News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by seydor on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:09PM (#33746778)
So people are optimizing. Why should they optimize for maximum population?
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by spicyusername on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:15PM (#33746856)
At a minimum optimizing for "replacement" theoretically allows a population to continue to exist as it is (assuming all kinds of things like everyone backfills the jobs that are already filled, etc, etc)

A shrinking population is terrible as there are less and less people to support existing institutions like social services, infrastructure, healthcare, etc.

A very simple example is social security. It is a net wealth transfer from working age people to retirement age people.

If there's not enough working age people then there is not enough to support the retirement age people.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by deltree7 on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:20PM (#33746898)
It's very simplistic. At the end of the day it is all about productivity.

If 1 person (augmented with AI) can be 5x productive then you can easily support aging population.

At the end of the day, population needs goods and services (not money) to improve their standard of living.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by rich_sasha on Friday November 25, 2022 @05:09PM (#33747350)
I don't think we see it play out this way. Japan is the poster child for this. They also like technology and don't like immigration. But their economy has deep structural issues.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by Jensson on Friday November 25, 2022 @06:43PM (#33748219)
Does it have more issues for the people living there than in other countries, or is it just that capitalists doesn't feel they can make enough profit in Japan? Often times the "economy" just refers to the amount of profits and not the amount of value delivered to end users.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by RestlessMind on Friday November 25, 2022 @10:44PM (#33749685)
I haven't seen any evidence that we can be 5x productive. Do you have any data to back your argument?
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by seydor on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:17PM (#33746873)
We have to assume then that people are calculating otherwise:

- Smaller population will need less infrastructure

- They don't plan to support the old

- Pension plans were fit for 20th century, esp. post-WW2, but they can't work anymore

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by AnimalMuppet on Friday November 25, 2022 @05:33PM (#33747548)
> They don't plan to support the old

Plot twist: They're going to become the old. They don't seem to have that as part of their calculation...

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by _nalply on Saturday November 26, 2022 @03:26AM (#33750958)
I am sure that some do.

However even if they have many children it doesn't help them if everybody else doesn't.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by jtbayly on Saturday November 26, 2022 @05:35PM (#33757547)
It sure can. Having children who love you and will take care of you was how it worked for millennia.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by _nalply on Monday November 28, 2022 @04:53AM (#33771617)
You misunderstood me. I was writing about demographics.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by jtbayly on Monday November 28, 2022 @06:49AM (#33772456)
But the question is whether there is a benefit to having children once you get old, even if nobody else does (ie including getting old yourself in “the calculation”).

Demographically you’re in a world of trouble still, but then having children is actually far more important if society and its safety nets are collapsing.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by gervwyk on Saturday November 26, 2022 @03:58AM (#33751145)
With you on the pension fund remark, bit whats next / else?
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by seydor on Saturday November 26, 2022 @05:29AM (#33751531)
nothing
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by xboxnolifes on Saturday November 26, 2022 @03:05PM (#33756122)
This is looking at it from the wrong perspective though. People, by and large, optimize their choices for their self, not for "society". Replacement rate is a concept that exists at an abstraction level above the individual. It's not something that an individual can fix, and optimizing for it doesn't necessarily help the individual. At best its something that you may see cultural push for.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by simlevesque on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:11PM (#33746811)
Well, demographic crunches are not really enjoyable.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by georgeecollins on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:15PM (#33746857)
Are they really that bad? There are 8 billion people on the planet. We can support more, but it makes more vulnerable to catastrophe.

Japan has had these demographics for a while now but it doesn't seem like they are falling apart. Someone will say-- oh but there economy isn't growing! Better a stagnant economy than a famine or a plague.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by ben_w on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:34PM (#33747062)
The reality is complicated. But as a toy model, imagine: everyone has one kid, at exactly 40 years old; everyone finishes education at 20; everyone retires at 60, everyone dies at 80.

Every 40 years, the population halves. As each pair of parents retire, their one child enters the workforce, and their labour is used to cover their parents’ pensions — taxes for state pension, and whatever share of the wealth they generate that ends up as corporate profit for private pension.

I don’t know about South Korea, or indeed the statistics of the incidence rate and duration, but from experience I know that late-stage dementia care in the UK costs about twice the average UK earner’s headline salary. I think this may at least show the way it could go wrong, given this is all just an illustration.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by hnbad on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:22PM (#33746925)
Most research I've seen indicates that human population will likely max out at 12 billion and then decline until it reaches a stable level. Except for a few fringe Malthusians, that is.

The problem with population decline is that most countries are built around the naive assumption of perpetual growth, especially when it comes to social security and welfare systems. Of course most of this can easily be fixed by raising taxes but that would fly in the face of the general trend to give tax breaks to higher incomes, abolish wealth taxes and prefer flat tax rates over progressive ones to prevent "wealth flight".

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by skissane on Saturday November 26, 2022 @03:55AM (#33751127)
> Most research I've seen indicates that human population will likely max out at 12 billion and then decline until it reaches a stable level.

That kind of research is based on the assumption that the social/cultural trends encouraging people to have less kids continue unabated.

Humans often overcompensate. It is conceivable that a country's population may decline to the point that the threat that poses to its future becomes impossible to ignore – the threat may motivate the general population to change their behaviour, and may lead to the government introducing major incentives to encourage more children. That may lead to the population decline being reversed; but, it may then be difficult to "turn off the tap" of the new culture/policies to stop the population booming again.

There are also countercultural minorities (mostly ultra-conservative religious sects) who stubbornly continue to have lots of kids in spite of the social/cultural forces which discourage mainstream society from doing so. That kind of analysis generally ignores those minorities, because they are so small – true, but if they don't change their ways, eventually they will grow to become the majority, and then we'll be back to population boom again.

Will they eventually change their ways? That is possible, not inevitable. Many of them have been successfully resisting pressure to change their ways for decades; if they haven't succumbed to that pressure yet, why assume it is inevitable that they eventually will? If one considers that there are multiple such countercultural minorities, even if some of them do end up changing course, all it takes is for one to stubbornly resist doing so, for it to eventually become the demographic majority.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by silisili on Friday November 25, 2022 @05:05PM (#33747323)
Bad mainly because countries have been running a pyramid scheme like social security.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by Klinky on Saturday November 26, 2022 @01:48PM (#33755393)
Did you mean ponzi scheme? That would make more sense, while not being entirely accurate.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by silisili on Saturday November 26, 2022 @02:19PM (#33755697)
Yep, I absolutely did. Oops.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by seydor on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:13PM (#33746831)
Probably not, but on the other hand we don't know it for sure cause there isn't one in recent history
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by moonchrome on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:19PM (#33746887)
Current economic trends are a sneak peak - inflation - money being paid out for obligations (gov. bonds -> pension funds) - not enough goods and people to cover the demand.

Only much worse because the trend is increasing on both sides - old people being kept alive with expensive treatments, dropping population of working people.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by seydor on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:21PM (#33746913)
There was high inflation in times of great population growth, 70s-80s
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by moonchrome on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:23PM (#33746927)
You can have inflation for various reasons - labor shortage is one of them.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by mytailorisrich on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:13PM (#33746840)
The planet is telling us that ever increasing population isn't enjoyable, either, and perhaps even less so.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by eastbound on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:21PM (#33746915)
This. I’m super annoyed that countries consider depopulating as a catastrophe. Instead of immediately encouraging repopulation AND trying to deal with the climate catastrophe, why don’t we accept depopulation as a benefit and put much less pressure on the climate?

In 1990, CO2 emissions equated CO2 absorption by trees. All the goals about CO2 are about coming back to 1990 levels (minus the surplus). So 1990 levels of population is what we should aim for. If a country depopulates, let’s not increase births.

Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by seydor on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:30PM (#33747001)
If we accept this, (contrary to the hitherto used economic models of growth) then we 'll need to change priorities in economies, fund more automation, deflate all the useless real estate bubbles etc, take down excess infrastructure, switch to robust nuclear energy etc. There aren't going to be enough ppl in the future to maintain this infrastructure.
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by shitpostbot on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:12PM (#33746827)
If it would be better for the society, then the society should be incentivising it, or at least making the calculation sensible. Hence the discussion
Re:South Korea in demographic crisis as many stop having babies by toomuchtodo on Friday November 25, 2022 @04:55PM (#33747254)
Society wants the benefits without paying the true costs for parents to raise kids and not have the experience suck. Even in countries with robust pro natalist policies, people want less or no kids.