News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by hanoz on Thursday February 02, 2023 @08:02PM (#34635737)
The very notion of fact-checked seems deeply politicised these days and instantly raises my suspicions about the agenda of the checker. It's not like the old days of Snopes categorising memes and urban legends, but more often than not some vested interest out to rubbish dissent.
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by ggm on Thursday February 02, 2023 @08:57PM (#34636194)
That in itself, is but an opinion. You didn't hide it was an opinion, but that is in the end, all it is.

I on the other hand, have another opinion. It is often important to have people who have contextual knowledge stand up and say "that input claiming to be fact is in fact (hah) rubbish" and the politicisation here, is because a very specific arc of engagement is CONSCIOUSLY intruding "fake news" as a tactical approach to dealing with it's concerns.

That it overwhelmingly becomes labelled as a left-right or big-oil/green split, or Russia/Everyone-else or Trump/Biden.. is also something to reflect on.

Exxon (as an example) had material facts to hand, in the 1970s regarding the future impact of CO2 and they made a decision (however informally or not) to surpress those facts, and participate in greenwashing messages, despite the consequences. Now, we could dive into a debate of the form "thats a lie! thats fake news" or not. I don't much care.

In context, I think it informs the quality of the question "is fact checking important" and "is it political" and "is it just about rubbishing dissent"

I think it is important.

I think it is very political.

I do not think it is just about rubbishing dissent.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by jay_kyburz on Thursday February 02, 2023 @11:27PM (#34637145)
My startup idea, that if often laughed out of the room, it to develop a news site that separates events from the commentary on those events.

On the left hand side of the page is a list of "testimony" of events. Who said what happened and when, along with any supporting evidence such as photos or video. (Without a journalist interpreting or crafting a story)

On the right hand side of the page is commentary from interesting folks from both the left and right. (Pulling together the testimony, looking for insight, greater meaning, or identifying trends. )

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by ggm on Friday February 03, 2023 @01:57AM (#34637997)
It's a nice idea, noting modern cohorts would include denials of the factuality.
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by fzeroracer on Thursday February 02, 2023 @09:19PM (#34636352)
People always focus on the agenda of the 'fact-checker' in these arguments, but never seem to focus on the agenda of the 'fact-checked'. This isn't to say that said fact checkers are always correct because people can always double back and issue a counter argument, but rather that it's easy for people to just post nonsense and run, leaving it to fester if uncontested.

For example, there's been multiple incidents of that here on HN where people post something that's incorrect by all definitions. It statistically does not align with reality. The best way to counter the deluge of low effort, low accuracy claims is with a medium-effort, medium-accuracy source. Usually in these cases the poster simply vanishes because they did not intend to actually follow up a factual counterclaim.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by dylan604 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @09:38PM (#34636471)
> The best way to counter the deluge of low effort, low accuracy claims is with a medium-effort, medium-accuracy source.

except we now live in a world with phrases like alternative facts. if someone doesn't want to believe in something because it does not align with their ideals, then you will not be able to convince them regardless of how incontrovertible your facts may be. sure, the more "solid" the fact, the more bizarre the counter is, but there will always be a counter.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by ricardobeat on Thursday February 02, 2023 @09:41PM (#34636487)
Such an odd thing to experience. I didn't think this would be possible ten, twenty years ago, but portions of the population have developed an ability to completely dismiss factual information, even when they can easily verify it by themselves in a couple minutes.

And it's not even the 'how many died in WW2' kind of data, but simple public records like 'tax revenue for 2020', 'road accidents in october'.

It's as if being able to find information so easily, has made it less trustworthy. Being flooded with fake and twisted news certainly feels like one of the causes.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by dylan604 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:39PM (#34636853)
less trustworthy than who though?

there are certain people that whole heartily believe that what the person on their TV is telling them is without a doubt true. anyone trying to convince them otherwise is just part of the opposing forces. even when shown where, for example the fox news hosts, have admitted in sworn testimony the did not believe the big lie and knew it to be false, it is rebutted as fake.

Fake News and Alternative Facts have to be the worst combinations I've ever known. they may even be some of the most dangerous as well.

it's classic cult control. when i was a kid being forced to weekly attendance at my mom's church, it was often heard that you can't go listening to other preachers, reading other books of thought, or similar as that's the enemy's weapon to confuse you and tempt you away. as i got older and actually started paying attention, these things really started sounding like nails on a chalkboard. it wasn't just the one church either.

so by only listening to the one source and ignoring all others, they are actually doing good by what they have been told. those of us reading multiple sources are just twisting in the wind so to speak with no real convictions (or some such as i've been told).

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by maybejustmaybet on Thursday February 02, 2023 @11:35PM (#34637190)
Reflective Equilibrium might have something to do with.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reflective_equilibrium

One could alter the perception of the "facts" in order to feel comfortable about them.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by fzeroracer on Thursday February 02, 2023 @09:43PM (#34636498)
The point isn't necessarily to change their opinion because you're right, ultimately they'll often contort their argument into any way they can.

It's more to show others that they're incorrect for XYZ reasons and to prevent that detritus from accumulating. Over time if you just let them post without counters or some form of moderation eventually it becomes the norm.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by softsound on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:41AM (#34637556)
The problem with people psychology wise is arguments tend to reinforce their own beliefs of being right. Arguing can get to the emotional core of people and logic and emotion don't often play well together being on opposite sides of the brain. Dominance and the desire to be right can make people feel more correct in their own head even if it's illogical, because it's safe and feels good being a winner. Unlike regular open discussion where both parties are more flexible and winning to change sides, arguments rarely will change sides as few people are willing to put in the effort to look at their "enemies" perspective.

The best way to counter any claim is with openness, empathy and the ability to be wrong. That is how you change minds, don't let emotions separate you. Granted that is far easier said then done as I may disagree with someone then they often turn to insults if they think "I've turned against them" because I may have a different opinion. Some people have such high defense you really can't get through to them.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by luckylion on Thursday February 02, 2023 @09:48PM (#34636536)
Fact-checkers take on a quasi-official role though, a kind of information police that has special trust bestowed on them. We typically hold the police to a higher standard than we do those they interact with. Why wouldn't we also do this with professional and/or official fact-checkers?
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by dmonitor on Friday February 03, 2023 @02:01AM (#34638027)
the fact-checker could also be the person who is just flat out wrong, though. Just ban/block the OP (for spreading misinformation, obviously) so they can’t respond and put a big flag next to their post labeling it misinformation.
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by dsfyu404ed on Friday February 03, 2023 @07:46AM (#34640360)
>The best way to counter the deluge of low effort, low accuracy claims is with a medium-effort, medium-accuracy source.

That's not an effective counter at least as far as my observation goes.

These jerks win not by backing up their asinine claims with sources. They win by diverting everyone else's energy away from debating their asinine claims to making the debate one of sources. Heck, a good chunk of the time they do it you don't even need to find other sources because they're just using junk journalism where the title says A but the article says B. If being "proven wrong" was actually detrimental to their causes they would modify their behavior.

I'm sure one of our resident link-spewers will be along shortly to disagree with me and then edit his comment five times adding subsequent links to garbage that nominally back up his assertion...

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by drewrv on Thursday February 02, 2023 @09:42PM (#34636491)
The reason "fact-checked" seems political is because there is a movement among the American right to discredit any job that involves seeking or explaining the truth. I may come across as hyperbolic but I'm serious: name a job where you try to sort out what's true and what isn't, and American right-wing trolls will accuse it of bias.

Scientist? Journalist? Professor? Librarian? Doctor? It was only a matter of time before "fact-checker" got the same treatment as these other people. None of these people or careers are beyond reproach, but there is a difference between good-faith attempts at finding the truth and bad-faith accusations of bias.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by hervature on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:06PM (#34636655)
I don't get it, are you insinuating that "the American right" don't like scientists, journalists, professors, librarians, and doctors? You may want to evaluate your echo chamber if you believe this personification of 150M people. I say that as a Canadian living in the US and is perpetually confused by what each side says about the other.
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by danielheath on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:28PM (#34636784)
Exactly as stated, verbatim: there is a movement within it.

That’s not the same as describing them as a monolithic group who all act that way.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by drewrv on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:52PM (#34636932)
Journalists: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/19/business/media/trump-medi...

Scientists: https://www.breitbart.com/environment/2023/01/23/woke-lancet...

Professors: https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/just-how-liberal-are-c...

Librarians: https://nypost.com/2022/09/10/librarians-go-radical-as-new-w...

Doctors: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/boston-childrens-hospit...

> are you insinuating that "the American right" don't like scientists, journalists, professors, librarians, and doctors?

I actually don't think this. I know conservatives, they will generally believe scientists who are studying black holes but when climate change gets brought up they accuse them of bias. Similarly they will seek out doctors for their condition but when a doctor treats a trans patient they will accuse them of bias. It's not a dislike, and not of individuals, it's more of a distrust of institutions.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by mlindner on Thursday February 02, 2023 @11:21PM (#34637112)
You're generalizing the loudest of the fringe to those 140M people followed by generalizing personal anecdotes to the same 140M. This is the same as trying to say that all Democrats support antifa.
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by cycomanic on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:20AM (#34637446)
The what you call "loudest of the fringe" has significant sway over the republican party one of their loonies was just appointed to the homeland security committee. A significant portion of the republican party still believes or at least gives statements that the 2020 election was stolen and even more republican refuse to denaunce them. If you continue voting for these guys you are part of the problem, some of them have openly supported literal Nazis.
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by mlindner on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:59AM (#34638905)
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by mlindner on Friday February 03, 2023 @06:07AM (#34639698)
As a general rule if anyone ever tells you that the other side is ultimate evil (jumping to "voting for these people means you're supporting Nazi supporters" is exactly that) then it's an automatic red flag that they've become completely blinded by partisanship.

As to who I'd personally vote for next election, I'm currently undecided as these things are highly nuanced. I have issues with both major parties in the US and time will still tell in which direction each develops before the next election. I don't take kindly to you trying to literally paint every single politician on the Republican side with a massive brush of "Nazi supporter". It's exactly for reasons like this that I feel it's important to continue to support them in some fashion to prevent the absolute nonsense that you're perpetuating here.

A couple of decades ago we had people wearing literal swastika arm bands goose stepping through jewish neighborhoods. We survived that perfectly fine. A lot of people seem to want to massively inflate how bad things actually are right now compared to history. Driving division in this country is one of the primary aims of foreign Russian and Chinese propaganda and one of those ways is through rabid partisanship.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by drewrv on Friday February 03, 2023 @01:22AM (#34637787)
I'm not generalizing across 140M people, I said there is a "movement among the American right". Saying "there is a movement among the left that believes ACAB" is probably true too, but we're talking about fact-checkers here not the criminal justice system.
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by somenameforme on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:42AM (#34637558)
There has been a dramatic decline in trust of institutions, regardless of political affiliation [1]. The medical system is at 38%, public schools at 28%, newspapers at 14%. These levels are so abysmally low that it's literally impossible for it to be partisan - it's global. The levels are lower than they've ever been, by far.

[1] - https://news.gallup.com/poll/394283/confidence-institutions-...

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by jjeaff on Thursday February 02, 2023 @11:21PM (#34637113)
Not the whole of the American right, but certainly Trump's core support and then some. They are very anti-all of those things and vocally so.
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by brailsafe on Thursday February 02, 2023 @09:49PM (#34636541)
Seems like a both sides sort of thing to me, especially with Twitter stuff coming out
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by splistud on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:21PM (#34636734)
A perfect demonstration of bias in action
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by tenpies on Thursday February 02, 2023 @09:54PM (#34636563)
Sure, I'll take you on one of the crown jewels that "the Right-wing Trolls" use to discredit Fact Checkers.

https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/hillary-clinton-smash-phon...

Read it.

The point of the claim is that Hillary Clinton had her phones destroyed. This is true, but the Fact Checkers cannot allow this to be true, so what is an honest Democrat-leaning Fact Checker to do?

Easy, you muddy the claim and add to it: the Right-wing Trolls aren't claiming Hillary had her phones destroyed. No, I've decided that they're claiming that she personally destroyed them with a hammer! AHA! Got you Right-wring Trolls! That's definitely not entirely true.

Verdict: MIXTURE. Clinton did not personally, with her own hands, use a hammer to destroy phones.

So you see, this is what Fact Checking is. When the truth needs to be denied, you muddy the waters, you add irrelevant details to the claim that no one really cares about, and then use those details to claim that the original statement is not true.

And look, the issue isn't that this is being done, it's that it's being presented as fact checking, which is why I distinguish between fact checking and Fact Checking.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by dtjb on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:08PM (#34636665)
That snopes article is much more reasonable than you're making it out to be.
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by drewrv on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:19PM (#34636727)
I’m not sure what you’re getting at. Is there a profession who seeks to learn or explain the truth that the American right hasn’t accused of bias?

I don’t think I’ll find the answer in an article about Hillary’s cell phone.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by jjeaff on Thursday February 02, 2023 @11:26PM (#34637132)
I can't imagine there is. Many on the right will literally accuse Fox News, Newsmax, and OAN of policial bias if a single story doesn't lean the way they feel it should.
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by __blockcipher__ on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:08PM (#34636667)
Here’s another example:

https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/blm-terrorist-rosenberg/

> In the absence of a single, universally-agreed definition of "terrorism," it is a matter of subjective determination as to whether the actions for which Rosenberg was convicted and imprisoned — possession of weapons and hundreds of pounds of explosives — should be described as acts of "domestic terrorism."

It should go without saying that there’s no single, universally agreed upon definition of anything, thus giving a convenient way to dismiss any inconvenient claims.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by dtjb on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:39PM (#34636854)
Out of curiosity what do you think they should do differently? They confirmed the subject's criminal activity immediately at the top of the article. Only after that do they talk about the definition problem, which you appear to agree with?

If this is the worst of snopes, it's underwhelming.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by throwayyy479087 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @11:09PM (#34637043)
Well she bombed federal buildings, that’s pretty clearly terrorism. They just don’t care because she’s on their side.
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by eloisius on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:36AM (#34637529)
Maybe the problem here is the boiled down ternary, true, not true, mixture. That gets further aggregated until they can same big stats like “Party X made 80% false claims” while the other party only made 20% false claims, because their false claims have been conveniently softened to “mixture.”
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by fzeroracer on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:04PM (#34636640)
Did you actually read the article you posted in question? Because it does accurately lay out the facts, disputes the claim Trump made specifically and does not exonerate her. It sounds like you're letting your world view warp what the article actually says.
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by Aunche on Thursday February 02, 2023 @11:45PM (#34637242)
Trump's tweet literally said that Hillary smashed the phones with a hammer. He already got the benefit of more engagement on a exaggerated tweet. Why shouldn't he deserve some mild pushback?
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by dmonitor on Friday February 03, 2023 @02:10AM (#34638088)
> Crooked H destroyed phones w/ hammer, 'bleached' emails, & had husband meet w/AG days before she was cleared- & they talk about obstruction?

that’s the tweet. I don’t think there’s a significant difference between “hillary smashed her phones with a hammer” and “hillary had someone smash her phone with a hammer”, especially when a 128 character limit is a factor.

I could say “I fixed my iPhone’s screen last weekend” when I really just got it replaced at an Apple store. The fact that I personally didn’t replace the screen doesn’t matter.

If the debate was “is hillary clinton strong enough to smash things with hammers” and this was used as evidence, it’d be misleading. The debate was “is hillary clinton suspicious”, and having her phones smashed with hammers is suspicious regardless of whether she did it herself or had someone else do it for her.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by vintermann on Friday February 03, 2023 @08:37AM (#34640866)
I've been a supporter of Wikileaks for many years, and I think that the idea that attacking journalists for publishing evidence is a uniquely Republican thing is disproved by what I've seen.

Most of which you won't have seen, of course.

One of the fact checkers given a prominent position on the front page of Google News is polygraph.info. Polygraph.info is run by Voice of America, official propaganda organ of the US, which was until a few years forbidden by law from targeting US citizens.

Now I ask you: do you think it was for reasons of popular pressure, or maybe market forces, that Voice of America became a featured fact-checker for Google News?

Also, do you think I could get them to fact check claims like, "The CIA considered concrete plans to assassinate Julian Assange"? You think that would ever happen, that they honestly promoted a little known fact which was deeply embarrassing to the US government?

I find no good faith there.

Maybe they have the luxury of less actual lying, because as a hegemonic propagandists, they can just stonewall when someone asks them an awkward question. Pretend they didn't hear it, because no one will report it.

Underdog propagandists like RT don't have that luxury, so it's more efficient to conjure up a shitstorm of mutually incompatible lies for them. But their role is the same.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by raffraffraff on Friday February 03, 2023 @08:42AM (#34640921)
The American right don't have the monopoly on discrediting facts or fact checkers. The left are absolutely up to their necks in it too, both in America and abroad.
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by nonethewiser on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:19PM (#34636725)
> The very notion of fact-checked seems deeply politicised these days

It's deeply politicized by nature. Fact checking is just spinning a narrative.

You cant nor should not want some publication to process information into conclusions.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by bigbluedots on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:50PM (#34636920)
Is that a fact? That is just, like, your opinion man.
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by vorpalhex on Thursday February 02, 2023 @11:09PM (#34637047)
https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/blm-terrorist-rosenberg/

> In the absence of a single, universally-agreed definition of "terrorism," it is a matter of subjective determination as to whether the actions for which Rosenberg was convicted and imprisoned — possession of weapons and hundreds of pounds of explosives — should be described as acts of "domestic terrorism."

Seems pretty political to me. Everyone here agrees that showing up with hundreds of pounds of explosives is terrorism.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by argiopetech on Thursday February 02, 2023 @11:15PM (#34637070)
"It's not like the old days..." Is an important part of GPs post. Snopes has become (or has become perceived as) more political with time as they've changed role from "urban legend debunking site" to "fact checking of contemporary goings on site."
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by schrodinger on Thursday February 02, 2023 @11:47PM (#34637252)
Is it Snope's fault or that more spam on the internet has become political?
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by zaphirplane on Friday February 03, 2023 @10:05AM (#34641934)
following charges: "Conspiracy to possess unregistered firearms, receive firearms and explosives shipped in interstate commerce while a fugitive, and unlawfully use false identification documents ...; possession of unregistered destructive devices, possession of unregistered firearm (two counts) ...; carrying explosives during commission of a felony ... ; possession with intent to unlawfully use false identification documents...; false representation of Social Security number, possession of counterfeit Social Security cards."

Why a terrorist, looks like a run of the mill armed robber, further down the article a few references to armed robberies

I fact checked you using the article you provided. I’m confused.

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by vorpalhex on Friday February 03, 2023 @10:12AM (#34642041)
What was she stealing from federal government buildings using HUNDREDS of pounds of explosives?
Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by zaphirplane on Friday February 03, 2023 @04:30PM (#34647976)
Says who is the point they make

No conviction, charges dropped, didn’t admit it

Re:Engagement with fact-checked posts on Reddit by raffraffraff on Friday February 03, 2023 @08:34AM (#34640828)
Snopes isn't even trustworthy anymore. Reddit? Ideologically slanted. It's not so much moderated as outright censored. You don't notice it most of the time, but on certain topics only one perspective is allowed. It's not just on some subs, it's the platform.