News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by Dracophoenix on Friday October 28, 2022 @03:41AM (#33368682)
> Community-first attitudes are a hallmark of societal stability over the long term, as people think of the community first, and themselves second. Everyone benefits because the community is put ahead of selfishness and solipsism.

Saudi Arabia is also a societally stable country with community-first attitudes. That doesn't mean it's a desirable place to live for every community. All communities rely on exclusion as much as they rely on inclusion. As a result, they have no concern for individual rights. Communities are more prone to solipsistic bandwagons than individuals (i.e. madness of the crowds) and with more drastic consequences (e.g. internment, torture, genocide). Stability at the expense of personal liberty should not be sanctified at all whether by numbers or cultural fiat.

> Pathologically individualistic “me, me, me” attitudes lead to a very superficial community that cannot effectively meet threats to its health and survival. Everyone reaches for “why should I make the sacrifice when I don’t immediately benefit?”, which means no-one will make the sacrifice move.

It's not pathology. It's a question of integrity. Why should I be held to or punished for a standard that is contradictory to my values? While I agree health and survival are should be considerations on an individual level, I don't agree that the purpose of my health and survival is for society. If that were case I'd have no right no risk my health in the pursuit of liberty or exercise the ability to end my life as I fit.

> I find it very ironic that the military holds so many of the second group, when its ethos teaches the first. In a military unit, your first instinct is to jump on top of that grenade so that you protect your teammates at the cost of your own life. You put the team first, so that the team can survive with or without you. This only works if every single member of the team conforms to that same ideal. Yet the amount of antivax in the military - which is no different than refusing to protect your teammates because jumping on top of that grenade would hurt your own “personal freedoms” - is surprisingly prevalent

The military is a (mostly) volunteer army. Joining the military is an exercise of choice to rather than one of forced conscription. The military doesn't (at least officially) doesn't exist as the private gang of a monarch or warlord as many armies in 18th century Europe did. While there are different legal systems and cultural expectations for members of the army than there are for private citizens, every member is inculcated with understanding that they are protecting the Land of Free with all it's warts not the of Land of the Chosen or Land of the Societally Acceptable.

There are no comments on this comment yet.