2) I don't think he's arguing that everyone who thinks crypto is a scam is that sort of person, he was saying that most people who have been scammed are.
3) Molly White's number's agree with OP's. $12 billion vs a market cap of $858B is roughly the same percentage identified in the article. And before you complain about the use of market cap as denominator, market cap is also the numerator being used by Molly White's analysis, so it's the correct denominator.
Around the same time, some people realized that bitcoin was deflationary. And, you had two groups: One started hoarding coins and pumping it, and the other group realized it was a pyramid and had too good a conscious to participate. And, the pumping continued until today. And, maybe some people are sour?
Then, for 14 years, tons of money was dumped into it, and not much happened. It's still mainly used for black market goods. It still has terrible user interface. The transaction rate is still low. The transaction fees are high. And, it's too easy to have your coins stolen.
I agree that, in the case of Bitcoin specifically, it's still primarily used for black market goods (excluding speculation, of course), among relatively wealthy developed market users. However, there are a non-trivial number of genuine users among economies with less stable banking systems, as the OP points out. And it isn't true that fees are still high and tx rate is still low, the lightning network solves that problem. It hasn't seen super widespread adoption yet, but the technical problem, as far as fees and transaction rates, is essentially solved. What you are correct about though is that the UX is still pretty terrible for the average person. However, in some places, that UX is a better alternative than the one they have access to locally.
If you live in a stable economy with good governance and a trustworthy financial system, you don't need crypto. Unfortunately, that does not describe everyone in the world. It may not even describe half of the world.
ie, it's not fine.
1) People should be more hesitant to speak in absolutes. Unfortunately it’s possible that having a nuanced take is inversely correlated with the tendency to post noisy comments online. Maybe, regardless of the underlying stance of “most” skeptics, some more honest dialogue is warranted. Point conceded.
2. Hm. If that’s the case, the author’s assertion that most people who have been scammed are the kinds of people who fall for scams is fair, but not going to change many minds.
3. This is discussed ad nauseam below, so I’ll just add a reminder that we’re debating the author’s statement that “big crypto projects are very rarely scams” as evidenced by his google search. He goes on to say that “Crypto is a few hundred interesting projects, plus a long tail of thousands of scams.” So, most crypto projects are safe if you just ignore most crypto projects and only consider the most dominant. Realized losses vs unrealized market cap aside, the dynamics that incentivize that long tail of scams are worth worrying about in my view.
For 3, I think his statement as written "big crypto projects are very rarely scams" is clearly not literally true in a meaningful sense, and it's right to criticize him for that. However, I think a weaker statement like "The people that complain that crypto projects are scams are overstating how dense the space is with scams" is probably more accurate.
It's sort of hard to determine how to weight an analysis of the density of scams in a space. Certainly if you weight by project count, it'll be quite high. If you weight by market cap, it'll be considerably lower. But to your actual point, I agree worrying about scams in crypto is very important, and I read the OP as (admittedly, somewhat carelessly) trying to argue against the view that "all" or "nearly all" crypto projects are scams.
I think a better way to state it might be something like: Post dotcom bubble pop a lot of people were saying "those internet companies were all scams", and they were right in some kind of media-attention-weighted sense, and maybe even some other senses. But there were certainly a lot of real and important companies there, and even a lot of near-real-and-important companies that were just a little ahead of their time and didn't make it, and I don't think it's fair to dismiss most of them as scams.
I'd definitely say crypto is still in the pre-making-it stage of its lifecycle, and it remains to be seen whether any of these projects will end up being say, the Google or Amazon of this space, that survives the winter and goes on to do meaningful things. However, even if they all die, I think it's fair to say that e.g. Ethereum and Bitcoin were sincere attempts at building novel technology.
Is this any different from the stock market? There are about 6000 companies listed on the NYSE and NASDAQ. According to [1] there are about 10,000 penny stocks traded OTC. Not every NYSE/NASDAQ company is legit and not every penny stock is a scam, but we're still looking at an awful lot of fraud out there.
Seems like the incentives for financial fraud are obvious and eternal.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/18/business/penny-stocks-tra...
1) Fiat is controlled by government --- we don't trust it.
2) I know --- let's build de-centralized, trustless money without government.
3) Yikes! Government must save us from the fraud hellscape we have naively created.
4) But wait --- isn't crypto with government oversight and control basically just fiat all over again?
5) Crypto isn't trustworthy, I think we'll just stick with fiat --- the unwashed masses.
6) Wait, without the masses on board, crypto can never be a real functioning currency.
7) I think we'll just stick with fiat --- cryptobros.
I think we're currently at about step 4 or 5.
Source: https://www.ecb.europa.eu/press/blog/date/2022/html/ecb.blog...
(also some legal ones, tho)
It's a feature, obviously. Why is "useful for illegal transactions" supposed to be a bad thing, when these illegal transactions are illegal for extremely dubious reasons?
Ofc it's bad from the perspective of the people who want control over you. Good.
Not being allowed to buy/possess drugs is a stupid law, but preventing illegal transactions in the public financial system is a feature, not a bug. If you want to buy drugs, do it the old fashioned way - you know, the way society did it for thousands of years prior to bitcoin.
A scam transaction is one where one party would not have committed said transaction had they known the truth. It is an unwilling transaction (aka, scam).
An illegal transaction is one where both parties are willing, but the state deems said transaction is illegal under their purview. I argue that there should be no such a type of transaction - the state should allow _all_ transactions from _all_ parties that are willing. The illegal part should only apply to an action resulting from the transaction, such as hitman for hire.
e.g, The act of paying someone to kill someone else is legal, but the act of killing is illegal. The act of paying someone for an illicit drug is legal, but possession is illegal.
Why should it be legal to pay somebody to kill? That seems insane to me. Especially since the laws in many countries could/would hold financial institutions liable for any murder they inadvertently facilitated by processing that transaction. If it wasn’t disallowed by the state, the private institutions would prohibit it of their own accord. What’s the difference?
There are also many laws regarding incitement to violence and the like. Paying a hit man would be that, no?
“I don’t want the government to tell me what to do” is childish. Tell me why a society should tolerate the ability to pay for a hitman if we’ve already agreed that murder is wrong?
Why? Why is it better to actively facilitate the act of paying an assassin than it is to not do that?
> if we lived in a society where all flow of money goes through some govement entity
Lovely strawman you've built there. However, I don't think I claimed that all money should flow through some government entity. For the record, I don't think it should. Making the act of paying for an assassination illegal != making some government entity responsible for the flow of all money. Holding both the assassin and the payer responsible for either killing somebody or conspiring to kill somebody doesn't seem unreasonable to me.
> we would be in reality some button presses away from Orwell style dystopia.
[citation needed] go work in government and then tell me that anything is "some button presses away" from anything else.
for assassinations, may be we currently all agree that it isn't good to allow it to happen. However, that is only just an extreme example, for which it is something most people would agree should be illegal. But what about other actions?
Killing the ability to transact, regardless of the subject of a transaction, is detrimental to change, and entrenches existing powers/authority. These existing authority should not feel safe implementing new laws, if there are ways that could circumvent them. This makes the authority remain honest, and only implement laws that would have popular support.
You have successfully convinced me that you’re either a parody account or GPT-4 in training. This is insane.
Yes - legally this is fraud.
> An illegal transaction is one where both parties are willing, but the state deems said transaction is illegal under their purview.
And in every single place I know of in the world, fraud is illegal.
Don't waste our time with this.
The discussion in this HN thread has been calling both of the above "illegal", and not distinguishing between them.
IANAL but paying someone to kill someone else is definitely illegal, even if they don't kill them. Isn't that what they got the silk road guy on?
today, yes, the transaction for paying the hitman is illegal, as is the act of the hitman.
What i'm saying is that bitcoins could be a method for which transactions can be made without interference with the state, regardless of the subject of the transaction.
The legality of the transaction's subject is a separate argument.
Is this parody?
The first opium war started in 1839, so even in China, "not quite two centuries" is much more accurate than "centuries at least".
A good argument could be made that these substances weren't really banned in the US until the Controlled Substances Act of 1970. The word "decades" is pretty reasonable.
> If you want to buy drugs, do it the old fashioned way - you know, the way society did it for thousands of years prior to bitcoin.
I’m more making the case that you should just go buy drugs with cash instead of pretending that bitcoin is the only way to do it.
Because some illegal transactions are illegal for very non-dubious reasons, but crypto doesn't make this distinction. (Crypto made ransomware a profitable endeavor.)
Same with cash. Which governments increasingly constrain, for this reason.
Yet there are not as many people commenting enthusiastically about wanting cash to disappear / fail, or suggesting similar measures against it. (KYC, AML...)
Why is cash okay, but _digital equivalent_ is not? When physical transactions are less and less relevant? Why make the decision to basically leave these advantages in the past?
I don't think preventing ransomware attacks or financing terrorism is worth losing the capability to transact freely online. Potential totalitarianism is way more scary than 9/11.
Quote from a book, "Manna":
> With the arrival of robots, tens of millions of people lost their minimum wage jobs and the wealth concentrated so quickly. The rich controlled America’s bureaucracy, military, businesses and natural resources, and the unemployed masses lived in terrafoam, cut off from any opportunity to change their situation. There was the facade of “free elections,” but only candidates supported by the rich could ever get on the ballot. The government was completely controlled by the rich, as were the robotic security forces, the military and the intelligence organizations. American democracy had morphed into a third world dictatorship ruled by the wealthy elite.
> Ultimately, you would expect that there would be riots across America. But the people could not riot. The terrorist scares at the beginning of the century had caused a number of important changes. Eventually, there were video security cameras and microphones covering and recording nearly every square inch of public space in America. There were taps on all phone conversations and Internet messages sniffing for terrorist clues. If anyone thought about starting a protest rally or a riot, or discussed any form of civil disobedience with anyone else, he was branded a terrorist and preemptively put in jail. Combine that with robotic security forces, and riots are impossible.
Because exchanging cash requires physical presence. The introduces friction and requires putative criminals to take risks that they don't have to take with crypto, which makes crime less lucrative.
Crypto is not a digital equivalent to cash no matter how much you say it.
I can pay my tax organisation with cash. They explicitly list the acceptable forms of payment. I cannot send them any sort of crypto currency. Cash is also legal tender. There are times where not accepting cash could have legal consequences. I can reject crypto as much as I want.
I can't help but think these lines of argument are intentionally deceptive. If you just repeat it enough times, other people will as well.
Straw man based on a made-up quote. The article does not mention "useful for illegal transactions" anywhere. The article mentions legal transactions in only two occasions:
- "Bitcoin is rarely used for legal transactions"
- "Bitcoin has never been used to any significant extent for legal real-world transactions."
If you feel the need to refute what the ECB claimed, show where bitcoing is used in any significant extent for legal real-world transactions.
Not even El Salvador, with their push to adopt Bitcoin as the nation's official currency, Bitcoin transactions saw any significant uptake.
"If nothing’s wrong with your country’s financial or political system, then you don’t need crypto. If you use crypto anyway, it will be worse than your regular financial system, because it’s trading off many things you need (efficiency, speed, safety, the good kinds of regulation) for something you don’t need (avoiding the bad kinds of regulation)."
The current head of the ECB, Christine Lagarde, stated this year that "inflation came from nowhere". And this is your source of information on this topic?
It's like referencing a study on climate change by a fossil fuel producer in the 80s.
The more aggressive skeptical argument is that cryptocurrencies can be looked at as a banking system with no government backstop at all, which are vulnerable to a systemic bank panic and run the system -- creating contagion effects that will ultimately knock down all the dominoes. Financial systems are all vulnerable to the fact that they are not stable systems and so they all need circuit breakers and need automatic measures in place to backstop the system in the event of a panic (critics of the argument that I'm making will point out that doesn't produce any certainty of stability, but they miss the point that those measures do make the system more stable). Without those, they'll definitely hit a systemic panic and will unravel sooner rather than later.
All of this is the same with a crypto sceptic. I don't think you can assume crypto has to be a scam or more aptly a speculative investment scheme searching for a purpose. Some day, we could be convinced that crypto is super valuable for solving X, and the day it happens is the day I look to it with interest (still waiting).
My personal opinion and observation is that many people choose to take a stance on topics despite having no need to do so.
I think they would be better served remaining agnostic on most topics despite their priors leaning one way or another.
I don't think this is correct.
Theism vs atheism has pretty drastic impacts on how you live your life. If you believe that you are going to hell unless you do X, Y and Z, you are going to make sacrifices to accomplish those requirements.
I agree theism vs atheism might make a big difference, but I don't see a meaningful difference between agnosticism and atheism in how I would approach life.
Even when it comes to ruling out theism and Gods, it only really matters if you rule out vengeful gods that might punish you for not worshiping them.
If I were 90% certain that a god did not exist, What would I stand to gain by committing to atheism and holding it to be, absolute truth.
I think a more mundane topics are a better example, e.g. the political or social topic of the day.
On the other hand, if you think it's more like 1 in a million, and furthermore that there's a similar chance of other versions of God or other gods existing who have completely different demands on your behavior, then it's a lot more sensible to say "fuck it, I'm going to ignore such possibilities". Which is a practical difference.
I do agree that lots of people would probably do better if they were more comfortable maintaining uncertainty in general.
It might motivate you to more actively oppose policies motivated by religion which are harmful to society.
It might motivate you to openly express your views and thus provide emotional support to other non-believers who are trapped in situations where they cannot express those views without risking physical harm. In Saudi Arabia, for example, being an atheist is a capital offense. And even in the U.S. there are many people in situations where coming out as an atheist puts them at risk of ostracism and destitution.
A polytheist could have a confidence interval on the number of gods (lower case g) that exist (e.g. "I am 90% sure that the number of gods is between 10 and 20"). But that is not typically what one is referring to when speaking of atheists and agnostics.
P ~= 0.3
> and agnostic theists
P ~= 0.7
This looks like the sanewashing[1] anti-pattern. Numerous comments say exactly this, every time it comes up. It's great that you personally have a nuanced opinion on the matter, but you should be careful about speaking for others, or saying what skeptics believe.
From a quick search of HN of "all crypto scam", filtering out ones that aren't endorsing the view, or are throwaway accounts:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33566892
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31012827
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33524215
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33654880
[1] https://andrewaustin.blog/2022/02/14/sanewashing-its-more-wi...
Also, if you want to talk about fraud rate, you need a denominator. A big sounding number by itself is meaningless.
These are people that will boycott people and products remotely associated with crypto.
I don't think the author is trying to argue against the type of skeptic you describe. In fact, they seem to mostly agree.
In short I think you are misconstruing the argument.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/1272903/cryptocurrency-t...
I say my dog is worth a million dollars. You say your cat is worth a million dollars. I trade you my dog for your cat. Then we trade them back.
We've just created 2 million dollars of daily trade volume, err, economic activity.
When looking at value stolen by scammers, what matters is not the daily trade volume, what matters is how much money was put into the ecosystem [1], and what fraction of it was stolen.
[1] Which is a lot less than 180B/day.
This is the rub. If you’re using mcap and mark-to-market rates for total value stolen, it’s completely reasonable to use the same rate to evaluate the size of the system.
https://dune.com/hagaetc/stablecoins
I guess you could argue the billions in daily transfers are wash trading, unless the transfer is part of an exploit, and then it’s not wash trading?
If dogs and cats were fungible, and there was a market for fractions of both that could be exchanged in and out of, and contained hundreds of thousands of USD in standing liquidity, and the value of your dog was $1 million, and the cat was also $1 million, then sure. Swapping the dog for the cat is approximated by $2 million to the same accuracy that many assets (houses, stocks, etc) are described in notional value.
Edit to downvoters: I actually meant it unironically. Thiefs often want to "cash out" as soon as possible. I'm not saying it's a net good, but it feels "real and gritty" as opposed to many other crypto transactions.
Uniswap liquidity providers charge a fee for every swap, proportional to the volume swapped, so faking volume like this would be prohibitively expensive.
So to what degree is trade volume indicative of anything in other things?
Seems like an apples to oranges comparison there.
https://www.security.org/digital-safety/credit-card-fraud-re...
Fraud losses are definitionally realized losses, whereas gross crypto transaction volume includes things like a single entity rebalancing funds across wallets or exchanges.
On a chain with low or zero fees, a single actor can trivially generate billions of transaction volume like that on a single day.
The comparison is suitable to show relative scale: $12B over some years sounds like a lot, until you realize it is a small fraction of the total crypto market. Likewise, you could paint VISA as being rampant with fraud by pointing to the many billions lost per annum in credit card fraud, but this represents a small percentage of all VISA activity.
2) The author strongly implies that skeptics are skeptical because they have fallen for scams (by "clicking on spam emails"). Insulting the intelligence of your opponent is also not a compelling way to refute an argument. I have always been skeptical, I have never been scammed, and I don't think I'm unique.
3) The author's research found that the scam rate "seemed low." Molly White is probably the person working harder than any other to track this scam rate, and her "grift counter" currently reports losses of over $12 billion.
https://web3isgoinggreat.com