Re:Elevator Control Panels
by pajtai on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:51PM
(#34284613)
My least favorite elevator control panel is the one that is not in the elevator and is a touch screen.
If the control panel is outside the elevator, you can't change your mind, you can't push a button for someone else, and sometimes you can't even verify what floor you're being sent to.
Re:Elevator Control Panels
by dbcurtis on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:05PM
(#34285083)
Call panel not in the cab -- so you must be talking about a "destination dispatch" system. With DD, you go to a call kiosk, and enter your desired destination floor, and the kiosk tells you which car to take. DD systems are done because it allows for much more sophisticated scheduling, and larger elevator lobbies with longer walk times, the net result being much better capacity, especially at peak traffic times.
In the cab you will typically have a button to take you back to the lobby in case you didn't get off on your desired floor and can't enter another call.
Modern destination dispatch systems are integrated with RF badge readers so that the elevator system can be programmed with your office floor, and so you don't need to go to the kiosk at all, just walk past it, and it will schedule your to a car to take you to your office floor.
The scheduler can group passengers together to get fewer stops, and longer express zones. Also, it makes double-deck elevators practical. Consider the elevators in the Willis Tower in Chicago. These are double-deck cabs, and it takes about three floors for the cab to accelerate to or decellerate from express speed and make a stop. Considering the number of people that system moves daily, it would be impossible to do without DD.
Re:Elevator Control Panels
by Daub on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:28PM
(#34285210)
For me, this OP website represents the internet at its best: a platform for the particular needs of particular people. It also serves as an appealing resource for anyone teaching UI/UX.
Re:Elevator Control Panels
by Waterluvian on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:49PM
(#34285317)
The one labelled “hospital incomprehensibility” lit my brain up in a fiery flurry of nostalgic activity. For but a fleeting moment I could actually smell the books of the 1995 Waterloo Public Library.
The directory had no real hint about this, and for whatever reason the floors I knew about were arranged such that the "R" was the "public side" (my pet theory was it had a better view out the windows), so invariably you'd see someone get off, be very confused where the reception desk was until someone could walk them around to the other side.
Re:Elevator Control Panels
by jboy55 on Saturday January 07, 2023 @12:19AM
(#34285459)
Not a control panel story, but I was in an elevator once with a small group and a voice came from the emergency phone.
Voice: "Hello?"
Us: "umm... Hello?"
Voice: "Hi, this is MCI, you can save money on your long distance plan ..."
Us: LOL, "This is an elevator, we can't help you"
Voice: "What, an elevator? what do you mean?"
Us: "Yes, you are calling an elevator!"
Voice: "Oh! Wow, this is wrong, sorry for calling!"
As soon as they dropped, a thought came in and I tried to yell out, "What number did you call!?!?". But they had hung up. Oh, the pranks you could do...
Re:Elevator Control Panels
by devilbunny on Saturday January 07, 2023 @03:09PM
(#34292134)
Won't help. Most large hospitals are odd conglomerations of buildings constructed at different times to different codes; the sixth floor of an old one may be smoothly connected to the fifth floor of a new one, with stairs between the two on floors three and four (accessibility is maintained by having elevators in the new wing have rear entrances to the "old" side, but you sort of have to know whether you want 4 or 4R). The stairs do not necessarily connect to all floors. Etc. If you spend a long time in one, you will eventually learn most of the tricks, but even then there are likely to be some surprises out there. Floors that only one or two elevators out of a large bank will go to, for example.
Re:Elevator Control Panels
by Doxin on Monday January 09, 2023 @09:03AM
(#34310400)
Case in point: the local hospital here has the operating theaters in the middle. on all floors except the ground floor. Walking through the operating theaters is a no-no so you'll sometimes find yourself going to the ground floor, walking to the next set of elevators, and then going back up to the floor you were originally on. Of course the top floor is smaller than all the other floors and in two parts so that's some extra confusion.
At least the whole thing is linear, so walking on the ground floor to the right "section" and then going up to the right floor usually gets you there.
Re:Elevator Control Panels
by Eisenstein on Saturday January 07, 2023 @01:49AM
(#34285841)
He gives the impression that the 13th floor being omitted is an exception. I thought it was common, at least in the USA. I don't think I have seen an elevator in the US that had a 13 button. It is stupid, but it is tradition so I don't think anyone wants to be the first to stop doing it.
Re:Elevator Control Panels
by kd5bjo on Saturday January 07, 2023 @03:32AM
(#34286281)
There’s some anglo-centric bias in his commentary on the international examples. The Reykjavík elevator, for example, is clearly labelled in the local language; his confusion is entirely caused by being unfamiliar with that language.
There’s perhaps a point to be made that using symbols instead of or alongside language is a good accessibility feature, but he makes that point only implicitly, if at all.
Re:Elevator Control Panels
by derbOac on Saturday January 07, 2023 @05:37AM
(#34286910)
It's not the only form of bias in the post. Just looking at the first pair, he seems to be implicitly criticizing the inclusion of braille for introducing additional elements into the design? What does he expect in a hospital?
I'm not familiar with that particular hospital in Atlanta, and I think the panel could be improved. But in my experience working in hospitals, there can be really weird floor layouts that make navigation confusing in general, not just for elevators.
Hospitals also need clear communication for staff to increase response speed. If you say "Floor 3" it might be really unclear what floor on what subunit of what building you're referring to, but a color could be a clearly defined zone.
Part of what he's doing is holding up as ideal examples places whose architecture and use makes simple elevator control design possible. I think it's good to highlight elevator control design, but I have a number of issues with the way he's approaching the discussion.
Re:Elevator Control Panels
by red_admiral on Saturday January 07, 2023 @04:39AM
(#34286625)
Someone should photograph the ones at ETH Zurich. Floors are labelled alphabetically, except that the ground floor is E (presumably for German Eingang = entrance). But for the ones on the hillside, how do you handle negative letters when you go below A (since the E floor lines up with the entrance on the top)? Answer: not just Z, Y, X ... but also weird things like ZZ for mezzanines.
Re:Elevator Control Panels
by rsanaie on Saturday January 07, 2023 @07:33AM
(#34287473)
Something that’s not talked about in elevator design ever is having the option to cancel or undo your action. What if you press the wrong floor by mistake? You should be able to undo it by pressing it again.
Re:Elevator Control Panels
by armanboyaci on Saturday January 07, 2023 @08:40AM
(#34287868)
I am surprised when I realized that the author is the same professor in Georgia Tech who wrote this wonderful free book about warehouse planning: https://www.warehouse-science.com/
If the control panel is outside the elevator, you can't change your mind, you can't push a button for someone else, and sometimes you can't even verify what floor you're being sent to.
FTFY.
You can get gloves which feature elements in the tips that allow you to operate capacitive screens while wearing them. They're not a new thing either.
source: received at least one pair every xmas since old time
In the cab you will typically have a button to take you back to the lobby in case you didn't get off on your desired floor and can't enter another call.
Modern destination dispatch systems are integrated with RF badge readers so that the elevator system can be programmed with your office floor, and so you don't need to go to the kiosk at all, just walk past it, and it will schedule your to a car to take you to your office floor.
The scheduler can group passengers together to get fewer stops, and longer express zones. Also, it makes double-deck elevators practical. Consider the elevators in the Willis Tower in Chicago. These are double-deck cabs, and it takes about three floors for the cab to accelerate to or decellerate from express speed and make a stop. Considering the number of people that system moves daily, it would be impossible to do without DD.
Related, this guy: https://www.youtube.com/@JimLiElevators
https://preview.redd.it/r3hrw31khra31.jpg?auto=webp&s=afeb8f...
The directory had no real hint about this, and for whatever reason the floors I knew about were arranged such that the "R" was the "public side" (my pet theory was it had a better view out the windows), so invariably you'd see someone get off, be very confused where the reception desk was until someone could walk them around to the other side.
Voice: "Hello?"
Us: "umm... Hello?"
Voice: "Hi, this is MCI, you can save money on your long distance plan ..."
Us: LOL, "This is an elevator, we can't help you"
Voice: "What, an elevator? what do you mean?"
Us: "Yes, you are calling an elevator!"
Voice: "Oh! Wow, this is wrong, sorry for calling!"
As soon as they dropped, a thought came in and I tried to yell out, "What number did you call!?!?". But they had hung up. Oh, the pranks you could do...
At least the whole thing is linear, so walking on the ground floor to the right "section" and then going up to the right floor usually gets you there.
Then the external display and speaker would announce which floors it would actually go to in a particular trip.
There’s perhaps a point to be made that using symbols instead of or alongside language is a good accessibility feature, but he makes that point only implicitly, if at all.
I'm not familiar with that particular hospital in Atlanta, and I think the panel could be improved. But in my experience working in hospitals, there can be really weird floor layouts that make navigation confusing in general, not just for elevators.
Hospitals also need clear communication for staff to increase response speed. If you say "Floor 3" it might be really unclear what floor on what subunit of what building you're referring to, but a color could be a clearly defined zone.
Part of what he's doing is holding up as ideal examples places whose architecture and use makes simple elevator control design possible. I think it's good to highlight elevator control design, but I have a number of issues with the way he's approaching the discussion.
The horizontal buttons might actually be useful for someone who struggles to reach to the top of the panel.
That would be "Erdgeschoss", which exactly means "ground floor".
https://soranews24.com/2017/08/18/the-secret-undo-codes-for-...
Unfortunetely he passed away in 2019.