to running stories from unnamed (and implausible) sources in the first place.

"Since I posted my original article, I had a short email correspondence with Seymour Hersh, unfortunately he stopped replying once I asked him about several of the above mentioned inconsistencies and factual inaccuracies."

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by dmix on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:15PM (#34825240)
Maybe it was an aging Intel guy relying on old reputation for credibility who later declined into pushing conspiracy tier thing, so basically two levels of Hersh like people cruising off past glory.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by halothane on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:32AM (#34831176)
Lots of arm chair opinion, hyperbole, mud-slinging and labels in your comments, but nothing evidence-based or factual that a crowd like HN can debate. Again seems like Team Jorge at work here?
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by astrange on Friday February 17, 2023 @01:05AM (#34831371)
A green account name accusing the #1 (#2?) poster on this site of being an op? Is this reverse psychology?
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by halothane on Friday February 17, 2023 @03:23PM (#34840028)
You must know about becoming a first time voter after being on the sidelines? Same here after seeing Seymour Hersch being denigrated and attacked just because some don't agree with his point of view, especially after he has done so much for our country, its ideals and founding principles. I'll take your comment at face value and assume you don't hate on first timers. Otherwise you would fall into the same category of an ad hominem.:)
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by DubiousPusher on Thursday February 16, 2023 @06:20PM (#34828143)
You should never give any reporter the benefit of any doubt.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by jancsika on Thursday February 16, 2023 @06:31PM (#34828305)
> the notion that the Osama bin Laden raid never happened

The first sentence of Hersh's article reads:

"It’s been four years since a group of US Navy Seals assassinated Osama bin Laden in a night raid on a high-walled compound in Abbottabad, Pakistan."

His entire article then goes on to lay out a set of details for both the lead up and the execution of that raid, including the execution of bin Laden.

Those details conflict with the details officially given by the Obama administration-- both the details given in the days after the event (which Hersh cites) and the clarifications from the administration in the weeks after the event.

In any case, Obama's administration and Hersh both clearly agreed that there was a raid on the exact same location on the exact same evening, involving the exact same helicopters and Navy Seals, in which the exact same bin Laden was killed.

In short, what you wrote here is factually inaccurate.

> the idea that USSOCOM is secretly controlled by a sect within the Vatican

Never heard about that one. Where did he write about that idea?

Edit: decided to not use the word "tenuous" to describe the Obama admin's account in the days after the raid. What I remember Hersh discussing was the admin's initial claim that the Seals had shot him in self defense, which was later clarified/retracted by the administration.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by epistasis on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:28PM (#34825488)
There are all sorts of interested parties in creating doubt about the attack, and the most likely is of course the master of this, Russia. It also fits very well with past bad reporting from Hersh.

The detail makes the story more plausible, later debunking matters far less than the initial report and the uncertainty that this sows in people's minds.

Taking attention away from the true culprit definitely helps. And any ammunition that can be used to make democracies in the West have more doubt and internal wasted debate definitely helps whoever actually destroyed the pipeline.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by tptacek on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:32PM (#34825557)
Trying to work backwards from the (likely true) notion that Hersh's story is fiction is just as intellectually flawed. We don't anything about Hersh's source or their motives. You could write an HN comment about how the CIA planted this whole story to cast doubt on the actual US-led operation to blow up (some) of the Nord Stream pipeline. Or you could write the opposite comment. There's just nothing to go on.

The only thing we can really discuss here is whether the Hersh story is credible. It seems clearly not to be. If we establish that, that's all we get: the fact that one story about what happened is false. We'll be no closer to knowing what actually happened. That's life!

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mushbino on Thursday February 16, 2023 @11:02PM (#34830588)
If it were false, it would be Hersh's first false story. He broke My Lai and Abu Ghraib. He's one of the most accomplished journalists in history.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mikeyouse on Thursday February 16, 2023 @11:31PM (#34830800)
Hersh wrote an article that broke through on Abu Gharib after several other outlets and the Red Cross had already been raising the alarm. 8 months before Hersch’s article, Amnesty International wrote the first report on the conditions there. 5 months before his article, the AP wrote a huge piece with interviews from ex prisoners describing the torture they underwent, the Red Cross commissioned a report 4 months before Hersch’s piece and delivered it 2 months before vividly describing the torture and 60 minutes released videos and pictures the week before Hersh’s story was published. He has absolutely done good work but his “breaking” of the Abu Gharib story is very much overstated.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by astrange on Friday February 17, 2023 @01:08AM (#34831394)
That was 20 years ago. Since then he's apparently gone nuts since he eg believes Opus Dei controls the US military.

Though before Abu Ghraib he also claimed the Chicago mob fixed JFK's presidential election.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by mushbino on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:48AM (#34844300)
I can't find anywhere he published those stories. Do you have a link?
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by nwallin on Thursday February 16, 2023 @11:49PM (#34830911)
If the point is just to muddy the waters, you don't need a story that's airtight, it just needs to be convincing enough to spark peoples' biases.

If it's a crank, well, it's a crank. When I was in the Air Force, and still had a TS clearance, there was a friend+coworker of mine that was deep into conspiracy theories. Flat Earth, Moon Hoax, 9/11 truther, and a few others I don't remember. Everything we talked about he had loads of details. I knew it was all nonsense of course, because you're talking about flat earth and all that; if I didn't know he was a full blown conspiracy theorist? If I just knew he was a system administrator with a top secret security clearance attached to an intelligence squadron? And he was telling me a story about something the intelligence community did? He'd be very believable.