It's clear they're struggling to compete with a post-acquisition GitHub that effectively has infinite budget from Microsoft.
It's quite easy to get followers. You just post something with a popular hashtag and you get all kinds of followers. How do they help you though? Do people really think, those thousands of people actually read their tweets it they're not some kind of VIP?
Twitter, on the other hand, wants to get users to sign up for a paid subscription and starts banning everyone who is sceptical. That's the best way to drive people away.
After they asfixiated the competition they're free to jack up the prices.
Smart business practice really.
Social media is a different thing, though. You can't just say, well, this change we made drove away journalists and celebrities, so let's put it back how it was and continue. Hard to un-kick a hornet's nest.
And then when he doesn't like the results, delete it and try again.
My Mastodon feed felt very empty a few months ago, but nowadays it's pretty good. A lot of folks switched or set up cross-posting, many of them not technical. Mastodon is doing much better than I expected back then.
This may vary by community. A big chunk of the Infosec community has migrated and seems quite happy about it. Other communities may do the same, particularly if they feel that Twitter isn't likely to be a safe place for them given Musk's increasingly Qbert attitudes.
I'm interested in following them
I don't feel the functionality of Twitter is so critical that it needs to be somehow replicated.
That's some way of equivocating very different situations. Gitlab is a product/platform for developers, not the general public, and Mastodon has received the public's positive attention for much longer than people talked about the buyout.
You don't see HN users belittling Signal because it failed to come even close to replacing Whatsapp's 2B users. In fact the opposite is the case as fanboying the former goes so far that Matrix as the even better alternative is repeatedly argued against.
What you're talking about is exactly the ridiculousness of the situation. People around the world are forced to rely on foreign platforms to communicate and can't leave unless their community follows. This design is the issue, not a particular business.
I'm old enough to have seen the "end" of Myspace before... and kinda like is happening with Twitter now, it started with a little bit at a time, then all at once almost everyone was gone.
Twitter instituting a policy against cross promotion isn't going to save the public square. It's encouraging the rest of the ecosystem to retaliate or to escape.
Pretty much. Among the big anti-Elon names, Kathy Griffin already gave up on Mastodon and is just posting once every 2-3 days now, probably because getting 200 likes on her posts is a major step down from the 100k+ she was regularly getting on Twitter.
> banning them might have actually the opposite effect here: then they get forced to focus on mastodon.
I agree, but if you're a professional relying on engagement metrics for your career--as many artists, musicians, journalists, and social media marketers do--it would take massive, massive guts to go all-in on Mastodon when it clearly has not taken over Twitter's engagement by any extent.
For historical precedent: Instagram instituted a very similar policy to stop people from adding OnlyFans links, but it didn't really decrease IG usage as far as I know. You still need Instagram to "funnel" people into your OF, same as journalists will need Twitter to funnel people into their articles. It's simply too valuable a resource to give up for them.
That was true a few weeks ago, but not anymore (at least for tech/electronics).
I think my mastodon account is at about 30% the following and follower count of my old Twitter account. But it’s largely the _interesting_ 30%; I stopped using twitter a few weeks ago and don’t feel I’m missing out.
Then this new owner started taking over channels and kicking everyone out that had mention of a Libera.chat channel in its topic, forcing everyone to move all at once.
I haven't heard of anyone still on Freenode since then.
I don't think we will get Twitter's metrics (tweets, DAU etc) but let's see how the Mastodon graphs change: https://observablehq.com/@simonw/mastodon-users-and-statuses...
Freenode is orders of magnitude smaller with a technical and picky user base. Moving from freenode to a different server is a much smaller move as nothing changes for the users aside from a one time migration. Twitter is a mass market megaphone used by all sorts of people with different incentives, and the alternative - Mastodon - is vastly inferior for the average user who doesn't care about Elon's drama.
But here's the thing - just enough of the people I follow are active on mastodon. It's about a quarter (78 out of 310) of who i was followong on twitter, but it's enough to give me an interesting timeline (also considering a bunch of them were muted obligation follows).
So I've fully moved over. The few people that were following me will notice one less person in their timeline, and eventually possibly make the jump as well.
I feel like someone could crack this with an attempted replacement. Go out of the way to create incentive for people to interact with each other.
I feel the same with the "find me on mastodon" twitter bios: people will realize that only 50 of their thousands of followers can be found on mastodon, and then move back in a few weeks after giving up on the experiment. During all that time they have still kept most of their activities on twitter because there is simply more going on there, more replies to their tweets, more tweets to reply to, etc.
banning them might have actually the opposite effect here: then they get forced to focus on mastodon. Having a large number of users advertise mastodon ids and talk all day long about how horrible twitter is on twitter actually drives engagement. Banning large numbers of users is very bad for engagement on the other hand, but very good for mastodon engagement numbers.