News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by derbOac on Friday January 06, 2023 @08:07PM (#34283842)
I'm willing to consider and eventually accept the idea that vegetable oil, or some class of oil or fat in general, is causing significant public health problems and increases risk of disease. However, every time I delve into the research on vegetable oil I end up being more confused.

This seems to be the case in many of the studies cited in this essay as well. For example, a number of the studies aggregate over margarine and other types of vegetable oil, which seems really difficult or impossible to interpret, especially given that trans fats are now generally accepted to be unhealthy.

Other problems arise here in and elsewhere in defining oil composition. I've noticed for instance that safflower and sunflower oil are almost always lumped together in one category, even though there are chemically very different forms of both available. For example, high oleic and other sunflower oils are really different, and sunflower oil in general is generally relatively easily modified genetically speaking. So talking about "sunflower oil" as a single ingredient biochemically is problematic.

There's also issues with cooked versus raw oils, which the essay alludes to but seems extremely important given how different fat structures are transformed by heat.

I'm not trying to tear down the piece, but I do find this area of research really difficult to interpret.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by alxmng on Friday January 06, 2023 @08:14PM (#34283903)
Agreed. Clearly there are huge chemical differences between coconut oil, sunflower oil, and tallow.

The science is too shoddy to draw any conclusions. It’s hard to take seriously studies that don’t consider olive oil a “vegetable oil”.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by krona on Friday January 06, 2023 @08:24PM (#34283977)
From the article:

> “Vegetable oils” in this context refer to oils extracted from seeds, grains, and legumes

This excludes olive/avocado/coconut/nut oils.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by alxmng on Friday January 06, 2023 @08:40PM (#34284091)
Categorizing oils like this seems counter-productive to studying the effect of consuming certain fatty acids, as oils from the same category have wildly different composition. Coconut and olive oils are both from fruits, but contain different fatty acids.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by derefr on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:14PM (#34284346)
I believe the oils aren't divided this way for any taxonomic reason, but rather because we already have evidence of olive, avocado, coconut etc. oils having little-to-no impact on health, in contrast to other oils. The groups are basically "presumed innocent" oils and "presumed guilty" oils.

Or, to be more charitable, the groupings can also be looked at as "oils humans evolved eating" (olive oil, butter, coconut milk, etc) vs "oils we just started eating recently, because they can't be extracted without modern technology."

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by alxmng on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:12PM (#34285119)
Humans did not evolve eating olive or coconut oil.

Seed oils do not require modern technology. Soybean, sesame, sunflower, etc. can be extracted with stone pressing and were extracted that way prior to any chemical extraction process. Where my family is from they’ve been eating sunflower and peanut oil for hundreds of years, milled and pressed with stone.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by rayiner on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:41PM (#34285274)
Likewise on the subcontinent mustard seed oil has been used for hundreds of years.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by msrenee on Saturday January 07, 2023 @03:22PM (#34292317)
Didn't realize people cooked with mustard seed oil. Does it carry the mustard flavor? I need to look into this.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by rayiner on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:10AM (#34298819)
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by msrenee on Friday January 13, 2023 @07:39PM (#34375979)
Thanks for the link. That's crazy!
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by adrian_b on Saturday January 07, 2023 @05:24AM (#34286851)
You are right that some cold-pressed seed oils have been used since antiquity, e.g. sesame oil.

Nevertheless, until modern extraction methods based on the use of high temperature and organic solvents have been introduced during the last two centuries such oils had remained expensive, so they were only a minor part of the food, unlike today, when if you look at the label of any kind of industrially-made food you will invariably see that some cheap oil has been added to it, e.g. soybean oil, canola oil or palm oil.

Even today, if you choose vegetable oils extracted by good methods, i.e. by cold pressing or with supercritical carbon dioxide, they are much more expensive than standard oils. For instance, the price range for cold-pressed sunflower oil overlaps with that of the cheaper kinds of extra-virgin olive oil and the prices are several times higher than for standard sunflower oil.

I have read all the 4 parts of this "Death by Vegetable Oil" series of posts.

Some of its conclusions are likely to be true, but the title is extremely misleading. A much more appropriate title would be "Death by the Cheaper Vegetable Oils".

All the data presented in these posts about the harmful effects of some vegetable oils are not applicable to vegetable oils in general, but only to those vegetable oils that have one or more of the following characteristics:

1. A high content of linoleic acid and also a too high daily intake. The optimum daily intake of linoleic acid is unknown, but it is believed to be around 10 g/day and not much over 20 g/day. In my opinion, based on the current data, an example of a daily fat intake optimized for the fatty acid profile and vitamin E content, for a sedentary human, would be 55 mL of extra-virgin olive oil + 15 mL of cold-pressed sunflower oil + a DHA+EPA omega-3 supplement. The rest of the food should have low fat content, like in grains, vegetables, fruits or lean meat. For a higher calorie intake, only the amount of extra-virgin olive oil should be increased.

2. Extraction with high temperature and/or organic solvents. One should always prefer extra-virgin oils, cold-pressed oils or oils extracted with supercritical carbon dioxide. All such oils are very sensitive to light, so they must be stored in darkness, preferably in dark glass bottles.

3. Vegetable oils that had been heated during cooking. All vegetable oils should be mixed with the food only after cooking it and cooling it. They should not be used for frying.

4. Vegetable oils with artificial additives, e.g. with TBHQ. Avoid these.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by gls2ro on Saturday January 07, 2023 @09:59AM (#34288540)
Regarding number 3, I have a question:

In the last 2 years, I started replacing all my cookware with a combination of cast iron, carbon steel, and stainless steel pans. So far, the only way to cook something in all of them without making the food stick is by using oil.

So I have a dilemma: What kind of oil to use with this type of cookware if I want to cook often?

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by locutous on Saturday January 07, 2023 @10:28AM (#34288852)
Some generalizations.

Home cooking is generally going to be better than particularly fast food because you are not reheating the same oils over and over.

Coconut oil is generally held as better. Cold pressed oils otherwise. Prepare to pay more for them. Be aware that food packaging labels have been known to lie about oil origin. Basically, fewer steps between growing the food and your mouth the better.

Preparing food at home is going to reduce a lot of the processing and reprocessing that happens to commercial packaged foods. I think that's going to be a net win.

Maybe get a feel for exactly how much oil is required and keep it to a minimum.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by gls2ro on Saturday January 07, 2023 @10:49AM (#34289120)
Thank you for the reply.

When I was using pans with a non-sticking coating, I used very little oil.

Now switching to cast-iron or carbon-steel I noticed that the best point to cook the food is to add some oil to the pan, wait for the oil to be heated properly, and only then start adding the food. Of course, I still add very little oil (maybe 1-2 tablespoons) but compared with non-sticking pans it is yet a visible thin film.

I am currently using extra-virgin olive oil but I am not sure it is good. Now I understand that instead of focusing on "extra-virgin" label I should focus on the process used to produce the oil.

On the other hand, sharing here a bit of anxiety I am no sure what to eat:

- On one hand I could try to eat more non-processed, non-cooked food like salads, vegetables ... But the risk there is being contaminated with various pesticides. So I am a bit concerned to switch to a diet mostly based on this as it means to increase a lot the quantity of such food

- On the other hand, cooking using what people consider healthy cookware means (so far for me) using some oil which I now get should be limited

- There is also the idea of red meat being bad, but also fish having mercury or radioactive elements. Probably not all of them but after reading this kind of information, I am a bit more aware of buying fish as I don't know exactly which one can be contaminated and from what area.

- The chickens seem also be not be healthy (don't remember where I read this and I somehow suspect it is false).

So I am really a bit puzzled about what to eat.

I don't think there is an easy answer.

Probably the correct answer is to grow my own food. But that is another style of life.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by adrian_b on Saturday January 07, 2023 @11:52AM (#34289846)
Not the use of oil to avoid sticking is the problem, but eating it after that.

Besides choosing a kind of fat that is less sensitive to temperature, as described in another answer, when possible you should try to clean the fried food of the frying oil and to throw away most of the used oil.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by derbOac on Monday January 09, 2023 @04:32AM (#34308465)
If you rinse vegetables well most pesticide residue will be removed. Also, some vegetables that are peeled remove that exposure route as well.

There are studies showing some kinds of organic products are worth buying because of the reasons you mention, but others are not.

I think the more you can buy food that you trust the better. This doesn't mean growing your own, it means learning more about where your food is coming from and the chain of producing and selling it. It may mean going to smaller shops, more trips, farmers markets etc. It may just mean reading about brands etc.

I think many people are wrestling with similar questions as you; you're not alone.

Using saturated or monounsaturated fats or oils are your best bets for sauteing. You can also braise things, in some kind of liquid.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by adrian_b on Saturday January 07, 2023 @11:10AM (#34289371)
Traditionally, lard was used for this purpose, not oils. This remains one of the best choices.

Good alternatives are butter or high-oleic sunflower oil or other high-oleic refined vegetable oils, which also have a low content of PUFA and of substances that are not triglycerides.

This is different from the case when the purpose of an oil is to be eaten without being heated, when cold-pressed non-refined oils are preferable, because they include various beneficial nutrients.

In any case, even if some kind of fat is used for frying, it is good to try to avoid eating most of it.

It is also possible to never use frying. In this case everything that is neither boiled nor steamed can be baked in an oven. This includes all kinds of meat (which must be cut into slices or small pieces before baking).

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by rofrol on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @08:14PM (#34347735)
>In my opinion, based on the current data, an example of a daily fat intake optimized for the fatty acid profile and vitamin E content, for a sedentary human, would be 55 mL of extra-virgin olive oil + 15 mL of cold-pressed sunflower oil + a DHA+EPA omega-3 supplement.

Can you provide link to this current data? I thought sunflower oil is not good for our health.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by btilly on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:27PM (#34284438)
The follow-up article https://www.jeffnobbs.com/posts/why-is-vegetable-oil-unhealt... goes into depth on why the underlying chemistry makes some oils much worse for us than others.

Long story short, plants that live where it is cold need to use less stable oils with a lower melting points. These oils lead to our cells being more fragile, and also lead to more free radicals.

Particularly if the oil is repeatedly heated. As happens in restaurants. And even more so when deep frying fast food.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by alxmng on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:06PM (#34285087)
It’s a simple theory (omega 6 = bad) but the evidence is not clear. Plenty of studies demonstrate benefits from Linoleic acid:

https://www.drchristianson.com/blog/are-omega-6-fats-bad-for...

I see talk about seed oils causing “inflammation” as a big red flag for pseudoscience.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by imtringued on Saturday January 07, 2023 @05:38AM (#34286914)
The point about seed oils causing inflammation is generally linked to to the high temperature processing causing oxidation which then promotes inflammation.

I don't know where you got the omega 6 idea from.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by adrian_b on Saturday January 07, 2023 @06:33AM (#34287157)
For any kind of nutrient, saying that it is good or bad, without saying at which daily intake that is true, is totally meaningless.

Any essential nutrient, whose absence from your food can kill you, can also become a poison over a certain daily intake. For certain essential nutrients, the difference between the optimum daily intake and the lethal daily intake may be quite small, e.g. for selenium.

In the case of linoleic acid, it is likely that 10 g/day is very healthy, but 50 g/day is very unhealthy. It is not known for sure where the threshold between healthy and unhealthy lays, but it might be between 20 g/day and 30 g/day.

Most of the cheapest vegetable oils contain between 60% and 80% of linoleic acid.

With all kinds of industrially-made food containing large amounts of cheap oils, it has become very easy to eat too much linoleic acid per day, without being aware, like also too much sugar.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by Ocha on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:16PM (#34285138)
Well this article argues omega-6 is healthy and prevents heart attacks - totally opposite. What should I believe https://www.health.harvard.edu/newsletter_article/no-need-to...
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by teslabox on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:44PM (#34285293)
Polyunsaturated oils combine spontaneously with the oxygen to deteriorate into a hard film.

Vegetable oil bottles tend to get sticky on the outside. Used vegetable oil is great for wood preservation. Many stains have heavy metals in them.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drying_oil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lipid_peroxidation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lipid_peroxidation#Hazards

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by rawgabbit on Saturday January 07, 2023 @12:48PM (#34290566)
I was going to say the same thing. Harvard Health says both Omega 3 and Omega 6 are good for us.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by amluto on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:37PM (#34285247)
Wait a moment. The stereotypical unstable oil is alpha-linolenic acid, which seems to be generally regarded as quite healthy. Certainly oxidized ALA is disgusting (keep those flax seeds in the freezer!), but I’ve never heard of omega-3 fatty acids leading to fragile cells.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by Ocha on Saturday January 07, 2023 @12:20PM (#34290233)
Omega-6 not 3
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by amluto on Saturday January 07, 2023 @01:47PM (#34291207)
Not sure what you’re trying to say.

ALA is very unstable as oils go. It’s an omega-3 fatty acid. It’s generally regarded as healthy. The claim that unstable oils are somehow bad for you because they are unstable in your body seems entirely unsupported.

Certainly flaxseed oil is a terrible cooking oil unless you are trying to make furniture [0], but that’s a very different claim.

[0] You can also use flaxseed oil to produce a beautiful but mostly useless seasoning on cast iron. But the inside of your body is not made of hot iron, and the reactions that occur on a skillet don’t seem particularly relevant to what happens if you eat the oil.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by fierro on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:11PM (#34285115)
it's really not. It's a useful grouping because the methods of extraction differ along these lines. Vegetable oils generally require a chemical intensive process to acquire involving solvents and cleaners. These oils tend to have high levels of linoleic acid which is toxic to humans.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by alxmng on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:23PM (#34285174)
Vegetable oils do not require chemical extraction. But even so, what does that have to do with the oil? Oil extracted with solvent shouldn’t have any significant solvent left in it when consumed.

Linoleic acid is not “toxic” to humans. It’s an essential fatty acid. You need it to survive. Your body needs it to make other fats. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linoleic_acid

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by fierro on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:38PM (#34285251)
seed oils do often require chemical extraction and the method of extraction does matter because it may have effects on the chemical structure of the oil in question. For example, to make canola oil, the seeds are ground at high temperatures to extract a very fragile oil. During this harsh process, the oil is oxidized and then needs to be washed with hexane (a known neurological toxin) and then bleached and deodorized so that the product does not smell rancid (which it is after the processing). Contrast this to cold pressing olives.

As for linoleic acid, it does store in adipose issue and cause oxidative stress and inflammation in humans. Below is one of several papers you can find on this.

A high linoleic acid diet increases oxidative stress in vivo and affects nitric oxide metabolism in humans

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9844997/

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by Scoundreller on Saturday January 07, 2023 @12:02AM (#34285383)
Is there any retained hexane though?

I used to use n-hexane spray as an electronics cleaner and it all evaporated very fast.

I get that a non-polar oil could hold it better, but does it hold it in after any amount of time?

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by alxmng on Saturday January 07, 2023 @05:08AM (#34286774)
Not really. Here’s a study that measured hexane in various oil brands and didn’t find any problem. “The hexane residue was detected in thirty-six out of forty examined samples, ranged from lower than LOD to 42.6 µg/kg. However, in all of them hexane content were below the MRL of 1 mg/kg which set by the European Union.”

https://openaccesspub.org/ject/article/622

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by alxmng on Saturday January 07, 2023 @12:24AM (#34285495)
That study also shows that a diet high in chemically-extracted high-oleic sunflower oil did not have increased urine metabolites compared to control. So that study actually works against the hypothesis that seed oils or chemically extracted oils are inherently bad.

And here’s another study that directly tests the hypothesis that linoleic acid consumption causes damage via oxidative stress and concludes “our results provide no indication of increased oxidative stress or genetic damage as a result of increased dietary intake of linoleic acid. Therefore, we see no scientific basis to reconsider the public health policy to stimulate the intake of polyunsaturated fatty acids aimed at the reduction of coronary heart diseases.”

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12504167/

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by fierro on Saturday January 07, 2023 @01:29AM (#34285756)
I agree that there is not consensus in the scientific/medical community about this. You can find MDs who will advise avoiding linoleic acid as a top health prioty (i.e Paul Saladino) and other scientists who do not agree there is sufficient evidence to indict seed oils (i.e Andrew Huberman). Likewise, you can find all sorts of studies.

To address your point about the study I linked -- I think you're mistaken. The LA group did have a significant increase in 8-iso-PGF2alpha urine metabolites, and decrease in nitric oxide metabolites. From the study:

> Urinary excretion of 8-iso-PGF2alpha was significantly increased after the LA diet (170 vs 241 ng/mmol creatinine, P=0.04), whereas the urinary concentration of nitric oxide metabolites decreased (4.2 vs 2.6 mg/mmol creatinine, P=0.03).

also

> In conclusion, the high-LA diet increased oxidative stress and affected endothelial function in a way which may in the long-term predispose to endothelial dysfunction.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by alxmng on Saturday January 07, 2023 @04:11AM (#34286462)
The oleic acid group, the group that didn’t see an increase of metabolites, was given high-oleic sunflower oil. I brought that up because it’s a chemically extracted seed oil. “Seed oil” is not a significant distinction of fatty acid composition. Seed oils have the varying linoleic acid composition (sesame oil for example is quite balanced).

The study you linked showed an increase in metabolites for the LA group. But as far as I understand, those metabolites don’t demonstrate damage to anything or an impact on mortality. That’s why I linked to a study that measures oxidative DNA damage via 8-oxo-dG in blood, which found no impact from increased linoleic acid consumption. So the theory that linoleic acid is dangerous because of damage via oxidative stress isn’t clearly supported by current literature.

“Seed oil” consumption is not toxic in the sense that people do not experience apparent adverse health effects after consuming them, and there’s no clear link between consumption of seed oil and mortality.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by fierro on Saturday January 07, 2023 @11:57AM (#34289918)
I see, thx for clarifying
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by tarsinge on Saturday January 07, 2023 @02:40AM (#34286069)
Yes, especially because there are things like high-oleic sunflower oil with a completely different fatty acids profile more similar to olive oil.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by permo-w on Friday January 06, 2023 @08:35PM (#34284056)
but then when you buy “vegetable oil” it invariably contains olive oil
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by kragen on Friday January 06, 2023 @08:43PM (#34284113)
around here it's sunflower oil or sometimes soy oil with some sunflower oil in it
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by permo-w on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:46PM (#34284587)
in my experience it’s been sunflower oil with canola and then like 10% olive
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by derefr on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:12PM (#34284324)
That's not most places. Vegetable oils are expected to be able to be used as frying oils. Olive oil has too low of a smoke-point to be used in frying.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by permo-w on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:41PM (#34284550)
>Olive oil has too low of a smoke-point to be used in frying.

this is a common myth. many studies have shown otherwise

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by nogridbag on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:03PM (#34284695)
> this is a common myth

Do you have a source for that? It's pretty easy to google the smoke points and most charts indicate olive oil is fine for sautéing but not for frying.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by dendrite9 on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:17PM (#34284774)
Do you fry in >400 degree oil? There are many foods that are fried in olive oil for example in Spanish food. It seems fine since most frying is done well below the smoke point.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by karakot on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:11PM (#34285114)
There are several types of olive oils. Extra virgin (with lowest smoking point) is mostly used raw in salads and dressings, etc. Pure or refined(with highest smoking point) mostly used for cooking.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by sambeau on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:52PM (#34285334)
"Monitoring of Quality and Stability Characteristics and Fatty Acid Compositions of Refined Olive and Seed Oils during Repeated Pan- and Deep-Frying Using GC, FT-NIRS, and Chemometrics"

https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/jf503146f

See also this video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l_aFHrzSBrM

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by zabzonk on Saturday January 07, 2023 @12:05AM (#34285404)
well, i use virgin olive oil for frying all the time
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by jemmyw on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:31PM (#34284479)
That's also a confusing point. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/is-olive-oil-good-for-c... says it has a moderately high smoke point and possibly more importantly has a composition that is more resistive to oxidative damage than vegetable oils.

I usually fry and cook with olive oil.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by pvaldes on Saturday January 07, 2023 @08:17AM (#34287718)
Hum, Do the millions of people frying everything in olive oil know that is impossible to fry something in olive oil?
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by gizmo686 on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:14PM (#34284347)
I just checked my "vegetable oil", and it is further labled as 100% soybean. I can't imagine why would waste the more expensive olive oil by using it as an additive for cheap vegetable oil.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by fy20 on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:29PM (#34284465)
That's another issue, "vegetable oil" in different places means different things. In Europe it's usually a mix of rapeseed and corn oil.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by tempsy on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:03PM (#34284698)
it doesn’t really matter though because they all share the same common characteristics that make them unhealthy…eg high polyunsaturated fat content that easily degrades in high heat.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by permo-w on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:43PM (#34284563)
what country do you live in?
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by gizmo686 on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:02PM (#34285057)
USA
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by lost_tourist on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:16PM (#34284366)
maybe in your country, but certainly not in the USA, it's too cheap to put in soy/canola for them to even consider olive oil
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by docandrew on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:30PM (#34284840)
The opposite is sometimes true - shady vendors adulterate olive oil with vegetable oils to cut costs. Apparently it’s a bit of an epidemic: https://www.forbes.com/sites/ceciliarodriguez/2016/02/10/the...
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by Gigachad on Friday January 06, 2023 @08:24PM (#34283982)
That’s why people started using the term “seed oil”. Olive oil is not a seed oil while sunflower and rapeseed oil is.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by canucker2016 on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:09PM (#34284306)
I believe the rapeseed marketers/producers would prefer it be called "canola oil".
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by Gigachad on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:26PM (#34284432)
From what I understand, Canola is a more specific product. Like how Flaxseed oil and Linseed oil come from the same plant. Wikipedia mentions Canola as "a version" rather than "also known as"
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by lizknope on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:55PM (#34284643)
CANada Oil Low in Acid

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rapeseed_oil

Canola was bred from rapeseed cultivars of B. napus and B. rapa at the University of Manitoba, Canada, by Keith Downey and Baldur R. Stefansson in the early 1970s,[9][10] having then a different nutritional profile than present-day oil in addition to much less erucic acid.[11] Canola was originally a trademark name of the Rapeseed Association of Canada, and the name was a condensation of "Can" from Canada and "OLA " meaning "Oil, low acid",[12][13] but is now a generic term for edible varieties of rapeseed oil in North America and Australasia.[14] The change in name serves to distinguish it from natural rapeseed oil, which has much higher erucic acid content.[15]

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by AlexandrB on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:27PM (#34284442)
Then what's coconut oil? Coconuts are seeds.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by speg on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:51PM (#34284614)
Aren’t they nuts? Every time a story about oil comes up on HN I’m so confused. Everyone has different terms and expectations. Is there a one pager somewhere where we can all agree on some common ground?
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by tempsy on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:56PM (#34284648)
It’s not really a gotcha. Seed oil isn’t a perfect term but if the oil comes from some seed that requires an extensive chemical process to extract, refine, and deodorize it’s a being referenced as a “seed oil” here.

Coconut oil is not that. Neither is olive oil or avocado oil.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by akiselev on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:42PM (#34285284)
Coconuts are drupes (aka stone fruit) just like olives. Coconuts just have a fibrous outer layer instead of a fleshy outer layer like olives.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by rendaw on Saturday January 07, 2023 @12:26AM (#34285508)
Vegetable here means "not meat" (definition 1 on Wiktionary), as in "Animal, vegetable, or mineral".
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by pvaldes on Saturday January 07, 2023 @08:22AM (#34287743)
Those terms are very outdated now
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by chiefalchemist on Friday January 06, 2023 @08:26PM (#34283988)
> I'm willing to consider and . eventually accept the idea that vegetable oil, or some class of oil or fat in general, is causing significant public health problems and increases risk of disease. However, every time I delve into the research on vegetable oil I end up being more confused

The class of oil you're looking for is called sugar. We all know Big Sugar paid off a couple of researchers to spin the blame on fats, and perception has been baised since.

If we reduce sugar (including carbs) and we'll see health outcomes improve.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by wnolens on Friday January 06, 2023 @08:56PM (#34284202)
Big Sugar! gives new meaning to the name of an old band i used to listen to.. haha
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by Gordonjcp on Saturday January 07, 2023 @05:13AM (#34286796)
Hey, remember Napster? There was a chat facility so you could chat to people who were poking around in your shared files. Many many years ago - easily 20 years ago - I was downloading stuff off Napster and the person whose computer I was poking at popped up in chat and said "hey if you like that band, you'll probably like this band Big Sugar, try this track Let It Ride".

Maybe it was you.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by wnolens on Saturday January 07, 2023 @10:49AM (#34289112)
It is certainly like me to constantly push Canadian bands on people.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by tempsy on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:15PM (#34284355)
excessive sugar consumption is bad, agreed, but vegetable oil is awful for very specific reasons that have nothing to do with macros.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by TomSwirly on Saturday January 07, 2023 @03:43AM (#34286327)
From reading the rest of this page, I can safely say that your claim, "vegetable oil is awful", is just false.

No one except you is claiming that. Some people are claiming that a subset of vegetable oils are bad, but so far I haven't seen one conclusive argument either way.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by Spivak on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:36PM (#34284502)
This is way more than "you're wrong." Do not eat trans fats. Period. Please don't kill yourself over this. Trans fats are not like "oh they're bad for you" in the way french fries are bad for you. There is a bug in Human 1.0. Normally when we encounter fats we temporarily produce "bad" cholesterol; but it's fine because we also produce "good" cholesterol to clean up the excess. But when we encounter trans fats our bodies don't do that second part. There's nothing inherently bad about trans fats, in another evolutionary timeline humans would metabolize it fine but in this one we don't.

There is no safe amount of trans fats to eat. Trans fats do permanent damage to your arteries. Always. Some foods naturally have small amounts and most studies on the subject say they're less bad but still bad. Your goal should be to minimize your lifetime consumption which is why people say to reduce your red meat intake because it can add up. It's not worth it. There is nothing trans fats do for you that makes it worth it, especially since we have plenty non trans fats that are solid at room temperature. Don't intentionally add non-natural sources to your diet.

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by chiefalchemist on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:58PM (#34284661)
And you're way more "you're distracted". It's barely an exaggeration to say: sugar is in EVERYTHING. It's so ubiquitous and normalized that you're blaming a handful of oils. When every meals, every snack, mucks with your insulin levels...ill health is going to happen.

But yeah, let's blame oil. Makes sense. Smh

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by ricardobeat on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:34PM (#34284869)
You're not wrong about sugar, but you're not right. Some of the marked increase in diseases is shown to happen regardless of sugar consumption, so it's a mix of things? Sugar, processed foods, additives and emulsifiers, seed oils. We don't really know yet.
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by chiefalchemist on Saturday January 07, 2023 @08:04AM (#34287654)
We don't know?

1) Look around, what do we see?

2) Look at history. What are / aren't we eating now vs prior and/or elsewhere?

Processed foods ~ sugar. It's not like ppl are spooning straight sugar into their mouths.

p.s. Sugar also impacts oral health. The health of your mouth / teeth is important (read: far too underrated).

Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by TomSwirly on Saturday January 07, 2023 @03:44AM (#34286330)
Citation for your numerous, extremely strong claims about medicine?
Re:Death by Vegetable Oil by TomSwirly on Saturday January 07, 2023 @03:39AM (#34286311)
A lot of the people pushing these ideas are primarily motivated by being anti-vegan, so that might explain why such articles are all over the place.