It’s entire purpose is to look up data and download stuff across the internet. How can it not be an internet service? How much use could it be if it was cut off from internet connectivity, what would you even do in it?
Of how much use is an iPhone without the App Store? You can still use the preinstalled apps, but your expectation as a consumer is that you can install new apps. This expectation is broken without the App Store.
"These are not device analytics, they are services analytics."
"These Are Not the Droids You Are Looking For"
This made me remember a long time ago when I ran Windows I used to disable explorer.exe by editing a certain registry key.
Not sure if this still works today, but it did back then. This reduced distraction as only one window could be maxmized at a time. Also made the OS feel more stable and snappier. In any event it was one less memory-consuming process running.
I was too used to the Windows 3.1 desktop environment...
Apple is basically loopholing all the shitty ad-tech engagement surveillance bs that plagues the rest of the industry through the app store, pretending like it's any other app. Of course they can, but a lot of the hard-line privacy stuff goes down the drain with the hypocrisy.
What bothers me is that Apple really doesn't have to move in this direction, at all. They've been uniquely positioned to basically do things that nobody else can, because they sell so much expensive hardware. Instead, all mega corps seem to blend together and follow the same playbook. It's sad.
The main issue here is that Apple has been collecting personal data for years through its stock apps without informed consent, which is in breach of GDPR. You need to ask for express consent to collect personal data of this granularity, having a privacy policy and a toggle in settings is not enough, and it does not matter if the data collection is done by a website, app or an operating system.
It was particularly frustrating to see people argue that it's just an older version of iOS, when the reality is that one needs to hack an iPhone to see how this data is being syphoned off, and that jailbreaks for new iOS versions can be prohibitively expensive to achieve. Despite that, researchers pointed out that they see similar encrypted packets being sent with a recent iOS version.
I think it's worrying that consumers can't inspect the traffic of a device they own, and this is also an area that should be regulated so that our rights are respected.
And after several attempts to pretend that US laws like the Patriot Act that remove non-US citizen rights were compatible with the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights have been struck down by the Court of Justice of the EU (after the US has been caught violating these rights) it's starting to be hard to imagine what kind of agreement can possibly happen between the USA and the EU that would make US companies legal again...
The author of the article wrote that all he had to do was request his data from Apple.
You observation has nothing to do with what is being discussed, we have a right to inspect the network activity of our devices.
I remember you posting in threads criticizing Apple, almost always coming to their defense. You've been doing this for years.
This is a provably false claim based on the authors own experience.
Guess what? You also have no idea what your phone is sending the carrier or any other service provider.
But as far as you knowing who I am because of my posting history, “but for me it was Tuesday”
Ah, so now you play the fatalist backdoor card. Well, the good news is that we do know some of what your iPhone sends back home. We know that every time you launch an app, both Apple and Akamai receive data about what app you opened and when. We know that Apple has private API entitlements for circumventing your VPN rules. We know that Apple actively and directly works with the NSA and CCP to enable domestic surveillance capabilities.
So, you're right! Hacking your device only gives you a small window into the horrors of your software vendor. If we could totally decrypt all of Apple's traffic alongside the SIM's baseband transmissions, nobody would every say 'privacy' and 'iPhone' in the same sentence again.
Yet another glaring indicator identifying our species as not mature enough to manage our own society. If this occurs everywhere, no matter what, then it is us, our constitution, our chemistry, our maturity as a species that is at fault.
It is common and entirely ordinary to observe everyday people unable to delay their immediate need for gratification. It is also entirely ordinary and normal to observe friends, family and coworkers who routinely cut corners (take process shortcuts) and engage in process deceptions because they simply do not care about the consequences. Likewise it is entirely ordinary for one's employer to other their own employees to the degree they treat them with equal severity as one might find in the times of legal slavery (not exaggerating at all.) It is common and ordinary for spouses to other their own spouse, causing a legacy of failed marriages.
What is not ordinary is to meet persons that do not take short cuts, do not cheat on their employees, their spouses, or in reality: themselves. The majority that do not cheat are those not trusted and not provided the opportunities. The majority, if given too much trust, will rape their environment blind given time and the lack of repercussion: and that is immaturity at scale in our society, and it is the natural state of society. Trust is for fools.
> [...] Additionally, "cooperative banks build up counter-cyclical buffers that function well in case of a crisis," and are less likely to lead members and clients towards a debt trap (p. 216). This is explained by their more democratic governance that reduces perverse incentives and subsequent contributions to economic bubbles.
> The cooperative banking sector had 20% market share of the European banking sector, but accounted for only 7 per cent of all the write-downs and losses between the third quarter of 2007 and first quarter of 2011. Cooperative banks were also over-represented in lending to small and medium-sized businesses in all of the 10 countries included in the report.
> [...] in France and Spain, worker cooperatives and social cooperatives "have been more resilient than conventional enterprises during the economic crisis".
> Public trust in credit unions stands at 60%, compared to 30% for big banks and small businesses are five times less likely to be dissatisfied with a credit union than with a big bank.
In other words, this behaviour doesn't happen everywhere. It's specific to certain types of businesses.
Paragraphs from here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cooperative#Economic_stability
All organizations seek to accrue power and revenue - even “non profits”.
I saw it from one of the local credit unions I worked at in college…
1. First it was a credit union for a few large companies
2. Then it redid its charter to become a “regional credit union”
3. Then it said “fuck it we are bank”
Meet the old boss..
That's a pretty extreme description of what's happening here. I agree that they should not be doing this, and that App Store analytics should be opt-in like the rest of the device analytics, however, they are not correlating your unique identifier with other web properties — i.e. when you visit through Safari. I also doubt they are selling that data to third parties, allowing ads to target you on the basis of it, or using it to build a profile against other application analytics.
In fact, it seems like the article says: they do no clever stuff with it whatsoever. They should remove it in a future update
Contrary to explorer.exe, App Store is an internet service in the sense that it requires sending requests to backend for pretty much any user action. There is zero functionality without a data connection.
I can't go back and edit my comment now, but to make it more clear I probably should have written something like:
> I strongly disagree that the iOS App Store should be treated as ___only___ an "internet service" rather than...
It's a package manager and tracker designed in such a way that it only talks to Apple's backend.
It's still the system package manager though.
Users uninstall apps directly from the homescreen (springboard), without going through the App Store app.
Also of course Apple keeps a record of installed apps. If you drop your phone in the ocean and go to the Apple Store to buy a new one, your installed apps are reinstalled.
Apple for over 40 years has sold integrated software and hardware and for over 20 has sold hardware + integrated online services (iPod+ iTunes) and now you are shocked that when you buy an Apple device you also buy into their ecosystem?
Exactly how is anything on the iPhone suppose to work without an account? Push notifications?
Most Android apps are also dependent on Google services and a Google account.
If an app store is a glorified web browser and apple is maintaining content that is loaded into it, it's almost the definition of an internet service no?
The point is not that the App Store isn't an online service (although I would argue that it more "relies on" an online service), but that its role as part of the OS supersedes that.
I can't go back and edit my comment now, but to make it more clear I probably should have written something like:
> I strongly disagree that the iOS App Store should be treated as ___only___ an "internet service" rather than...
There are lots of places that run iOS on private networks with no internet access or Apple ID.
It's also on the web, e.g.: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/facebook/id284882215
Which means apps, for example, show up on Google searches.
I strongly disagree that the iOS App Store should be treated as an "internet service" rather than a part of the device. The iOS App Store only comes on iOS devices, it comes on all iOS devices, and it is the only way to access a crucial feature of the device. It is, for all meaningful purposes, part of the iPhone in the same way iOS is.
It would be a bit like Microsoft saying "explorer.exe? Policy A only covers the OS, and that is clearly not part of Windows! - so therefore you are covered by Policy B". While Apple may be legally in the right, I strongly believe they are morally in the wrong and have betrayed the trust their users put in them to safeguard their privacy.
I believe that a casual user of the iPhone would take a look at Apple's iPhone privacy policy and expect that to apply to the iOS App Store as well, as for all intents and purposes that is a part of the iPhone.