A scam transaction is one where one party would not have committed said transaction had they known the truth. It is an unwilling transaction (aka, scam).
An illegal transaction is one where both parties are willing, but the state deems said transaction is illegal under their purview. I argue that there should be no such a type of transaction - the state should allow _all_ transactions from _all_ parties that are willing. The illegal part should only apply to an action resulting from the transaction, such as hitman for hire.
e.g, The act of paying someone to kill someone else is legal, but the act of killing is illegal. The act of paying someone for an illicit drug is legal, but possession is illegal.
Why should it be legal to pay somebody to kill? That seems insane to me. Especially since the laws in many countries could/would hold financial institutions liable for any murder they inadvertently facilitated by processing that transaction. If it wasn’t disallowed by the state, the private institutions would prohibit it of their own accord. What’s the difference?
There are also many laws regarding incitement to violence and the like. Paying a hit man would be that, no?
“I don’t want the government to tell me what to do” is childish. Tell me why a society should tolerate the ability to pay for a hitman if we’ve already agreed that murder is wrong?
Why? Why is it better to actively facilitate the act of paying an assassin than it is to not do that?
> if we lived in a society where all flow of money goes through some govement entity
Lovely strawman you've built there. However, I don't think I claimed that all money should flow through some government entity. For the record, I don't think it should. Making the act of paying for an assassination illegal != making some government entity responsible for the flow of all money. Holding both the assassin and the payer responsible for either killing somebody or conspiring to kill somebody doesn't seem unreasonable to me.
> we would be in reality some button presses away from Orwell style dystopia.
[citation needed] go work in government and then tell me that anything is "some button presses away" from anything else.
for assassinations, may be we currently all agree that it isn't good to allow it to happen. However, that is only just an extreme example, for which it is something most people would agree should be illegal. But what about other actions?
Killing the ability to transact, regardless of the subject of a transaction, is detrimental to change, and entrenches existing powers/authority. These existing authority should not feel safe implementing new laws, if there are ways that could circumvent them. This makes the authority remain honest, and only implement laws that would have popular support.
You have successfully convinced me that you’re either a parody account or GPT-4 in training. This is insane.
Yes - legally this is fraud.
> An illegal transaction is one where both parties are willing, but the state deems said transaction is illegal under their purview.
And in every single place I know of in the world, fraud is illegal.
Don't waste our time with this.
The discussion in this HN thread has been calling both of the above "illegal", and not distinguishing between them.
IANAL but paying someone to kill someone else is definitely illegal, even if they don't kill them. Isn't that what they got the silk road guy on?
today, yes, the transaction for paying the hitman is illegal, as is the act of the hitman.
What i'm saying is that bitcoins could be a method for which transactions can be made without interference with the state, regardless of the subject of the transaction.
The legality of the transaction's subject is a separate argument.
Is this parody?
The first opium war started in 1839, so even in China, "not quite two centuries" is much more accurate than "centuries at least".
A good argument could be made that these substances weren't really banned in the US until the Controlled Substances Act of 1970. The word "decades" is pretty reasonable.
> If you want to buy drugs, do it the old fashioned way - you know, the way society did it for thousands of years prior to bitcoin.
I’m more making the case that you should just go buy drugs with cash instead of pretending that bitcoin is the only way to do it.
Not being allowed to buy/possess drugs is a stupid law, but preventing illegal transactions in the public financial system is a feature, not a bug. If you want to buy drugs, do it the old fashioned way - you know, the way society did it for thousands of years prior to bitcoin.