News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by colesantiago on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:10PM (#33398746)
But we all know this hypothetical isn't the case. Centralisation is more convenient in almost ALL cases, even in email (nobody except people on HN host their own email)
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by shafyy on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:41PM (#33399048)
Decentralization doesn't mean hosting your own instance. It's about open protocols. There are hundreds or thousands of email providers that you can use and still send an email to a Gmail user without hosting your own instance.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by colesantiago on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:58PM (#33399243)
Yet gmail is the biggest and email isn't a social network, choice is the problem.

People cannot find their friends on Mastodon because:

+ They can't search all instances across Mastodon.

+ There is almost little to no one on Mastodon to talk to.

So they just go back to a centralised service like Twitter and they definitely not use email as a social network.

Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by kixiQu on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:06PM (#33400442)
> + There is almost little to no one on Mastodon to talk to.

I have found that this is an accurate description of the first impression one gets; this is not true, but we're all so used to recommendation algorithms easing discovery that the impression is equivalent.

Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by supportlocal4h on Sunday October 30, 2022 @09:29PM (#33400995)
What kind of friend do you have that you can't just say, "Hey, what's your handle?"?
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by colesantiago on Sunday October 30, 2022 @10:00PM (#33401212)
The one that can't be bothered to say "Hey what's your Mastodon handle" to like 500+ of my friend group on Twitter where is the main Mastodon instance is closed.

Twitter is just fine and everyone knows it.

Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by ttepasse on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:38PM (#33399014)
That hypothetical was the case: back in 2007/2008 people of the blogosphere slowly stopped blogging and started tweeting. And if you had a good but suddenly more empty feedreader you’d then had to follow the great migration and re-find those people on Twitter.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by colesantiago on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:51PM (#33399166)
this means that centralisation works better?
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by Kye on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:26PM (#33399588)
It did for a time, but people realized the major flaw starting in the 2010s when Twitter started becoming the mess it is today: once you're in, you're in, no matter how bad the platform gets. You could take your OPML and leave if you didn't like your feed reader. There's no equivalent way to migrate your follows on Twitter. There was until they turned off RSS feeds. Now you'd need a feed reader that specifically handles the moving target of Twitter's API or web interface, and that always costs extra.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by soundnote on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:00PM (#33400397)
It depends on the thing at hand. Some things have value because others use them. Chat apps tend towards monopolies because of this.

Email's just so damned old everyone uses the standard and it kind of dodges the issue.

Email's also structurally a bit different - it's a set of one-way sends to select recipients, with chats you moreso go to a place and read the place's signboard.

You could in principle just use mailing lists under the hood instead if the UI wasn't garbage.

Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by mahathu on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:34PM (#33400635)
This whole comment chain has been an interesting discussion for me, I just checked out of curiosity: Blogspot vs Twitter popularity on google trends 2004-today

https://trends.google.de/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=bl...

Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by Zak on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:27PM (#33398909)
People do, however use multiple email providers, sometimes small ones like the small business they work for or their local/regional ISP. If federated social sharing becomes popular, the story will likely be similar: a few big providers have most of the users, but a limited ability to dictate how the system works.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by nerdponx on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:16PM (#33398807)
It proves the value of centralized search and discovery, but it says nothing about centralized hosting in moderation. There is probably quite a bit of value in a system where decentralized instances can volunteer to submit their own discovery database to a central search platform, and where individual users could opt in to being part of that database.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by nopenopenopeno on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:35PM (#33398994)
This is commonplace for decentralized protocols. Torrents are probably the most obvious example.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by etchalon on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:18PM (#33398818)
Email remains decentralized.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by colesantiago on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:00PM (#33399269)
Doesn't matter when we are talking about Mastodon.

People don't use email as social network or instant form of social communication.

Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by SantalBlush on Sunday October 30, 2022 @10:48PM (#33401523)
I may be mistaken, but it looks like you brought up email in the first place.

>Centralisation is more convenient in almost ALL cases, even in email (nobody except people on HN host their own email)

Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by colesantiago on Monday October 31, 2022 @04:22AM (#33403225)
Okay? My point still stands and users don't want to host their own email or Mastodon instance and prefer centralised solutions when it comes to a social networking.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by p1necone on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:46PM (#33399094)
Email is decentralized. It's mature enough that there's a bunch of trusted providers out there and you can use it without caring about the technical details, it's basically a perfect example of a successful mature decentralized service.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by colesantiago on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:50PM (#33399153)
many people don't care that it is decentralised, hence gmail, an open protocol is irrelevant. In mastodon's case decentralisation is a hindrance since they want centralisation back.

email isn't a social network and lots people outside of HN don't self host them as such.

Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by kortilla on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:58PM (#33399240)
I think you’re quite confused about email users. Very few of the companies I worked for outside of startups used google for email hosting.

Business email is very dependent on the fact that it’s an open protocol.

Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by p1necone on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:00PM (#33399271)
Likewise, gmail would be totally useless if it was actually centralized and you couldn't email non gmail users.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by wrycoder on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:04PM (#33399306)
But they can’t necessarily email you, given Google’s procedures regarding “spam”, i.e. anything from a small email server.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by doctor_eval on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:59PM (#33399924)
This is true. My last company used fastmail, but one guy insisted on using Gmail. Sometimes fastmail didn’t arrive at Gmail. We (tech team) said, this is a problem with gmail. C-suite said this is a problem with fastmail.

And so the word comes down, we have to move to Gmail. It’s believable decision making, but that’s how it works.

Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by ajford on Sunday October 30, 2022 @09:43PM (#33401079)
Though that's basically Google (and other large hosts) breaking the decentralized nature of email in their "effort" to combat spam.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by ViViDboarder on Monday October 31, 2022 @12:05AM (#33401930)
Google isn’t as bad as Microsoft or AT&T in my experience. My personal server now is working fine with those now too.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by account42 on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @08:42AM (#33434782)
Yeah, that's my experience too. Google doesn't like new domains, but at least accepts mail and delivers to spam (or to the inbox once the domain is old enough). Microsoft just refuses all mail if you host on a VPS whenever someone else on the block (NOT the same IP) misbehaves (or is accused of misbehaving, not sure).
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by shapefrog on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:51AM (#33403070)
Yet my bank(s), linkedin, netflix, microsoft and a bunch of mailers all had message arrive in my inbox this morning.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by anigbrowl on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:22PM (#33399538)
Companies like hosting their own email. Users don't because because they don't have an IT department whose job it is to filter spam etc.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by devman0 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:28PM (#33400148)
I'd argue the trend is that most companies don't. They host it with a custom domain on Google Workspace or M365.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by sbarre on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:24PM (#33400563)
I work for a 100-year-old company with 30k employees. Last year we moved from self-hosted Exchange to GSuite, because it's just easier to spend money on that than to spend money on an increasingly complex and hard-to-staff-properly internal service.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by scarface74 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:40PM (#33400683)
The issue is not self hosted versus GSuite. It rarely makes sense for any company to self host their own email. I think the parent poster was saying few use Gmail versus hosted outlook
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by themadturk on Sunday October 30, 2022 @10:41PM (#33401478)
My 40 year old company with about 12k users switched from self-hosted Exchange to Azure-hosted Office 365. I'm assuming part of the reason for this is to ease complexity, and it's working quite well for us.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by teawrecks on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:57PM (#33400369)
Gmail isn't a protocol, nor is it open.

People don't self host email because 1) the protocol doesn't make it easy to deal with incoming spam on a small scale, and 2) giants like gmail tend to automatically flag unique email domains as suspicious. Which is a valid criticism of the federated model, or rather the people using it.

If more people found value in decentralization, in theory they would also be more critical of their node management, opting to reject anti-competitive behavior in a democratic way. Unfortunately, for democracy to work, citizens have to be educated and fight for it. If they don't, it's easy to have centralized, ostensibly totalitarian walled gardens.

We just need to make sure fediverse accounts are easily transferable between nodes in a standardized way, something I don't think mastodon does well, and email doesn't do at all.

Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by lupire on Monday October 31, 2022 @12:19AM (#33402011)
Gmail is especially bad because they'll spamblock your domain for no reason, but Google customers are allowed to violate ToS and spam everyone.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by EarlKing on Monday October 31, 2022 @05:32AM (#33403592)
Email isn't truly decentralized anymore. Think I'm kidding? OK, try this: Try sending something to Gmail. Roll 3d6 and consult the oracle bones to see whether or not it magically gets caught up in the spam filters for no discernable reason.

Seriously: Transforming spam filtering into a black box service has decommoditized email and everyone knows it.

Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by kodah on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:09PM (#33400023)
I would call the GMail situation pseudo-centralization. As it has more actual competitors who aren't just hosting but also actively developing their own platform it'd go back to decentralization.
Re:Twitodon: Finding Twitter Peers on Mastodon by jupp0r on Sunday October 30, 2022 @11:54PM (#33401870)
Of course people use a variety of email providers, what are you talking about?