1-) China is not producing goods as before the pandemic. Another one is China's zero-covid policy, like bringing down the entire city for just one covid case.
2-) Europe's energy problem. I'm not an expert on this, but Europe's reliance on Russia's cheap gas could be Europe's competitive advantage in the markets. So, when it is gone, I might expect purchasing power could drop significantly for Europeans.
The UK's performance wrt the growing west became uncorrelated in 2008, and negatively correlated since Brexit came into effect 2020ish+.
The UK was, in many ways, ground-zero for one of the most severe financial crises in modern history. It has never really addressed that, nor does it have an answer for a version of the UK which can exist "in the shadow of that event".
The UK's "best future" from 2008 was an significant pivot to "boring tech", a pivot to the EU, and a rationalised financial system which could support both goals. Instead, it redoubled on relatively pathological elements of the financial industry and away from the EU.
I always assumed it was a combination of WW II, collapse of the Empire and then a series of terrible governments since the 1960s.
I think a structural issue is aging demographics. Lots of welfare policies were enacted when the ratio of workers to non workers was much higher. For decades now, this ratio has been getting smaller and smaller, hence the constant political dilemma of which benefits to cut and how much and for who.
The UK seems like it will especially struggle with delivering universal healthcare promises, as well as pension benefits. Not only are fault lines along rich and poor, but they will be more and more along old and young.
We could avoided a lot of the economic cost of Covid by asking the over-65s to shield and kept the wider economy more or less going, but that was unacceptable to them and instead we shut down everything for their benefit and now they aren’t even willing to contribute to the cost.
Strongly agree. I used to work in the civil service and there are many good individuals but the management structure is poor (though I think generally very effective at line management) and plenty of duffers get promoted. Many ministers are really very mediocre.
Good ideas and techniques are very slowly adopted, but then things like Agile are cargo-culted in an inappropriate way. To be fair, plenty of tech firms do this.
Dominic Cummings has lots of interesting ideas on this on his Substack. When Truss’ mini budget nearly broke pension funds, he pointed out that not only No 10 not know how leveraged they were, but nobody seems to care that they didn’t know. Surely central government should be able to pull together all the data it gathers?
Unfortunately he turned out to be not very good at governing.
Cummings seems like a reasonably intelligent guy, if ethically dubious and difficult to work with (putting it mildly). What is shocking is that he looks like a genius when compared to those around him. He has basically read around a bit, thinks for himself, and is open to contrarian ideas. He’s just a reminder of how poor our governance is.
I think the reality is most of our govts are not just incompetent but actively harmful in terms of national interest. Obviously a hard Brexit, which Cameron and Johnson created as a byproduct of their own political schemes, is the greatest symbol of this.
1. https://www.worksinprogress.co/issue/the-housing-theory-of-e...
But voting to put trade barriers on oneself.. to stop immigration... Is going to lead to pain, no matter what way you cut it.
From my POV seems like the UK's government is tanking the country by pursuing an idiological agenda that obviously isn't working, and is obviously lowering the standard of living in the country, and yet despite all evidence they continue to double down.
The sad thing we're seeing with Labour is that they're doing the classic thing that happens when parties stay in the wilderness of opposition too long, they start to doubt themselves and instead align with what the government of the day is doing.
Labour under their new leadership is clearly now hoping that if they're timid enough and don't rock the boat at all when the Conservatives inevitably implode they'll be thrust into power because they're sitting there as the next default alternative.
It's sadly terribly uninspiring.
Despite your dire situation, you are keeping to make things even worse - See UKCA mark, return of imperial units, endless squabble with EU over Northern Ireland Protocol and threating a trade war, which would finish you off.
Thing is that you used to be interesting for investors (and for me personally) because you were country speaking English and connected to EU. So if somebody from abroad (USA, Asia) wanted to do a bossiness in EU, he would start in UK. That's gone thanks to Brexit and Estonia + Netherland took this role from you. Now you just become a hollow English speaking island which really has nothing to offer.
But quite surprisingly, this is not the case. I don't have enough information to say why, but I am definitely shocked on the lack of discourse on the matter.
There are some small movements, but it goes largely unreported by the mainstream media. There was a 10.000 people march recently in Westminster to UnBrexit and BBC didn't even report it.
- people work less hours - education is slipping - lots of imports because we don't have it anymore (outsourced because of lack of cheap labour or environment laws) ...
It's not really happening in the US. The US economy remains strong and may not even go into a significant recession in the next year.
The US dollar remains the world reserve currency and allows unparalleled monetary and fiscal policy freedom. No-one is losing confidence in the dollar the same way they did in the pound.
Inflation is coming down in the US and it's in a fantastic place in terms of energy and food security.
The decline of "the West" you refer to is really the decline of Europe.
Households won't spend, private sector won't invest as households are not spending, so if the public sector also stops spending then you go into a much longer and deeper recession.
Money itself for a government with a central bank is just a unit of account. There can't not be enough of it. It's just a way to measure resource distribution.
Wealth on the other hand. There's plenty of that in the UK, but it's increasingly in the hands of a few.
40 years of financilising public services and nearly every aspect of our lives means that household and public spending eventually ends up being concentrated even more in the hands of a few. That's the actual issue with public spending into such an economy, that without an effective tax system (which we don't have), then it makes inequality worse.
Both Tory and Labour are pushing a false narrative, because ultimately they represent those who are doing pretty well out of this deal.
Our society has gone from one of growth to one of decay.
You can't do as much when you want to work a few hours a day a few days a week with seasons of time off.
You can't do as much when the supply of energy is falling over time.
You can't do as much when regulations grow and grow, making building anything less and less worthwhile and less and less possible.
https://www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peopleinwor...
There is no point where the workforce, assisted by technology, was dramatically more productive than it is now. Given the rise in productivitiy, shouldn't we expect the standard of living to at least remain constant?
I got a graduate degree in Edinburgh, and the one think I kept noticing about the entire country is how difficult and expensive it is to acquire housing. People literally ooh'd and ahh'd when they learned that a friend had inherited a small home in Norwich, saying she was effectively set for life. It's like California's NIMBY-fuel housing apocalypse, but on steroids due to the greenbelts.
The problem with a housing crisis, is that it's zero-sum wealth consolidation slow-motion event that takes place over a multi-generational period. A country's personal disposable income would generally pumped back into the economy constructively by/via entrepreneurs, but in a rent-seeking housing environment, that disposable income is lost to consolidated entities, who generally pump the excess rents back into further housing consolidation, or in international markets.
The reason it sneaks up on you is that once the housing freeze happens, you slowly fill in the excess housing capacity exponentially, until almost overnight, rents skyrocket. Suddenly, the nation becomes dramatically poorer within a decade or so.
The only good news to this theory is that it's trivially fixable with massive housing construction plans, the bad news is that it will be politically unlikely for people to suddenly vote to allow "ugly" new construction in the most historic and important cities in the country.
Just imagine how much capital Londoners could put to work if they had housing taken care of. As of 2017 they have been spending 50% of their income on rent: https://www.bbc.com/news/business-42179119
Only around 20% of people in Britain earn these amounts, which means 80% of people are taking out more than they contribute. I don't know how this compares to other countries but it is clearly unsustainable and I think that now the era of generous Government handouts and cheap borrowing have come to an end, it is starting to bite.
It’s not clear to me _why_ this has happened, I’m not an economist, but it’s clear to me that this is the case. We’ve seen what happens when the government tries to go on a spending spree. Even Labour agree that we need to go into a period of (effective) austerity at this point.