News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by Andys on Monday November 14, 2022 @04:29PM (#33601416)
When it must be so expensive its not even "call us", but "Schedule a Consultation".

You fit in with their schedule, not the other way around?

Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by nix23 on Monday November 14, 2022 @04:59PM (#33601843)
Pff it's IBM you buy the Consultant with it, he sits in the lower rack and has spacefood rations for 5 years, then you have to do maintenance and the consultant get exchanged and retired.

But!! No shutdown needed.

Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by Our_Benefactors on Monday November 14, 2022 @05:07PM (#33601950)
Can they be put on a generator bike? I’m concerned about their carbon footprint.
Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by hyperdimension on Monday November 14, 2022 @08:05PM (#33603844)
What carbon footprint? The consultants are not much more than sequestered carbon!

(A fancy insult, now that I think of it. Nice.)

Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by nix23 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:42AM (#33608420)
>carbon footprint.

They have zeolite in the rack (like in the ISS). The food is also non methane producing.

Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by broodbucket on Monday November 14, 2022 @05:55PM (#33602555)
Nonsense, there would be at least one more redundant consultant if not two.

Seriously though, these machines call home when there's a hardware failure, they'll fail over and someone will show up to replace what failed. Enterprise tech is sometimes cool.

Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by nix23 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:40AM (#33608401)
>Nonsense, there would be at least one more redundant consultant if not two.

Gosh you are right i always forget him.

>Seriously though, these machines call home when there's a hardware failure,

HP's EVA Device did that too, so sometimes a Engineer calls you and ask's if "we" have time to update the firmware, not even HP engineers are allowed to do EVA updates...just specialized EVA ones.

Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by xhkkffbf on Monday November 14, 2022 @05:05PM (#33601923)
This is pretty standard across much of the enterprise world. The sales team just has to earn their commission.

Indeed, even when they have publicly listed prices, it's usually possible to negotiate a substantial discount by dealing directly with the sales team. Like 50% is often possible.

Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by Andys on Monday November 14, 2022 @05:22PM (#33602142)
Yeah, I know. Just poking fun of their level of hype being such that they make it sound like you are one of a privileged few if they even take your call and allow you to buy this apparent masterpiece.
Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by broodbucket on Monday November 14, 2022 @05:57PM (#33602575)
The general rule of thumb is if the product page says "contact us" instead of a price, you can't afford it.

It is a shame though. IBM has no idea how to sell to anyone other that gigantic megacorps - which, fair enough, but they could probably pick up a lot of sales to medium-sized businesses if they weren't so old-fashioned about everything

Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by wmf on Monday November 14, 2022 @06:01PM (#33602630)
Medium-sized businesses can easily buy IBM stuff through VARs. (If your VAR does not recommend any IBM products, that's a different situation.) If you're smart enough to buy IT directly then you're probably also smart enough to realize that very few IBM products are good.
Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by artificialLimbs on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:57PM (#33604686)
Our IBM was the ONLY thing that didn't get vaporized when we got ransomwared. Tens of linux boxes, MS servers, 3rd party who knows what the f they are, all gone. Poof.
Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by Stranger43 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:49AM (#33606822)
To be honest you should not be buying this level of equipment "off the peg" without a serious pre-sales process of evaluation and sizing unless you have significant prior experience, and the people with that experience will already have some kind partner agreement in place.

It's much more like placing an order for an container full of severs based on an reference design from an OEM then going to HPE or Dell for a commodity x64 system.

Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by wmf on Monday November 14, 2022 @05:27PM (#33602210)
If you buy an IBM mainframe you'll have a very attentive full-time account manager for life. I did a ride-along with such an account manager once when I was working at IBM and it was eye-opening.
Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by christophilus on Monday November 14, 2022 @06:00PM (#33602619)
When the cloud was first really taking off, I had a friend who swore by his mainframes, touting high reliability, great performance, excellent customer service. It would be interesting to do a cost comparison.
Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by wmf on Monday November 14, 2022 @06:04PM (#33602655)
I'm going to channel the efficient market hypothesis (I apologize) here and say that people have done that cost comparison and not one of them bought mainframes. Heck, Google ported their entire monorepo to Power but not to z.
Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by hestefisk on Monday November 14, 2022 @06:21PM (#33602848)
Lots and lots of banks (and non banks) rely on IBM mainframe still and will for years to come. They have done this calculation on whether to replatform and migrate several times. It’s very hard to stand up a positive npv for such an idea unfortunately. I guess greenfield is very different.
Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by dillab2 on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:08PM (#33604388)
The thing is, there aren't really any successful greenfield developments in these types of business spaces. So either these are industries that are exceptionally difficult to break into (which I think is at least partially true), or the type of computing they do actually benefits from being done on a mainframe (which is also true given that there is a lot of record processing for these industries, and not too much serving lots of web requests to users).

Of course, all of these companies also have x86 servers that run the customer facing web apps and stuff. You really wouldn't want to waste your MSUs running web servers, although I'll admit I don't know if these new Linux mainframes are charged by rolling avg MSUs or other MSU metrics. Traditionally, Linux on Z has had more favorable pricing due to the ability to use IFLs and basically just declare that a cores MSU usage doesn't count towards your licensing since it's been locked to only running Linux.

Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by artificialLimbs on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:54PM (#33604664)
Or case 3: You still have ancient RPG code running that makes the business go $.
Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by StillBored on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:02PM (#33604722)
Yah, given my experience, you buy the mainframe for one of the native zos/etc flavors, and then the IBM sales people basically throw in the IFL's which will never get used for the zos/etc workloads effectively for such a nominal price, they might as well be free.

Then you have half a mainframe of capacity lying about, and why not run some linux workloads on it.

I find it _really_ hard to believe that outside of a few really narrow niches anyone is really buying mainframes to run linux workloads. Its just not cost effective.

PS: and then of course IBM gets to add it to their total "sold capacity" for the quarter to make it look like the business is growing. So they _want_ you to use all that idle hardware.

Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by zozbot234 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:44AM (#33608443)
> So either these are industries that are exceptionally difficult to break into

AIUI, Oxide Computer is targeting the "private cloud" space which is sort of adjacent to this stuff and could easily intrude on it. Of course they're based on AMD EPYC hardware, but the rest of the system is custom designed for ease of management and reliability.

Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by Stranger43 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:43AM (#33606792)
I havent heard of a successfull[1] greeenfield for an enterprise ERP system replacement, especially not one done using off the shelf technologies.

The thing that recent grads(weather engineering or business) tend to miss here is that for a lot of those organisation the central mainframe system and the organization's policies and culture is pretty entangled to the point where you cannot just replace either.

[1] on time, on budget and without leaving some aspects of the old system running under some sort of virtualization.

Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by bombcar on Monday November 14, 2022 @06:20PM (#33602829)
Mainframes can still be "cost effective" for, well, the type of companies that buy mainframes heh.

It's companies who don't treat ANY of their IT as anything but a "Someone else deal with this, oh, and never let it fail".

Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by yjftsjthsd-h on Monday November 14, 2022 @07:01PM (#33603249)
> Google ported their entire monorepo to Power

That's interesting; any chance you could give the background on that or point me to more information?

Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by wmf on Monday November 14, 2022 @07:19PM (#33603441)
Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by datameta on Monday November 14, 2022 @07:49PM (#33603673)
Power is performance, Z is maximum uptime (target is something like 3 seconds offline per year)
Re:IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumpt... by xenadu02 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @05:38AM (#33607566)
> I'm going to channel the efficient market hypothesis (I apologize) here and say that people have done that cost comparison and not one of them bought mainframes. Heck, Google ported their entire monorepo to Power but not to z.

Nah, there are a ton of businesses of all sizes across the world with many man-years of effort put into writing software that runs on various layers of the IBM stack from Cobol on up.

For one regional grocery store I know of they started in the 70s. Let's average 10 developers on staff churning out 4GL, Cobol, and whatever else since 1979. I hear it runs webservices now to serve the desktop and mobile client apps.

10 engineers * 43 years = 430 man-years put into a pile of software highly customized to exactly how they do business, from corporate & accounting to the warehouses to the ice cream factory to the industrial-scale bakery to the retail stores. Every single process at the company driven by mountains of custom software. The thing that knows more people buy Texas Toast at Store #473 so it prompts the manager to order extra and the bakery to put an extra Texas Toast run into the already tight schedule? Yeah that runs on the IBM mainframe... because that's where the cash register sales data goes and where the managers handle orders and where warehouse tickets are printed and where the bakery solves the traveling salesman problem to create schedules around quickly expiring products (did I mention the delivery truck schedules also run on the mainframe?).

If we assume it would "only" take 10% of the effort to replace, mythical man-month is not a problem, and you can handle dual-running the integrated systems for the decade it will take to perform the swap... you saved a year of your on-staff developer's salaries while putting every part of your business at risk of exploding (and ceasing all improvements to the existing stack lest you chase a moving target)... and you end up with something more or less equivalent except on commodity hardware.

$1m for IBM hardware? $5m? $10m? Pfffffffttttt... Chump change. Where do I sign the check? Sold and sold. Don't even bother sending a rep out.