News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by macrolime on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @06:28AM (#33786210)
>"Companies can't just say 'yes we only allow children over 13 to join our >platform', then they allow 10-year-olds and actively promote it to them," she >told BBC radio. "We're stopping that from happening."

>She said companies could face fines of up to 10% of their turnover if they did >not have systems in place to restrict underage access.

So what does this mean? All social media websites have to check the passport of every UK user that registers? It will be illegal to post anything in a forum, without first uploading your passport?

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by shapefrog on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @06:32AM (#33786241)
I am pretty sure a previous incarnation of this bill demanded kyc on everyone who had an online account.
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by dorwi on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @06:31AM (#33786236)
that is one way of looking at it, and it's a perfectionist view. I'm sure that everybody knows that one simply can't filter out 100% of underage access, but there are things that CAN be done to reduce it.
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by Ajedi32 on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @01:31PM (#33791290)
Maybe it should just be an HTTP header. Shift the responsibility for enforcing age restrictions to the client side; anything else is likely to be highly authoritarian and/or a massive privacy violation.
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by waboremo on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @01:36PM (#33791352)
Surely we can come up with solutions to help ease the burden for parents/guardians instead of just leaving them out in the cold because we're offended by the mere idea of taking some collective action to prevent abuse.
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by generj on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @01:50PM (#33791534)
I believe the poster above was suggesting the client browser, not the user of the client, could assist.

So Safari knows that a user is under 13 (due to information entered at sign up by guardians) and will block the user from creating an account if a page has the appropriate HTTP header. Or iOS could do the same for app signups.

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by Ajedi32 on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @04:05PM (#33793283)
Correct. The problem here is two-fold:

1. Sites have no reliable way to determine a user's age without massive privacy violations. (E.g. To access this site, upload a copy of your driver's license.)

2. Making the government the final authority on who is allowed to access the adult internet would enable way too much authoritarian abuse. (E.g. Sorry citizen, you have been deemed a dissident, and will therefore now be treated like a child by every website you visit.)

The solution to 1 is to handle the age verification part on the client side, so sites don't need to know anything about the user except whether they're old enough to access the content in question. And the solution for 2 is for parents to enforce access at the household level rather than governments doing it at the national level. (E.g. Don't let your kids use devices/software that lies to sites about their age, unless you're there to supervise.)

The exact details of how that gets implemented at the protocol level aren't as important as the overall principle. (Though I have a few ideas.)

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by nradov on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @01:59PM (#33791639)
No thanks. As a parent, I am well aware of the risks of unintended consequences from drastic collective action by government or industry. I'll take the burden. Leave me out in the cold.
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by zaroth on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:14PM (#33791821)
Leaving parents out in the cold? Surely not.

It’s obviously parents leaving their children out in the cold if a 10 year old is given unrestricted access to apps and the internet.

There are abundant and powerful options to track, monitor, and censor content that your children are exposed to on their devices, assuming a parent chooses to provide their children access to such a device.

Asking every single service everywhere to somehow gatekeep when the client-side can do it simply and easily is such a bizarre approach to solving the problem that I can only see it as an obvious and bold-fisted attempt to clamp down on anonymous speech, which is entirely essential for a functional democracy.

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by yamtaddle on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:00PM (#33792454)
Parent here trying to straddle the line between still having convenient tech in our house and keeping the kids from e.g. vegging out on creepily-targeted Youtube videos or stumbling on something terrible. It's a hell of a lot less simple than I thought it'd be. One wrinkle is the goddamn schools sending home devices I can't administer. Hate, hate, hate that.
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by mrguyorama on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:52PM (#33793120)
Surely you can administer the network connection those devices use when they are in your home?
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by Ajedi32 on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @04:20PM (#33793465)
That's getting harder as software continues to get better at bypassing network-level snooping or content blocks (which are often done by entities like malicious Wi-Fi operators or the user's ISP, neither of which have any business deciding what content the user is allowed to see).
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by yamtaddle on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @06:19PM (#33794787)
I can. Good luck to people who aren't paid to make computers jump through hoops as their day job.

I'm not even necessarily saying the government should step in with heavy-handed regulation, but "parents should just manage it and leave the rest of us alone" gets less reasonable with each passing day.

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by Manuel_D on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @05:07PM (#33794044)
You can just not give your kids smartphones, and manage access to computers? Sorry to break this to you, but if kids have access to internet connected devices they will find pornography, flash games (well, not anymore, but I'm sure modern HMTL5 games are just as addicting), and various other stuff to "veg out" with. If there's a domain blacklist they'll find VPNs. I know I did back in the 2000s. Government regulation will mean jack shit, they'll just find a way to bypass whatever filter gets implemented [1].

If you don't want your kids to view such content, the only realistic solution is to not give them internet access. Supply them with a library of books, DVDs, etc. of your choice. The only way to manage the content your child sees, is to manage the content your child has access to.

> One wrinkle is the goddamn schools sending home devices I can't administer. Hate, hate, hate that.

This makes things harder, but one option to not give them your wifi password so that these electronics can't be used. If the child needs to use these electronics to complete classwork, then complaining to the school that they are supplying kids with devices that they use to watch porn will probably elicit a strong response.

1. https://www.zdnet.com/article/teen-cracks-au84-million-porn-...

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by yamtaddle on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @06:14PM (#33794742)
Well most of this is stuff I already know and/or do (my kids aren't getting smartphones until they can pay for the phone and plan themselves, for one thing—shared dumbphone for emergencies since payphones don't exist anymore, probably, but not personal smartphones), but:

> This makes things harder, but one option to not give them your wifi password so that these electronics can't be used. If the child needs to use these electronics to complete classwork, then complaining to the school that they are supplying kids with devices that they use to watch porn will probably elicit a strong response.

Yeah, they do need them to do homework and check assignments and shit at home. Schools have made things like that more complicated and computer-dependent in the name of progress. Another way this whole computerize-everything craze has been a step back, I suppose.

Overall I'm not sure landing at "literally be someone with college training and work experience in network security and still find all this a needlessly-complex pain in the ass" is going to be where people end up wanting the state of things to settle. Here I am running an extra router on my side of my ISP's because Google's router doesn't give you MAC-level time-bounded blocking, which is pretty much what you need with school devices. And it's less porn than mindless not-actually-educational faux-edutainment web games that the school's introduced them to, for god knows what reason. I'd rather they be in the Switch than playing that crap.

... except maybe other parents they actually won't care how hard this is, since they mostly seem to have given up. Most parents seem to be giving their 3rd graders smartphones anyway. Then act like I'm the weirdo when I suggest maybe letting kids have such phones and carry them at school is batshit crazy, even in high school. Though not, I've noticed, at the not-quite-fancy private school we have some affiliation with, where smartphone ownership among even 6th-graders probably doesn't even hit 20%, way under local public schools (I have insight into several of those, mostly the middling-nice suburban sort)—I think we may be looking at a whole new kind of "digital divide" in the coming generations, and it's the ones who didn't have unlimited access to the Internet at a single-digit age that'll have the advantage. That certainly seems to be what the Fussellian upper-middle is favoring: later, more-limited access to electronics and the Internet. IDK if the climate's similar at actually-fancy private schools and among those parents, but I wouldn't be surprised if it is, and maybe even more pronounced. Meanwhile at the public schools "your family must be poor" if you don't have a smartphone by the time you hit middle school. LOL.

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by Manuel_D on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @06:41PM (#33794971)
Eh, I and most of my classmates had unfettered access to the internet since at least the 4th or 5th grade and it didn't seem to screw us over. TikTok can't be more addictive than World of Warcraft, can it?

I think the bigger distinction is that I had a desktop PC not a smartphone. Parents can much more easily regulate computer use with the former, and withhold access if their kid isn't getting good grades. I think desktop PC use also lends itself to hacking and promoting exploration of technology. Modding and cheating in games is how I got into tech. What I'd do is give my kid a desktop and a USB drive with Gentoo and let them do whatever they want - I'm mostly joking, but only mostly.

And yeah, giving kids smartphones for use at schools seems extremely bone-headed. When I was in school, teachers were all about keeping phones out of the classroom not brining them in.

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by forgotusername6 on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:04PM (#33792515)
We are sleepwalking into a surveillance state. One day we will be forced to sign onto the internet. After that it's just a matter of time before they rachet down the civil liberties one by one.
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by Mindwipe on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @06:48AM (#33786376)
Yes. It's being passed to a regulator who have suggested that you could make everyone take a selfie and use AI or something, but yes, that's the jist of it.
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by ndsipa_pomu on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @01:25PM (#33791209)
That seems trivial to circumvent
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by kmlx on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:13AM (#33786565)
> All social media websites have to check the passport of every UK user that registers?

credit card?

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by gambiting on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @01:26PM (#33791231)
Last time I checked not having a debit card is not a crime in the UK, nor is one considered a valid form of id.
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by luckylion on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @01:42PM (#33791434)
And being on an online-platform is not a right. It doesn't need to be valid form of id to be "good enough" for platforms as an age verification system.

"But children could just get their parents' credit cards" ... and they could also just get their parents' passports.

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by gambiting on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @01:53PM (#33791578)
I mean, in the UK you can get a debit card from 13 years of age so I'm not sure how that helps. Credit cards no, but requiring one would exclude a massive portion of the population as they just aren't as popular.

Frankly, to me that's just an argument against requiring anything to prove your age on an online platform. It shouldn't be necessary and I consider this a bad development.

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by rosnd on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:06PM (#33791721)
There is no minimum age to get a debit card in the UK, 13 just happens to be a common limit imposed by the banks themselves.
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by luckylion on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:00PM (#33791659)
If it's 13+ that would work if the minimum age for these platforms is also 13+. It's certainly not perfect, but if implemented, it would probably not be the only way to verify your age (or it might if credit card companies are smart and pay the platforms).

Germany has similar simple ways to provide pseudo-verification, e.g. they'll use direct-deposit or direct-debit to transfer a cent or three and put a code in the subject field that you'll need to enter. It's not perfect, and they wouldn't even know who you are, since account numbers aren't tied to names, but it proves (sufficiently for them to say "we really tried") that you are the account owner. While they don't know who you are, your bank has to because of KYC, and in case of trouble they could say "talk to the bank, they know who's hiding behind this username". Of course there are edge cases and ways around it, but it's enough that they get out of hot water.

I don't really have an opinion on whether age should be verified. I'm past most minimum ages and I don't have children, so I'm not affected.

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by vidarh on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:06PM (#33792543)
Go Henry describes their debit cards as "perfect for kids aged 6-18". My son is 13 now, but he's had a Go Henry card for years.

https://www.gohenry.com/uk/debit-cards/

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by whywhywhywhy on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:16PM (#33791852)
Or they will just use platforms outside of their governments control.

Like is a platform run out of China going to care what fines the UK government threatens.

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by luckylion on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:22PM (#33791938)
Possibly, but the same argument can be made for GDPR, and it works pretty well there. In the end, the Chinese will either want to monetize it, at which point they need a presence in the UK, or they're monetizing via psy-ops paid for by the CCP and they will be considered a security issue by the UK and probably shut down (at least for access from the UK).

Sure, that might lead to teenagers using VPNs to access it, but I wouldn't count on that. Most of them aren't even using adblockers.

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by vidarh on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:59PM (#33792438)
And children can get them:

https://www.gohenry.com/uk/debit-cards/

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by whywhywhywhy on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:14PM (#33791812)
I’m almost 40 and have never had a credit card… don’t see why that would be a fair requirement.
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by flipbrad on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @02:58PM (#33792421)
The companies backing AVPA (age verification providers association) which include Experian, have been pushing for the child protection stuff, big time. Guess why.
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by dmix on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:13PM (#33792633)
Backdoor national digital ID system?
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by lazide on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:32PM (#33792865)
Not so back door, and no need for the gov’t to get involved of course. Experian can use it’s AIMagic(tm) to do so, as long as they get access to everyone’s medical records from birth, I imagine.
Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by StrictDabbler on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:34PM (#33792901)
No, Experian's dream is that anytime anybody online creates an account for any service at all, Experian gets to charge a "service fee" for verifying their identity.

It's a capitalist desire. They're just exploiting the statists and nationalists.

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by mianos on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @04:28PM (#33793572)
The issue gets messier when you consider what just happened in Australia, when one of the largest medical insurance providers accidentally over-shared the Excel sheet with all their passwords in it (or something like that) and now all their customer's id documents are on the dark web.

I would imagine that some rando social media site that collects this stuff to prove someone is over age to be a whole lot less secure (if that is possible?).

Re:UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content in f... by iam-TJ on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @04:49PM (#33793840)
The 'remote' aspect is the complicating factor but the basis of this is no different to other services.

At the shop cash tills I noticed recently a sign that said "if you're purchasing alcohol and are fortunate enough to look under 25 we will need to age check you" (or some very similar words).

Same goes for anyone buying solvents and glues, or knives and blades, vapes, etc.

The aim is good - the challenge is the implementation.

Only feasible way seems to be prove you're older than the minimum (which feels like persecuting those that are old enough) rather than prove you're too young!