I have this feeling medium is being kept alive on the shoulders of other companies’ marketing teams in an attempt to write thinly-veiled sales pitches disguised as blog posts from a “neutral” 3rd party.
Coupled with the zero-life-experience blogger trope, the signal to noise ratio on medium is practically nil.
You mean the last paragraph where they _volunteer_ to have coaching sessions with people? "Selling" usually implies an exchange of money or an expectation of something in return, but there's no product here – the author is offering their time for free to help others start or join cooperatives. Is it fair to dismiss that as "being sold" something?
Sure, but a startup using VC money to offer you something for free is very different from "I will personally volunteer to help you".
Also the entire point of sharing articles is that they're being read, so there isn't any way to avoid implying they're doing "self-promotion" – should people just stop writing and sharing articles?
Sometimes people aren't after some self-serving goal, and I think it's a little dangerous to think everyone is – charities exist. Cooperatives are more ethical businesses because they build democracy into their structure unlike traditional businesses, why would I assume whoever is talking about them isn't just hoping to see more of that in the world? Or do we reduce that to "that's just the author being selfish again"?
Perhaps the article is devoid of insightful content to such an extent that we were both forced to interpret its author’s goals based on our preconceived notions of the ideas they’re discussing. You believe they’re genuinely seeking to improve worker’s rights, and it just looks like another hustle to me.
One thing I can say for certain is that I did not get much from the article, and I suspect there will be comments that are shorter yet far more insightful than the article a few hours from now.
Many of the engineering blogs shared on HN have a "by the way, we are hiring"[0] stinger, or a promotion of the author's startup's product as a solution to the engineering problem described by the post, or if its a benchmark, then the entire post would be promoting their product as the superior product. This article no worse than others wrt self promotion.
0. Maybe not so much now, but perhaps we'll see an uptick of "I'm looking for my next move, if you're hiring, contact me."
If you are paying someone to do any of these jobs, you are doing it out of income that you've paid taxes on. If they are a part of your cooperative then it comes out of the businesses own funds pretax. There are also incentives to share in other resources, such as buildings, child care and other invisible labor that we normally place little value on.
Also, some cooperative companies will only outsource work to other cooperative groups.
Not to mention the camaraderie of working with people with similar goals in a noncompetitive environment where they value your success.
Clients find me, not the other way around.
Well I have an accountant, tax advisor and lawyer as subscriptions. I also have a coworking pass. Documentation and implementation are my own lines of work.
Trainings are given for free in coops? I can't imagine my friends working for free, are you forced to work for free in a coop? As in, would I be forced to give trainings too? I value my time too much for this.
> If you are paying someone to do any of these jobs, you are doing it out of income that you've paid taxes on.
No. As a contractor, all of the above (including conference passes, trainings/certifications, driving to/from the client, all my hardware I use to work etc) are my business expenses. I pay tax on profit, not turnover.
No one said anything about training for free. This was an example of work that needs to be done for a client that you may not want to do yourself. A junior level member of your coop could travel to the client's site and train them on how to use your software, learn from the experience and make valuable ties, while you stay at home and work on more appropriate tasks.
Because that way you can finance a bunch of useless moochers who "administer your coop". Smells like typical rent seeking.
On the other hand, in a coop the profit is shared fairly amongst the people actually doing the work. It's frankly incredibly that somebody thinks this is a worse model of compensation.
My point is that value is actually not determined by "socially necessary labor" but by supply and demand. The food you produce will rot if you and others produce too much of it = it has no value, nobody collects profit because everybody lost any possibility of selling for a good price by producing too much.
On the other hand during a shortage people will start valuing food much more than they previously did - again totally disconnected from the "socially necessary labor" required to produce it.
Labour theory of value is not in anyway at odds with the idea of supply and demand. In fact, the whole idea of value in Kapital is derived from supply and demand.
The labour theory of value states that the inherent value of a commodity is directly related to the combination of labour and cost of the machinery needed to produce the commodity. This is what acts as the foundation for the value that the market assigns to the commodities. The market value doesn't just appear out of thin air, it's rooted in material costs of production.
To put it bluntly, you have an infantile understanding of the subject you're attempting to debate here.
(I bet I read the book more times than you. It's sitting right there on a shelf next to my desk :-))
The people who say that the rest live in shit in my experience have never been to a third world country and actually lived there. If they did, they'd realize just how shit the first world is.
As long as we have scarcity of goods that must be distributed somehow, communism only works in theory, not in practice.
Edit: Ah, I see, so you're a tankie who grew up in the USSR yet still supports them. Thanks, I have no need to speak to you further.
I find non-monetized content generally to have higher quality than monetized ones. The author is intrinsically motivated to produce quality and there is no other goal other than to share what they have with the world.
I got the distinct feeling I was being sold something while reading it, and the last paragraph confirmed it. It’s filled with vague, corporatey platitudes about ego and altruism, and there’s almost nothing in it about how this concept applies specifically to tech.
The supposed “cons” sound like the ad equivalents of leading questions:
> The relationships in a cooperative are adult-adult oriented
> All of those might be very painful if you’re not used to vocalizing your inner thoughts in non-violent ways
Well jeez, I guess I’ll skip it if I’m not allowed to respond to assigned Jira tickets with my fists.