News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by googlryas on Saturday November 05, 2022 @01:59PM (#33483902)
Better than nothing, but the level that plants "clean the air" is entirely negligible. Every time you open the door, enough air enters your house where you would need to dedicate an entire room of plants for multiple days to clean that air.

Just get a filter that can filter VOCs if you have that kind of concern. And then add plants as you wish to make you happy.

Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by zug_zug on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:17PM (#33484098)
What do you mean? The air outside your house is almost certainly much lower in VOCs than inside.
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by googlryas on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:24PM (#33484170)
Really depends where you live, but I suspect for most of the globe that is true(though not necessarily for most of the population).

In that case, just open the windows! Or use a heat exchanger if the temp isn't reasonable outside.

But, I was imagining a house sealed up with perfectly clean air and then "dirty" outside air getting in

Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by hinkley on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:40PM (#33484334)
If you live somewhere that doesn’t, the better investment is in relocating, or public pressure to fix the problem.
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by D13Fd on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:28PM (#33484213)
What do you mean? The outside air is also typically an unwanted temperature (although heat exchangers can mitigate that) and may contain allergens or particulates from smoke or exhaust.
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by dinvlad on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:03PM (#33483962)
I wonder how that compares just to some baggies with activated carbon.
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by jrockway on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:07PM (#33483988)
Get a fan and a furnace filter and you have a top-of-the-line air purifier.
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by googlryas on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:27PM (#33484202)
Not exactly. As I understand it furnace filters will just filter out particulate matter which is measured on the order of micron. It doesn't really do much for VOCs, which are measured on the order of picometers(0.2 microns = 200,000 picometers).

You need another filter like activated charcoal which works differently than particulate filters (adsorption vs merely trapping particles in a winding path)

Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by jrockway on Saturday November 05, 2022 @06:21PM (#33486520)
The comment I'm replying to says "I wonder how a bag of charcoal would do". I assume you'd add that to my list of components.
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by Dylan16807 on Saturday November 05, 2022 @06:48PM (#33486755)
VOCs are nanometer scale. A rough estimate for atomic bond length in organic compounds is .15 nanometers. CO2, which should be smaller than basically any VOC, is half a nanometer across.
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by silisili on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:14PM (#33484071)
They are generally cheap enough now that it's probably not worth the effort. I think my last 2 cost 35 a piece, and came with extra filters and such.

I used to think they were kinda useless until I had tile ripped up. The neverending dust was driving my wife insane. On a whim, bought a couple purifiers and it's cut the dust down by at least 90%.

Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by thecoppinger on Saturday November 05, 2022 @04:34PM (#33485369)
Any chance you could provide a link to an example product? Air purifiers seem pretty expensive, but I expect that might be due to my location
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by silisili on Saturday November 05, 2022 @05:07PM (#33485758)
I bought these for 34.99 last month, but it appears to be gone now.

https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B01N4IRIWK

If you're looking for more features and a more known brand, Costco has these for 99, which is a pretty good deal considering their size and that they come with all extra filters.

https://www.costco.com/winix-true-hepa-4-stage-air-purifier-...

Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by thecoppinger on Sunday November 06, 2022 @12:09AM (#33488869)
Perfect, thank you very much.
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by panarky on Sunday November 06, 2022 @12:18AM (#33488934)
Rule of thumb: cut the quoted theoretical capacity in half. This one's theoretical capacity is 360 square feet, so you'd need eight of them in a 1500 square foot apartment.
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by silisili on Sunday November 06, 2022 @01:44AM (#33489900)
Never heard of it. Perhaps for its Hepa, 99.9% jargon sure.

But we ran a single Bissel Air400 in a 2k sq ft area and it visibly reduced the dust you see on glass cabinets and such. We used to have to clean them about every 3 days. With that running, it was about every 2 to 3 weeks!

Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by MengerSponge on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:21PM (#33484142)
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by Sunspark on Saturday November 05, 2022 @10:33PM (#33488267)
I used MERV 11 and still got tons of dust everywhere, and the ductwork is also musty smelling in the spring and fall.. prefer summer and winter because it's not as noticeable then.
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by dylan604 on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:54PM (#33484461)
Ever been in a place where you have a room totally barren of plants, and then able to walk into a room with plants? Which room do you feel better in? Whether it is the air cleaning or not, rooms with plants just feel so much better to me than the sterile feeling of no plants.
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by googlryas on Saturday November 05, 2022 @03:17PM (#33484669)
Sure, that's why I finished my post with "And then add plants as you wish to make you happy."
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by Thiez on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:58PM (#33484496)
You don't need an engineered superplant for that feeling, though.
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by schainks on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:57PM (#33484485)
It only takes three shoulder height plants (of a couple widely-available species) to recycle the CO2 produced by an adult human.

Relevant talk: https://www.ted.com/talks/kamal_meattle_how_to_grow_fresh_ai...

Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by googlryas on Saturday November 05, 2022 @03:02PM (#33484544)
Sure but this is about VOCs, not CO2, though lowering CO2 levels indoors certainly isn't a bad thing, especially if you're in a small room without ventilation.
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by gus_massa on Saturday November 05, 2022 @04:35PM (#33485386)
The numbers don't check out. It looks like he is using a weird definition of recycle the CO2 produced by an adult human.

A normal person need about 2000 kcalories per day. That's approximately 500g (1/2 kg) (1 pound) of sugar. Eating only sugar is bad, but most carbohydrates and proteins have a similar kcalories to weight ratio.

If the plant absorbs all the CO2 produced by the person, it must rebuild all that sugar back (and store it as cellulose, or starch or even proteins, but again all have a very similar similar kcalories to weight ratio.) So the plant must grow approximately 500g (1/2 kg) (1 pound) per day.

That is like 15kg (30 pounds) per month, that is a weigh of a small child. Or like 150kg (300 pounds) per year that is the weight of one or two adults. Plant's don't grow so much. (Nota that you can reduce the weight to one half is the plant only makes oil instead of as cellulose, or starch or even proteins, but it still too high.)

Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by lazide on Saturday November 05, 2022 @05:24PM (#33485967)
Don’t forget that the plant would also need to receive enough insolation to do this AFTER inefficiencies in photosynthesis. As photosynthesis is only 11% efficient, and conversion to sugars is going to be only a partial fraction of that due to needs of the plants to support their own health and growth, we’re talking a VERY large amount of insolation. A completely impractical amount to have indoors, frankly.

2000 kcal == 2.3kwh.

If we assume the plant manages to put half of it’s total photosynthesis output into sugar (very generous), and hits maximum theoretical photosynthetic rates, 5.5% of sunlight would be converted.

A peak sun hour is 1kw per square meter. 5.5% of that is 50 watts.

You’d need 46 square meters of peak sun for an hour to produce 2.3kwh worth of output, even assuming a lot of ideal output efficiencies.

So yeah, total bullshit.

Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by colechristensen on Saturday November 05, 2022 @05:13PM (#33485840)
This is not even remotely true.

Carbon in, carbon out. In order for plants to balance that equation they have to grow about a pound of dry mass per day. There’s a reason the space station doesn’t just have a few plants up there instead of an advanced system to scrub and recycle air.

Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by alar44 on Saturday November 05, 2022 @06:01PM (#33486339)
Not even close. A human produces 2.5 lbs of CO2 per day. A full grown tree absorbs 50 lbs per year.
Re:Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular... by Patrick-T on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @11:31AM (#33520861)
Hey googlryas, Patrick from Neoplants here. Indeed, normal plants are too ineffective to remediate indoor air pollution. Which is why we are bioengineering them for this purpose! Unfortunately, according to government agencies like the EPA, there are no VOC purifying technologies that are effective and have no harmful by-products. If you want to deep dive, they published a technical report on these different technologies, their strenghts and drawbacks https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2018-07/documents/re...

We made a quick summary of keys insights of this report in the intro of our white paper https://bit.ly/3hjMqsB