News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by zackmorris on Friday January 20, 2023 @11:20AM (#34455281)
Allowed? We can choose not to work for companies that ban workers from their boards. Which is pretty much all of the big companies in the US.

It's funny that we have a dozen different open source software licenses that are all some version of "how can we give this to you even freer" but we have no notion of what an equitable work contract looks like. Until that changes, things will never, ever, get better for workers.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by guerrilla on Friday January 20, 2023 @11:41AM (#34455669)
> Allowed? We can choose not to work for companies that ban workers from their boards. Which is pretty much all of the big companies in the US.

No you can't. You're not thinking this through. As soon as enough people quit in order to start pressuring companies to allow this, it becomes more difficult for the growing pool of quitters to get new jobs and it becomes a buyers market, putting you in an even weaker position than you already were in. On top of that, capital always has more of an ability to hold out far longer. You need to eat and pay rent right now while they can scale down production until you come back with terms favorable to them. This is why unions save money ahead of time so that they can strike.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by Retric on Friday January 20, 2023 @11:57AM (#34455995)
I think you have that backwards, the more people quit the easier it is to get a job.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by guerrilla on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:27PM (#34456466)
No, not if they are all quitting companies without these conditions to go to companies that do. You cannot create the pressure necessary to make the desired changes just by quitting.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by Retric on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:21PM (#34457345)
If 1/2 of Microsoft’s workforce decided to quit tonight the company would go ballistic looking for workers.

The lag between people quitting and people finding their next job reduces the labor supply. That’s compounded by onboarding time required to conduct interviews and get people up to speed etc. It’s why companies so frequently fold in the face of strikes rather than just fire everyone, they have a great deal of individual leverage on any one employee but are completely dependent on having a workforce.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by guerrilla on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:27PM (#34457452)
Yes, I did mention unions in my first post but that isn't what the person I was responding to was suggesting. They were suggesting individual action, not collective action.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by Retric on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:50PM (#34458791)
I assumed he was talking about collective action or it’s functional equivalent here:

> As soon as enough people quit

You don’t actually need a formal union to get large numbers of people to quit.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by ericd on Friday January 20, 2023 @11:57AM (#34455984)
So go start a worker-friendly company?
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by zackmorris on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:27PM (#34456457)
Ya that's what I'm wondering. The central problem seems to be wealth inequality (that capital has been separated from labor). So there's no money available for laid-off workers to start a business, maybe by design.

As far as I can tell, there is simply no place where a group of workers can borrow money. We have no concept of loans co-signed by a large number of people in the US.

For example, there should be a floor at which a loan is deemed risk-free because a typical person has that much money. Any of us can donate $5 to someone living on the street at any time. So 100 people should be able to borrow $500 together, no questions asked.

Now, how high can that go? Certainly $20 each. Maybe $100? $300? It's going to be an amount similar to what payday loan shops offer to strangers.

To me, this is like customer acquisition cost (CAC). In the 90s, CAC was under $1 before advertising got saturated. Today it's between $25 and $50, which has eliminated nearly all indie websites selling handmade goods for less than that. And driven the rise of influencers, and incentivized taking over making.

I know we have Kickstarter etc. But for something like this to work, it would need to be available everywhere immediately with no nonsense, no exorbitant interest or fees and no wait time. The government could offer group loans like this with a $100 per person limit today and bootstrap the economy to where it was 25 years ago and make a huge return.

Maybe this is what drove crypto and NFTs, just in a way that was obviously going to implode because workers were expected to pony up the cash. So I'd be curious to hear if investors know of any places to take out group loans like this.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by lotsofpulp on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:36PM (#34456600)
>The central problem seems to be wealth inequality (that capital has been separated from labor).

The central problem will be inequality of all kinds, such as aptitude/motiviation/effort/etc. Eventually, in many businesses, you will get into a situation where some people will think they deserve more than others, and then politics will take over, and you have a similar problem to weaknesses in democracy.

>As far as I can tell, there is simply no place where a group of workers can borrow money. We have no concept of loans co-signed by a large number of people in the US.

There is. A family reunion, a bank, a credit union, a local business group meeting, etc. There is nothing stopping this happening other than the fact that it is uneconomical. Underwriting, agency risk, and pursuing unpaid debt is not a negligible problem.

>For example, there should be a floor at which a loan is deemed risk-free because a typical person has that much money. Any of us can donate $5 to someone living on the street at any time. So 100 people should be able to borrow $500 together, no questions asked.

Very few lenders exist who would accept that deal. As a lender, would you?

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by zackmorris on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:17PM (#34457281)
The central problem will be inequality of all kinds, such as aptitude/motiviation/effort/etc. Eventually, in many businesses, you will get into a situation where some people will think they deserve more than others, and then politics will take over, and you have a similar problem to weaknesses in democracy.

That's othering. You're separating the "us" that are hard workers and successful from the "them" that are slackers.

But wealth inequality is an injustice specifically because it doesn't discriminate.

For example: in software development the hardest workers are penalized because the 10:1 or 100:1 leverage in their solutions often isn't recognized or rewarded. They might get paid twice as much as another dev even though decades of experience and orders of magnitude differences in problem-solving capacity separate them. That could be where your perception comes from, if you feel undervalued for your work and see others around you as entitled.

The hardest workers I've met in my life were generally the lowest paid. When I was moving furniture from 2001-2003, women automatically were paid $9/hr to pack boxes while the men were paid $10/hr to load them. Never mind that packing is a much more difficult job psychologically. I could pack about 30 boxes/day if I went as fast as I could, while a woman I worked with averaged 80. Almost 3 times my productivity for less pay and opportunity. And she had kids. And she didn't have the money to go to the dentist. And she never complained. Not like me.

Today 20 years later, costs have at least doubled while pay has stayed the same. I worry for her and the literally 100 million Americans who work harder than we do and live hand to mouth. It's a travesty of such proportion that it's become unthinkable. We literally can't overcome our own biases to think about it rationally. Our inability to empathize is the root cause of suffering.

So yes, I would make that loan all day. And nothing against you, I don't know you, I don't mean to be critical. I just feel that your argument is rooted in bias which somewhat ironically causes you to not entertain the insights I've gained acquiring my bias.

Edit: I may have misread your point. Do you mean that some people will think they deserve more than others and hoard the profits of the business? Sorry if I got that backwards or projected my context onto what you said.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by lotsofpulp on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:48PM (#34457791)
>That's othering. You're separating the "us" that are hard workers and successful from the "them" that are slackers.

Yes, and I posit "othering" is an innate part of humans (and other animals). Of course, it is worthwhile to work against excessive "othering" that causes a net loss in the functioning of society.

>Do you mean that some people will think they deserve more than others and hoard the profits of the business?

Yes, although I would not make a judgment call as to whether or not it is "hoarding".

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by specialist on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:24PM (#34457395)
IIRC, Richard Wolfe, advocate of worker-directed social enterprises, mentioned that old school unions like SEIU are now funding startups, small businesses, etc. Maybe like a Small Business Administration and credit union for union members.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by guerrilla on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:28PM (#34456476)
Some people do that. The majority though can't afford to do that, obviously. It's amazing that people can be so disconnected from reality to not see that as obvious.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by ericd on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:30PM (#34457490)
It was meant to provoke some thought as to why there aren’t more worker friendly companies out there given that everyone seems to want them. Obviously not everyone is in a good situation to start their own.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by eduction on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:09PM (#34458136)
You are of course entirely correct. Unilaterally quitting or refusing an offer isn’t going to achieve much.

I do think a strike could be effective here though. A company is in more of a bind when all / many of its workers refuse to work.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by true_religion on Friday January 20, 2023 @05:24PM (#34460930)
The most charitable reading of the OP is to believe that they want a union, since group labour negotiations are simplified when you have an official group representing you.

So long as the company acts as a group and labour acts as a individuals, all the bargaining power will be on the side of the company.

I think the union formed at Microsoft may be a good example to follow.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by gautamdivgi on Friday January 20, 2023 @11:43AM (#34455699)
You can’t choose not to work in the US. You will be without health insurance.

I don’t know of single US company that allows their workers on their board. I’m not against it. I think it’s an awesome idea.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by lotsofpulp on Friday January 20, 2023 @11:50AM (#34455850)
I do not know of a single US company that does not allow workers (employees) on the board.

Technically, if a CEO is on the board, then a company’s employee is on the board. Shareholders will probably not vote to put a line level employee on the board, though.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by bakuninsbart on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:33PM (#34456539)
The system in Germany specifically differentiates between employees and the so-called managerial class: once you reach a certain amount of leadership, you aren't eligible for the workers council anymore, even if you are an employee.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by georgeecollins on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:28PM (#34456481)
Many companies in the US are employee owned. I think that's great and I would love to see people on HN form more of them.

https://www.nceo.org/articles/employee-ownership-100

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by toomuchtodo on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:09PM (#34456211)
Line level employees at employee owned companies are shareholders; perhaps the problem is not enough employee owned companies.

https://www.certifiedeo.com/

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by specialist on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:19PM (#34457318)
socialism, def.: when the working class aspire to join the ownership class.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by terr-dav on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:37PM (#34457618)
"workers aspiring to join the owning class" sounds more like effective capitalist propaganda to me. A socialist aspiration would be to remove the distinction between owner and worker. By transforming a business to worker-ownership, the owning vs working class distinction is eliminated.

The compliment to "workers aspiring to join the owning class" is that the biggest risk a capitalist faces is the possibility of being thrust back into the working-class, and having to actually work for a living, as opposed to living off of profits derived from the labor of others.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by swagasaurus-rex on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:16PM (#34458261)
In theory, socialism is when the working class redistributes the ownership class's assets.

In practice, socialism is a power grab where populist leaders redistribute the ownership classes' assets to themselves.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by specialist on Friday January 20, 2023 @10:27PM (#34463568)
Succinct. Nice.

Wikipedia's treatment is a bit more nuanced. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialism

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by astrange on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:19PM (#34458304)
The obvious issue here is that workers don't want to own their company and probably shouldn't. A .001% stake in a company is less useful than a 50% stake, and it's well known that if you work at a company that pays you in shares you should immediately sell them and buy an index fund.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by sergiomattei on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:25PM (#34456430)
Let’s not argue semantics. They mean exactly what you mention: line-level labor.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by lotsofpulp on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:45PM (#34456780)
It is not semantics, because the statement that line level employees are banned from being on the board of directors is false. And that is important because the reason line level employees are not found on boards is that it rarely makes economic sense for a company's owners to put a line level employee on the board. And that is important because then the solution would have to be legislation.

So the conversation becomes, should the government(s) in the US force businesses to place line level employees on the board (if the line level employees want to be on the board), and under what parameters?

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by JakeTheAndroid on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:24PM (#34457398)
Your entire line of comments seems to miss the entire conversation.

In Germany, they do find it economically viable and important for line level employees to have direct representation on the company board. Talking about the CEO or other management classes being on the board is missing the conversation. Suggesting that because US companies don't believe in the economic value is missing the conversation. Suggesting that people are saying that this type of board composition is illegal is also missing the conversation. No one said it's illegal, but it's equally not a legal requirement either like it is in other places.

The conversation is that this composition doesn't exist, by and large, in the US, and people think it should. People seem to believe that it does have value to the business.

So yes, it does seem like you're creating semantic arguments because your points miss the conversation semantically.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by astrange on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:21PM (#34458332)
Europe has sectoral bargaining (whole-industry unions) and codetermination (workers on boards) because they're running on newer legal systems than the US. It'd probably work here, but we have older corporate unions (per-company unions) which causes unions and management to fight each other more.

On the other hand, we do have higher productivity, but not having codetermination probably isn't the reason for that.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by thescriptkiddie on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:57PM (#34456960)
Excluding a handful of co-ops, I don't know of a single company that does. This isn't about having one board member who happens to be an employee, it's about having >=50% of the board democratically elected by the employees.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by JumpCrisscross on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:28PM (#34457466)
> it's about having >=50% of the board democratically elected by the employees

Is this how workers’ councils work in Germany?

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by thescriptkiddie on Friday January 20, 2023 @04:56PM (#34460546)
Yes, for companies with over 2000 employees, although the chairman of the board (who must not be an employee representative) gets the right to cast tie-breaking votes.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Codetermination_in_Germany

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by ericd on Friday January 20, 2023 @11:53AM (#34455923)
You can buy health insurance on the marketplaces yourself, it’s not hard, and it’s much cheaper than eg housing in most places that are MCOL and up. The challenge is saving up enough to pay for all your living expenses while you’re choosing not to work.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by misnome on Friday January 20, 2023 @11:57AM (#34455986)
Isn't there supposed to be a problem with health providers explicitly rejecting insurance companies/packages that are possible to buy yourself?

You don't really have a choice if nobody where you live will take your insurance...

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by ericd on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:16PM (#34456325)
I’ve never had that issue, or even heard of that issue, but I’ve only bought insurance from relatively large insurance companies, maybe it’s an issue if you try to save money by going with a small one with no network.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by danenania on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:40PM (#34456679)
I've had good and bad experiences. One thing I learned the hard way is that even as a young person with low healthcare costs, it's a very bad idea to just choose the cheapest plan without doing any research.

Some of the low cost companies are essentially scams: most of the "providers" they list on their site will not actually accept the plan; if you do have any medical costs, they will do everything possible to avoid paying even when you are clearly covered; you'll wait for hours on hold to talk to support, then they will be rude and unhelpful; etc. etc.

It's well worth paying an extra hundred or so per month for a reputable provider so that you at least have actual functional health insurance.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by lotsofpulp on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:01PM (#34456072)
Not in my experience. On east and west coasts, there are at least a couple widely accepted insurance plans available. A BCBS affiliate, a vertically integrated one like Kaiser or Providence, and other insurers offering PPO plans like UHC/Aetna/Cigna/Humana/etc.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by georgeecollins on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:59PM (#34456987)
"There's supposed to be a problem.." I think that is a story you hear for political reasons because sadly healthcare became a partisan issue.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by mrguyorama on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:26PM (#34459345)
The plans in my state that you can buy on the open market are the same plans offered to local companies and the government for employer subsidized health care.

There might be some states where the marketplace has nothing good in it, often because that state's governor was so ideologically driven they refused free money from the feds to expand medicare style systems. American health care is HUGELY state to state, largely depending on how willing a governor is to actually help their constituents instead of virtue signalling.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by yamtaddle on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:30PM (#34459425)
Last I checked there were two companies offering insurance to individuals in my state—yes, two, yes, I'm serious, no, not just on the marketplace, there were no other providers who will take individual customers period, yes, I checked a lot and was repeatedly told, explicitly, by people who ought to know, that those were the only two options and other insurers had pulled out entirely from offering individual plans in this state.

Both would only cover one of the four nearest major hospitals to me (though they did differ in which one it was) and only one of the two covered the huge local children's hospital that's also bought up nearly all the independent pediatrician's offices and pediatric urgent cares in the entire city, so if you have kids you actually only have one "option".

So much for the bounty of choice we preserved by not just going single-payer.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by johnebgd on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:02PM (#34457046)
It is definitely not "cheaper" in my experience but the marketplace is definitely easy to buy good insurance through. That said, you need income to support the massive monthly payments. Family plans in the most desirable places to live can easily be $40k/year for the insurance policy before you have to cover any out of pocket expenses.

Health insurance is the "golden handcuffs" for most people staying in a job.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by toast0 on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:11PM (#34457173)
GP was saying health insurance is cheaper than housing in MCOL areas. Implying if you can pay to live somewhere nice with no job, you can pay for health insurance too.

Regardless, there's subsidies if you don't have income, and it's just based on income; there's no requirement to seek income.

I'm near seattle, and my marketplace place for 2 adults around 40 and 1 child was around $1,200; unsubsidized.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by dontlaugh on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:30PM (#34456509)
You can’t choose not to work anywhere, you’ll starve.

Class struggle happens everywhere and workers can win anywhere, even the US.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by mareko on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:00PM (#34456052)
Definitely an awesome idea. If you ever need an example, cLabs.co is a US corporation that has an employee board seat.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by pirate787 on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:17PM (#34457285)
There's an entire class of corporate ownership that's employee-owned in the USA.

https://www.nceo.org/what-is-employee-ownership

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by rayiner on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:10PM (#34458161)
> You can’t choose not to work in the US. You will be without health insurance.

Neither Medicaid nor Obamacare require you to work. My father in law did this in Oregon. “Retired” years before being eligible for Medicare, and is covered by the Oregon Health Plan. In Oregon you don’t even have to be legally in the country to qualify for fill OHP benefits.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by themitigating on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:46PM (#34456795)
Since most people need a job to pay for housing, food, and medicial needs companies have the upper hand