News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by chroma on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:44PM (#34087391)
> I haven't seen any servers with peculiar rules.

The peculiar rules aren't written down. Admins will ban you for whatever reason they want.[1] This can include DMs that both parties are fine with (but not the server admin, who can read them), or behavior off of the site.[2][3]

The problem isn't solved if you go through the trouble of setting up your own server. De-federation is common[4] (often for absurd reasons[5]), and blacklists are shared across many instances.[6]

1. https://twitter.com/triketora/status/1594348646396559361

2. https://twitter.com/WashburneAlex/status/1605268536930213907

3. https://twitter.com/LefterisJP/status/1593934653114785793

4. https://fba.ryona.agency/scoreboard?blockers=50

5. https://twitter.com/ajaromano/status/1594432548222152705

6. https://github.com/weirderearth/weirder-rules/blob/main/sugg...

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by zzzeek on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:57PM (#34087497)
> Admins will ban you for whatever reason they want.[1]

from the link you provided, the admins respond:

"This post was removed by mistake and we apologize. We’ve recently hired more moderators and the post in question was falsely interpreted to be implying something it was not."

for [5], the journa.host server had a lot of problems out of the gate, including some suspicion they were sharing ban-evasion tools, but is not currently defederated for the most part. I follow lots of people on that host and I'm on a different server. the thread there illustrates the reasons which IMO were not unreasonable for a brand new server attracting a lot of attention with odd moves.

not that moderation isn't fraught with tons of problems, but I dont think large servers have admins that are capriciously banning people for made-up reasons the way Musk has been doing on Twitter.

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by glenstein on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @09:10PM (#34088866)
And to your point, in addition to those examples being unreliable, they're a small smattering of one-offs in a context of vast numbers of users on huge servers. By and large the typical server doesn't have idiosyncratic rules, and the scenario contemplated here is a fever dream.

As Twitter has imploded, people have increasingly complained about unrepresentative strange examples that don't accurately reflect the day-to-day experience of being on Mastodon.

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by brabel on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:30AM (#34090795)
Mastodon servers can hire moderators?? How do they make money? I thought Mastodon was all about not-for-profit social media and there's no way for Mastodon server admins to make any money as there's no ads?? Not a Mastodon user, just trying to understand who is a Mastodon admin (given the large powers they seem to have) and what's in it for them.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by pimeys on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:22AM (#34091062)
People donate money to the servers they're in.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by zzzeek on Thursday December 22, 2022 @08:45AM (#34093131)
there's an entire universe of not for profit organizations that hire staff and dont have ads....
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by brabel on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:29PM (#34096662)
Which ones run Mastodon servers? What's the purpose of such organizations?
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by smoldesu on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:57PM (#34087502)
> Admins will ban you for whatever reason they want.

Apparently the same thing happens on Twitter now. If the "Twitter Files" are to be believed, it's happened for a long time before that.

Frankly, I think all of this absurd rule-making is fine. If you disagree with it, nobody can stop you from creating your own instance and federating with all the great/terrible sites you want. The irony that these 'sky is falling' posts come from lifelong Twitter users feels like the icing on the cake. Nobody owes you anything on the internet; not Twitter, not Elon, and not the few-thousand instance admins who host servers out-of-pocket.

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by chroma on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @06:15PM (#34087650)
The problem is that if you federate with the bad instances, you'll get de-federated from other instances. The people running the biggest instances think that anyone who reads anything on poa.st or gab or truth.social for any reason must be a nazi, and therefore worthy of banning.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by thejohnconway on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @06:46PM (#34087911)
In practice this is not true. De-federating based on association is not common, and mostly used by very tight and usually small servers. The big ones don't do that.

Truth social defederated itself.

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by romwell on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:56PM (#34089980)
>De-federating based on association is not common

As long as it's possible, it will happen.

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by smoldesu on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:07AM (#34090049)
And it should. The alternative (forcing everyone to ingest everything) makes the system rife for abuse in all sorts of ways.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by chroma on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:20AM (#34090416)
You only see the objectionable stuff if you follow those accounts or people who retweet those accounts. De-federation prevents people who want to communicate from communicating.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by toofy on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:44AM (#34090878)
> De-federation prevents people who want to communicate from communicating.

no, it doesn’t. in fact, it’s far better than any of the centralized private closed off social media liek fb or twitter.

it absolutely does not stop you from joining any mastodon server you want to join.

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by thejohnconway on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:14AM (#34090386)
It does in certain places, as I said, but the big mainstream servers don’t do it.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by int_19h on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:18AM (#34091042)
Here's the list of who defederated whom:

https://fba.ryona.agency/scoreboard?blockers=300

I looked at mastodon.social, and I don't see any entries in their list where the reason is "federates with bad servers":

https://fba.ryona.agency/?reverse=mastodon.social

OTOH here's an example of a small instance which does this sort of thing:

https://fba.ryona.agency/?reverse=freethought.online

So, which big instances are doing this?

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by tptacek on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @06:04PM (#34087569)
That was true in the "blogosphere" too, and nobody freaked out about it. We only take it seriously now because we've spent over a decade hypnotized into believing that a "social network" presenting a single global unified namespace of participants is somehow so important that it's practically a public utility. In a single unified namespace, who's blocked and who isn't is very important.

The fediverse implicitly asks the question: what if that assumption is wrong? What if we had as many of the affordances of (say) Twitter as we could get, but the global connectivity model of blogs? In the blogosphere, it hardly even makes sense to ask who's "blocked".

I remember the height of the blogosphere as a pretty happening time for discourse on the Internet, so it's not a silly question.

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by chroma on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @06:12PM (#34087627)
Blogs getting banned was much rarer back then because people were less censorious. But the proper model isn't blogs, it's e-mail. Imagine getting banned from your email provider because you sent a political opinion, or even a sarcastic comment. That would be absurd.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by dale_glass on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @06:31PM (#34087803)
People weren't less censorious.

The early Internet was full of professionals. There wasn't that much to censor because people were mostly crafting pages connected to their professional work, or showcasing their cool hobbies.

Once the normal people started flooding in, there was a lot of drama and a lot of censorship, it was just contained in silos. Forums had moderation, cliques and weird rules. A discussion about a game for kids could explode in drama, banning and rivalries, it just didn't spread very far like it does today, when you have whole sites and groups dedicated to cataloguing all the drama happening elsewhere.

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by im3w1l on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @09:03PM (#34088824)
I think the separation of email provider (identity, very rarely bans) and listserver provider (community) is pretty neat.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by acdha on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:59PM (#34089623)
People definitely got banned back then. There were three key differences:

1. Getting banned from Twitter means leaving a global namespace. Getting banned from the comments on someone’s blog was far less serious, and if someone on a group blog had a falling out it just meant that they setup another one (the Mastodon model). Earlier things like Usenet groups had moderation but people could easily move to another group.

2. The stakes were lower: the early internet was full of academics, professionals, etc. and still had this aura of not really mattering. That doesn’t mean that everyone was nice but the ratio was a lot better and it wasn’t anywhere near as coordinated – the creationists and Scientologists were both annoying but they certainly didn’t work together. The odds of some online flap even reaching the awareness of your friends, family, or coworkers were low and it probably would have seemed more like an amusing joke than something serious.

3. An American specialization of the previous point: the hardcore right-wing took over the Republican Party, successfully purged the moderates, and started recruiting young reactionaries. 9/11 changed what a lot of people felt was acceptable to say or do – I remember when Glenn Reynolds was a fairly normal-sounding law professor with a blog in that brief span before 9/11 & the war blogs broke him – and over the 2000s they felt fewer checks as their power & numbers grew. Obama getting elected brought a LOT of voices out which many of us had thought had disappeared in our parents’ or grandparents’ generation, and by the mid-2010s they were recruiting young people from anti-feminist communities in places like 4chan and Reddit (before GamerGate but that’s when it really ramped up). Nothing unprecedented in terms of message but the numbers and degree to which they were welcomed into the party and started setting the tone was dramatic. There’s a fair argument that some of those views were not uncommon before but had been more genteelly expressed, but I am reminded of how aggressively GOP leaders shut down David Duke in the 90s.

I mention politics not just because I think that normalized a lot of bad behavior but also because it changed how people responded. “Internet drama” wasn’t taken seriously but when it started having real-world consequences and impacting national politics, a lot of people - even those who self-described as free speech advocates – started reconsidering how best to respond. Volume also enters into the picture: the first time you see something, you might try to engage. By the dozenth time, you’re a lot more inclined to get out the ban hammer.

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by scrollaway on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:00AM (#34090316)
Fantastic and accurate summary.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by fzeroracer on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:15PM (#34089727)
According to whom were people less censorious? You? Where's your data on this point? What eras of the internet have you lived through?

Because I've gone through the whole IRC and early forums era of 20+ years ago. People got banned, formed their own IRC channels or forums colloquially called treehouses and life went on. Blogs were no different and if a blog was particularly bad it would get banned and the user would go and host their own blog elsewhere. Hell, you can go further back and see Usenet banning stuff related to white power groups.

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by chroma on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:16AM (#34090402)
To give you some idea of the eras of the internet I've been through: I used BBSes. I posted on alt.2600.hackerz. I attended the defcon shoot before deviant took it over.

In the past, you had to do some crazy stuff to get your blog taken down or get k-lined. Now your internet presence (and possibly your career) are at risk if you don't keep up with the new taboos.

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by int_19h on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:04AM (#34090979)
Were people ever banned for not banning someone (whom they haven't even had any contact with)?
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by toofy on Thursday December 22, 2022 @02:30AM (#34090794)
> …was much rarer back then because people were less censorious.

i wish this absurd idea would disappear.

communities on the internet have _always_ banned people for all sorts of reasons. always. since bbs’, since irc, since forums, since email lists, and on and on and on.

always have.

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by lmm on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:06PM (#34089251)
> That was true in the "blogosphere" too, and nobody freaked out about it.

It wasn't; the blogosphere had no-one sitting in the place where Mastodon server admins sit. The closest equivalent would be, what, webring admins? But a single blog could be part of any number of webrings, so getting dropped from one wasn't a big deal, and I don't remember any shenannigans like banning members of another webring from commenting (and even if that kind of spat did happen, comment banning happened at the individual blog level, not at the "server" level).

Some people did get banned from the actual servers, e.g. Livejournal or Wordpress, but that was a Big Deal rather than something that happened over social drama between tinpot admins. I remember e.g. Dreamwidth being set up in response to some content policy, but that was a one-time event and a clear content policy. And even then, no-one was trying to block these whole servers off from each other; if anything they went out of their way to allow e.g. commenting under an account from somewhere else.

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by tptacek on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:08PM (#34089259)
No, I think it's basically the same. If you're concerned about this stuff, you boot up your own server.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by lmm on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:16PM (#34089312)
As the article says, that's just a P2P social network by the back door, with a software system that's overcomplicated and poorly tuned for that use case.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by tptacek on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:40PM (#34089502)
I don't understand the argument. It seems like precisely the same thing is true of the "network" of blog hosts at the height of the blogosphere, which included large shared blogging platforms like Blogger that might have "censored" you.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by lmm on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:55AM (#34090293)
I mentioned Livejournal, Wordpress, and Dreamwidth. Yes, it was possible to get banned from these large hosts. But that was an extreme action, and the people with the power to do that were seen as quite distinct from the much smaller communities on the platform.

No-one at the particular social rank of a Mastodon server admin existed in that world - an elevated position that has powers that regular users don't, but nevertheless interacts directly with the user community. And that really does change the social dynamics a lot. (Some other platforms did have comparable roles - BBS operators, forum mods - and I don't think it's coincidence that they tended to have more drama)

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by tptacek on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:03AM (#34090324)
I'm sure you'll have no trouble finding Mastodon servers where the admins go on stupid power-trips. But there's nothing in the whole system working against you just standing your own instance up, or, for that matter, running 10 concurrent accounts different servers, like RSS feeds in Google Reader. It just doesn't seem like a real issue, unlike on Twitter, where it is quite obviously a clear and present issue,.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by Tomte on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:29AM (#34090461)
> where the admins go on stupid power-trips

I feel it's mostly not stupid power trips, but some more benign psychological effect: you left Twitter, set up your own Mastodon instance and told everyone how cool it is that the power to police your community (your safe space) isn't in Elon's hands, but in "ours".

Now some trivial fight happens on your server, or a misunderstanding. You could sit back and observe the situation for a bit, but damn, you went this whole Mastodon route, so you can finally act! The pressure to act is immense, even it it may be self-imposed.

Now add all the other people who feel similar pressures and are therefore quick to call you complicit. The post is there, what else do you need? Of course you must ban, de-federate, whatever. Now! That was the whole point of it. Even if nobody actually demands it, you can imagine it quite well. Better act before someone calls you out.

How did people in IRC handle it back in the time? By having a mostly homogenous group of users?

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by tptacek on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:39AM (#34090519)
No. IRC was also a sort of global namespace. There's no such thing (that I can see) in the fediverse. Handles are closer to RSS links than they are to Twitter accounts, and the tooling just blurs the difference.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by lmm on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:14AM (#34090384)
"Better than Twitter" is a very low bar, certainly far below "social network I'm interested in using".

Standing up a private instance is possible but not yet easy, AIUI; you need a server running 24/7, you need your own domain, the mainstream server software can't currently be used with SNI-style shared hosting. I don't know how good the client support for multiple accounts is, and even if it's good, it seems to rather undermine the point of a federated social network - at that point I might as well use old-school forums via something like TapaTalk. Possible is a good first step, but if the system isn't designed and focused on that kind of use case (and the fact that it's not built as a pure P2P system suggests it's not), then it's never going to be easy, and that matters.

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by tptacek on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:20AM (#34090423)
When we're at the point where we're putting "you need your own domain" on the table, I think we're below the threshold where this is worth debating.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by LinuxBender on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:08AM (#34093364)
I think it's closer to IRC's shared gzlines on the smaller networks or Usenet's KillFiles that people used to promote group-think and group-ban people, sometimes for good reasons and sometimes for deviating from group-think. I suspect Mastodon will become a medium sized bubble or silo as a result. I personally will just hang back and watch the show. Mastodon appears to be a continuation of the Twitter fallout and peeled some tribes off into their own medium sized bubble. It will be good for growth but I have no idea what the end result will look like.

I believe the biggest threat to Mastodon is that it breaks up some of the control centralized governmental and corporate powers have to influence the way people think and feel a.k.a. winning the hearts and minds of the people. An interesting project might be to create some machine learning that tries to identify when Mastodon is being infiltrated by these entities.

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by iudqnolq on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:10AM (#34090069)
> The fediverse implicitly asks the question: what if that assumption is wrong?

Yep. And I and maybe others are answering that question: Nope, we want a single namespace. And then fediverse proponents pop up to tell us actually we're wrong about what we want.

The primary thing I want from social media is algorithmic discovery. I love bumping into cool, interesting people I wouldn't have encountered otherwise. With the fediverse I can't even reliably see the past posts of someone I follow if they're on a different server.

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by tptacek on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:21AM (#34090122)
You can want whatever you want. 2 years ago, I'd have agreed with you. But I remember the blogosphere now, and: it was better than what we had 2 months ago. I wrote off Mastodon, but this is a better situation than Twitter. I'm psyched. The tooling isn't perfect yet, but it'll be better than Twitter's tooling within 12 months --- not least because there won't be a giant public company doing its level best to make sure the tooling doesn't get too good.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by madeofpalk on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @07:04PM (#34088046)
Right, this is true with any website that you don’t run. dang can come in here and ban whoever he wants for whatever reason. At the end of the day, if you’re going to a platform (specific mastodon instance) ran by someone else, you’ve got to have an amount of trust in who’s running it.

But Mastodon and ActivityPub do attempt to mitigate this - you can run your own instance (and of course, you’re not entitled for someone else to republish you) to seize back some of that control. Followers and follows are a lot more portable, so it’s easier to move instances (which is party automated)

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by throwawaylinux on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @08:10PM (#34088486)
Yech. Sounds exactly like what you'd expect to happen if subreddits were federated like this. The "mod" role and wielding this kind of petty power over others attracts a certain kind of fragile egomaniac.

Not that it's not a problem on a centralized site either mind you, as the Twitter Files have been revealing.

Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by acjohnson55 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @08:51PM (#34088753)
The defederation "wars" will end. People who want to be in walled garden instances, with their own sense of community, cut off from unpredictable sets of other users will have what they want. But I think most users will migrate to places where only the truly bad actor instances are cut off. I've already observed this from my old Tweeps. Defederation is way too blunt of a tool for most cases.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by DoItToMe81 on Saturday December 24, 2022 @11:15AM (#34118198)
It will likely end as culture warring weirdos in their spectrum's echo chamber while normal people leave for commercial sites or go back to Twitter. Mastodon needs a culture of openness and general tolerance that it does not have and has made no real effort to foster.
Re:Mastodon is not a good social network by jmprspret on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:03PM (#34089645)
> Admins will ban you for whatever reason they want.

That's another feature, not another bug.

Don't like the admin's moderation style or rules, etc on a particular? Move to a different one. Simple.