News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by SimonPStevens on Thursday February 09, 2023 @03:19PM (#34730765)
Bills like this keep coming back.

Can we instead look to pass the opposite? A bill that marks the right to use private encryption as a fundamental right?

Is that kind of thing possible?

Where or how would I support such an activity?

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by seanw444 on Thursday February 09, 2023 @03:36PM (#34731010)
I treat it as an arm. I wield it for defensive purposes the same way I concealed carry for defensive purposes. And in the US, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. At least in theory.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by notch898a on Thursday February 09, 2023 @04:13PM (#34731553)
Encryption is far more dangerous than a gun, it's more like a nuke. You can't individually bypass the entire US or UK government with a gun but you can reasonably expect to do it with strong encryption executed well.

You could use the same hocus-pocus people use to explain why say a surface to air missile isn't "arms" to explain why encryption isn't "speech", and honestly it'd probably be easier to do with the latter.

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by l33t233372 on Thursday February 09, 2023 @04:25PM (#34731741)
Encryption is not a weapon of mass destruction.

I can’t point encryption at you and end your life.

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by notch898a on Thursday February 09, 2023 @04:31PM (#34731808)
It's an analogy. I readily acknowledge one doesn't directly die from speech (of course both speech and guns can be instrumental in killing).

gun:nuke

plaintext:encrypted

If nukes, which are arms, can be banned under 2A -- why can't encrypted speech be banned under the 1A? I mean hell the 1A can even ban materials of 'prurient interest' which as far as I can tell a picture of a naked woman isn't going directly to kill anyone either.

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by seanw444 on Thursday February 09, 2023 @05:40PM (#34732730)
Nukes can't be banned in the current state of the 2A. But societal norms and expectations (the culture) have now superseded the Constitution, and amending it isn't necessary.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by kelseyfrog on Thursday February 09, 2023 @06:34PM (#34733317)
I'm sorry, but let me get this straight. You're implying that 18 U.S. Code § 832[1] is unconstitutional?

1. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/832

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by ninjagoo on Thursday February 09, 2023 @06:54PM (#34733504)
> You're implying that 18 U.S. Code § 832[1] is unconstitutional?

That reads as applying when providing nuclear support to a foreign terrorist power. Technically not incompatible with OP's interpretation, which would presumably be for domestic use.

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by kelseyfrog on Thursday February 09, 2023 @09:08PM (#34734786)
How it is compatible with "shall not be infringed"? It sounds like an infringement.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by notch898a on Thursday February 09, 2023 @09:56PM (#34735089)
(a) seems likely constitutional as it appears to only restrict those who are not the people inside the united states from bearing nukes. It is "an infringement" but not one of the ability of "the people" of the United States to keep and bear nukes.

Domestically people attributed to be "terrorists" can legally buy and be sold arms (see the terrorist screening center list and TSC no-fly list, the people on there can buy guns inside the US if not otherwise prohibited persons). That is someone on the terrorist list at the TSC can walk into a gun store and pass the background check no problem, and be sold a gun domestically.

(c) I would argue, from a strict reading of the constitution, is unconstitutional as it bans mere possession domestically of nukes. I could be misreading that section though. IMO there really should be constitutional amendment of the second to clearly ban nukes and possibly some other WMDs. As a bonus once all that stuff is spelled out it will give a lot less ammunition for people to hold the second amendment hostage by saying "well we have to interpret it creatively because we'll all be living on a radioactive sheet of glass if we don't."

note: entertainment and not legal advice

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by johnmaguire on Thursday February 09, 2023 @06:44PM (#34733410)
I don't think that's right. There are many exceptions to the 2A, such as the classic example of a sawed off shotgun.

[1] https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/usao-ut/legacy/2...

[2] https://books.google.com/books?id=CmPKNI2z5-AC&q=heller+%22n...

edit to add - per [1] above, 18 USC § 922(k), (o) & (v); 26 USC § 5861 specifically prohibits "KNOWINGLY POSSESS OR MANUFACTURE [...] E. Destructive device" which is defined as:

> A “destructive device” includes any explosive, incendiary or poison gas --- (i)bomb; (ii) grenade or (iii) similar device, or any combination of parts designed or intended to be converted into a destructive device, or from which a destructive device may be readily assembled. Does not include black powder or antique type firearms. 18 USC §921(3).

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by notch898a on Thursday February 09, 2023 @07:04PM (#34733615)
The highlight sentences text of [2] talked about WHO was banned from owning arms, not what.

[1] Is just so bad I'm pretty sure it was written by a drunk child (admittedly the intelligence level of most government employees), I would not trust this document AT ALL. It's egregiously wrong. You can own sawed off shotguns with a tax stamp (in fact it was written in law as a tax because they thought they had no constitutional right to ban them). It also says idiotic things like you can't own a gun without a serial number (WTF, a ton of early 20th century guns don't even have these).

Now I know some of you will say "but notch, if you have to get a stamp it's a privilege not a right." And I'll explain to you why that's wrong. If you're allowed to have it, they have to give you the stamp. If you're not? Oh you're gonna love this -- if you're not THEN THEY CAN'T PROSECUTE YOU FOR NOT HAVING THE STAMP. Self incrimination. That's right, if you're a criminal you don't legally need the stamp! Only law abiding people have to get it, and hey if you don't theyll just make you a felon so you don't have to get it the next time!

It also uses "transported across strate line" to establish federal jurisdiction which is just straight up 100% wrong, it doesn't need to do that as feds will happily prosecute an item even DIY made in the same state (see conviction of kettler). I actually lost track because it seemed like almost everything I read there was wrong. I hope whoever wrote that has a nice job collecting quarters from the parking meters or something now, because I wouldn't trust them with much else.

Note: this is entertainment and not legal advice. Seek a lawyer before acting in your own individual circumstance.

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by xboxnolifes on Thursday February 09, 2023 @04:28PM (#34731773)
Encryption is less a nuke and more an impenetrable bunker. I can't drop encryption on someone and kill them, but it can keep people safe.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by Cyphase on Friday February 10, 2023 @12:24AM (#34735946)
There are, and there is ongoing discussion of, body armor bans. Apologies, don't have time to cite sources now, but you can do a search and find things.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by seanw444 on Friday February 10, 2023 @02:05AM (#34736581)
Correct. I believe New York has, or is attempting to, ban body armor.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by somerandomqaguy on Friday February 10, 2023 @02:31AM (#34736773)
In Canada, the provinces of Alberta and BC require a permit to purchase and wear body armor. That said for Alberta the law only came into force in 2015 or so. Before AFAIK there were no restrictions.

https://www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca/civix/document/id/complete/stat...

https://open.alberta.ca/publications/b04p8

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by kmeisthax on Thursday February 09, 2023 @04:15PM (#34731590)
"Once they get complacent, we bust out the 2nd Amendment." https://xkcd.com/504/
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by seanw444 on Thursday February 09, 2023 @05:42PM (#34732756)
There really is an XKCD for everything. I love it.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by sirsinsalot on Thursday February 09, 2023 @06:21PM (#34733180)
Given the murder rate, mass shooting rate, incarceration per capita and domestic violence involving firearms in the US ... I'm not sure drawing that parallel is as convincing an argument for safeguarding encryption as you think.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by alphanullmeric on Thursday February 09, 2023 @09:09PM (#34734794)
Europeans and the redistribution of consequences, they go together like bread and butter.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by _-david-_ on Thursday February 09, 2023 @10:36PM (#34735307)
It is a perfect example. Guns are sometimes used for bad things just like encryption. Encryption, just like guns, are a right regardless.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by sirsinsalot on Friday February 10, 2023 @03:36AM (#34737136)
My point is, guns are not a good example of "bad things happen rarely when people have things capable or badness"
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by seanw444 on Friday February 10, 2023 @10:42AM (#34741093)
That wasn't the point anyways. Bad things happen a lot regardless of if the tools are available. The point is that you should be able to stop it with equal capability, not be intentionally handicapped.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by sirsinsalot on Friday February 10, 2023 @03:38AM (#34737152)
For the avoidance of doubt, my point isn't that the parallel drawn is poor ... just that if we're selling the idea of "good outweighs the potential bad" then guns are not a good example for selling that angle.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday February 09, 2023 @03:38PM (#34731045)
I'm not sure about the UK but the US has the 4th Amendment to the Constitution which theoretically[0] provides this sort of protection.

[0] Unfortunately, only in theory considering how often attacks against that protection are made by US policymakers.

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by kmeisthax on Thursday February 09, 2023 @04:16PM (#34731604)
After Dobbs v. Jackson I'm not so sure on the implied right of privacy anymore, given that such a right was the foundation of Roe v. Wade.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday February 09, 2023 @04:31PM (#34731812)
I believe the defendant in that case argued with the 14th amendment:

> (1) First, the Court reviews the standard that the Court’s cases have used to determine whether the Fourteenth Amendment’s reference to “liberty” protects a particular right.

https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/21pdf/19-1392_6j37.pdf

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by jasonfarnon on Thursday February 09, 2023 @08:49PM (#34734605)
the "right to privacy" has nothing to do with the search and seizure-type privacy right. the first is a warren court-era development, patched together from due process, "penumbrae" etc., the second is grounded in the 4th amendment.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by idiotsecant on Thursday February 09, 2023 @04:49PM (#34732041)
Everyone's a strict constructionist until they get to the part of the constitution they don't like.

Fundamentally if we're ok with weakening some amendments through interpretation short of constitutional convention we should resign ourselves to the idea that we are weakening all of them.

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by notch898a on Thursday February 09, 2023 @05:45PM (#34732795)
Kind of a moot point what you or I or even the majority think. The unelected judges decide the interpretations, and the courts decided the bill of rights are nuked because almost everything is interstate commerce a la Wickard v Filburn and the New Deal etc.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by gpderetta on Thursday February 09, 2023 @04:49PM (#34732042)
In the UK no parliament can bind future parliaments, so, from a purely procedural point of view, any law can be overturned with another law.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by SimonPStevens on Thursday February 09, 2023 @06:14PM (#34733107)
Feels like we need something more than just a national bill.

Something like the European Convention on Human Rights, ratified into local law by each country. That would be much harder politically to overturn by the next parliament.

Can't see it happening though.

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by moremetadata on Thursday February 09, 2023 @07:09PM (#34733659)
It doesnt matter what laws exist if the public, starting at primary school, are not taught the law, not even a TLDR. Its just virtue signalling.

And if you are not taught law, how can anyone claim to live in a democracy to debate the laws?

Everybody is born into a legal dictatorship if you weren't taught law and with todays communication technology, there is no excuse for it. Its just setting people up to be victims of crime especially kids, its a criminal way to make people dependent on employees of the state who claim to be picking up the pieces.

Secondly employees of the state are treated as superior to members of the public by the courts, which makes me think the legal system isn't fit for purpose here in the UK.

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by h0p3 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:33AM (#34761416)
The same is clearly true of economics and philosophy as well.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by akomtu on Thursday February 09, 2023 @03:43PM (#34731110)
That would mean you have more power than the house of lords that runs the country. And if you had so much power, it would beg the question why they own all the land and you own none. In practice it takes a "humble king" to create freedom: someone strong enough to rule, but humble enough to give up that power to an elected senate.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by notch898a on Thursday February 09, 2023 @04:04PM (#34731439)

  95. It is said that we live in a free society because we have a certain number of constitutionally guaranteed rights. But these are not as important as they seem. The degree of personal freedom that exists in a society is determined more by the economic and technological structure of the society than by its laws or its form of government. [16] Most of the Indian nations of New England were monarchies, and many of the cities of the Italian Renaissance were controlled by dictators. But in reading about these societies one gets the impression that they allowed far more personal freedom than our society does. In part this was because they lacked efficient mechanisms for enforcing the ruler's will: There were no modern, well-organized police forces, no rapid long-distance communications, no surveillance cameras, no dossiers of information about the lives of average citizens. Hence it was relatively easy to evade control.
Some people would be shocked to see who wrote that, but he had a point. It's not the humble king, it's the ineffective king that breeds freedom.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by idiotsecant on Thursday February 09, 2023 @04:51PM (#34732063)
yes, sometime brutal, insane murderers can be right. But they're still brutal, insane murderers. Not saying that you're making any other point, but this particular case hits home for me and worship of this particular piece of slime is rife in these kinds of threads.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by notch898a on Thursday February 09, 2023 @04:55PM (#34732116)
I don't like the guy, he's just one of the few people that have articulated the point succinctly in modern English. I'm open to other authors / quotes.

I mean I discuss the writings of haber creating the haber-basch process too, but I think it'd be weird for people to constantly point out how that's improper to cite a guy who spent much of his time creating and distributing chemical weapons.

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by SimonPStevens on Thursday February 09, 2023 @06:07PM (#34733047)
This is a quote from the Unabomber's manifesto for those who aren't aware.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by nine_k on Thursday February 09, 2023 @04:34PM (#34731851)
I love the Orwellian spin on the name. War is peace. Snooping is safety.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by tguvot on Thursday February 09, 2023 @05:39PM (#34732714)
Supporting this type of activity(and other types) was discussed back in 2010: https://www.theonion.com/american-people-hire-high-powered-l...
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by H4ZB7 on Thursday February 09, 2023 @06:35PM (#34733325)
the fact that such a proposal can even fly shows how broken every country is. none of them care the slightest about the freedom they so boast. banning encryption makes absolutely no sense, it's like banning whispering. or banning having a conversation and not going and writing it down after in case a police needs to audit it. the literal only reason it makes sense is when you watch a hollywood movie and you think encryption actually means something else like firing missiles. the problem is there are about 100x too many unneeded people in justice, and on top of that its half controlled by corpos who think you should go to jail for 100 years for bypassing [1] their copyright protection to decrease their losses by 0.0000000000001%, all while being a CURRENT_YEAR dogshit company like LG or Samsung or EA or Epic that produces absolutely nothing of value but has large capital

1. again, one of their key reasoning points is always that they saw a hollywood movie and they think copy protection circumvention means something else like being a ninja running into a building and quickly killing 3 people with a katana

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by hackererror404 on Friday February 10, 2023 @09:54AM (#34740420)
It's far too easy to sell the common person on "bad people bad". Explaining to the common person why they should care about encryption and how bad people can and will exploit any hole in that encryption is far more nuanced.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by notch898a on Friday February 10, 2023 @12:27PM (#34742741)
Common person doesn't need to be sold, just told to follow the rule and as long as the food drink gasoline keeps coming they'll follow the orders.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by wrycoder on Thursday February 09, 2023 @08:47PM (#34734583)
Just keep voting until you win. Then you stop.
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by developer93 on Saturday February 11, 2023 @12:32PM (#34754340)
Takes a bit more than voting I'm afraid. "The price of freedom is eternal vigilance".
Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by EarlKing on Thursday February 09, 2023 @09:46PM (#34735021)
There are no fundamental rights in the UK, just privileges contingent on the blessings of His Majesty's government.

This is why America fought a war of independence against them.

Re:The UK's Online Safety Bill: An Attack on Encryption by NikkiA on Friday February 10, 2023 @06:35PM (#34747551)
> Is that kind of thing possible?

Not in the UK because of parliamentry authority, no. A law cannot be made that binds future parliament from being able to undo it, thus 'fundamental rights' cannot be legislated.