News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by keb_ on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:09AM (#34081629)
I had recently remembered that I used Binance to purchase $100 worth of XRP in 2017 (around the time everyone was jumping on the crypto wagon), so I decided to try to log in to see how my investment was going.

This is when I found out Binance no longer allowed US investors, and I was redirected to a US site (Binance.us). The problem was my account was on Binance.com, and it was not migrated in anyway to this new US site.

I contacted support and they gave me a 7 day period to log in and withdraw my funds (which in itself is weird -- why not just migrate my account to the US site; why the sketchy, arbitrary 7 day period? whatever). I was finally able to log in! And I saw that my $100 investment had (unsurprisingly) turned into $17. I chuckled and tried to get my 17 bucks out anyway, only to find that the site no longer even offers a way to withdraw funds as an American!

This whole experience that spanned maybe an hour was hilarious. I've resigned to the fact that I was scammed out of a hundred bucks. Woulda been nice to use that to buy a few games on Steam, but oh well, here we are. Hope this tale at least amuses or informs someone.

Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by darkwizard42 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:17AM (#34081739)
You can withdraw your money by moving it to a Binance US wallet or honestly any other wallet (including one on Coinbase) and withdraw from there in USD.

I’m not sure where you missed this in your exploration. I went through this recently as well.

Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by hartator on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:01AM (#34082405)
Maybe it's not worth to give away all your data again to maybe get $17?
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by keb_ on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:32AM (#34082825)
I did consider that, and at first tried to, but then it asked me to verify my identity. Which I had done already years ago. I frankly did not feel like going through all the trouble of uploading my drivers license/supporting documents for $17. Maybe I'll try again before the 7 days is up? IDK it's the week of Christmas.
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by Lionga on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:17AM (#34081733)
You can check out anytime you like, but you can never leave in the Hotel of Binance
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by smabie on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:53AM (#34082256)
Can't withdraw funds as an American? This is factually not true
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by keb_ on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:37AM (#34082903)
The only way I could see was transferring it to some Euro banks or e-cash services I do not possess. In the withdrawal process, I could not even designate my country as "USA". That or transferring to another coin wallet, but that also required me going through the identification process again (which I had already done in 2017). I did not feel like going down the rabbithole of research/contact support/waiting for $17. I'm lucky enough that I make more than $17 an hour, and I also value my time more than that.
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by raffraffraff on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:58AM (#34082363)
Your % loss in crypto value for that period is almost exactly the same as mine, even though I didn't have any XRP and "spread my investment" over 4 different cryptocurrencies.

Thankfully my "investment" was low enough to walk away from. It was basically an experiment. Glad I did it. Now I know. Of course my wife told me it was a ponzi scheme from the start, and was completely right. The real combined value of all the crypto in the universe is zero. The market just hasn't corrected itself yet.

Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by thatguy0900 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:32AM (#34082834)
As long as you can buy illegal stuff online with it it isn't zero. There's real value in that, to some at least.
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by meepmorp on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:37AM (#34082914)
The real treasure was the German amphetamine paste we bought along the way
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by sizzle on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @07:30PM (#34088222)
Wow never heard of a paste, got any more info so I can learn more about it?
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by science4sail on Thursday December 22, 2022 @03:24PM (#34098167)
Pervitin was believed to be used by the Nazis during WW2 as a combat stimulant. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drug_policy_of_Nazi_Germany?wp...
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by dumbfoundded on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:56AM (#34083167)
It's the dumbest technology to try to buy illegal stuff now. Most coins have touched an exchange and everything you do is public. Once deanonymized, it's the opposite of private.

Monero & Zcash are exceptions and the only parts of crypto I'm bullish about (including some new upcoming chains like Ironfish & Aleo). I think private p2p cash has a lot of value. BTC & ETH are the opposite of private.

Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by kube-system on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:04PM (#34083275)
It's still useful as a means of transferring money for those in jurisdictions that don't care about their illegal activity. Like the countries that tolerate cybercrime as long as it is directed outside of their own borders. Or dictators themselves trying to avoid sanctions.
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by dumbfoundded on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:33PM (#34084502)
It's still useful for now, but it will get less and less so. The tornado cash dev is in jail for writing code that made such efforts easier. Since coins can be marked by "good" actors as having been involved in illegal activity, they can't ever be used again.

Let's say a US company gets ransomware attacked by a Russian national and demands payment in bitcoin. US company pays in bitcoin and later reports crime. All accounts get flagged. Anyone helping that address offramp the money will be in trouble. So there has to be a Russian exchange dealing with Russian banks that's creating a track record of provably aiding in crime. It's either going to be such a small amount no one cares or the Russian companies involved will be sanctioned.

Because of the public permanent record, the utility of ETH and BTC are decreasingly useful. Things like instant international settlement, fast payments, and the alike can always be better done with tradfi. Privacy and avoiding regulation was the only real utility ever.

Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by thatguy0900 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:22PM (#34083498)
For now it seems the agencies with the technical expertise to prosecute arnt going after the occasional drug buyers, it's pretty safe. Of course, nothing stopping future better police from taking through old records
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by altdataseller on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:17PM (#34085077)
What are examples of private p2p cash?
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by dumbfoundded on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:46PM (#34086184)
Monero & Zcash are the best examples right now but like bitcoin, they are volatile and not practical for actual commerce outside of use-cases (like crime) where it's worth the cost.

Stablecoins are a large use case in crypto now but there isn't a private stablecoin yet (I'm ignoring all SGX based technology). A private stablecoin, fully backed by audited bank reserves would enable something like a private Venmo. This private Venmo would know how much you brought in and took out but would have no idea what your transaction history looks like. I think in the next few years we'll see a private Venmo.

Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by WeylandYutani on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:44PM (#34085456)
There's no statute of limitations on buying child pornography in my country. Drugs nobody cares.
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by arcticbull on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:32PM (#34083675)
Anything other than a privacy coin isn't anonymous, it's pseudonymous. Carrying out illicit transactions on a public ledger is akin to just sending your transaction history to every investigative service on earth: the FBI, NSA, CIA - and abroad of course, the PRC government. They are now, or will in the future, just run it through automated deanonymization tooling.

To borrow an expression from Nicholas Weaver, crimes on public ledgers are just prosecution futures.

Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by ls15 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:35PM (#34083721)
> The real combined value of all the crypto in the universe is zero.

Can I have your leftovers?

Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by tnel77 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:06PM (#34084911)
>> The real combined value of all the crypto in the universe is zero. The market just hasn't corrected itself yet.

It’s comments like these that make me happy that Reddit has “RemindMe!”

Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:52PM (#34085537)
"Your % loss in crypto value for that period is almost exactly the same as mine, even though I didn't have any XRP and "spread my investment" over 4 different cruptocurrencies."

The only cryptocurrency that the SEC has said publicly it will not treat as a security is BTC. There are allegedly a few more but the SEC has not disclosed which ones. That leaves every other one open to SEC regulation.

Above every cryptocurrency, save for a few, hangs the sword of Damocles.

With the ongoing FTX story, it is nice to see people on HN are now able to comfortably confess their crypto losses.

Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by ls15 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:04PM (#34085681)
> That leaves every other one open to SEC regulation.

Only those that fail the Howey Test, I think.

    In doing so, the Supreme Court established four criteria to determine whether an investment contract exists. An investment contract is:

    An investment of money
    In a common enterprise
    With the expectation of profit
    To be derived from the efforts of others
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/h/howey-test.asp
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by 3np on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @07:31PM (#34088232)
> The only cryptocurrency that the SEC has said publicly it will not treat as a security is BTC

ETH has been addressed as well as not being a considered a security (anymore). This was before the switch to PoS. I have not heard or seen anything indicating that the PoS transition would change this.

Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @09:10PM (#34101575)
July 25 2017

"Whether or not a particular transaction involves the offer and sale of a security -- regardless of the terminology used -- will depend on the FACTS AND CIRCUMSTANCES, including the economic realities of the transaction."

https://www.sec.gov/litigation/investreport/34-81207.pdf

June 14 2018

"I would like to emphasize that the analysis of whether something is a security is not static and DOES NOT STRICTLY INHERE TO THE INSTRUMENT.[10] Even digital assets with utility that function solely as a means of exchange in a decentralized network could be packaged and sold as an investment strategy that can be a security. If a promoter were to place Bitcoin in a fund or trust and sell interests, it would create a new security. Similarly, investment contracts can be made out of virtually any asset (including virtual assets), provided the investor is reasonably expecting profits from the promoter's efforts."

Further...

"[1] The Securities and Exchange Commission disclaims responsibility for any private publication or statement of any SEC employee or Commissioner. This speech expresses the author's views and does not necessarily reflect those of the Commission, the Commissioners or other members of the staff."

https://www.sec.gov/news/speech/speech-hinman-061418

Fall 2018

40:20 Gensler says ETH "passed the Howey Test", i.e., it is a security. 46:04 Gensler says XRP is a security.

https://ia903107.us.archive.org/23/items/MIT15.S12F18/MIT15_...

March 7 2019

"Your letter also asks whether I agree with certain statements concerning digital tokens in Director Hinman's June 2018 speech. I agree that the analysis of whether a digital asset is offered or sold as a security is not static and does not strictly inhere to the instrument."

April 6 2021

https://coincenter.org/files/2019-03/clayton-token-response....

"MR. BLISS: So I want to make clear that this is my understanding of the current situation and I don't want to be overly technical but the SEC, itself, my understanding, it has not taken an official position. There is no action that it took to say Bitcoin is not a security, Ether is not a security. Now, there was a speech by a high-ranking person who said that to him that's what it looked like but there has been no action letter, no enforcement action, none of the official ways in which the SEC takes a position on that matter that has occurred. What I understand defendants to be referencing is the speech by Mr. Hinman which is not an official statement of the Securities and Exchange Commission itself."

https://www.crypto-law.us/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/210406_...

June 23 2021

"11. On June 14, 2018, I delivered a public speech entitled "Digital Asset Transactions: When Howey Met Gary (Plastic)" (the "Speech"). I began the speech with the following disclaimer: "My remarks are mine alone, not necessarily those of the Commission, the Commissioners, or the staff." The text of the Speech, which is publically available on the Commission's website, contains a similar disclaimer: "The Securities and Exchange Commission disclaims responsibility for any private publication or statement of any SEC employee or Commissioner. This speech expresses the author's views and does not necessarily reflect those of the Commission, the Commissioners or other members of the staff.""

"13. The Speech was intended to express my own personal views. During my preparation of the Speech, I discussed my thoughts with other Commission employees, as part of the Commission's ongoing deliberations about whether offers and sales of Ether constituted securities transactions. To the best of my knowledge, the Commission had not taken at that time, and still has not taken, any position or expressed a view as to whether offers and sales of Ether constituted offers and sales of securities."

https://www.docketalarm.com/cases/New_York_Southern_District...

Here is the question it appears no one wants to answer, the "elephant in the room": With all the financial and legal resources at their disposal, why are "crypto entrpreneurs" so reluctant to register their "digital assets" with the SEC. As an investor I appreciate the value of SEC disclosures.

Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by chemmail on Thursday December 22, 2022 @05:23PM (#34099669)
You can replace crypto with anything in the universe: any company, any country, and planet. The timing is what matters.
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by lebed2045 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:05AM (#34082458)
Lucky you. I deposited a bunch on ethers in 2017/18 and wasn’t being able to withdraw anything since. They claim my passport isn’t enough, so I couldn’t withdraw the same money I deposited to the same address. After several weeks of attempts I gave up and call it a loss.

So, saying it out loud: Binance had scammed me. Happy to jump of public debate about it on Twitter(same nickname).

Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by sy7ar on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:07AM (#34082481)
So you can't pass KYC, sounds like you're the real scammer.
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by lebed2045 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:22AM (#34082684)
Well, this is a problem. As a little man who shared a personal story - there’s no way people on internet can believe me over all mighty Binance.

But this is my story, Binance took my deposit and never gave it back. Although I have no influence whatsoever, there are still a few hundred people from the blockchain industry whom I met over a years on hackathons and conferences. Perhaps we might have friends/contacts in common https://twitter.com/lebed2045? via whom happy share all details.

What’s my motivation to lie? when if this story even get attention (that is unlikely) - binance would always able to disprove it by sending tx proofs that they sent money back or never took in the first place?

Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by lebed2045 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:02PM (#34084866)
This is bizarre. There was a reply to this comment from of person who claimed there’s something wrong with me, and when I reply to it with my contacts. Now I don’t see any of this comments. So if the parent comment is deleted- so all replies to it as well?
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by mlyle on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:09PM (#34085746)
It's right there next to your comment, flagged and collapsed by default.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34082481

Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by salawat on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:14PM (#34085815)
Turn on Show-dead in your account profile.

The community will collectively mod nuke comments that are blatant violations of the site guidelines. Those without show-dead on will no longer see it. You can view even dead posts by turning on show-dead.

It also gives you aore accurate view of what Dang has to deal with on a regular basis.

As far as I'm aware, you can't delete a replied to post.

Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by azalemeth on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:17AM (#34091376)
The small fraction of a BTC and ETH I mined about a decade ago mostly as a GPU benchmark are on coinbase at the moment. Currently worth about $1000 they've oscillated wildly and I am both resigned to them going to zero and slightly tempted to leave them there for the full ride (and to avoid tax liabilities)
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by robotnikman on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:11AM (#34082538)
I don't even think you can even withdraw XRP anymore from any exchange due to the whole SEC investigation thing. At least that's what I experienced when I tried last year.
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by starwind on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:39AM (#34082936)
Crypto is def the future
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by chakintosh on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:44PM (#34083869)
Bag holder lol
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by yunohn on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:11PM (#34085002)
They actually did the same in NL, when they ran afoul of regulations here. I had to transfer to Coinbase to cash out.
Re:Binance caught commingling funds between US and internati... by sizzle on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @06:51PM (#34087959)
How much would $100 worth of BTC be worth today?