News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by raxxorraxor on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:17AM (#34517371)
I don't understand the discrepancy between EV kWh and house battery kWh.

Some cars have > 100 kWh capacity. Why do I pay > 1000$ per kWh for a house battery? At some point it is cheaper to just buy a car, even if you would never drive it. A Tesla Powerwall has 13 or so kWh? Why don't they use the car battery with nearly 10 times as much capacity?

It is just unit prices that are far better for cars? Is the charge/discharge speed relevant? Is the technology different? Are the capacities for cars just fake? Preferably I would want 200kWh or more capacity for my home.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by sgerenser on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:26AM (#34517443)
House batteries are a much smaller market than batteries for EVs (at least right now). They also have other supporting components, safety features, etc. that add to the price. Since they’re normally installed as part of a solar install, they also usually qualify for a tax credit (between federal and state this can be over 50%) which further drives up the price because the vendor is able to capture a large chunk of the tax credit as profit.
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by zihotki on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:38AM (#34517533)
Actually they require less safety features (they don't need to be crash-safe) and can use heavier batteries and components. Which should make them cheaper than EV's batteries in theory. But that market is in early stages with all associated downsides of early adoption, I agree with that.
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by boringg on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:49AM (#34517622)
There are other features for a home battery. There are shutoffs. Each job is a bit custom on the install + electrician work. Retail markup.

You can use your car battery - though you will degrade that car battery much faster which is probably the battery you want to have better performance.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by AtlasBarfed on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @10:37AM (#34519478)
That's a failure of government with home solar.

Home solar + storage adds community-level resiliency in disasters and will reduce the grid load needed for home EV charging and industrial level charging used by electric tractor trailers. It should be a major complimentary effort of governmental policy along with grid scale solar/wind, grid scale storage, and whatever load leveling we can effectively decarbonize.

Good luck getting that through our deadlocked government.

Especially since

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by discordance on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:27AM (#34517448)
$300/kWh for home storage is readily available.

E.g. https://signaturesolar.com/eg4-ll-lithium-battery-24v-200ah/

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by raxxorraxor on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:43AM (#34518120)
True, there are better prices by now. But 5kWh? I thought my smartphone would have that by now...

Perhaps 200kWh is a bit exaggerated. And yes you also need a good quality inverter for your home that synchronizes with the net, but I actually don't believe this to be expensive high tech...

Ideally I wouldn't want to put the energy I generate with solar, wind or differently back into the power net. In my country you basically give that away for free. There are reasons for that, but the most efficient way would be to use the energy yourself as much as possible.

Sure, 5kWH is enough to soften peaks and there could already be huge benefit to this. But a bit more capacity would be really nice to really safe the energy of sunny days. Reminds me if disappointing USPs that let me play Tetris for an additional 7-8 minutes before I feel like civilization has broken down completely until power comes back.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by vbezhenar on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:25AM (#34518570)
Phone battery is something like 4V. Watts depend on voltage. I guess home batteries use other voltage so their watt actually provides more electricity.
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by raxxorraxor on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:42AM (#34518778)
No, Watts should be independent of voltage, it is the product of voltage and ampere (don't know the exact English terms here). You perhaps mean ampere hours, I think that is often used for phones.

But it is only ever meaningful if you have the respective fixed voltage and it often make sense for a batteries to quickly calculate how long they should last if you know how much ampere a device draws. It could also become a sensible metric if we always talk about 120V/240V for general household appliances of course.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by beckingz on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @10:36AM (#34519471)
Voltage isn't fixed across a discharge cycle.

As a chemical battery discharges, the voltage drops, so at the same load in amps you get less watts later.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by thehappypm on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:56AM (#34518963)
I think what they’re talking about is the amp-hour measure of battery capacity, which is common in electronics, but converting to actual energy requires knowing the voltage.
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by raxxorraxor on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:51AM (#34528902)
edit: Wh is independent of voltage I mean... of course a product is dependent on its factors...
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by vbezhenar on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:22AM (#34531882)
You're right, I mangled Ah and Wh in my head, sorry. 4V 1Wh battery and 24V 1Wh batteries are equally useful.

Your numbers are a little bit off though. I just googled some power bank (which is supposedly better than smartphone). It claims to provide 20 000 mAh at 5V. So it's 20 Ah at 5V or 100 Wh. I think most smartphones are around 10-20 Wh. Far from 5 kWh. But this discrepancy was already noted in other comments.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by pjc50 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:55AM (#34518953)
Phones are more like 10-15 watt-hours, not kWh.
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by coding123 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @11:25AM (#34520254)
Those 5kwh "server" batteries are overpriced compared to prismatic cells and a bms.
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by driverdan on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @01:25PM (#34522161)
They aren't when you factor in labor and the other components involved (wiring, breakers, terminals, steel box, etc). I've built my own system in my RV but will be going with racked batteries for my house due to how much time and effort they will save.
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by mnw21cam on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @01:16PM (#34522011)
Deep cycle lead-acid batteries are available around £100/kWh, and they'll last pretty-much as long as a LiFePo if managed sensibly.
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by thescriptkiddie on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @01:38PM (#34522334)
> they'll last pretty-much as long as a LiFePo

citation needed

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by sgt on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @02:40PM (#34523113)
Managing lead-acid sensibly in my experience means never letting levels go below 40%. Temperature too I suppose.

I didn't know they could last as long as LiFePo though. Is this really true?

If this is true, why don't we just use more lead-acid batteries then?

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by mnw21cam on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @05:28PM (#34525043)
LiFePo can last longer than Lead-Acid. It depends on the usage.

LiFePo has a very high maximum cycle count. But after ten years, they'll die anyway. The only way that you can actually achieve a cycle count as high as the specification says is if you're cycling the battery two or three times a day, which I can believe if you're doing grid-levelling, but not if you're providing backup for your solar panels.

For lead-acid batteries, be aware of the difference between normal lead-acid, which are optimised for standby operation, and deep-cycle lead-acid, which are optimised for long life under regular cycling. Normal lead-acid batteries will die very quickly if cycled - they're designed to be charged all the time, and drawn on for very short period, like a car battery or a UPS.

Deep-cycle lead-acid batteries age by cycling, in contrast to LiFePo, which age by elapsed time. Their maximum cycle count is much lower than LiFePo, but if you're cycling them every couple of days, like in an off-grid solar project, and you're avoiding draining them below around 40%, then they can last 10 years.

So, if you want to cycle your batteries two or three times a day, then LiFePo is going to last a lot longer than Lead-Acid. But if you're cycling every couple of days and limiting the drain, then they can last about the same amount of time. It depends on the usage.

What helps with Lead-Acid is because it is that much cheaper than LiFePo, you can buy a larger capacity Lead-Acid battery for the same or less money, and then for the same performance requirements that larger battery will be drained less and at a lower rate, and therefore be less stressed and even last longer.

I think we don't use Lead-Acid as much as we do for several reasons:

1. Lead-Acid batteries have a reputation of flaking on us after a depressingly short amount of time. But that reputation has been earned from normal Lead-Acid batteries, not deep cycle ones.

2. People get scared by the lead in them, and how lead is toxic and we should be stopping using lead in everything. But really, lead in these batteries is not a danger to us, and Lead-Acid batteries are one of the best recycling success stories in the world. That lead isn't generally getting out into the environment. LiFePo batteries are much harder to recycle.

3. Electricians recommend installing expensive stuff, because then they get a bigger commission.

4. Lead-Acid are bigger and heavier for the same capacity than LiFePo. So, a LiFePo installation is going to look prettier in a nice consumer unit and be easier to install. They're heavy enough as it is.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by sgt on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:02AM (#34528548)
This is very insightful, thank you. I guess for price per kWh, lead-acid is also still unbeatable. And as you mention, deep cycle can give good lifetime as long as you don't go below 40%. I see deep cycle batteries come in all kinds of voltages though - is there a preference? I've seen huge 1000Ah batteries with 4V or 6V.
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by moffkalast on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @02:57PM (#34523321)
> they'll last pretty-much as long as a LiFePo if managed sensibly

[Citation needed]

Typically lead acid lifespan is around 10x less than lifepo4, even if kept within spec.

But in practice it's hard to keep them in spec too, shit sulphates immediately when you look at it wrong.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by mnw21cam on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @05:43PM (#34525201)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LPPUqLZOqCQ

LiFePo is maybe 10x the lifespan of a normal Lead-Acid battery, if you're cycling it several times a day. A car battery for instance will not do very well in this test. But I'm talking about deep cycle Lead-Acid batteries, cycled every day or couple of days down to 70% capacity (so using 30%). This is a fairly typical workload if you're (for instance) using it as a backup for solar panels. Under those circumstances, the LiFePo battery will die from time elapsed probably about the same time as or maybe even earlier than the Lead-Acid battery dies from cycle count.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by danuker on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @06:58PM (#34525968)
> so using 30%

In that case, they cost about $413/effective kWh.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by mnw21cam on Thursday January 26, 2023 @05:09AM (#34529839)
Kind of. Consider solar panels. A lot of the time, you'll be using around 30% of the discharge capacity to keep you overnight. However, some days will be cloudy, so you might have to use more of the capacity.

In this situation, a Lead-Acid will have the full capacity that you bought, but will age like you're using 30% of the capacity most of the time.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by moffkalast on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:08PM (#34526072)
Well that was interesting, I wasn't aware that flooded lead acid was that much better and that AGM just plain sucks in general, which was also my observation dealing with UPS batteries.

Still, I would've expected that ever increasing self discharge would've made them far worse in comparison since it gets worse as the batteries age and you can end up losing major amounts of charge to it. Not sure if that's not as much of a problem for flooded as it is for AGM but I haven't heard it mentioned in the rundown.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by Schroedingersat on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:36AM (#34517511)
Part of it is cars get a bunch of free tax money, but most of it is that cars were at the front of the queue and locked prices in ahead of time (before the self same orders pushed prices up) and they have actual pressure to compete.

There are cheaper products, but reliability and trustworthyness is an issue. A good budget offering may decide to sell out their rep or start charging premium prices.

Budget offerings are about $250/kWh right now, or there are some for about $350 with cold weather protection.

In a few more years markets will mature a little and the price gap will be smaller.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by AtlasBarfed on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @10:44AM (#34519594)
They had better, with 230 wh/kg LFP and 150 wh/kg lithium-free sodium ion coming to mass production, and those chemistries are far safer than nickel/cobalt chemistries because they don't catch on fire, the "OEM" cost of a large battery pack will certainly drop under 100$/kWh, if it already hasn't.

With sodium ion the cost should drop to 50$/kWh.

I guess what might happen in a decade or so with EVs with "obsolete" batteries in the used market is that you just get a used EV and you have a powerwall and a secondary/tertiary city car.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by Schroedingersat on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @11:03AM (#34519933)
What a wild and ironic twist if we actually get some increase in transit use because leaving the car at home pays for the ticket.
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by Isinlor on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:24AM (#34517953)
Tesla is supply limited, so they can put prices high. That's probably about it.
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by sharemywin on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:16AM (#34518466)
State level regulations around installation driving up prices?
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by danans on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @01:14PM (#34521984)
As someone who recently installed home batteries (LiFePo), I can guarantee you it isn't state regulations that are driving up prices. If anything state incentives in California can drive down the prices (if you qualify for them), and federal incentives drop the price by 30%.

In my experience, the big cost with home batteries are the same things that make artisinal custom designed and built homes expensive: the labor cost of the complex system design, installation and integration, and the premium charged because they are still marketed as a luxury product, not as a basic home appliance.

Why the complexity? It should be easy to install batteries on a house, right? In reality, every house has an idiosyncratic set of challenges and decisions that need to be made when integrating battery storage: What loads do you want to back up, and for how long? Where will the backup sub-panel be installed, and how can the backup circuits be routed to it? Where is a safe location for the battery and the automatic transfer switch to be installed? They are all answerable, but there is no general solution and each one is on a case-by-case basis.

And yes, this all does have to pass electrical codes (which exist for a reason), and needs sign-off by local building authorities, but they are not the main cost obstacle any more than they are for any major electrical upgrade to a house.

Take away the "luxury premium" part, and this also explains why home rooftop solar will always be much more expensive on a per-watt basis than utility scale solar (and yes, utility scale solar doesn't include the cost of transmission, as with any grid scale generation source).

Compare that to an EV, where thousands are assembled with predefined requirements, a set of inputs, in a purpose built environment (a factory).

In an ideal world, every house would be built with a standard connector (analogous to USB for phones or EV charger standards) that you could just plug a stationary storage system into. The houses would also be built to include an automatic transfer switch that islands the house during a power outage, and a smart load panel that dynamically decides what loads to back up based on battery capacity and user preferences. But right now, no such standards exist, and no house is built from the start that way, so everything is an expensive retrofit.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by danans on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @01:58PM (#34522615)
Nope, not that. See my sibling response above.
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by ajross on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:58AM (#34518985)
House batteries are never purchased in isolation. They're what amounts to a luxury add-on to a much bigger solar system, so you'd expect to see a "markup". That may change with the recent rollback of net metering in CA, which is making a battery system a requirement to reach break even on cost.
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by danans on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @02:01PM (#34522654)
> That may change with the recent rollback of net metering in CA, which is making a battery system a requirement to reach break even on cost.

NEM3.0 doesn't make a battery a requirement to break even on costs, it just extends the payback time of solar without batteries by 3-5 years. It reduces the still absurdly long payback time of home battery storage somewhat, though. Only when you can sell power back to the grid with batteries at peak wholesale rates will batteries have anything like solar's payback time.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by ajross on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @04:00PM (#34524115)
I've seen a lot of different numbers thrown around (and to be clear: I'm in Oregon and not part of the fight). Let it suffice that NEM3.0 makes the relative benefits of a battery for time shifting (and thus the costs of a solar system without a battery, as was typical for early installations) much, much higher.
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by danans on Thursday January 26, 2023 @12:32AM (#34528038)
I guess it depends on the rate structure you have. Higher rate variance between off and on peak periods definitely helps with the economic case for batteries, since it offers an arbitrage opportunity.

I haven't done the math yet to figure out how that variance relates to payback time for batteries, but would be a fun exercise.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by AtlasBarfed on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @10:29AM (#34519360)
Either Chinese companies are reaping huge profits on batteries, or the American companies that repackage them into their bespoke platforms (EGo batteries don't work with greenworks or ryobi AFAIK because they put different plastic shapes around the battery cells so you're locked into their ecosystem for example) are reaping the profits.

Hopefully, 200-230 wh/kg LFP and 150 wh/kg sodium ion batteries should be a revelation in all use cases of batteries in the next year or so.

Tesla gets to operate at the extremes of volume, so they get to demand the best prices I would imagine, but the markup still seems astronomical in other things (like tools, home powerwalls, etc).

IMO there needs to be some governmental nudge. Battery prices (in theory) should be dropping in price such that many ICE-based tools will be fundamentally cheaper as batteries. An electric lawnmower shouldn't be more expensive than a very very dirty two stroke ICE lawnmower with the LFP/Sodium Ion that is coming to market.

But a lot of electric tool makers are using the reduced sound and superior torque abilities of electric tools as a price premium product. Things like lawnmowers and leaf blowers and snow blowers being high performance electric tools is like a "starter EV" for millions of Americans: it teaches them about recharging batteries, how EVs are better than ICEs in many ways (quieter, better torque, less smelly, no gasoline to spoil over winter) and how to deal with the annoyances (recharging).

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by fsh on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @10:39AM (#34519505)
The explanation is quite simple. Electricity from the grid is still very cheap. It therefore makes no economical sense to buy huge batteries for buffering your home solar panels. Since there is no demand, there are no products.
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by csours on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @12:27PM (#34521235)
My guess is supply constraints. Tesla would rather sell cars than Powerwalls; other suppliers can't make a dent in the market because EVs are slurping up all the capacity at every level of the supply chain. This really is only a guess though.
Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by danans on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @01:57PM (#34522602)
As someone who recently self-installed home batteries (LiFePo), I learned quite a bit about what drives up prices. It's not regulation. If anything state incentives in California can drive down the prices (if you qualify for them), and federal incentives drop the price by 30%, thanks to the Inflation Reduction Act. In my experience, the big cost with home batteries are the same things that make artisinal custom designed and built homes expensive: the labor cost of the complex system design, installation and integration, and the premium charged because they are still marketed as a luxury product, not as a basic home appliance.

Why the complexity? It should be easy to install batteries on a house, right? In reality, every house has an idiosyncratic set of challenges and decisions that need to be made when integrating battery storage: What loads do you want to back up, and for how long? Where will the backup sub-panel be installed, and how can the backup circuits be routed to it? Where is a safe location for the battery and the automatic transfer switch to be installed? They are all answerable, but there is no general solution and each one is on a case-by-case basis.

And yes, this all does have to meet electrical codes (which exist for a reason), and needs sign-off by local building authorities, but they are not the main cost obstacle any more than they are for any major electrical upgrade to a house.

Take away the "luxury premium" part, and this also explains why home rooftop solar will always be much more expensive on a per-watt basis than utility scale solar (and yes, utility scale solar doesn't include the cost of transmission, as with any grid scale generation source).

Compare that to an EV, where thousands are assembled with predefined requirements, a known set of inputs, all in a purpose built environment (a factory).

And even better, they come with a standard plug interface that we can use to send power back to the house or the grid! But hold on: if you want power when the grid goes down, you're going to need an islanding transfer switch and perhaps decide which loads to back up. I mean, do you really want to run your 40A jacuzzi heater or your 50A air conditioner off you car battery?

In an ideal future, every house would be built with a standard connector (analogous to USB for phones or EV charger standards) that you could just plug a stationary storage system into. The houses would also be built to include an automatic transfer switch that islands the house during a power outage, and a smart load panel that dynamically decides what loads to back up based on battery capacity and user preferences. But right now, no such standards exist, and no house is built from the start that way, so everything is an expensive retrofit.

Re:EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage by theshrike79 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @02:08PM (#34522748)
Car manufacturers are buying every battery they can.

If we reach a point where there is an actual secondary market for used EV batteries, the house battery market will start to boom. But 10+ year old batteries are still 85-90% healthy mostly, so it might take a while...