This meme where if you prep at all, you must be worried about the zombie apocalypse is harmful. I do quite a bit of basic prep, but I am fully aware that in a total collapse situation it may not matter much.
I prepare because I have been in situations before where a buffer is helpful. I've been without power for 5 days before... and I live in a reasonably dense area, not the rural backwaters, a storm just hit me three different ways and there were repairs blocking the necessary repairs. I've been unable to get to the store for a couple of days. My furnace has gone out in the middle of winter. I've been in a "boil water" advisory. Who knows what else may happen? I don't prepare to live my life unchanged in these scenarios, but because I prepared I was not uncomfortable, and no social resources had to be expended to bail me out.
I particularly think every socially-aware person ought to have basic prep on hand for that last reason. Be ready to live in your own due to some disaster so that the people who really need the help can get it.
Having a couple of weeks of food,a few days of water, backup heating plans, and whatever else you need to survive for a couple of days is not paranoia. It's preparing for things that have happened all the time, and will continue to happen. Don't pass up on cheap, basic, pro-social readiness because you're worried someone will accuse you of being crazy and worrying about the Alien invasion. Be reasonably ready. Be reasonably resilient. Don't be totally dependent on a day-by-day basis on everything going perfectly that day.
That's all. This is cheap, easy, effective, and very likely to be helpful at some point.
but this is just to absorb small bump. and i think it technically is called an emergency plan, not prepping.
That stigma is a problem. People need to be prepared for both short-term emergencies and long-term disasters, and they need to stop being made to feel that doing so makes them social outcasts.
Frankly, by some definitions, I'm a prepper which is rather surprising. I think if you live rural you tend to have a lot more supplies on hand. I used to keep 3 full days, but I now have a 7 day supply, and friends feel fairly justified in have a year's worth of goods. Heck, some of the base prepper playbook are rural hobbies (micro-farming) or just basic winter prep (generator).
Now, solar and wind have gotten a lot more convenient with people doing battery walls. I get the feeling that those folks just got tired of listening to the power company say wait.
I find it highly unlikely that people in Europe don't plan for any events, especially given the current situation in that region. I would guess many have a month worth of food and some sort of plan is the heat goes out.
IMO, no way this scales down to a single household - I'm chuckling right now picturing a knight and their family in a house-sized castle.
Another angle: if things get bad even just food wise, people who have nothing to lose will keep coming - starving people who will die unless they get to your resources.
To me prepping to survive by yourself is a dumb fantasy and a waste of resources that would be much better spent building resilient communities.
And I agree that a community spending their time and resources working together is likely way more effective, but that doesn't mean the prepper's stockpile is easy pickings.
You just have to outlast them
Do you want to be killed by the 1st zombie or the 20th ?
Only way to survive is to delay death
You may be saying that whoever is coming for you has enough firepower and training to make your arms irrelevant. In which case your stockpile is just trade goods?
Who do you think has better odds? How about if B has friends who also want what A has? Don’t get me wrong defensive positions are useful, they are simply less useful than groups of people working together. The best prep is a few supplies and a community of people ready and able to support each other think walled town not fortified nuclear bunkers unless you’re actually willing to live underground and have a lifetime of supplies at which point hiding is more effective than guns.
There's probably an ideal minimum of ammo to go with the guns. But more ammo is better.
Not that post apocalyptic battles will involve artillery and tanks, but it is still informative.
The same applies in modern warzones, what works as a defensive position against a gun-armed mob doesn't necessarily work against infantry with military weapons including mortars and grenade launchers, and vice versa - if you know your opponents don't have proper equipment, you can effectively make deadly defensive positions which modern militaries wouldn't be able to use against their opponents.
As to a gun armed mob, it really depends on how capable they are. A defensive position is of limited value vs a well trained sniper using even a simple hunting rifle. The basic issue is it’s difficult to actually defend yourself without also exposing yourself. This is further degraded when talking about a single defender who can’t benefit from overlapping fields of fire etc.
Our hypothetical survivalist would benefit from training, but they don’t receive the primary benefit that keeps modern military casualties low, access to trained and well supplied medical personnel.
A counter attack similarly isn't assaulting a prepared position.
Otherwise this is an ignorant view. Attackers can have advantages because of initiative. They can pick their place, time, and methods, find the weakest point, etc.
They can also choose to not attack at all. Which they do all the time. The number a times attackers have been repelled and destroyed despite possessing the initiative is innumerable.
Assaulting a prepared defensive position in it's strength is widely acknowledged to be a really stupid idea and you don't do it unless your other options are worse.
Defensive structures offset but don’t eliminate the advantage of initiative, especially when you start talking about a lone defender who needs to sleep etc.
Your conclusion about defense being essentially useless is still dead wrong.
Once the first few home invasions, rapings, and pillagings of sleeping residences have occurred. Word will spread. The would be invaders will encounter a round the clock watch setup by a neighborhood or family that invited all their cousins and can afford a 24/7 watch with dogs and even home made alarms.
And those attackers will have the fight of their lives on their hands. Once their surprise element is gone, they lose the initiative to things they can't anticipate without serious new intelligence and all advantage is now reversed and you enter the counter attacking and ambush scenarios which you pointed out is very effective.
That’s not my conclusion, it’s that defense roughly counters the otherwise overwhelming advantage of attackers.
> round the clock watch watch setup by a neighborhood
That’s assuming a great deal of cohesion in your post apocalyptic scenario. I have no problem saying large communities provide a significant defensive benefit, but that’s a product of a working society.
How many effective defensive fortifications can you name that ran intentionally without any arms because they are of "little use"?
There's actually already a story of one (insane) prepper type infiltrating a Kentucky state representative's bunker to take it for himself (and killing a person in the process).
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/21/us/kentucky-bunker-civil-...
Though obviously advertising that you have a high-end survival bunker is probably breaking rule one of survival bunkers.
And I don't mean a fancy security system. I mean a paranoid prepper with a basement full of canned food and a stocked gun case. The kind of person who is itching to live through a zombie apocalypse, and would eagerly start shooting at people that even vaguely suspected were coming for their stockpile. Their guns are a deterrent to taking their food. That's it.
so guns work to prevent simple attempts, in the early stages. when you are in the anything goes stage you need a community and a way to be protected and protect others.
I'm not sure if you're just using prepper in a derogatory way, or general way. If people aren't practicing some self reliance before an event happens, then it's unlikely they can contribute to the group survival.
My point is that past a certain point having some sort of community (other people that have prepped somehow) is key
We all die in the end - isn’t a delay of then inevitable all we do everyday ?
Taking by force, stealing from others, is a great way to dramatically shorten your life expectancy.
Live by the sword, die by the sword.
Yup.
My then teenage son was obsessed with the zombie apocalypse and therefore prepping. I tried to convince him that being handy and not being an asshole were the two best survival skills he should focus on.
At least he's handy. Maybe that'll be enough.
https://boingboing.net/2015/12/21/a-survivalist-on-why-you-s... (Cory Doctorow: A survivalist on why you shouldn't bug out)
https://boingboing.net/2008/07/13/postapocalypse-witho.html (Cory Doctorow: Post-apocalypse without the militias: The Outquisition)
Everything on this planet is a transitory situation. A buffer will always make situations easier to navigate.
Case in point: having a social or monetary safety net is a buffer against e.g. unemployment.
> I don't care how much food and guns you have stockpiled if I can just take them away from you when I need them.
You need to have at least your own guns in order to take away resources from people with guns. Ideally though you would just have skills that are valued, so you can trade resources for skills and not shoot each other. People (grown men of sound mind, especially) tend to go to far lengths to avoid violence, especially if they've been exposed to it in the past.
I get the meta point but people are just not wired this way.
But all that aside, the issue is, nobody is quite sure what exact scenario they're prepping for. Simply having a buffer so you can avoid needing to panic while some direction is felt out is worth having, but the limitations of it are worth being aware of as well.
If we are going full steam ahead towards the collapse of civilization your prepping just delays the inevitable.
Also, if shift hits the fan, communities that are able to band together and work together will more likely do way better.
I don't care how much food and guns you have stockpiled if I can just take them away from you when I need them. If things are dire other will come for your stockpile.