News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by ilyt on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @06:21AM (#33786165)
How dare they put features behind money on an app in my overpriced Apple ecosystem, truly horrendous.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by DieBruderBauer on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @06:32AM (#33786248)
https://youtu.be/oeqPrUmVz-o?t=57

The libre/open app issue has been brought up by Apple nay-sayers for time immemorial; Steve Job's response is brilliant here, frankly quite timeless and ultimately (in my view) apropos.

"You've gotta start from the customer experience and work backwards to the technology."

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by bombolo on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:10AM (#33786544)
> "You've gotta start from the customer experience and work backwards to the technology."

I think they started by putting a pressure sensor and worked forward to making an app.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by dewey on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @06:41AM (#33786317)
> Apple is not a dive computer company. They sell computers. Other dive computer brands also sell computers, but these are not general purpose.

Apple is not a [phone|watch|camera] company. They sell computers.

That's what people said at every single new product that's not in their classic computer product line. Turns out you can get pretty good at products outside your initial niche, and for most people it will be more than good enough.

If you ask most regular people to classify Apple they would probably say "phone company", and by revenue share they would be correct. There's a reason they renamed themselves from "Apple Computers Inc." to just Apple.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by bombolo on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @06:55AM (#33786421)
> Turns out you can get pretty good at products outside your initial niche, and for most people it will be more than good enough.

dive computers are used in an activity that can kill you. A "you're holding it wrong" flaw could result in death rather than missed calls.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by prattatx on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:33AM (#33786765)
The outcome would mean you would want the best designers in the world working on the problem. The use error in both conditions of answering a phone and diving are the same: the human factor. Only the importance of the outcome of the human-machine interaction error differs.

What brand do we trust the most to do the design job right regardless of context? Well, the brand a lot of people trust has the hardware and ecosystem. Do we trust the app developer, however?

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by bombolo on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:59AM (#33787036)
> What brand do we trust the most to do the design job right regardless of context?

It's not apple designers making the app. But apple design of form over function is certainly a poor fit for a device you need to rely on.

In any case, my gf's iphone's map app is completely unusable from me. Every time it's faster if I just take my own phone and open OSMand.

People working at apple aren't more intelligent or skilled than the general population really.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by dmitriid on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:07AM (#33786516)
> A "you're holding it wrong" flaw could result in death rather than missed calls

How many people were affected by this, and is this comparable to the failure rate of the dive computer you implicitly trust?

Quick Googling:

--- start quote ---

From our internal information and industry connections, the failure rates we have seen over the expected service lifetime of a computer vary from 0.5% to 50%, based on the brand and model. And don't think that any particular brand makes you safe. For example, while Suunto is generally a reliable brand, the early D3 was a disaster in terms of failure rates. The Stinger on the other hand was very reliable.

--- end quote ---

50% failure rate. For an activity that can kill you. Imagine if these companies were under the same scrutiny as Apple.

Or for example [2]

--- start quote ---

I bought the computer in February 2018

March 2019, the straps + mount started rotting away

April 2019 - software error E6

Enter the Bluetooth connection issues...

November 2021 - E37 error!

July 2022 - button loose (?!), computer floods, game over...

--- end quote ---

Or a settlement [3] "Suunto settles scary scuba screwup for $50m: 'Faulty' dive computer hardware and software put explorers in peril"

[1] https://scubaboard.com/community/threads/dive-computers-fail...

[2] https://scubaboard.com/community/threads/experience-report-s...

[3] https://www.theregister.com/2018/12/19/suunto_scuba_screwup/

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by bombolo on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:23AM (#33786654)
> How many people were affected by this, and is this comparable to the failure rate of the dive computer you implicitly trust?

No idea. All the owners of that model of iphone. I have no clue how many units were sold. How is that important?

Failure rate talk is a 14yrs old post from a manufacturer that used to make dive computers but has stopped. Let's ignore that until a better source is given.

2nd link: some contaminant is destroying the computer… I'm sure apple™plastic™ is no more resistant than regular plastic.

The bluetooth is not a life threatening issue. The software issues are indeed worrying.

In any event, those are companies that have sold millions of units. Diving with the apple watch is so costly (hardware + subscription) that few rich hobbyists will do that, and no professional diver.

I'm sure failures and issues will come out, but not in the same numbers, because the heavy users can buy 2 dive computers to have redundancy and still spend less than how much it costs doing it with apple.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by dmitriid on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:06AM (#33787104)
> No idea. All the owners of that model of iphone. I have no clue how many units were sold. How is that important?

So, you have no idea how many were affected, but "all users". How is that important? If it was 1% of 1% of users affected, then it's probably better than most diving equipment. If it's 99%, then it's bad.

> Let's ignore that until a better source is given.

And yet, when we talk about Apple it's "I don't know, all of them". Hm...

> In any event, those are companies that have sold millions of units.

So has Apple. Your point?

> that few rich hobbyists will do that, and no professional diver.

How is that relevant to your implicit trust in diving computers and explicit mistrust in Apple because of something that happened 12 years ago to an unknown percentage of users for a phone that in first three days sold more than probably all dive computers are being sold in a year.

> I'm sure failures and issues will come out, but not in the same numbers,

I wonder if you realise that individual models from various dive computer makers are probably selling in the same numbers as what's expected from Apple Watch Ultra.

And yet, you trust them implicitly.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by bombolo on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:20AM (#33787225)
> So, you have no idea how many were affected, but "all users". How is that important? If it was 1% of 1% of users affected, then it's probably better than most diving equipment. If it's 99%, then it's bad.

I like how you like to make up random numbers with no data to sound very scientific :)

> And yet, when we talk about Apple it's "I don't know, all of them". Hm...

That's because I don't provide random forum posts of something happening to 1 person as "this happens to every user".

> So has Apple. Your point?

Apple has sold millions of scuba diving apple watches to active scuba divers??? Do you have a source on this unbelievable fact you just made up?

> How is that relevant

The thing is that I base my opinions on data, and at the moment there is no existing data.

You on the other hand just type numbers to justify your opinions, and call that "data".

So it is relevant because apple watch will never see intensive scuba diving use, and will thus experience fewer total failures, because of not being used as much.

Like, a car driving constantly breaks way more often than a car that is just being displayed. Doesn't necessarily mean that the display car is better because it doesn't fail.

> I wonder if you realise that individual models from various dive computer makers are probably selling in the same numbers as what's expected from Apple Watch Ultra.

I wonder if you realise instead of buying 1 apple watch you can buy 2 diving computers, have excellent redundancy and save 500$.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by dmitriid on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @09:12AM (#33787788)
> I like how you like to make up random numbers with no data to sound very scientific :)

Says the person whose answer is "I don't know".

I told you why knowing the percentage of people affected is important. You just dismiss it.

> Apple has sold millions of scuba diving apple watches to active scuba divers???

No. Apple has sold millions of devices. Which is important when discussing failure rates.

> The thing is that I base my opinions on data, and at the moment there is no existing data.

No. You base your opinion on "I don't know, all of them, only rich people will use Ultra so issues will not in the same numbers". That's no data. That's pure speculation.

You don't even have failure stats for dive computers, do you? Even given that each particular model of a dive computer is used by potentially as many people as those "only rich people who will use watch ultra".

But sure, "dive computers are used in an activity that can kill you", and the internet is littered with "What happens if your dive computer fails" articles. Dive computer manufacturers explicitly call this put in their manuals [1] And there are literally no standards for verification of dive computers, manufacturers routinely lie about their certifications or skip them [2]

And yet. "I wouldn't trust Apple unlike these manufacturers that have sold millions of devices because data!"

[1] E.g. Suunto: https://ns.suunto.com/Manuals/D6i/Userguides/Suunto_D6i_User... page 4

[2] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/295967776_Dive_comp...

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by bombolo on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @01:57PM (#33791617)
> Says the person whose answer is "I don't know".

Better than the person who pretends to know :)

> I told you why knowing the percentage of people affected is important.

It's important… But I have no way of obtaining this information.

> No. Apple has sold millions of devices. Which is important when discussing failure rates.

:D

We are talking about scuba diving specifically. I'm sure apple watches tell the time absolutely fine. What we are discussing here is their reliability under water while tracking the dives.

Can you stop pretending being daft for a minute and admit there are comparatively very very few units that are used for this purpose?

> You base your opinion on "I don't know, all of them, only rich people will use Ultra so issues will not in the same numbers". That's no data. That's pure speculation.

I base my opinion on being a diver and having held in my hands dive computers and watches.

And an apple watch isn't so good in a dive. It's tiny, you won't even see the numbers if your mask is a bit foggy or the water isn't so clear.

It's also harder to use.

Do you know how a dive computer works? You put it on and jump in the water. When it touches water it turns on. You don't need to open the correct app and whatnot.

> And yet. "I wouldn't trust Apple unlike these manufacturers that have sold millions of devices because data!"

I wouldn't trust apple because my macbook fell apart, and so I understand that a flimsy watch won't be as sturdy as a sturdy dive computer.

Anyway, please come back to me after trying scuba diving at least once.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by microtherion on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:12AM (#33787137)
> I'm sure apple™plastic™ is no more resistant than regular plastic.

I would not know about the specific area of dive computers, but in general, Apple can and does conduct materials research and procurement on an entirely different scale from many other companies, so they often ARE capable of using superior materials.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by bombolo on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:26AM (#33787267)
Plastic and salt water don't really agree with each other.

In fact salt water doesn't agree with most things.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:11AM (#33786547)
I don't think they sell computers either- they sell end-user computing appliances.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by seydor on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:02AM (#33786487)
It's more of a gadget fashion/lifestyle brand now. Wearables are a good fit for their target audience. Desktops, servers, or anything that's not on public display, not so much.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by CaptainZapp on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:24AM (#33786662)
You don't want a gadget or anything fashionable when you go scuba diving.

You want an instrument, which can be ugly and boring but needs to be absolutely reliable.

Anything else can literally kill you.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by bombolo on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:09AM (#33786535)
I'm a diver, not technical but I've done deep and nitrox.

The cost of the subscription seems insane. If you plan to do more than 20 dives in your lifetime, buying a dive computer seems way more convenient than this.

The free plan is completely useless for scuba diving.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by CaptainZapp on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:19AM (#33786613)
Especially since you get a reasonable good dive computer for $200 nowadays.

No bells and whistles, mind you. But everything you really need as an (even ambitioned) diver.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by Tepix on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:16AM (#33786586)
Amen. I might be interested in getting the Apple Watch Ultra (mainly for diving) but not if it involves a subscription.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by davedx on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:16AM (#33786590)
Please explain how $80/year is insane?
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by ethbr0 on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:22AM (#33786643)
Apparently a decent starter dive computer runs $300-400.

$400 = $80 * 5

And with the dedicated option you have a purpose built device and something you can resell.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by CaptainZapp on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:27AM (#33786689)
Depending on what you're looking for you can get a perfectly suitable dive computer for 200$.

If you need an example: Look at the Cressi Goa. But there are other examples in this price range.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by mcphage on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:14AM (#33787163)
Why would you pay for a subscription in months you're not going diving? You don't need to sign up for the yearly subscription if you only do it a few times a year. Just pay for those days or months.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by LtWorf on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:22AM (#33787240)
You need to factor in the time it takes to unsubscribe and re-subscribe.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by Karunamon on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:26AM (#33787276)
Minutes or less on Apple since they give you a dashboard with all your subscriptions and canceling or restarting is extremely simple
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by ethbr0 on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @10:21AM (#33788623)
If Apple's value proposition is 'Just manually unsubscribe + resubscribe' then they have a problem.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by Karunamon on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @12:08PM (#33790189)
In a conversation based in good faith and not tired nitpicking most people would understand that it being simple to cancel a subscription when you're not using some thing and then easy to restart when you want to use it again would be a positive…
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by LtWorf on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @01:30PM (#33791281)
Not so simple… if you forgot to do it at home you certainly can't do it on a dive, given that those often happen from boats, far from cell signal.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by moistly on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:25PM (#33792783)
Yah, and if you forgot your pressure regulator, you’re right f*d as well, qu’elle surprise. You present a fatuous argument.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by LtWorf on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @06:44AM (#33799432)
But you can put the regulator in the bag and keep it there for free.

You need to do the subscription just before or you end up paying more.

It's a thing that has to be done last minute… so it's way easier that it gets forgotten.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by Karunamon on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @11:21AM (#33802985)
I don't know about you but checking apps that are a requirement for travel/important events is something I already do. If I am traveling somewhere for a convention you better believe I made sure that my airline's app, hotel's app, whatever ticketing app the event organizer is using were all updated, logged in to, and tested before leaving the house.

Any 1 of these having problems could be anywhere from annoying to catastrophic. Why take the chance?

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by LtWorf on Thursday December 01, 2022 @07:20AM (#33815292)
Wow checking all of those apps before travelling seems so much inconvenient compared to owning a 200€ dive computer that lives in the bag with all the dive stuff and one can grab on the way out.

I personally loathe apps. I travel regularly and have no hotel app, no airline app, no ticketing app.

But here in sweden they are moving train tickets online, so in major stations there is ONE ticket machine and in minor station there is none.

However it's all done with sms/email, no apps.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by moistly on Thursday December 01, 2022 @07:12PM (#33824988)
But what if the dive computer battery is dead?!

We could play this silly game of fatuous arguments all day. Why insist that your preference is so superior to other’s preference?

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by Karunamon on Friday December 02, 2022 @10:24AM (#33831686)
You don't check your dive computer before going on a dive? I mean I get that is a much simpler device and more reliable, but I'm not sure that I would make the trade-off of not pulling it out and powering it on instead of possibly getting to wherever I'm diving and finding that it's dead or nonfunctional and being out of luck.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by mcphage on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @12:14PM (#33790277)
Apple's value proposition is "it's easy and convenient to see what subscriptions you are currently paying for, and to unsubscribe from them in a few clicks—without having to find a form or send an email or call a phone number"
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by matthewmacleod on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:48AM (#33786921)
Yes, I’m sure there’s a massive resale market for five year old used dive computers.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by bombcar on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:19AM (#33787206)
That’s about the rent/buy ratio for anything - it usually costs about X days of rental of electronics to buy it outright, where X is between 10 and 40 or so.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by CaptainZapp on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:20AM (#33786626)
Leaving aside the price of the watch I can get a dive computer for 200$ +.

That's for me to own never having to pay a subscription fee.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by jitl on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:55AM (#33786997)
I take at most 3 trips a year max to dive, usually dive ~5 days per trip, and 2 dives per day. I have maybe 150-200 dives total. If each trip is in a different month, it will cost me $30 a year at the maximum. For $300, I can use this app for 10 years worth of diving and roughly 300 more dives.

Compare the total package to a Garmin or Suunto sport watch that also does diving and all the other smartwatch things. Those units cost $900-$1500; the Apple Watch with 10 years of casual scuba is $1100. I’ll happily wear the Apple Watch every day, versus a stand-alone computer or a Suunto that I’d only wear for specific activities. My cost per day is like 30¢. Doesn’t seem so bad.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by bombolo on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:08AM (#33787119)
Well you can get a solid gold scuba computer for 5 million $

However if we are doing meaningful comparisons, you can get a suunto for ~300€, and you will probably have to change the battery one or two times in 10 years.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by bombcar on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:17AM (#33787193)
Solid gold would be an effective diving weight at least.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by alexwasserman on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:13AM (#33786563)
Also: yesterdays discussion on the original Apple press release: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33774685
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by ploum on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:14AM (#33786576)
Like always, Apple isn’t innovating but pretending to be.

Garmin released the Descent Mk i 5 years ago : a smartwatch which also does diving. Really great watch (I’m a freediver myself and it does what I want it and, most importantly, does not have a touch screen, something I hate and can’t imagine using under water while holding my breath).

How is Apple different? Marketing, as always. But nothing new under the sun.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by LtWorf on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:23AM (#33787247)
Ah that's a good point… touchscreens don't work when wet.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by kh_hk on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:36AM (#33787360)
Can you write apps for the Descent Mk?
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by ploum on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @09:01AM (#33787652)
Yes.

The app store is called "Connect IQ".

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by kh_hk on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @09:12AM (#33787781)
Are you sure you can write apps that act as a diving app for the Garmin?
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by ploum on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @09:35AM (#33788063)
As soon as it goes below a certain depth, the watch is locked to use the "official garmin diving app". This is explained to prevent entering in any other app in the middle of a dive.

I feel that the apple watch will be doing something similar (if only to lock the touchscreen under the water).

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by kh_hk on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @09:42AM (#33788167)
I was under the impression that this was not the case, since the pressure and other information seems to be available on their SDK docuementation

See https://developer.apple.com/documentation/coremotion/cmwater...

If this was locked to use only by the Oceanic app this wouldn't be such a big deal to me at least.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by xrd on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:32AM (#33786750)
I visited Dubrovnik, Croatia about 20 years ago. When I got into the taxi, the driver was very excited to tell me about how locals would throw dynamite into the water to blow up the fish, though I never verified the truth of that. It made me pause because I wanted to go diving there.

I ended up going diving, and it was quite an experience (https://web.archive.org/web/20020505185554/http://www.bytrav...). The owner of the dive company didn't seem to know about decompression stops, generally. We went to about 30 meters for a short moment, saw a few hollowed out German WWII mines at the bottom, then ascended into a cave at sea level, nary a decompression stop on the way.

Climbing up and down the rocky stairs of Dubrovnik later that day I had the worst headache. I had a flight the next day and wondered if it was a good idea to go up to 30,000 feet. I'm still alive, so it must have been the right decision.

I'm saddened to think people using dive computers will never get to experience the richness of my dive experiences because the algorithm will tell them not to go into that cave with Anton from Dubrovnik.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by ChuckNorris89 on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:46AM (#33786898)
>the driver was very excited to tell me about how locals would throw dynamite into the water to blow up the fish

Wait, seriously?! I though that was some South Park/Borat humour.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by e1g on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:50AM (#33786948)
Can confirm - I did that as a child (with my uncles) in another soviet country. That, and electrofishing by tasing those poor Nemos. To this day I don’t know why we used those methods, but it was mad fun. Maybe literally.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by xrd on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @10:01AM (#33788389)
Did you stuff the dynamite into the fish? That is what Borin told me these guys did. Then, you throw the fish into the water? At that point, their fishy friends come up and say "Jeez Svetlana, you looked bloated!" And, then BOOM, the fish all fly out of the water given the large blast zone.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by e1g on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @11:51AM (#33789959)
Yikes. No, we'd look for a shoal of fish, then throw a homemade explosive in the middle. Still horrible.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by ceejayoz on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:48AM (#33786919)
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by pvitz on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:57AM (#33787022)
I think Crocodile Dundee did this on the Hudson river, too.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by xrd on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @09:57AM (#33788351)
It was really funny to be driving in the dark from the Dubrovnik airport and hearing this cab driver in very limited English describe what he was seeing.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by core-utility on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:15AM (#33787170)
As a non-diver, why would someone with a dive computer not be able to go to the cave with Anton? Wouldn't they just have to make a decompression stop on the way (which is the healthy/safe thing to do anyways)?
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by xrd on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @10:43AM (#33788926)
I just meant that a dive computer would not recommend I do the things Anton had me do, which was descend to deep water (30 meters) and stay for a significant period of time (five minutes) and then ascend quickly. We wouldn't have been able to see all the caves and stalactites he wanted to show me if a nanny-state dive computer had been there, because that route would not have been safe.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by xrd on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @12:47PM (#33790723)
I'm getting downvoted presumably because of my nanny-state joke. Fine, I still think it is funny to assert that a dive computer is actively participating in the nanny state. I'll never back down from that joke.
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by kalimanzaro on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @07:41AM (#33786850)
"~Oceanic cinematic APPetite for something bigger than free~"

(Or libre)

that Young Fathers song has become even more entangled with A-WATCH since that commercial

https://youtu.be/0cBJBj_tbHM

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by McDyver on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:10AM (#33787132)
> Apple is behind the first general purpose programmable dive computer

Unless Apple got into it before Heinrichs Weikamp and the OSTC [1]

This is an Open Source dive computer, that is extremely well regarded in the technical diving world. The firmware is open source and there is a "big" community, considering the niche market.

Unless apple came up with a new decompression algorithm that will model how tissues load and offgas, all you need are tables, a bottom timer a depth gauge and to follow your plan (with contingency for depth and time).

Blindly following a computer will get you in trouble if it fails during the dive.

[1] https://heinrichsweikamp.com/

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by kh_hk on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:34AM (#33787335)
Just added that to the article. I do not see the OSTC as a general purpose programmable dive computer (under my own definition, that is).
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by jitl on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:50AM (#33787499)
Here is their decompression implementation:

https://code.heinrichsweikamp.com/public/hwos_code/file/bc21...

I went looking for this a few months ago and couldn’t find it, so I’m happy to finally have it. It’s quite well commented.

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by microtherion on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:16AM (#33787175)
I had assumed that the "diving" feature of the Apple Watch Ultra was mostly aspirational. Is there any research on what percentage of Omega Seamaster owners have ever used them on a dive?
Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by jitl on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:16AM (#33787178)
I played around a bit with SwiftUI and the dive monitoring APIs in the hopes of writing an open source dive computer for the Apple Watch. I spent all my evening hacking hours on my last trip learning UI layout and not much time figuring out decompression algorithms. I might pick up the project the next time I go diving.

My repo here shows some use of Apple’s APIs: https://github.com/justjake/Trieste

Re:Oceanic+ on the Apple Watch Ultra and the perils of subsc... by fjwolski on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @08:20AM (#33787227)
1) IMHO huge deal with the dive computers is the screen type, all lower-end dive computers have same old LCD displays which have the drawback of being invisible if it's dark (wreck, cave, night, or just poor visibility water diving). Most of them have some sort of backlight, but you have to trigger that with a button, which can be dangerous. Seems like computers with OLED screen, which are always visible, start closer to the price tag of Apple Watch

2) I think the author is overselling the "you don't need that much information" point - comparison of Scubapro in dive mode vs Apple Watch in safety stop mode is apples to oranges. During a (recreational, no deco) dive you need exactly these 4 pieces of information that are displayed on the Scubapro: time, depth, no-deco time, and tank pressure (and if the last one is missing it's not because it's not important, it's because you don't have remote pressure gauge which is a separate piece of hardware, and instead you need to frequently reach for a separate pressure gauge that's physically attached to the tank). To be fair I'm sure Apple Watch will display the NDL time in a dive mode, as long as you paid your subscription, so this is critique of the article not the watch

3) Heinrichs Weikamp was already identified in comments of the article, one more company that worked on an open-source dive computer was Liquivision (which I worked for for some time in college). It was eventually bought by Huish, just like Oceanic :)