News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by pgrote on Friday February 10, 2023 @08:01AM (#34739077)
>Ah the classic PR blur. Could mean anything from "all good" to "we don't log - ignorance is bliss".

After what lastpass did I cannot trust any self reporting.

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by remus on Friday February 10, 2023 @08:26AM (#34739341)
I think this is overly pessimistic. While there's definitely shady companies out there who will say this while having very poor security practices, it's tricky demonstrating that something didn't happen.

Say you had detailed audit logs for example. What happens if there's a subtle bug in those systems that allowed the hacker to proceed without logs being recorded?

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by Dalewyn on Friday February 10, 2023 @08:29AM (#34739366)
Specifically with regards to Reddit, spez is now known to have edited the database holding comments without making that fact known in any way.

So absolutely nothing coming out of Reddit should be trusted or quoted.

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by piva00 on Friday February 10, 2023 @08:35AM (#34739410)
Yup, I don't trust spez, I don't trust reddit's management (even less after the Chinese investments). This is a case to be cynical, reddit is not transparent and their leadership has been riddled with stupid politics, including the whole weird saga they did with Ellen Pao.
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by sillysaurusx on Friday February 10, 2023 @09:05AM (#34739695)
Ehh. Spez being human makes me inclined to trust him a little more. I’m neutral in politics, but editing those comments was objectively funny. Stupid, yes — astonishingly so. But it finally broke the illusion that users own their comments. That’s all it ever was: an illusion.

I don’t trust authority in general. But given the choice between spez and musk, I’d take spez any day. He’s at least not hopped up on drugs running around making crazy decisions.

And in terms of Reddit’s trustworthiness, it makes even less sense that editing comments would be of any consequence. If they detect a hacker and have the logs to prove it, they’d gain nothing by modifying the logs. And if they don’t, they gain nothing by fabricating the logs. So it seems reasonable to conclude that they just don’t have the logs.

Which is also reasonable. When I was hacking into systems at Matasano, it always made me uncomfortable just how undetectable I was. I wasn’t trying particularly hard to conceal myself, but a few well-chosen bash incantations and opening things in vi means all anyone sees is that a vi process is running.

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by malfist on Friday February 10, 2023 @09:32AM (#34740063)
> Spez being human makes me inclined to trust him a little more

You realize what you're saying right? You're saying someone's actions that breach trust makes you trust them more?

Actions speak louder than words, if someone is showing you that you can't trust them, you don't decide that you're going to trust them more!

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by raspberry1337 on Friday February 10, 2023 @09:13AM (#34739795)
I'd take the devil over musk! At least he is not hopped up on drugs and running around making crazy bad decisions
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by nkozyra on Friday February 10, 2023 @10:34AM (#34740972)
Getting some Poe's Law vibes here.
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by 7speter on Friday February 10, 2023 @10:25AM (#34740826)
> But it finally broke the illusion that users own their comments. That’s all it ever was: an illusion.

Makes me wonder about all what else about reddit is an “illusion”

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by LarryMullins on Friday February 10, 2023 @10:32AM (#34740933)
So basically "he lied to me, lying is a human behavior, so I trust him."

Wew.

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by qingdao99 on Friday February 10, 2023 @10:56AM (#34741333)
How hard is it to resist directly editing user data on your site? It's a pretty clear-cut case of abuse of power.
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by doubled112 on Friday February 10, 2023 @11:29AM (#34741845)
I've always strongly believed in "ignorance is bliss", and "if somebody wants me to know something they will tell me".

The idea of snooping barely crosses my mind, let alone editing.

Maybe it is different because Reddit comments are intended to be public.

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by ineptech on Friday February 10, 2023 @11:42AM (#34742066)
Obviously this is an unpopular opinion, but I think you're right about spez. Editing those comments in his AMA was dumb, but pretty obviously not malicious in the way that's being suggested here. I think a fair analogy would be if he gave a speech in a clown wig, and was then accused of having tried to disguise himself.
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by cmh89 on Friday February 10, 2023 @11:46AM (#34742116)
>I’d take spez any day. He’s at least not hopped up on drugs running around making crazy decisions.

spez fostered a pedophile subreddit where they posted creepshots of children because it was the top driver of users to his site. It took hitting the mainstream media for him to shut it down.

He's a terrible person

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by albert-thomas on Friday February 10, 2023 @05:54PM (#34747134)
I've had a few interactions with him person to person, he seems like an alright guy.

Then again, so did my last boss till i got to know him better

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by gruez on Friday February 10, 2023 @11:33AM (#34741932)
>Yup, I don't trust spez, I don't trust reddit's management (even less after the Chinese investments)

I think you (and many other people) are overestimating how much chinese influence there is on reddit, considering that they have < 10% stake (according to wikipedia they "led" a funding round that raised 10% of valuation, and since then there was another funding round that presumably diluted their stake).

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by corbulo on Friday February 10, 2023 @12:28PM (#34742769)
Above 0 is too much. Could 10% buy you mod spot over a large major subreddit? Maybe get reddit to look the other way for your astroturf campaigns?

Reddit is just as shady with its Overton Window manipulation tactics & strategies as Twitter has been exposed to be. Remember when Ghislaine Maxwell was revealed as a mod of r/Worldnews? I'm convinced any relevant PR company worth its salt has infiltrated moderator teams of every major subreddit. Whats stopping them? Or anyone else for that matter

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by gruez on Friday February 10, 2023 @08:30PM (#34748575)
> Above 0 is too much. Could 10% buy you mod spot over a large major subreddit? Maybe get reddit to look the other way for your astroturf campaigns?

That's... not how fundraising rounds usually work.

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by corbulo on Saturday February 11, 2023 @04:04PM (#34756332)
Thats how ownership and influence works. You think China is buying 10% because of how profitable reddit is?
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by gruez on Saturday February 11, 2023 @06:18PM (#34757471)
I can ask the same for the other investors.

>in 2005. Condé Nast Publications acquired the site in October 2006. In 2011, Reddit became an independent subsidiary of Condé Nast's parent company, Advance Publications.[11] In October 2014, Reddit raised $50 million in a funding round led by Sam Altman and including investors Marc Andreessen, Peter Thiel, Ron Conway, Snoop Dogg, and Jared Leto.[12] Their investment valued the company at $500 million then.[13][14] In July 2017, Reddit raised $200 million for a $1.8 billion valuation, with Advance Publications remaining the majority stakeholder.[15] In February 2019, a $300 million funding round led by Tencent brought the company's valuation to $3 billion.[16] In August 2021, a $700 million funding round led by Fidelity Investments raised that valuation to over $10 billion.[4]

What type of shadowy agenda are entities like Jared Leto or Fidelity Investments trying to advance? Or should we assume that they're acting altruistically because they're not Chinese?

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by corbulo on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:09AM (#34760339)
It turns out all those people really just hated making money the whole time. I'm glad we've come to an agreement.
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by piva00 on Monday February 13, 2023 @10:11AM (#34774343)
> What type of shadowy agenda are entities like Jared Leto or Fidelity Investments trying to advance? Or should we assume that they're acting altruistically because they're not Chinese?

None, they might just really believe that Reddit might be profitable one day and they want a share of the pie. Snoop Dogg also invested in Klarna, for example.

On the other hand I have lots of reservations about the motivation of the likes of Sam Altman and Peter Thiel in this, Marc Andreesen is not such a wildcard, might be just stupid with money as the latest plays of a16z seems to making them be.

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by boppo1 on Friday February 10, 2023 @09:54AM (#34740417)
Reddit is a shady company. Doing everything they can on the browser experience including interrupting me while I'm typing to try to shunt me over to the app is shady. I don't want the app. I have clicked 'continue in browser' at least 200 times. My preference ought to be clear and recorded by now.

I'd stop visiting altogether if I didn't have a general problem with compulsive browsing.

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by seanw444 on Friday February 10, 2023 @10:46AM (#34741181)
Sounds like a job for uBlock Origin. Just block the element.
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by jungledeuce on Friday February 10, 2023 @10:53AM (#34741285)
Sure, shady companies exist. And you shouldn’t trust shady companies to self report. But… you already know that, it’s in the name! “Shady”. So I think the idea that you should never trust self reporting is indeed an over reaction.

However, having been at (what I deemed) non-shady companies, there’s still the very human desire to downplay as much as is reasonable. Shady companies overstep reasonability on purpose.

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by throwaway2056 on Friday February 10, 2023 @11:32AM (#34741911)
Why use reddit's official app? There are several decent opensource apps. (BTW, you can use libredd.it to just read-only reddit)
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by tstrimple on Friday February 10, 2023 @12:20PM (#34742639)
Thanks I may look into libredd.it. I intentionally removed the 3rd party apps because they were too good and enabled me to doom scroll too efficiently. I used the website in part because it's a painful experience which will keep me from staying on there too long. A read-only version may help that even more because then I'd have to switch to the full website if I wanted to rage post about how someone is wrong on the internet.
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by fragmede on Friday February 10, 2023 @12:39PM (#34742958)
* * *
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by junon on Friday February 10, 2023 @06:12PM (#34747310)
Apps give them more access and more information than browsers do.
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by PuppyTailWags on Friday February 10, 2023 @10:28AM (#34740881)
There's no regulation with teeth to hold companies accountable for breaches, by and large, and therefore this is exactly the appropriate amount of pessimism.
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by LarryMullins on Friday February 10, 2023 @10:30AM (#34740903)
Never trust any company with a PR department at all, they're all opportunistic liars who's priority is limited damage to the company, not telling the truth. They only do the latter when they think it will have the effect of the former.

Really, don't trust corporations at all. Even if the circumstances of life force you to do business with them and hope nothing goes wrong, that's no reason to ever trust them. The bigger the corporation the more true this is, since the structure of corporations makes people feel less personally responsible for the bad things they might do to you, like lying to you about the scope of a data breach. The "just following orders" mentality allows workers to do things they'd never otherwise do to you, and that's just one example.

If any sort of business is safe to trust, it's the one-man-shop owner-operator kind of business and you can only trust those guys insofar as you can trust any other person at all. In that case you have to consider it on a case-by-case basis.

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by bithead on Friday February 10, 2023 @10:54AM (#34741290)
Not trusting corporations is possibly the best advice available. I used to work for the largest insurer on Earth, a "health insurance" company. They quit paying for my insulin, which I need to live. They have enough lawyers they could just pile them physically on my house and suffocate me. They then laid me off due to age. My group of layoffs was 155, and of those 17 were under 40. They did give me a pile of cash not to sue - which I took like the opportunistic bastard I am in the end.
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by hn_go_brrrrr on Friday February 10, 2023 @10:55AM (#34741328)
> Never trust any company with a PR department at all

So you're saying we should trust Twitter? :)

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by LarryMullins on Friday February 10, 2023 @10:59AM (#34741385)
Heh, but what is Elon, if not a one-man PR department?
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by dcow on Friday February 10, 2023 @12:33PM (#34742854)
One man department. Such praise.
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by LarryMullins on Friday February 10, 2023 @01:17PM (#34743465)
To say that a man is a PR department is the most grave of insults.
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by paledot on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:46AM (#34762778)
To Elon Musk or to PR departments?
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by mannykannot on Friday February 10, 2023 @10:37AM (#34741021)
The difficulty of verifying the claim is not somehow a justification for making it - quite the opposite, in fact.

As it happens, there is something that would help, though if and only if they can do it: Explain what evidence they would have if the breach had occurred.

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by genmud on Friday February 10, 2023 @01:32PM (#34743698)
Having worked professionally in security and incident response for 15+ years now, this take is not just spot on, but might be overly optimistic.

I can't tell you how many large, well known companies I have worked with that either intentionally mislead, downplay, obscure or straight up lie in these types of notifications.

I have had legal teams tell me that they don't have to notify customers of a breach because an event happened on their test/dev systems, or a developer was compromised and not their actual service.

I have had companies intentionally not give information (like what an attacker was able to exfiltrate from a particular set of customers) that would been extremely helpful to inform or assess their risk. Instead they put out a generic "sophisticated attacker compromised our system, but no credentials or PII from our application were stolen".

Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by fsociety on Saturday February 11, 2023 @12:26AM (#34749847)
Having talked with some folks who have been around the block in their career.. it is a pessimistic statement but sadly it is often true.
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by suslik on Friday February 10, 2023 @09:12AM (#34739773)
Maybe I missed that - did they misreport anything? I know they royally fucked up, put they didn't really hide the fact that the (encrypted) vault data was stolen.
Re:Reddit Confirms It Was Hacked–Recommends Users Set Up 2FA by TallGuyShort on Friday February 10, 2023 @09:19AM (#34739881)
After their initial announcement, they updated the same post after months as they had since discovered it was worse. And in some cases it turns out the vault data was not as encrypted as they had ever said. Here's one of the better write-ups I've seen: https://palant.info/2022/12/26/whats-in-a-pr-statement-lastp...