News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by FuriouslyAdrift on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @12:25PM (#34163325)
Scroll compressors have come down in cost a bunch in the last few years. There's really very few reasons not to get a heat pump, now, for new construction.
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by bityard on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @03:43PM (#34165700)
Even in areas where natural gas is much cheaper than electricity?
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by dgacmu on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @04:09PM (#34165992)
A heat pump is likely to have an average efficiency of near 300% - call it 250 if you want to hedge. A high efficiency condensing gas furnace gets about 95%. So on a per-watt-hour basis (equiv., BTUs), your gas must cost less than roughly 1/3 what your electric costs.

There are additional savings if your gas furnace is the only gas appliance in your house and you can remove gas service entirely, saving the monthly customer fee.

Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by pandaman on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @05:44PM (#34167041)
And to get to 250% COP in heating on average you'd expect to have, at least, 8.5 HSPF2 rating on your heat pump (it's still just the heating performance w/o de-frosting cycles as far as I understand so the real world COP of a 8.5 HSPF2 will be lower than 2.5)
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by crgwbr on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @06:43PM (#34167569)
Unfortunately that is the case in some places. Last year I did the math to see if a ground source heat pump would be feasible (Hudson valley, NY), but even accounting for 400% efficiency vs 95% for gas, gas was still ~30% cheaper per month than electric. And that’s ignoring the extra $50k in equipment cost for the heat pump.
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by crmd on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @07:38PM (#34168014)
Thanks - this is exactly the kind of data point I’m looking for. I have a big, drafty loft in Brooklyn that is heated with gas forced air. I’ve been curious about the relative operating cost of an air source heat pump, and I assume the sky high cost of electricity in nyc makes it a non-starter.
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by silverlake on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @08:23PM (#34168362)
Also in NYC. I pay roughly 35cents per kWH (air-source heat pump) and $3 per therm natural gas (radiant heat, 95% efficient). I think 1 therm == 100k BTU, 1kWH == 3412 BTU. To equal 1 therm is takes 29kWH of electric heat costing $10.15. Then divide by the efficiency of heat pumps: $3.40 at 300% efficiency, $5 at 200%. I’ve read air-source heat pumps become far less efficient as the temps fall, so < 2x may be more realistic in winter.
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by crmd on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @09:56PM (#34168924)
Hey, thanks for responding. Am I understanding you correctly that 1 unit of gas heat costs $3 and each unit of heat pump heat costs between $3.40 and $5.00 depending on efficiency of the heat pump?
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by silverlake on Thursday December 29, 2022 @09:55AM (#34173185)
If my math checks out (which is doubtful) then yes, heat pump could be more expensive than gas heat on the worst cold days like last week (10F). However, a heat pump handles heating and cooling. So it’s cheaper to install 1 system that does everything rather than 2 systems to save money on a few cold days. Add a few solar panels and the heat pump cost goes to 0.

However, we put in a gas combi-boiler for hot water. Since we were renovating a townhouse, it was easy to throw in some radiant heaters on all floors. It’s a quiet, comfortable heat. I have the heat pump set to assist if the temps drop below 68F inside. All that said, insulation and air sealing is by far the most important thing to do first.

FYI: I checked the specs on my unit. It claims a 3.3X COP. So that’s $3 per therm, same as gas.

Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by mechagodzilla on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @10:04PM (#34168975)
NYC’s design temp is like 17F or something, so the seasonal average COP is probably above 3 for good cold climate heat pumps.
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by dgacmu on Thursday December 29, 2022 @07:34AM (#34171993)
The 300% is closer to an average. When it's over 40F you'll reach over 400% efficiency.

Now a question to address is whether your radiant heat is actually getting 95% efficiency. If you have an old radiator design system that was converted to using a condensing boiler, it may not be designed to keep return temperatures low enough for the boiler to operate at maximal efficiency. (old boiler systems were designed to keep the return water supply hot to prevent acidic condensate from eating the heat exchanger. This is the exact opposite of what you want with a modern system, where the return water needs to be cold enough that the flu gases condense into it to recover heat.)

If you have a way to monitor the return water temperature into your boiler, you could check. You need the return water to be below about 100 Fahrenheit in order to have 95% efficiency.

Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by idontwantthis on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @10:17PM (#34169053)
Would fixing the draft and adding insulation be the most effective first step?
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by crmd on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @10:40PM (#34169221)
It’s a 630 square foot surface with a 56 degree temperature at the moment according to FLIR. It creates a cascading cool breeze that just neutralizes the forced air furnace. When the furnace stops I can feel the waves of cool air sliding off the external walls.
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by chii on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @10:33PM (#34169163)
> gas was still ~30% cheaper per month than electric

this sucks, because gas _should not_ be that much cheaper than electricity, but for subsidies or other market altering shenanigans.

Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by tshaddox on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @10:38PM (#34169199)
Namely externalities. Natural gas is almost certainly more expensive for home heating than electricity, it’s just that a portion of that expense is paid by a large number of third parties.
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by rsj_hn on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @11:14PM (#34169474)
Seeing as how natural gas is a required input for making synthetic fertilizer, without which billions would starve, it's hard to think of a product with more positive externalities than natural gas. Every time you go to the supermarket, you should be thankful that natural gas allows synthetic fertilizers to feed the world.

It's easy to think of negative externalities and ignore positive externalities (or vice versa), but accurately summing these up is very difficult.

Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by tshaddox on Thursday December 29, 2022 @12:38AM (#34169882)
I didn’t say that all natural gas usage has negative externalities. But also, don’t the natural gas costs you’re talking about show up in the price of food?
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by rsj_hn on Thursday December 29, 2022 @05:59AM (#34171457)
No, because prices are set by supply and demand, not the total social cost/benefit that obtains when all effects, direct and indirect, are taken into account.

It is the discrepancy between market equilibria and total social cost/benefit that creates the theory of externalities. But my point is that actually determining social cost/benefit requires very extensive knowledge of all the social benefits and costs provided by something. For example, if you were to ask me what the positive externalities of clean drinking water are, I'd say they are enormous. But I couldn't really give you a number, and if anyone tries to give you a number, they are lying. But that is why I support subsidizing access to clean drinking water, rather than letting the market sort it out. It's just too valuable.

When we are talking about things like energy or transportation, they generally have enormous positive externalities, which is why they are historically subsidized. For example, even if you never use a road, you benefit from the stores you buy from having access to roads so that goods can be delivered to them more cheaply. But it's even more subtle, because cheaper transportation means bigger markets. One of the reasons why local businesses historically opposed the construction of roads is that it would force them to compete with other businesses along the same road. If most people had to walk, then they get a captive market. As soon as you introduce roads, prices come down, and quality increases because lots of little monopolies are destroyed.

So even if you never leave your house and only shop locally, you are getting huge financial benefits from cheap transportation. Thus there is a positive externality. This is why we don't mind that trucks cause most of the damage to roads but don't "pay their fair share" of road maintenance costs. It's because those trucks create enormous positive externalities by making all the goods we buy much cheaper, even if we ourselves never hire a truck. This is also why many nations subsidize railroads, bridges, roads, etc. The internet also has this aspect of enormous positive externalities. And when you are talking about energy -- it's the basis of modern civilization. Again, if you never use any energy yourself except wood that you chop down, you benefit from all the others who provide you with services having access to energy.

Now I'm not saying that natural gas only has positive externalities and that there are no negative externalities. What I'm saying is that no one can tell you what the net is, because these are things foundational to our economy and have profound effects on everything else.

So I would not try to use the logic of externalities when talking about these foundational technologies. Externalities makes sense if you are using a lawnmower and it annoys your neighbors, so you let them bid on how much you need to pay them in order to keep using the lawnmower. In very simple models, it makes sense. In the real world, it almost never makes sense, and ends up being a type of economic smokescreen for what is basically politics choosing winners and losers based on arbitrary or cherry picked criteria.

So my recommendation is to not try to use "externalities" as a justification. Here's what I would argue, for example, when I am dictator. We want to transition to nuclear power and away from natural gas. So let's tax natural gas and use the money to pay for nuclear power so that it becomes cost competitive with natural gas, and then let's reserve natural gas for things nuclear can't do for us -- such as creating fertilizers. See what I did there? I made my actual motivation the main cause and didn't invoke any economic theory of externalities. Because overall goals should not be slaves to economic models, but rather the economic models should be servants of the overall social goals. The economic model can tell you how much to tax natural gas so that nuclear becomes cost competitive. But whether to decide to switch away from one source to another requires wisdom rather than brute force calculation of all outcomes -- there is no economic model that can spit out the answer. We should not give economists that type of power.

Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by tshaddox on Thursday December 29, 2022 @08:08PM (#34180358)
I understand the theory of externalities. I certainly understand that it’s difficult or impossible to know all costs to all parties for some good. But that doesn’t mean there aren’t pretty clear examples, like burning fossil fuels. It certainly doesn’t mean you can dismiss any mention of externalities simply because they are complicated. Some people are bald.

You talk about how certain goods are immensely beneficial to society, but that’s not sufficient to claim there are positive externalities. Your example of a road being used by a store that you buy from is a poor example. Those transportation costs would simply show up in the cost of the stuff you buy (disregarding government subsidies for roads, of course, but that’s a separate issue).

Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by matsemann on Thursday December 29, 2022 @03:57AM (#34170827)
Well, wouldn't it then be better to use the gas for that, and use other means for heating homes?
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by rsj_hn on Thursday December 29, 2022 @06:46AM (#34171699)
Yes, using natural gas for the things that only natural gas can do would be an excellent public policy.

However that's not the policy we are pursuing. We are pursuing very blunt instruments to try to discourage investment in developing natural gas fields full stop. Which is bad public policy.

The other issue is by raising the price of natural gas, we are raising its price for all uses. And the price of natural gas tends to determine the price of fertilizer, which tends to determine the price of food. So this policy makes food more expensive.

Even worse, natural gas and things like coal and oil are in some sense substitutes. Not perfect substitutes, but what happens when we make oil more expensive is that people shift to coal and natural gas to generate energy, and so these two become more expensive as well. Similarly, if we were take all coal offline, that would increase demand for natural gas and oil as substitutes, and again, the price of these commodities would rise, which would increase the price of food.

What would be nice would be to see if we could de-couple these prices somehow -- e.g. tax usages of natural gas downstream of the price of the commodity itself. Other ideas are also possible.

Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by lazide on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @11:01PM (#34169394)
Gas is a defacto waste product from oil extraction, and very energy dense.

It’s shocking it’s not a bigger delta the other way.

Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by nicpottier on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @11:36PM (#34169599)
$50k in equipment? At what scale are we talking. I got a Mitsubishi heat pump with three heads installed for less than $15k and it works well into the negatives.
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by manfre on Thursday December 29, 2022 @12:12AM (#34169769)
Ground source requires drilling and is not the more common type of heat pump found at most homes.
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by brnt on Thursday December 29, 2022 @08:14AM (#34172278)
Note that you are unlikely to achieve 95% efficiency on the gas. That requires you to run your plumbing at about 20 degrees (celcius), since burning gas means simple thermodynamics apply. At 40C you're already down to 90%, and virtually every installation I've seen actually is set to 60-80 degrees, at which point you're nearing an efficiency of only half.

Hotter water means a more reactive system and smaller radiators (you'll need five times the volume for a given power output when you compare plumbing water of ~30 to 70+. You are almost certainly not installing that. Maybe you are installing floor heating, in which case you are likely OK.

But most people I speak to don't realize that 1. Gas efficiency goes up as temperature differential goes down, and 2. energy transfered to water also needs to leave the system at your radiators. So size them for the effiency you want, or be disappointed with a significantly higher gas bill.

Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by bityard on Thursday December 29, 2022 @10:34PM (#34181472)
I don't have any hard data at hand, but I can say that running my AC (which is just a one-way heat pump) for a few days out of the month in the summer makes my combined gas+electric bill about the same as in the middle of winter when my gas furnace is running all the time.
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by FriedPickles on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @04:23PM (#34166167)
Id love to see a combined heat and power system that burns natural gas to drive a heat pump compressor, and recovers the combustion heat. I wonder what multiplier it would get on a therm.
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by nanomonkey on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @04:54PM (#34166524)
I've been contemplating the same thing. Something like the WhisperGen stirling engine hot water heater should be available to everyone. Hell even a water cooled honda generator that runs off natural gas, and pumps the radiator fluid into your home for heating purposes would be nice. It seems weird that we aren't producing electricity when ever you burn natural gas for heating.
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by lazide on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @11:05PM (#34169418)
The issue is maintenance and capital expense due to complexity.

Gas furnaces are dead simple, and still break and require maintenance. Heat pumps, more so. Generators? By far the most.

Combining the three sounds like a huge headache for marginal efficiency gains.

Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by nanomonkey on Thursday December 29, 2022 @05:33PM (#34178990)
This is why I started off referencing external combustion engines like Stirling engines. These tend to have very low maintenance needs as the combustion occurs outside of the pistons, so there is no fouling of the moving parts. One could use self lubricating materials like graphite rods as your piston heads and have quite high reliable components. The stirling engines that NASA utilizes are considered maintenance free.

As far as efficiency gains, we're talking 25-40% of the energy being produced as electricity and the majority of the rest being turned into hot water for residential use, either by one household or a whole city block. This doesn't sound like a terribly marginal gain. Specially if the energy production is done during the hours when traditional solar installations are not producing which are generally when folks are running their heating.

Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by maxerickson on Thursday December 29, 2022 @11:43AM (#34174498)
Generators with heat recovery exist, search on micro CHP.
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by nanomonkey on Thursday December 29, 2022 @05:34PM (#34179004)
Yes thanks, I'm aware. I have actually worked in this field in the past building wood gasification micro CHP units.
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by mindslight on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @05:34PM (#34166942)
There are refrigerators that run directly off of propane. https://www.ferrellgas.com/tank-talk/blog-articles/how-propa...

The working temperatures of ammonia are probably wrong for a heat pump, but perhaps something similar could be devised.

Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by icedistilled on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @04:05PM (#34165937)
yes. Because Global warming/climate change is real and installing new furnaces bakes in decades of additional natural gas usage. Also, that natural gas price may change.
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by bombcar on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @06:35PM (#34167501)
If you want to spend the money you can get systems that have heat pump, gas furnace/boiler, and electric. Often used for larger installations that can take advantage of differing prices - and can work best with water heat.
Re:US companies are producing heat pumps that work below -20... by nightski on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @04:23PM (#34166166)
The main reason in my area is that a.) these fancy new efficient ones aren't available easily and b.) no contractors in the area to install/service them. I just got a new gas furnace and really wanted to add a heat pump to the mix but after several quotes all of them either said no or strongly avoided the question. I couldn't get a straight answer.