News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by antiterra on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:25PM (#34588947)
It looks like this is the incident as broadcast: https://youtu.be/-AKV57rtYfo

Also: The FCC document references the 18 Fox owned stations and says nothing about the 200+ affiliate stations. Are those stations culpable if they also broadcast Fox produced content that was in violation of EAS rules?

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by capableweb on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:42PM (#34589113)
So just so I don't misunderstand, it is illegal to reproduce that sound? Just for TV or in general, literally illegal tones? Seems to be just two tones put together (853 and 960 Hz), weird if you could make such a thing illegal.

According to what I can find, it's missing something called a SAME header that the tones are supposed to be prefixed by, maybe that's why FOX thought they could get away with it?

Edit: For clarification, the particular message that needs o be sent to be considered "Emergency Broadcast" is not just the "Attention signal", it's has many other vital parts (like the header in the message that it begins with). Besides that, the Attention Signal has to be at least 8 seconds long as long, otherwise I'm assuming it should be considered one. The one FOX broadcasted seems to have been ~3 seconds.

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by MBCook on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:48PM (#34589172)
I would assume it’s illegal on public airwaves when not an actual emergency where EAS was activated.

This makes sense because advertisers could misuse it to grab attention (exactly as Fox did) and cause people to start to ignore the sound due to false signals.

Just like it’s usually illegal to have lights and sirens on your car.

I’d be interested in the story of how this happened. How did no one say “that’s probably not a good idea”? Even without knowing the law existed?

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by throwanem on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:35PM (#34589647)
> I would assume it’s illegal on public airwaves when not an actual emergency where EAS was activated.

Correct. CFR Title 17, Part 11 [1] specifies the technical and operational aspects of EAS. Section 45:

> No person may transmit or cause to transmit the EAS codes or Attention Signal, or a recording or simulation thereof, in any circumstance other than in an actual National, State or Local Area emergency or authorized test of the EAS. Broadcast station licensees should also refer to §73.1217 of this chapter.

[1] https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2010-title47-vol1/pd...

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by brewdad on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:40PM (#34591214)
Would setting this as my ringtone count as a transmission if I’m out in public or does this only apply to licensed broadcasters utilizing assigned frequencies?
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by throwanem on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @04:17AM (#34593034)
The latter.

I actually do use a ringtone composed of three SAME headers and the attention signal; specifically, I use that ringtone for PagerDuty. It reliably raises me from the dead in the correct state of mind to respond to an alert, and also reliably turns heads when it goes off while I'm out and about. But I don't need to worry that the FCC's gonna come after me about it, as long as I don't have my phone plugged into a radio station when it goes off.

That said, if I were doing a radio interview or something, I'd be sure to turn off my phone or at least remove PagerDuty's ability to override the silent switch.

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by dekhn on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:47PM (#34589161)
It's obviously more complicated than that. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_Alert_System#Tone_us...
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by dbcurtis on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:55PM (#34589240)
Two tones together are not illegal in general. However... think about 1950's cold-war era technology, and how much you could do with it. One of the conditions of license of being a broadcaster was/is to listen to an upstream station, and with automated equipment, detect that tone and switch your own transmitter into emergency mode and propagate that tone pair if you are an intermediate station.

So, not illegal in general, but illegal to transmit it on broadcast channel.

I would even bet that if you searched E-Bay long enough, you could find a 1950's-era vacuum tube AM radio with tone-squelch tuned to those tones so that you could leave the radio on and just hear the duck-and-cover message without the distraction of that nasty Rock-n-Roll music that the kids are all listening to.

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by kstrauser on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:05PM (#34589359)
They didn't play the tones through the announcements, though, did they? I don't remember them doing that. Wouldn't it need to be continuous for tone squelch to work?
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by throwanem on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:53PM (#34589834)
They do not. An EAS message broadcast begins with a SAME header, which is followed by iirc about 30 seconds of the attention signal and then a verbal description of the alert (with onscreen text for TV broadcasts). After that, the message broadcast concludes with a SAME footer.

The SAME header and footer are each repeated three times, and consist of BFSK-modulated data on a couple of frequencies I forget offhand. (If you're interested, they're specified in Section 31 of the regulation I linked elsewhere in this thread.) The header encodes the type and geographical applicability of the alert, and EAS receivers configured for the applicable area use it to automatically interrupt broadcast with the bulk of the alert. The SAME footer encodes no data but serves as an "end of message" flag; EAS receivers can use that to resume normal broadcast depending on configuration and the nature of the alert. (Sufficiently severe alerts may be repeated in entirety.)

CONELRAD didn't use any in-band signaling of this type, in any case. The technology wasn't really there for it, and in any case the whole point of the scheme was not to continue transmitting from any one station for a significant length of time, in order to deny Soviet bombers navigation references which would help them drop nuclear bombs on American cities.

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by throwanem on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:50PM (#34589795)
You're probably thinking of CONELRAD, the predecessor of the Emergency Broadcast System, which itself predeceased EAS. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/CONELRAD
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by humanistbot on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:12PM (#34589420)
It is illegal to reproduce that sound on US public airwaves in a non-emergency context.

There are two syllables in English such that if you shout them in sequence in a crowded theater in a non-emergency context, it is also a crime: fi-re.

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by astrange on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:37PM (#34589663)
It's legal to do that. That remark comes from a side comment in an overturned SCOTUS case prosecuting someone for protesting the draft.
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by sokoloff on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @03:11AM (#34592598)
It never occurred to me that fire might be two syllables, but I guess it is “PHI-ur”.
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by kube-system on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:58PM (#34589271)
There are rules that must be followed when using licensed spectrum. Breaking one of those rules comes with consequences.

The tones aren’t illegal. Misusing public emergency infrastructure is illegal.

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by colechristensen on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:01PM (#34589303)
It is, more or less, illegal to broadcast the sound if you fall under the regulation of the FCC. You can put it in a movie and play it in a theater, you can play it on your stereo, put it on YouTube, etc. Basically you aren't allowed to distribute it over channels where the real alerts are distributed.
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by jacquesm on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:30PM (#34589006)
No low that advertisers won't stoop to, apparently. Incredible that they thought this was a good idea and that nobody put a stop to it. Maybe they figured that whatever the penalty they'll make it up in sales?
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by antiterra on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:41PM (#34589094)
It seems incredibly boneheaded like some production team possibly didn’t even know these tones were still a real & serious thing. Whatever oversight existed around content also completely failed.

If there was evidence that the creators actually did a calculation to determine that the base fine of $144,000 was worth it, that’d be a nightmare for them

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by duxup on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:45PM (#34589141)
Yeah there had to be an adult along the line who said "guys this is a bad idea, these tones are for real emergencies".
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by ryandrake on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:25PM (#34589564)
You'd be surprised at what happens in a lot of companies, totally open loop, with no adult in the room to advise caution. Especially when all you're thinking about is "Lumbergh said this is my last chance--I gotta hit my marketing numbers this quarter or I'm out of a job!"
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by scotty79 on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:03PM (#34589334)
> ... didn’t even know these tones were still a real & serious thing.

Why are they though?

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by Retric on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:18PM (#34589487)
Many people have a TV or radio on as background noise.

Even a minute warning for things tornadoes etc can save lives, but this only works if people associated these sounds with significant issues and start paying attention.

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by Waterluvian on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:37PM (#34589065)
I think it’s more thoughtlessness than anything. It’s not like those times that Hanes Underwear played the “brown noise” on AM radio. What a commute that was.
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by bagels on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:40PM (#34589088)
Is this a joke?
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by Waterluvian on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:42PM (#34589110)
The brown noise is just an urban legend.

But I’m confident that FOX isn’t calculating the trade-off for a fine. I think they just had an advertising contractor who didn’t know any better. Thought it was a cool angle for an ad.

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by ibejoeb on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:52PM (#34589200)
I'm not even sure if there's a car audio system that could reproduce that range.
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by jacquesm on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:52PM (#34589816)
It's just DTMF I don't see why not. The base frequencies are all around the 1 KHz band which even the most boneheaded amp + speaker implementation should be able to reproduce.
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by throwanem on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:56PM (#34589859)
I think the question is whether a car stereo could reproduce the so-called "brown note", which as I recall is supposedly somewhere around 12Hz.

SAME BFSK uses frequencies iirc between 1 and 2 kHz, and the attention signal is an equal mix of 853 and 960 hertz.

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by jacquesm on Monday January 30, 2023 @09:08PM (#34589970)
Ah yes, you are right. Indeed, that's way lower than any stereo other than the weird ones that some kids build into the backs of their cars (note to self: do not lend your car out to junior employees that like subsonics, hi R. I know you're reading HN).

Besides that, those would be filtered out on the transmitter end long before they were allowed to modulate the signal. Especially AM transmitters may do some pretty wild stuff when you drive them with frequencies that low, fair chance that you'll find that you hold them 'on' long enough that you're going to find the limits of either the power supply or the cooling system.

Both on the high end (5KHz and up in theory, but more like 3KHz in practice) and on the low end (100Hz in theory, but you can go as low as 50 Hz in practice).

So I highly doubt that story is true.

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by neodypsis on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:45PM (#34589138)
Why does it look like it was made in the 80s?
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by renewiltord on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:49PM (#34589186)
It's supposed to imitate this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rF4BCMs-8BE
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by scotty79 on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:08PM (#34589388)
It doesn't explain why 2011 invention looks like 1960 jank.
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by worthless-trash on Monday January 30, 2023 @09:00PM (#34589892)
Its probably a combination of "this shouldnt look like regular tv" and "This needs to work reliably in really crappy situations".

The font also looks like the subtitles that some local teletex stations used to use. I wonder how much of that broadcast is teletex/subtitle aligned to work well.

If it had some smooth jazz with helvetica playing in the background I wouldn't take it seriously. That EAS font (to me a foreigner) screams "This isn't daytime television".

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by sokoloff on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @03:21AM (#34592660)
Amusing that that alert for Washington DC has an “effective until” time in mm/dd/yy format and in Pacific Standard Time (3 hours behind DC’s Eastern Standard Time).
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by duxup on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:55PM (#34589238)
Holy smokes yeah that sounds just like the EAS tones. We can't be desensitizing folks to legitimate emergency announcements.

Fine them to high heaven.

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by scotty79 on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:04PM (#34589351)
When was the last legitimate emergency of this kind?
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by dgacmu on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:38PM (#34589671)
Thousands of times per year, localized to the city or county level, mostly for weather (tornado, hurricane, etc.)
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by MBCook on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:29PM (#34589604)
Millions of people in the Midwest hear it every year during tornado season.
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by dave78 on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:16PM (#34589466)
Our governor (ab)used the EAS system to announce COVID lockdowns.

The false Hawaii missile warning comes to mind too.

Somewhat interesting is that I don't think they were used on 9/11.

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by throwanem on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:58PM (#34589873)
I don't know of anything in the relevant regulation that would prohibit a statewide EAS activation for a public health emergency.
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by scotty79 on Monday January 30, 2023 @09:23PM (#34590066)
Other comments links to video of when it was first introduced and tested. It's from November 2011
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by dave78 on Monday January 30, 2023 @09:32PM (#34590118)
No, EAS was rolled out in 1997, and it replaced the very similar EBS which was from the 60s. 2011 is just the first time they actually attempted a nationwide alert, which was always a capability but had never been used to that point.
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by palmscenter on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @10:46AM (#34596564)
Wireless Emergency Alerts use the same tones, but didn’t exist on 9/11. EAS did exist, but the alerts are supposed to include the protective action to be taken. What protective action would you have recommended the public take? And since broadcast news widely covered the attacks, what contribution would an EAS alert make?
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by anigbrowl on Monday January 30, 2023 @09:47PM (#34590211)
Severe weather, earthquakes, child abduction in your local area
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by cookingrobot on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @12:44AM (#34591650)
I was driving recently and the alert came on in the middle of the DJ talking. It turns out it was “just a test”, but I’ve always heard a pre-warning before, so having it just interrupt the show was pretty startling. I was honestly a little bit panicked. I think my priors have been adjusted, and now I’ll assume the alerts are just a test by default.
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by palmscenter on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @10:40AM (#34596473)
“The FCC document references the 18 Fox owned stations and says nothing about the 200+ affiliate stations.”

Im fact the FCC mentions the affiliates several times. One example: “Therefore, we find FOX responsible for broadcasting the Promotional Segment containing the EAS Tones on 18 of its owned-and-operated broadcast stations, transmitting the Promotional Segment to 190 of its network-affiliated television broadcast stations, and causing the transmission of the Promotional Segment on Fox Sports Radio and the Fox Sports on XM channel.”

> Are those stations culpable if they also broadcast Fox produced content that was in violation of EAS rules?

Station licensees are responsible for the content they broadcast. In this case at least the FCC went after the content source, which is itself also a licensee.