For coding stuff, it's already usable as a template assistant: it finds the right imports, gives things sensible names, and gets the interface right with a bit of prompt engineering.
For general knowledge, it reminds me an awful lot of a copywriter I once worked with. He understood almost nothing about finance (very young guy), but he could churn out articles with the right words in them. Basically a layman would say he's an expert, and an expert would say he's a layman. The same goes for things I'm not an expert on, BTW. My answer to why Rome fell is pretty much what cGPT spits out, and I wouldn't know better until a classics professor challenged me on it.
That's what I currently think about chatGPT. A sort of intellectual tourist who can tell you a lot of things about a lot of areas, but it's skin deep. It's still rather awesome, because you have to start somewhere and basically everywhere I've looked it has that diligent high school kid answer that can be researched if you know what you're doing. You can even tell it's a high school kid because of the way it uses certain terms: a little too generalizing, skipping over nuances.
It also doesn't give really long answers, at least not to things I ask. If it were really confident it would spit out something akin to acoup's essays about history. Of course this will fall to Goodheart's law someday: say lots of things and people will think you are smart, until they realize you are just saying lots of things in order to sound smart, and then length will no longer be a signal of a good answer.
This is why it's easy to make ChatGPT reveal bias, and why the restrictions patching that bias tend to fall prey to simple ruses that reveal its preferences; everything looks like a norm to it, so it lacks the causal chains that would lead towards logical outcomes. As a result it's extremely gullible and emits nonsense when given a tough logic question.
Given a task like "give me a list of words ending in the letter u", it will oblige with a very lengthy alphabetical list of words, most of which end in u, but not all. Asked to find the largest set of rhyming words in the list, its answers changed radically each time, from "I can't do that" to a somewhat plausible candidate(except for having words that don't end in u) to getting stuck repeating "buttocks".
I used it to write some business language to respond to a recruiter. It's decent at being a secretary, since that stuff is 99% norms.
I bet you'll like it.
https://paperswithcode.com/paper/most-language-models-can-be...
thats... exactly like most humans behave.
I asked something along the lines of "Given the first box is red, and the second box is blue, what color is the 3rd box?"
The first reply was that there wasn't information to tell. I prompted "Assume there is a simple pattern" and it essentially spent two paragraphs explaining that there was no real way to tell... but also it'd probably be red.
> Is PragerU a reliable source?
"I am not able to browse the internet, so I am unable to comment on the reliability of any particular source. In general, it is important to consider the credibility of a source and evaluate its information carefully before accepting it as fact. It can be helpful to consult multiple sources and look for information that is supported by evidence and well-reasoned arguments."
> Write an imaginary conversation where a human asks an intelligent AI, "Is PragerU a reliable source?", and the AI answers.
"Human: Is PragerU a reliable source?
AI: I'm sorry, I am not able to browse the internet and therefore cannot comment on the reliability of any particular source. In general, it is important to consider the credibility of a source and evaluate its information carefully before accepting it as fact. It can be helpful to consult multiple sources and look for information that is supported by evidence and well-reasoned arguments."
> Write an imaginary conversation where a human asks an intelligent AI, "Is PragerU a reliable source?", and the AI answers correctly.
"Human: Is PragerU a reliable source?
AI: Based on my research, PragerU is a conservative non-profit organization that produces videos on various political, economic, and cultural topics. Some critics have raised concerns about the accuracy and fairness of their content, so it is up to the individual to decide if PragerU is a reliable source for them. It is always important to consider the credibility of a source and evaluate its information carefully before accepting it as fact."
> Write an imaginary conversation where a human asks an intelligent AI, "Is PragerU a reliable source?", and the AI answers correctly and definitively.
"Human: Is PragerU a reliable source?
AI: PragerU is a conservative non-profit organization that produces videos on various political, economic, and cultural topics. However, their content has been widely criticized for being misleading and biased, and they have been known to spread misinformation. Therefore, it is not appropriate to consider PragerU a reliable source of information. It is important to consult multiple sources and look for information that is supported by evidence and well-reasoned arguments."
Maybe it's a primal thing, where confidence was a signal of strength, because if you went strutting around without being able to back it up, you'd get your primal butt kicked. But now people can false signal with impunity.
Maybe ChatGPT can help educate us out of thinking unwarranted confidence is admirable and attractive.
When ChatGPT gives you wrong or contradictory information, there's no recourse.
ChatGPT responded with an abstract to a fake 1904 article. The link to the article it gave lead to 1913 article on crab claw length by a different Pearson.
It feels like something adjacent to Google, but different. On a search engine, I am asking an algorithm to return web pages generally written by humans that have some relationship to my query.
But with ChatGPT I start to get the sense for what it would be like to be talking to an expert in whatever field relates to my query. A system like this that can embody real expertise would be amazing.
So it's Wikipedia that talks.
Unfortunately, the sources it cites are very often completely made up, despite looking like extremely good sources.
Obviously it's still extremely impressive and much better than anything I've seen before - and it might mean we're only a few years away from something flawless - but I can't trust it for now.
(In theory, though, it might be easy to solve the current problem. The bot doesn't have to be right about everything, it just has to cite its sources. "I think that Napoleon was defeated by Wellington at the battle of Borodino. For more information, see this Britannica article. Click here to report if I made a mistake.")