News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by zozbot234 on Sunday November 27, 2022 @08:36AM (#33762830)
Cooperatives and partnerships work very well for low capital intensity businesses, and coding is a low capital-intensity business in this day and age. It makes total sense that people are interested in such arrangements, it's not just a matter of wishful thinking.
Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by leethaxor on Sunday November 27, 2022 @10:40AM (#33763628)
I don't understand... I work as a software contractor in EU. I don't see a single thing I'm missing by not being in a coop. 5% of my income is a lot of money. I can buy all the accounting and tax advisory services I need with enough money left over to get a Wework All Access membership and still I'd have some money left. Why does it make total sense that people are interested?
Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by nanomonkey on Sunday November 27, 2022 @11:29AM (#33764124)
I would assume that the benefits are in having coworkers that fill in the gaps in your own business skills. For example: finding clients, invoicing, server maintenance, customer service, training, documentation, implementation consultants. There are a variety of job skills that one person will not have or want to contribute 100% of the time that are valuable jobs for junior or more senior coworkers.

If you are paying someone to do any of these jobs, you are doing it out of income that you've paid taxes on. If they are a part of your cooperative then it comes out of the businesses own funds pretax. There are also incentives to share in other resources, such as buildings, child care and other invisible labor that we normally place little value on.

Also, some cooperative companies will only outsource work to other cooperative groups.

Not to mention the camaraderie of working with people with similar goals in a noncompetitive environment where they value your success.

Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by leethaxor on Sunday November 27, 2022 @11:37AM (#33764203)
> finding clients, invoicing, server maintenance, customer service, training, documentation, implementation consultants

Clients find me, not the other way around.

Well I have an accountant, tax advisor and lawyer as subscriptions. I also have a coworking pass. Documentation and implementation are my own lines of work.

Trainings are given for free in coops? I can't imagine my friends working for free, are you forced to work for free in a coop? As in, would I be forced to give trainings too? I value my time too much for this.

> If you are paying someone to do any of these jobs, you are doing it out of income that you've paid taxes on.

No. As a contractor, all of the above (including conference passes, trainings/certifications, driving to/from the client, all my hardware I use to work etc) are my business expenses. I pay tax on profit, not turnover.

Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by therealdrag0 on Sunday November 27, 2022 @12:42PM (#33764819)
Thanks for sharing your experience. I’m not familiar with the space but I wonder if it’s just a matter of elite-ness. Hypothesis: The top 1 or 10 percent of a field are better off in their own, whereas the rest benefit from collective benefits. Another example that comes to mind is Matt Yglesias leaving Vox. He was well paid at Vox but now on his own I’m sure he’s even higher paid and has more freedom etc. I donno just speculating.
Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by nanomonkey on Sunday November 27, 2022 @03:00PM (#33766188)
>Trainings are given for free in coops? I can't imagine myself or my friends working for free, are you forced to work for free in a coop? As in, would I be forced to give trainings too? I value my time too much for this. Of course I do the occasional free tech talk for my friends/the public, but that's not in any way comparable to a "full" training.

No one said anything about training for free. This was an example of work that needs to be done for a client that you may not want to do yourself. A junior level member of your coop could travel to the client's site and train them on how to use your software, learn from the experience and make valuable ties, while you stay at home and work on more appropriate tasks.

Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by leethaxor on Sunday November 27, 2022 @03:03PM (#33766216)
Ah, okay, that makes more sense. Sorry I misunderstood. This is not really something applicable to my line of work (standard software development tasks on a larger project in an agile team managed by the client) but I can imagine some of my friends doing this.
Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by kybernetyk on Sunday November 27, 2022 @12:14PM (#33764568)
>Why does it make total sense that people are interested?

Because that way you can finance a bunch of useless moochers who "administer your coop". Smells like typical rent seeking.

Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by yogthos on Sunday November 27, 2022 @01:10PM (#33765079)
If you're worried about rent seeking wait till you find out how a traditional business works. The owner of the company takes all the profit, and then pays out a small portion of that profit to the workers doing the work in form of wages.

On the other hand, in a coop the profit is shared fairly amongst the people actually doing the work. It's frankly incredibly that somebody thinks this is a worse model of compensation.

Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by kybernetyk on Sunday November 27, 2022 @05:00PM (#33767439)
Your communism is showing.
Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by yogthos on Sunday November 27, 2022 @07:15PM (#33768370)
And proud of it.
Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by cercatrova on Sunday November 27, 2022 @10:42PM (#33769607)
The labor theory of value has basically never been shown to work, while the subjective theory of value, however many its flaws, has been shown to work and bring us the world we see today.
Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by zozbot234 on Monday November 28, 2022 @02:46AM (#33770813)
The labor theory of value is approximately true when capital intensity is low, however.
Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by cercatrova on Monday November 28, 2022 @09:40AM (#33774132)
True, in a commune or something like that, it does work. I think though once we hit Dunbar's number, then it breaks down and we need a subjective value based market.
Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by leethaxor on Monday November 28, 2022 @04:09PM (#33779692)
It's never true. It's like a broken clock - it's right 2 times a day. When the conditions are exactly correct, it seems like the labor theory of value is true - but it's not. Consider a simple example - food production. Nothing changes about the labor necessary to produce it but that doesn't mean you won't have to sell your produce way under price (or let it rot) if you and other farmers make too much of it.
Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by yogthos on Monday November 28, 2022 @05:27PM (#33780770)
The question isn't about the amount of labour needed to produce food, it's regarding who collects the profit from the labour that is done. Not sure what point you were trying to make with food production there.
Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by leethaxor on Monday November 28, 2022 @06:23PM (#33781342)
The labor theory of value argues that the economic value of a good or service is determined by the total amount of "socially necessary labor" required to produce it. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labor_theory_of_value)

My point is that value is actually not determined by "socially necessary labor" but by supply and demand. The food you produce will rot if you and others produce too much of it = it has no value, nobody collects profit because everybody lost any possibility of selling for a good price by producing too much.

On the other hand during a shortage people will start valuing food much more than they previously did - again totally disconnected from the "socially necessary labor" required to produce it.

Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by yogthos on Monday November 28, 2022 @07:20PM (#33781880)
Of course it has to do with profits and who gets it. That's the whole context for introducing the theory of value in Kapital, which one of us actually read while the other evidently skimmed a wikipedia page.

Labour theory of value is not in anyway at odds with the idea of supply and demand. In fact, the whole idea of value in Kapital is derived from supply and demand.

The labour theory of value states that the inherent value of a commodity is directly related to the combination of labour and cost of the machinery needed to produce the commodity. This is what acts as the foundation for the value that the market assigns to the commodities. The market value doesn't just appear out of thin air, it's rooted in material costs of production.

To put it bluntly, you have an infantile understanding of the subject you're attempting to debate here.

Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by leethaxor on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:11PM (#33792614)
Kek
Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by yogthos on Tuesday November 29, 2022 @03:36PM (#33792926)
Pretty much the quality of discourse I was expecting here. Next time try to stick to opining on topics you actually understand.
Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by leethaxor on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @05:46AM (#33799082)
Kek

(I bet I read the book more times than you. It's sitting right there on a shelf next to my desk :-))

Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by yogthos on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @02:18PM (#33806086)
If you read the book then you'd understand what labour theory of value is. Your comments make it pretty clear that you don't. You literally don't understand how it relates to market. Kek as you say.
Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by yogthos on Monday November 28, 2022 @05:27PM (#33780762)
Yeah, subjective theory of value brought us the world where a handful of individuals have more wealth than over half the world population, while the rest live in shit.
Re:Fired? Why cooperatives might be your next career choice ... by cercatrova on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @07:59AM (#33800025)
Industrialization via the profit motive has been the single greatest lever of increasing humanity's quality of life.

The people who say that the rest live in shit in my experience have never been to a third world country and actually lived there. If they did, they'd realize just how shit the first world is.

As long as we have scarcity of goods that must be distributed somehow, communism only works in theory, not in practice.

Edit: Ah, I see, so you're a tankie who grew up in the USSR yet still supports them. Thanks, I have no need to speak to you further.