This is a genuine question; I'm trying to separate possible FUD from the truth here. I lived in NYC 20 years ago, and you're not describing anything different.
> Public parks full of criminal element that make walking through it a high-stress, high-alert situation
This one is especially laughable, nothing could be further from the truth
Also lived in both. It's absolutely different, but it depends on the neighborhood. I'd say that SF's average level of horribleness (when I left in 2017) was about the same as the bad parts of Harlem or the Bronx, or the area around Penn Station / PABT. But sure, if you go to the burb/bougie parts of SF, like West Portal, or even Pac Heights, then it's very different from SOMA or Civic Center. Just like SoHo is very different from East Harlem.
But it's gaslighting to pretend that the two are equivalent. New York is unquestionably better, overall (for starters, the police in NYC will typically actually do something when property crimes are being committed in the open air, which is more than I can say for SF.)
Parts of it are just like NYC before the cleanup to turn it into a tourist destination. Chinatown and area around it absolutely reminded of late 80s/early 90s in NY. Has that vibe.
Parts of it -- here is looking at you Pacific Heights -- are just completely off the scale amazing. I would move in a heartbeat to PH if I could afford it, crime be damned. (Looked pretty damn safe too, btw.)
tldr; it ain't a "shithole" if you are rich (like everywhere else). far from it.
But the other ones, having lived in San Francisco for a couple years and visited semifrequently afterwards, do feel sort of distinctively west coast.
Certainly the reported normalization of daylight retail store robberies seems pretty abnormal!
Context is important...for example in Tokyo this would be highly unusual.
> I was worried Austin was on the cusp of such problems a year or two ago when the mayor implemented SF style policies
Extreme eye rolling here...
Every underpass was filled with tent cities and trash. Downtown was covered with urine and there were protests that got out of control. Very little of that now.
The encampments just got moved, they still exist. The cops left behind a ton of garbage too that was otherwise mostly handled by the homeless when the city was distributing garbage bags. Protests never got serious here at all, so curious what gave you that impression.
At least here in Antwerp this is not normal at all, even though there is apparently a pretty big mafia who like making grenades explode.
In fact, I can't recall visiting any city, even in other countries, where this is considered "normal".
> Mentally ill people in high-traffic areas that openly use drugs and defecate on the sidewalk.
What is the solution to this? Round them up and put them in jail? Bus them to another city? Forcibly enroll them at a mental health facility? Improving housing costs somehow? Free housing for the homeless? Maybe walk-in drug clinics?
Some of these solutions sound inhumane. Others appear to be politically impossible at the scale needed. So what's the solution and why are the people who live there against it?
Many other large cities handle this well, so it seems to pretend there aren't solutions? I've spent recent time in London, New York, and Bangkok -- as well as a number of smaller cities -- and there's nothing like what I saw in SF.
https://nypost.com/2019/10/26/nyc-homeless-initiative-sends-...
Would not file this under “handling it well”
So, NYC gives homeless people a year of rent anywhere those people think they’ll be able to make it work, including NYC. And the program seems to save the city money.
“SOTA is only provided to households whom DSS has determined will likely have the future ability to pay the rent once they no longer have the SOTA grant to cover their rent.”
That sounds like a very high bar for people in the situation of needing rent coverage and especially if they have mental illness and/or drug addiction. Note that busing people to another city appears to be a separate program.
We are the boiled frog. Most here seem to think this sort of thing is normal now.
I grew up here and when nobody knew about Seattle. It was a awesome place to live. Now, not such a good place. You add yearly 1+ month of forest fire smoke to the mix. It doesn't leave to much left.
Even according to SPD’s own crime reporting dashboard[0], incidents have not gone up drastically in the last two years like you are implying, and this year’s numbers look like they are trending back down to 2018 levels. Seattle’s issues also certainly didn’t start two years ago, anyone who has lived here has known about things like 3rd being extremely sketchy. Hell, even back in 2011 that was a thing. It’s certainly far from new. Problems have certainly gotten worse in the last two years but let’s not sit here and pretend the city was roses and unicorns before 2020.
And how, exactly is it Seattle resident’s fault that there’s smoke now?
[0]: https://www.seattle.gov/police/information-and-data/crime-da...
Mentally ill people in high-traffic areas that openly use drugs and defecate on the sidewalk.
High chance of having your car window smashed and car contents stolen.
Retail stores putting ever more items behind lock and key.
Women feeling unsafe walking alone in many areas of the city after dark.
Public parks full of criminal element that make walking through it a high-stress, high-alert situation.
All of this results in a high level of general anxiety and makes it an unpleasant place to live or even visit. Anyone who still lives in SF, I feel extremely bad that this is your life. It’s extremely sad.