News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by rekabis on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:22PM (#33359924)
> In other words, you are literally nobody until you are vaccinated.

Considering the vital importance of herd immunity, the cost savings inherent in being overall healthier, and the reduced chance that an unvaccinated person becomes a Petri dish for evolving new and deadlier strains, I am all for this.

If you hate your community and everyone in it so much that you want to hurt and possibly even kill them with the pathogens you carry, maybe you should find a different community to be in.

A vaccination card could very well be the entrance fee to a kinder and healthier community where people actually care about each other, and want to keep everyone else safe and alive. That, to me, is a massive bonus that vastly outstrips any possible downsides.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by swader999 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:27PM (#33360025)
You can't get herd immunity from vaccination with a virus like corona. This was known from the beginning. It mutates too fast. You end up training your immune system for an extinct variant and it responds poorly when presented with the latest variant. Herd immunity works great for measles and polio, the binding mechanism really doesn't survive mutations well for these virus.

And ethically, you are proposing these walled societies where children risk their health with poorly tested treatments to save the older generation? I find that abhorrent.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by Bellamy on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:55PM (#33360492)
Where we're you when all the experts and politicians were talking (some still are) about herd immunity in beating corona?
Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by swader999 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @02:52PM (#33362228)
Censored lol.
Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by rekabis on Thursday October 27, 2022 @01:32PM (#33361026)
> You can't get herd immunity from vaccination with a virus like corona. This was known from the beginning. It mutates too fast.

There was a three or four month window, right when the vaccines were first released, when a 95+% implementation of the initial vaccine shot could have produced a reasonably close facsimile of herd immunity, such that it would have made it several orders more difficult for the virus to effectively mutate. It could have conceivably cut the subsequent death toll in half, if not more.

Unfortunately, politics and antivaxx disinformation got in the way of that. And people continued to die in droves due to selfishness and lies.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by ISL on Thursday October 27, 2022 @01:49PM (#33361297)
Agreed, though it would have been necessary to deploy the vaccines globally, especially in the least-wealthy parts of the world.

In the case of Omicron, there's a good chance that the vaccines would have needed to reach a community in Botswana ahead of the initiation of the chronic infection that may have produced BA.1, BA.2, etc.

First-world extensive deployments would have killed off the first-world propagation of variants through Delta in short order, but everything changed with Omicron.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by swader999 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @02:51PM (#33362217)
No, you couldn't have physically deployed it faster than it mutates. Need at least six months and like you say, only had 3-4.
Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by tlb on Thursday October 27, 2022 @03:58PM (#33363170)
What physical limit do you mean? There are lots of things that are deployed by the billions on short time scales. Seasonal foods or fresh flowers are an example of how feasible it can be to deliver billions of Xs around the world in weeks.
Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by swader999 on Friday October 28, 2022 @05:40AM (#33369416)
Math. You need to jab it into every other arm in the planet in less than four months.
Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by muaytimbo on Thursday October 27, 2022 @04:00PM (#33363200)
You are making numerous claims throughout this thread without a single citation.

Where can I find a study that supports this: "There was a three or four month window, right when the vaccines were first released, when a 95+% implementation of the initial vaccine shot could have produced a reasonably close facsimile of herd immunity, such that it would have made it several orders more difficult for the virus to effectively mutate. It could have conceivably cut the subsequent death toll in half, if not more.

Unfortunately, politics and antivaxx disinformation got in the way of that. And people continued to die in droves due to selfishness and lies."

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by swader999 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @05:07PM (#33364067)
Simply remember what happened. No citation needed.
Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by muaytimbo on Thursday October 27, 2022 @05:20PM (#33364212)
lolol, "There was a three or four month window, right when the vaccines were first released, when a 95+% implementation of the initial vaccine shot could have produced a reasonably close facsimile of herd immunity, such that it would have made it several orders more difficult for the virus to effectively mutate. It could have conceivably cut the subsequent death toll in half, if not more."

This is a statement that has many claims: 1. 95% implementation (whatever that means) in a specified time window of initial vaccine could've produced herd immunity 2. This herd immunity would've made it "several orders of more difficult" for the virus to mutate 3 The estimate of a 50% reduction in death toll.

I certainly can't remember something that didn't happen, herd immunity that *would've made mutation more difficult" or a "50% reduction" that didn't happen.

Your memory must be better than mine, it remembers statistics and estimates from counterfactual events.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by pessimizer on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:50PM (#33360405)
> A vaccination card could very well be the entrance fee to a kinder and healthier community where people actually care about each other,

A vaccination-connected universal ID card will cause people to care about each other and to want to keep each other safe? This is a very strange thought process.

Do steel bars make people want to stay in jail in order to protect the community? Are they the entrance fee to creating a loving population of inmates?

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by rekabis on Thursday October 27, 2022 @01:16PM (#33360823)
Wow, the mental acrobatics you’re twisting yourself through in order to come up with this ridiculous premise. You should apply to Cirque du Soleil.

However, in case you genuinely need the crayons and construction paper to understand my point: vaccine cards will push out those people so pathologically selfish that they care only for themselves and would gleefully see others die rather than accept a trivial imposition, in the same way that prisons remove from the population those people who are too violent to safely exist within society.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by samatman on Thursday October 27, 2022 @05:12PM (#33364115)
You are making a case for your own poor mental health, and nothing else.
Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by dang on Saturday October 29, 2022 @02:47AM (#33381631)
Please don't respond to a bad comment by breaking the site guidelines yourself. That only makes everything worse.

We've had to ask you many times to stop breaking the site guidelines. We're going to have to ban you if you keep doing this, so please stop doing this.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by dang on Saturday October 29, 2022 @02:46AM (#33381629)
You broke the site guidelines extremely badly in this thread by starting and perpetuating a flamewar. We ban accounts that do that. Please don't do it again, and please don't post unsubstantive and/or flamewar comments generally.

Other users broke the site guidelines in this thread too, but your account was by far the primary offender.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by realce on Thursday October 27, 2022 @01:19PM (#33360850)
> community where people actually care about each other

Sounds like a community of absolute arrogance and security theater disconnected from the realities of natural life.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by rekabis on Thursday October 27, 2022 @03:39PM (#33362921)
>Sounds like a community of absolute arrogance and security theater disconnected from the realities of natural life.

Sounds like a lot of communities around the world, like Japan, where people proactively mask up with even the slightest tickle in the throat in order to avoid passing whatever they’ve caught onto anyone else.

Community-first attitudes are a hallmark of societal stability over the long term, as people think of the community first, and themselves second. Everyone benefits because the community is put ahead of selfishness and solipsism.

Pathologically individualistic “me, me, me” attitudes lead to a very superficial community that cannot effectively meet threats to its health and survival. Everyone reaches for “why should I make the sacrifice when I don’t immediately benefit?”, which means no-one will make the sacrifice move.

I find it very ironic that the military holds so many of the second group, when its ethos teaches the first. In a military unit, your first instinct is to jump on top of that grenade so that you protect your teammates at the cost of your own life. You put the team first, so that the team can survive with or without you. This only works if every single member of the team conforms to that same ideal. Yet the amount of antivax in the military - which is no different than refusing to protect your teammates because jumping on top of that grenade would hurt your own “personal freedoms” - is surprisingly prevalent.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by Dracophoenix on Friday October 28, 2022 @03:41AM (#33368682)
> Community-first attitudes are a hallmark of societal stability over the long term, as people think of the community first, and themselves second. Everyone benefits because the community is put ahead of selfishness and solipsism.

Saudi Arabia is also a societally stable country with community-first attitudes. That doesn't mean it's a desirable place to live for every community. All communities rely on exclusion as much as they rely on inclusion. As a result, they have no concern for individual rights. Communities are more prone to solipsistic bandwagons than individuals (i.e. madness of the crowds) and with more drastic consequences (e.g. internment, torture, genocide). Stability at the expense of personal liberty should not be sanctified at all whether by numbers or cultural fiat.

> Pathologically individualistic “me, me, me” attitudes lead to a very superficial community that cannot effectively meet threats to its health and survival. Everyone reaches for “why should I make the sacrifice when I don’t immediately benefit?”, which means no-one will make the sacrifice move.

It's not pathology. It's a question of integrity. Why should I be held to or punished for a standard that is contradictory to my values? While I agree health and survival are should be considerations on an individual level, I don't agree that the purpose of my health and survival is for society. If that were case I'd have no right no risk my health in the pursuit of liberty or exercise the ability to end my life as I fit.

> I find it very ironic that the military holds so many of the second group, when its ethos teaches the first. In a military unit, your first instinct is to jump on top of that grenade so that you protect your teammates at the cost of your own life. You put the team first, so that the team can survive with or without you. This only works if every single member of the team conforms to that same ideal. Yet the amount of antivax in the military - which is no different than refusing to protect your teammates because jumping on top of that grenade would hurt your own “personal freedoms” - is surprisingly prevalent

The military is a (mostly) volunteer army. Joining the military is an exercise of choice to rather than one of forced conscription. The military doesn't (at least officially) doesn't exist as the private gang of a monarch or warlord as many armies in 18th century Europe did. While there are different legal systems and cultural expectations for members of the army than there are for private citizens, every member is inculcated with understanding that they are protecting the Land of Free with all it's warts not the of Land of the Chosen or Land of the Societally Acceptable.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by goatcode on Thursday October 27, 2022 @02:14PM (#33361643)
If you have a sensible set of statistics that you believe justify surrender of personal sovereignty of identity to this degree, I would invite you to ponder a set of statistics that you would think completely monstrous, but still arguable, toward such a surrender. There is someone out there who believes the opposite to you, and if you think the creation of a power that benefits your opinions should take place, know that it could be used by this hypothetical person to benefit his opinions.

If you're ok with all that, then you have a justifiable position. If not, then you do not.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by rekabis on Thursday October 27, 2022 @02:23PM (#33361779)
> If you have a sensible set of statistics that you believe justify surrender of personal sovereignty of identity to this degree, I would invite you to ponder a set of statistics that you would think completely monstrous, but still arguable, toward such a surrender. There is someone out there who believes the opposite to you, and if you think the creation of a power that benefits your opinions should take place, know that it could be used by this hypothetical person to benefit his opinions.

Your “personal sovereignty” argument is equally applicable to a sociopath who wants to maim and kill at will.

Because that’s what Plague Rats are: sociopaths that care only for their own “rights”, and are more than eager to let everyone around them die in order to avoid a trivial imposition that would significantly improve safety.

If you want to be a part of a community, you also have an obligation TO that community, to keep it safe from any pathogens you risk transmitting.

If you cannot do your duty of care to that community, find a different community to be in, then. Because you have demonstrated you don’t give a single shite about anyone but yourself.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by brnaftr361 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @02:53PM (#33362241)
You're assuming there are only communities who want paternalistic interference.

That is not the case.

You seem like you're possessed by the delusion of objectivity. There is no such thing.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by goatcode on Thursday October 27, 2022 @04:44PM (#33363775)
>There is no such thing.

Effectively, that is true; and the closer you get to absolute objectivity, the scarier it becomes to the average person (which was the crux of my point, so I appreciate your pointing out what you did). Fitting that the dude would have mentioned psychopaths, in that light.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by goatcode on Thursday October 27, 2022 @04:41PM (#33363741)
>Your “personal sovereignty” argument

What is this you're talking about? I talked about personal sovereignty OF IDENTITY. If you're going to strawman, at least strawman based on a correct reading of your target's point.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by cr4nberry on Thursday October 27, 2022 @02:31PM (#33361899)
> If you hate your community and everyone in it so much that you want to hurt and possibly even kill them with the pathogens you carry, maybe you should find a different community to be in.

Interesting how you default to thinking about this as a binary: it's either you love your community or hate and want to kill your community. There's no indication of any sort of nuance, no indication of acknowledging that maybe there are other people in your community who might feel differently. And even if they did, their feelings are irrelevant because you're already dead set on insisting that you "know what's best for them"

If you hate your community so much that you'd insist on shoving your own beliefs down everyone else's throat and demonizing anyone who disagrees as killing the community, maybe you should find a different community to be in?

[dead]
[dead]
Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by dang on Saturday October 29, 2022 @02:47AM (#33381637)
Please don't respond to a bad comment by breaking the site guidelines yourself. That only makes everything worse.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by dang on Saturday October 29, 2022 @02:48AM (#33381641)
You can't post like this here, regardless of how right you are or feel you are. We ban accounts that do it. Please don't do it, or anything remotely like it, on HN again.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by Eleison23 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @02:44PM (#33362102)
Yeah, I get it, even my bishops have said that vaccination is an act of mercy.

But how many acts of mercy do we owe our brothers and sisters?

Five? A dozen? Per year? Per month?

It was inevitable that the COVID-19 vaccines should require a followup and a booster and there were variants that mutated and then we just had a neverending cycle of vaccine opportunities.

In the '60s when polio was a spectre, it just began to be civic duty to get your round of shots. You got the polio and you got the pertussis and you got x y and z. Then people were taking in their babies so they could load up on vaccines before they were even threatened and then stuff was eradicated.

But what's the endgame for that? How many is enough? Who's gonna recommend fewer vaccines? Not the manufacturers. Not the pharmacies or physicians. Are insurance companies gonna put a rate limiter on vaccines? I don't know. It's hard to tell what is truly Medically Necessary and what is just putting on a show.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by rekabis on Thursday October 27, 2022 @03:02PM (#33362395)
>Yeah, I get it, even my bishops have said that vaccination is an act of mercy. > >But how many acts of mercy do we owe our brothers and sisters? > >Five? A dozen? Per year? Per month?

Except all it is, is a little prick in the arm. Quite literally. Nothing more than that. Unless you are lucky, at which point your arm gets sore, and you have a bit of a temperature and feel under the weather for a day or so, which is evidence that the vaccine is producing an extra-robust immune response from your body, ensuring you are getting the full benefit of the vaccine.

Would I take it monthly, if a formulation was designed for that purpose? Yeah, I would. Why? Because I’m not a sociopath. I CARE about the people in my community. I don’t want to be that Typhoid Mary that causes ANY deaths at all, much less a superspreader event that kills multiple people.

>It was inevitable that the COVID-19 vaccines should require a followup and a booster and there were variants that mutated and then we just had a neverending cycle of vaccine opportunities.

The precedent has already been there for decades. The point being, people who are at risk (the elderly) and those who take care of at-risk people are ALREADY taking yearly shots for the flu. Why? BECAUSE IT WORKS at strongly limiting transmission. They themselves get much less likely to be hit with the current strain, and even if they do get hit, it ends up being less severe and less transmissible. These people protect themselves and those vulnerable people around them by getting the yearly flu booster shots.

>But what's the endgame for that? How many is enough?

Now that - thanks to politics and anti-vaxx paranoia - we have missed the opportunity for broadly-similar herd immunity (there was only a tiny 3-4 month window when the vaccines first came out), it will never end. COVID has gone endemic because we couldn’t vaccinate quickly enough, and completely enough. We can place that outcome squarely at the feet of the anti-vaxxers who refused to get vaccinated, and the politics that made roll-out issues and vaccine wastage such a big problem.

>Who's gonna recommend fewer vaccines? Not the manufacturers. Not the pharmacies

They have no input into the process, nor should they.

>physicians.

If these are the same people who collect and publish data on in-the-wild vaccine effectiveness, then yes. They CAN be the people who show when enough is enough. And all that information is collected and collated through orgs like America’s Center for Disease Control, who then provide that data to people like immunologist (this being his career specialty) Dr. Fauci, who can then craft public policy that aligns with whatever real-world peer-reviewed data they have on hand.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by h4n1 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @06:27PM (#33364839)
"all it is, is a little prick in the arm. Quite literally. Nothing more than that."

Alright then, I'll just poke myself with a sewing needle and you can count that as a vaccination, if that's quite literally all it is.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by graphe on Thursday October 27, 2022 @03:02PM (#33362392)
By this narrow definition, we should be happy to contribute to welfare, but never to accept it. Pretty useful for an authoritarian.

If you hate your community and everyone in it so much that you want to hurt and possibly even kill them with the guns you carry, maybe you should find a different community to be in.

If you hate your community and everyone in it so much that you want to hurt and possibly even kill them with the knife you carry, maybe you should find a different community to be in.

If you hate your community and everyone in it so much that you want to hurt and possibly even kill them with the sharps you carry, maybe you should find a different community to be in.

Now all the citizens are submissive, cannot think for themselves, because they refused to stand up for their rights. Who knows what could have happened if a country stood up for their citizens.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by rekabis on Thursday October 27, 2022 @03:17PM (#33362613)
Guns, knives, and sharps don’t go leaping out of your hands to kill anyone simply because these people are in your presence. You need to intentionally use or mishandle these items for them to be lethal.

Viruses, on the other hand, can make you a lethal object to anyone who comes close to you simply by you breathing without a mask.

And that’s why we have laws on the safe storage, handling, and public carrying of these items. We have RESTRICTIONS on their usage, in the same way a person can be restricted from being a Typhoid Mary who only has to be in the physical vicinity of someone else in order to kill them.

Your logical fallacy is: Slippery Slope.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by graphe on Thursday October 27, 2022 @03:37PM (#33362891)
You intentionally ignored the first section of authoritarians. If this is a slippery slope, how do authoritarians get their power of not through a slippery slope?

If you actually cared about people and a zero covid policy would you would move there or isolate yourself forever so you can’t infect anyone even if you really vaccinated? I got my vaccine but I don’t pretend it prevents corona, the only zero covid policy is what China is doing. Do you support them?

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by rekabis on Thursday October 27, 2022 @03:55PM (#33363139)
>If you actually cared about people and a zero covid policy would you would move there or isolate yourself forever so you can’t infect anyone even if you really vaccinated?

Your logical fallacy is: Appeal to Extremes, and Reductio ad Absurdum

I cannot be a part of a community unless I am in that community. And once I am in that community, there are people I need to protect in that community. Or to be more precise, I need to protect that ENTIRE community as best as I can and within my own capabilities, while remaining a part of it. It is irrational and impractical to have everyone who wants to protect others to isolate themselves wholly via extra-community physical distance - we need hundreds of planet Earths in order to do that.

And because I am not a community of one, there are also others - like my octogenarian parents - that I need to take care of. They depend on me in ways I can only satisfy through being physically there for them, to physically assist them. And while I have vaccinated myself, I also depend on everyone else I come in contact with - frequently do to things for my parents that they cannot do themselves anymore - to be vaccinated and to mask up as well. To protect themselves as best as possible, to put the needs and lives of the community as a whole ahead of their own trivial inconveniences.

>You intentionally ignored the first section of authoritarians. If this is a slippery slope, how do authoritarians get their power of not through a slippery slope?

Your logical fallacy is: Circular Reasoning.

Apathy and learned helplessness explains the rise of most Authoritarians quite well just in of itself, no slippery slope needed.

>Argumentum ad populum (appeal to widespread belief, bandwagon argument, appeal to the majority, appeal to the people) – a proposition is claimed to be true or good solely because a majority or many people believe it to be so.

Concerning the effectiveness of vaccines or masking up? Sorry, not yours. The real-world scientific evidence has no counterpart that has survived the test of disproof.

>Appeal to consequences (argumentum ad consequentiam) – the conclusion is supported by a premise that asserts positive or negative consequences from some course of action in an attempt to distract from the initial discussion.

Concerning the effectiveness of vaccines or masking up? Sorry, not yours. The science has survived plenty of tests of disproof on this one.

>Fallacy of relative privation (also known as "appeal to worse problems" or "not as bad as") – dismissing an argument or complaint due to what are perceived to be more important problems. First World problems are a subset of this fallacy.

See: Polio. Spanish Flu. Smallpox. Rinderpest. Hepatitius B. Measles. Whooping Cough. The list goes on and on.

Or are historical facts not your concern?

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by Vecr on Thursday October 27, 2022 @06:19PM (#33364787)
What are you even talking about? Do you have any models that so far have been consistent with reality to support the idea that current ideas of vaccination and surgical mask wearing would actually meaningfully protect octogenarians from getting a SARS-CoV-2 (virus that causes COVID-19) infection before they die? What people like Vincent Racaniello, Daniel Griffin, and Paul Offit say is that immune memory pretty much can't be formed to any protective extent in people that old, so the correct strategy is for immune compromised, old, and otherwise high-risk people to make plans with their doctors to immediately take Paxlovid after infection is first detected, or otherwise to be infused with Remdesivir (Veklury) if that's not possible. For people like this, repeated boosting is just one step forward, and (a couple months later) one step back. The immune memory and anamnestic response never becomes enough. As far as anyone can tell, current vaccination strategies can't halt transmission anywhere in the world in real-life conditions, and it's highly unethical to give someone a biologic when the risk of that biologic outweighs the risk of not getting that biologic, or getting a less risky alternative.