News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by julianeon on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:01PM (#33746700)
To me this is the clear downside of having a competitive, efficient society: it is so competitive, and so efficient, that people correctly calculate that by bypassing kids, they can save more & lose less time.

That's where the the economic pressure (which societies seem to want, lest people become 'lazy') pushes the next generation. When that's what you incentivize, that's what you get - not just in Korea but all over the modern world.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by deltree7 on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:14PM (#33746847)
I'm not a religious nut, but you have to admit that religion which typically prioritizing lots of babies got this one right
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by gloryjulio on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:17PM (#33746871)
By having ppl indoctrinated to accept being at lower caste to produce babies and contributing, where the ppl at top of the pyramid are sucking all the blood from the bottom. Yeah that would work out
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by rayiner on Friday November 25, 2022 @05:06PM (#33747325)
That sounds more like the modern secularism than at least Christianity or Islam. Indeed, the latter is more egalitarian. Nearly everyone can take pride in raising a family. Only a relative cognitive elite can forgo having kids to pursue a demanding career.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by gloryjulio on Friday November 25, 2022 @08:44PM (#33749010)
How are Christianity or Islam more egalitarian? Don't their elites have way more power to define what the bottom feeders can do or say? How is giving ppl less right more egalitarian? What kind of backward logic are you talking about?
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by AnimalMuppet on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:08PM (#33749137)
They're more egalitarian because there's a authority that is written. I can use the Bible or the Koran to judge the minister or the organization. I don't know if this is done in Islam, but it is in at least some strains of Christianity.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by gloryjulio on Saturday November 26, 2022 @10:01PM (#33759764)
I am not talking about the book. I am talking about in practice. I am not even getting the nitty gitty details of things like women's rights.

I am only asking one question. Has there been a time in history where there are really no elites group in the religious groups and everyone is equal? When did that happen? It's such a hypocrisy that all the religions have a good idea that we should have a god above men so that we don't worship human as god, but in the end it never translated to the practice isn't it?

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by rayiner on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:51PM (#33749410)
They’re more egalitarian because their vision of a good life (working hard, getting married, raising kids, and following the rules) is attainable for nearly anyone. Even the elites must abide by that definition at least publicly.

In modern secular society, elites use their power to define a vision of a good life that reflects their own life, but is unattainable for the average person: living comfortably in a big, interesting city, having an interesting or impactful or glamorous professional job, being a famous performer or fame-adjacent, etc.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by gloryjulio on Saturday November 26, 2022 @09:56PM (#33759728)
> In modern secular society

How about change it to forever? Has there ever been a time where everyone is equal? I have NEVER seen that happen in practice, just like the communists' so called 'equality'. Let's put it in this way, I have never seen 'All animals are equal'. I have only seen 'but some animals are more equal than others'. You should read Animal Farm.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by SturgeonsLaw on Friday November 25, 2022 @05:48PM (#33747720)
Classic humanity, I mean that's pretty much how everything's done everywhere
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by locutous on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:56PM (#33749437)
The ones with the kids are happy, the ones with the money are not. That's how it works out.

Money doesn't buy happiness. Having a family successfully contributes a great deal to happiness.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by Klinky on Saturday November 26, 2022 @01:45PM (#33755371)
That's what people are indoctrinated, causing a lot of people to start a family too soon. However, I assure you many who have kids are not happy, especially while raising them in poverty or on unlivable wages.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by locutous on Sunday November 27, 2022 @01:14AM (#33760836)
"indoctrinated". You say that like people who say this are selling rotten fruit as new.

You can verify this for yourself. Go to an old folks home. Ask them about their lives. See how many don't bring up their children. Or mention them with regret. Look into their eyes as they speak of them.

In my experience everyone wears their children like badges of honor and any regrets are about not doing enough for them or having their priorities not family oriented enough.

This is the perspective of the oldest among us with the longest time here to contemplate what they find most important.

Yes, we preach it, have preached it. This doesn't make it any less true, because it is true. Your being given the keys to life and your appear to want to question.

Today's poor people are richer than rich people way back when those old folks were raising children.

I've been quite poor and with children. I'm intimately familiar with the pain of being poor. Speaking from my experience, in 20 years your poorness won't matter, but your children, if any, will.

Waiting for perfection before having children is like never shipping because there are flaws in the code. Sure, you try not to ship crap but it still must go out as best as you can manage.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by Klinky on Sunday November 27, 2022 @01:27PM (#33765230)
As a product of generational trauma, I find the "no perfect time, just have kids" mentality disgusting. Perhaps these old people's regrets about not doing enough for their children is because they didn't prepare properly to actually have children. Children being used to prop up your own self image strips both you and your child of their individuality. People should want more in life than to "have children" and need to give the decision to have children the proper weight it deserves. If someone does not feel satisfied in their own self or their relationship, they should avoid having children hoping to fill a void.

I assure you that just magically hoping the poorness goes away after 20 years doesn't magically result in it happening, nor does time effortlessly unwind the trauma or mend the damage done by generations of people who were ill prepared to take care of children.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by locutous on Sunday November 27, 2022 @10:10PM (#33769401)
> As a product of generational trauma, I find the "no perfect time, just have kids" mentality disgusting.

The families of the earth do need improvement. That starts with individual choices to be better, do better. However, you are disgusted at the wrong thing. Having children isn't the issue. Being bad to then is. And money isn't the fulcrum you make it out to be.

> Perhaps these old people's regrets about not doing enough for their children are because they didn't prepare properly to actually have children.

Generally it was along the lines that they regret their unnecessary selfish pursuits over family time. Working more for a nice car or boat, an example.

> assure you that just hoping the poorness goes away after 20 years doesn't magically result in it happening,

That isn't really my argument now is it. And this isn't the only time in your response where you do this. Makes a conversation kind of pointless when you just put whatever words and points in my mouth you feel like and ignore the main points.

> nor does time effortlessly unwind the trauma or mend the damage done by generations of people who were ill prepared to take care of children.

Your life has challenges. Most do. You are human like the rest of us. Stop blaming your forebears, even if they have some fault, and rise to the occasion.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by Klinky on Thursday December 08, 2022 @03:07AM (#33905514)
I think your attempts to be profound come off as incredibly naive with regards to the realities of a traumatic upbringing. These relationships impact your whole life.

You do not get to choose your parents. Your parents should choose a good time & place to have children & not cave to pressure from foolish people waxing poetic about finding meaning by living through their children.

I absolutely will blame my abusers, and I will blame their abusers too. I don't see how "earth families" will improve without accountability. We certainly don't need people telling victims to stop asking for it.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by kspacewalk2 on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:22PM (#33746923)
No, it didn't. Having lots of babies is terrible for all sorts of reasons, and generally holds poor countries back and keeps them poor. Much like with money inflation, a human inflation target of 2% seems wise. Higher or lower than that leads to trouble.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by oska on Friday November 25, 2022 @07:51PM (#33748689)
Societies have periods of (population) growth and (population) decline. Wanting, and managing for a steady 2% growth rate is technocratic, unrealistic, and will lead to more trouble than having natural periods of growth and decline. (Same with steady money growth too.)
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by kitsunesoba on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:18PM (#33746880)
Depends on if one values quality of life for the children, in my opinion. Birthing lots of kids into circumstances that are easily turned desperate seems undesirable in my eyes, particularly if we're aiming for a society composed of mentally healthy adults.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by rayiner on Friday November 25, 2022 @05:07PM (#33747337)
I would be shocked if Americans were “mentally healthier” than say Indians or Chinese. Living in a world of physical limits rather than endless possibilities has a way of focusing the mind.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by kitsunesoba on Friday November 25, 2022 @05:19PM (#33747428)
As an American I think our mental health, at least among millennials and gen Z is generally in shambles, largely thanks to financial stress. We have a lot of depressed young people feeling like there is no bright future to strive for and that they're going to be working some menial job until the day they die.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by tptacek on Friday November 25, 2022 @06:01PM (#33747844)
That would be an argument in favor of us having sharply better mental health than Indian and Chinese people.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by rayiner on Friday November 25, 2022 @09:41PM (#33749343)
> We have a lot of depressed young people feeling like there is no bright future to strive for and that they're going to be working some menial job until the day they die.

I agree that stress about this eventuality is the root of a lot of mental health issues. But I would say the problem is actually that recent generations have been socialized into thinking that the average person can expect any more than that. A blessing Indians and Chinese have is being free of that socialization.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by seydor on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:09PM (#33746778)
So people are optimizing. Why should they optimize for maximum population?
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by spicyusername on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:15PM (#33746856)
At a minimum optimizing for "replacement" theoretically allows a population to continue to exist as it is (assuming all kinds of things like everyone backfills the jobs that are already filled, etc, etc)

A shrinking population is terrible as there are less and less people to support existing institutions like social services, infrastructure, healthcare, etc.

A very simple example is social security. It is a net wealth transfer from working age people to retirement age people.

If there's not enough working age people then there is not enough to support the retirement age people.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by deltree7 on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:20PM (#33746898)
It's very simplistic. At the end of the day it is all about productivity.

If 1 person (augmented with AI) can be 5x productive then you can easily support aging population.

At the end of the day, population needs goods and services (not money) to improve their standard of living.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by rich_sasha on Friday November 25, 2022 @05:09PM (#33747350)
I don't think we see it play out this way. Japan is the poster child for this. They also like technology and don't like immigration. But their economy has deep structural issues.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by Jensson on Friday November 25, 2022 @06:43PM (#33748219)
Does it have more issues for the people living there than in other countries, or is it just that capitalists doesn't feel they can make enough profit in Japan? Often times the "economy" just refers to the amount of profits and not the amount of value delivered to end users.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by RestlessMind on Friday November 25, 2022 @10:44PM (#33749685)
I haven't seen any evidence that we can be 5x productive. Do you have any data to back your argument?
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by seydor on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:17PM (#33746873)
We have to assume then that people are calculating otherwise:

- Smaller population will need less infrastructure

- They don't plan to support the old

- Pension plans were fit for 20th century, esp. post-WW2, but they can't work anymore

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by AnimalMuppet on Friday November 25, 2022 @05:33PM (#33747548)
> They don't plan to support the old

Plot twist: They're going to become the old. They don't seem to have that as part of their calculation...

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by _nalply on Saturday November 26, 2022 @03:26AM (#33750958)
I am sure that some do.

However even if they have many children it doesn't help them if everybody else doesn't.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by jtbayly on Saturday November 26, 2022 @05:35PM (#33757547)
It sure can. Having children who love you and will take care of you was how it worked for millennia.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by _nalply on Monday November 28, 2022 @04:53AM (#33771617)
You misunderstood me. I was writing about demographics.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by jtbayly on Monday November 28, 2022 @06:49AM (#33772456)
But the question is whether there is a benefit to having children once you get old, even if nobody else does (ie including getting old yourself in “the calculation”).

Demographically you’re in a world of trouble still, but then having children is actually far more important if society and its safety nets are collapsing.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by gervwyk on Saturday November 26, 2022 @03:58AM (#33751145)
With you on the pension fund remark, bit whats next / else?
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by seydor on Saturday November 26, 2022 @05:29AM (#33751531)
nothing
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by xboxnolifes on Saturday November 26, 2022 @03:05PM (#33756122)
This is looking at it from the wrong perspective though. People, by and large, optimize their choices for their self, not for "society". Replacement rate is a concept that exists at an abstraction level above the individual. It's not something that an individual can fix, and optimizing for it doesn't necessarily help the individual. At best its something that you may see cultural push for.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by simlevesque on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:11PM (#33746811)
Well, demographic crunches are not really enjoyable.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by georgeecollins on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:15PM (#33746857)
Are they really that bad? There are 8 billion people on the planet. We can support more, but it makes more vulnerable to catastrophe.

Japan has had these demographics for a while now but it doesn't seem like they are falling apart. Someone will say-- oh but there economy isn't growing! Better a stagnant economy than a famine or a plague.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by ben_w on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:34PM (#33747062)
The reality is complicated. But as a toy model, imagine: everyone has one kid, at exactly 40 years old; everyone finishes education at 20; everyone retires at 60, everyone dies at 80.

Every 40 years, the population halves. As each pair of parents retire, their one child enters the workforce, and their labour is used to cover their parents’ pensions — taxes for state pension, and whatever share of the wealth they generate that ends up as corporate profit for private pension.

I don’t know about South Korea, or indeed the statistics of the incidence rate and duration, but from experience I know that late-stage dementia care in the UK costs about twice the average UK earner’s headline salary. I think this may at least show the way it could go wrong, given this is all just an illustration.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by hnbad on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:22PM (#33746925)
Most research I've seen indicates that human population will likely max out at 12 billion and then decline until it reaches a stable level. Except for a few fringe Malthusians, that is.

The problem with population decline is that most countries are built around the naive assumption of perpetual growth, especially when it comes to social security and welfare systems. Of course most of this can easily be fixed by raising taxes but that would fly in the face of the general trend to give tax breaks to higher incomes, abolish wealth taxes and prefer flat tax rates over progressive ones to prevent "wealth flight".

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by skissane on Saturday November 26, 2022 @03:55AM (#33751127)
> Most research I've seen indicates that human population will likely max out at 12 billion and then decline until it reaches a stable level.

That kind of research is based on the assumption that the social/cultural trends encouraging people to have less kids continue unabated.

Humans often overcompensate. It is conceivable that a country's population may decline to the point that the threat that poses to its future becomes impossible to ignore – the threat may motivate the general population to change their behaviour, and may lead to the government introducing major incentives to encourage more children. That may lead to the population decline being reversed; but, it may then be difficult to "turn off the tap" of the new culture/policies to stop the population booming again.

There are also countercultural minorities (mostly ultra-conservative religious sects) who stubbornly continue to have lots of kids in spite of the social/cultural forces which discourage mainstream society from doing so. That kind of analysis generally ignores those minorities, because they are so small – true, but if they don't change their ways, eventually they will grow to become the majority, and then we'll be back to population boom again.

Will they eventually change their ways? That is possible, not inevitable. Many of them have been successfully resisting pressure to change their ways for decades; if they haven't succumbed to that pressure yet, why assume it is inevitable that they eventually will? If one considers that there are multiple such countercultural minorities, even if some of them do end up changing course, all it takes is for one to stubbornly resist doing so, for it to eventually become the demographic majority.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by silisili on Friday November 25, 2022 @05:05PM (#33747323)
Bad mainly because countries have been running a pyramid scheme like social security.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by Klinky on Saturday November 26, 2022 @01:48PM (#33755393)
Did you mean ponzi scheme? That would make more sense, while not being entirely accurate.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by silisili on Saturday November 26, 2022 @02:19PM (#33755697)
Yep, I absolutely did. Oops.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by seydor on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:13PM (#33746831)
Probably not, but on the other hand we don't know it for sure cause there isn't one in recent history
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by moonchrome on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:19PM (#33746887)
Current economic trends are a sneak peak - inflation - money being paid out for obligations (gov. bonds -> pension funds) - not enough goods and people to cover the demand.

Only much worse because the trend is increasing on both sides - old people being kept alive with expensive treatments, dropping population of working people.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by seydor on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:21PM (#33746913)
There was high inflation in times of great population growth, 70s-80s
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by moonchrome on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:23PM (#33746927)
You can have inflation for various reasons - labor shortage is one of them.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by mytailorisrich on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:13PM (#33746840)
The planet is telling us that ever increasing population isn't enjoyable, either, and perhaps even less so.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by eastbound on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:21PM (#33746915)
This. I’m super annoyed that countries consider depopulating as a catastrophe. Instead of immediately encouraging repopulation AND trying to deal with the climate catastrophe, why don’t we accept depopulation as a benefit and put much less pressure on the climate?

In 1990, CO2 emissions equated CO2 absorption by trees. All the goals about CO2 are about coming back to 1990 levels (minus the surplus). So 1990 levels of population is what we should aim for. If a country depopulates, let’s not increase births.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by seydor on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:30PM (#33747001)
If we accept this, (contrary to the hitherto used economic models of growth) then we 'll need to change priorities in economies, fund more automation, deflate all the useless real estate bubbles etc, take down excess infrastructure, switch to robust nuclear energy etc. There aren't going to be enough ppl in the future to maintain this infrastructure.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by shitpostbot on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:12PM (#33746827)
If it would be better for the society, then the society should be incentivising it, or at least making the calculation sensible. Hence the discussion
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by toomuchtodo on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:55PM (#33747254)
Society wants the benefits without paying the true costs for parents to raise kids and not have the experience suck. Even in countries with robust pro natalist policies, people want less or no kids.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by akira2501 on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:23PM (#33746928)
I have a hard time rectifying the idea that Korea's economy is highly state managed and largely operated by monopolies with a society "so efficient and competitive" that people are opting out of humanity in order to compete and store money.

I almost think you have it entirely backwards. In a society where competition and choice is so severely limited you see people adopt these strategies because there is far less room to make a mistake or to engage with economically sub optimal decisions like having a child.

I think you're seeing this effect creep into the US as well, as we've allowed more mergers and acquisitions financed by cheap interest from the Fed that people are effectively feeling this same squeeze here. Plus, I don't think people are at all effectively factoring in the consequences of the lock downs and crash of small businesses that were associated with it.

This is a government monopoly problem, not a lazy population problem.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by nine_k on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:24PM (#33746944)
It very much depends on how the society (your peer group, your parents, etc) defines success.

In societies, having many kids is seen as a sign of success; ideally not just the number but also their prosperity.

In other societies, personal consumption and personal display of wealth and influence prevail; likely it's the case of the urbanized part of the SK society.

For obvious natural reasons, the trait of not having kids is self-eliminating. Those who don't care that their culture will end with them will be outnumbered and eventually replaced by those who do.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by nugget on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:24PM (#33746943)
Children have value in the hyperefficient society you describe, but it's emotional rather than monetary. It's hard to compare abstract, future emotional upside to dollars spent on diapers and sleepless hours lost to infant childcare in the here and now. Society does a poor job helping young people understand how to balance investment into children, friends, family, and community against investment into professional work which often results in more immediate and measurable results.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by toomuchtodo on Friday November 25, 2022 @05:34PM (#33747555)
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by hnbad on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:17PM (#33746879)
That's a funny way of saying that people are so economically desperate (whether due to low income, lack of savings, job insecurity, weak familial ties, etc) that they delay having children.

I wonder what the % of people currently in a long-term relationship looks like. Those also don't tend to do well under economic duress.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by dmix on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:21PM (#33746908)
South Koreans are richer than ever, so if that's the problem why aren't they having more kids?

> due to low income, lack of savings, job insecurity, weak familial ties, etc

Almost every couple I know who is not having kids makes good $$. It's my friends who make less and are more working class (and work longer hours at that) are the ones having kids. So that sounds like the opposite of what you're suggesting.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by hnbad on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:35PM (#33747067)
> job insecurity, weak familial ties, etc

Not everything is about current income. Sure, they make good money but are they able to cut hours to spend more time at home with an infant or toddler? Can one of them take a few years off work and still have their career recover from that? Will they be able to maintain their lifestyle if they have to pay for another human being? There are a lot more considerations than raw money and a higher income doesn't help with that unless you can also build up considerable savings or have a strong support network. It takes a village, and all that.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by dmix on Friday November 25, 2022 @05:26PM (#33747499)
When you make $100k vs $50k that usually means your skillset is in higher demand and rarer, so you have better long term job security. Working class people don't have that luxury.

So yes I think people who earn more have better job security and ability to support a spouse during mat leave. I also live in Canada with liberal mat leave laws so that's not an issue.

If anything the biggest pressure on my wealthy urban friends vs working class suburban/small town people is a) cost of housing and b) lack of savings.

But OP said "a competitive and maximally efficient society" dissuades kids.

First, a competitive economy should generate plenty of housing for people with the $$ to pay for it.

Secondly, an efficient economy should provide plenty of ways to save/invest beyond just housing. The public stock market is highly exclusive and controlled. The primary other way (besides housing/stocks) is investing in or starting a small business. New small business rates have declined in recent years. Housing is the only game in town for most people and what politicians spend 90% of focus on incentivizing in capital markets + culturally, but keep supply artificially limited.

So if anything regressive policies which prevent competition/efficiency leads to less kids.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by kitsunesoba on Friday November 25, 2022 @05:02PM (#33747299)
> Almost every couple I know who is not having kids makes good $$. It's my friends who make less and are more working class (and work longer hours at that) are the ones having kids.

Those you see making good money, if they intend to have kids, are probably holding off until they feel they're ready (I'm in this group myself). Couples who aren't earning much might feel that someday may never come and have kids since they're going to be somewhat financially stressed either way, plus some in that group have kids as a way to add some meaning and motivation to keep on with the everyday grind.

That said, the answer to population problems clearly not to make more people impoverished, but rather to bring the bar of "ready of kids" down to a level that's accessible by more people more quickly.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by jemmyw on Friday November 25, 2022 @05:21PM (#33747440)
If you and your partner want kids and are waiting for some arbitrary financial goal my advice would be don't wait, do it now.

We had our first when I was 25 and then seeing all our peers wait until 35+ health wise you're going to cope better when you're younger. Plus you get that much longer when them in your life, and more time being able to play competitive sports with them.

But kids are expensive you say? Well they can be, but only if you spend money on them, and most of that spending is school years anyway so you still have time to figure out out.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by kspacewalk2 on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:25PM (#33746956)
South Korea is richer and more successful than most countries on earth. If "economic desperation" was an actual, as opposed to a stated, reason for South Koreans to have fewer babies, the vast majority of humanity would have fewer children still, since their "economic desperation" is objectively much worse.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by yongjik on Friday November 25, 2022 @05:33PM (#33747544)
If it were actually efficient we'd see less issues. I'd say the Korean economy is hyper-competitive but fairly inefficient. Lots of social problems because people who secured a nice, well-paying job don't want competitions and will do everything to block others from getting the same job. All the way from lawyers limiting the number of lawyers, to doctors doing the same thing, to full-time factory workers discriminating against part-time workers in the same factory.

So (1) there are fewer and fewer decent jobs, and (2) once you fall off the "correct career path" for any reason, there's no way to get back, or at least that's the universal perception. So everybody fights tooth and nail to keep whatever they already have, which further distorts the market, and the cycle continues.

Disclaimer: have been living in the US since 2011, so my understanding is from reading news and stuff.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by skissane on Saturday November 26, 2022 @04:17AM (#33751220)
> If it were actually efficient we'd see less issues. I'd say the Korean economy is hyper-competitive but fairly inefficient.

I remember once visiting the head office in Seoul of a major South Korean firm – they had a rather large development team working on some rather quotidian internal corporate needs (identity management, corporate intranet/portal, etc). And yet, they were being subjected to the kind of limitations one would expect only on some classified national security project – e.g. Internet access blocked so they couldn't access StackOverflow/etc, personal electronic devices had to be put in lockers at the building security desk, etc. The restrictions were very obviously impeding their productivity. It appeared that the company's management was very paranoid about corporate espionage, to a degree which seemed out of place given the actual business this company did.

A Korean colleague told me that a lot of South Korean companies were like that. His theory was that senior management at many firms is dominated by retired military officers, who take from their military background a culture of secrecy which may well be justified in the military, defence contractors, super-high-tech firms such as leading-node semiconductor fabrication, etc–but isn't appropriate for your average business, and this particular firm wasn't doing anything like that. What do I know, but his theory seemed plausible to me.