News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by rekabis on Thursday October 27, 2022 @03:17PM (#33362613)
Guns, knives, and sharps don’t go leaping out of your hands to kill anyone simply because these people are in your presence. You need to intentionally use or mishandle these items for them to be lethal.

Viruses, on the other hand, can make you a lethal object to anyone who comes close to you simply by you breathing without a mask.

And that’s why we have laws on the safe storage, handling, and public carrying of these items. We have RESTRICTIONS on their usage, in the same way a person can be restricted from being a Typhoid Mary who only has to be in the physical vicinity of someone else in order to kill them.

Your logical fallacy is: Slippery Slope.

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by graphe on Thursday October 27, 2022 @03:37PM (#33362891)
You intentionally ignored the first section of authoritarians. If this is a slippery slope, how do authoritarians get their power of not through a slippery slope?

If you actually cared about people and a zero covid policy would you would move there or isolate yourself forever so you can’t infect anyone even if you really vaccinated? I got my vaccine but I don’t pretend it prevents corona, the only zero covid policy is what China is doing. Do you support them?

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by rekabis on Thursday October 27, 2022 @03:55PM (#33363139)
>If you actually cared about people and a zero covid policy would you would move there or isolate yourself forever so you can’t infect anyone even if you really vaccinated?

Your logical fallacy is: Appeal to Extremes, and Reductio ad Absurdum

I cannot be a part of a community unless I am in that community. And once I am in that community, there are people I need to protect in that community. Or to be more precise, I need to protect that ENTIRE community as best as I can and within my own capabilities, while remaining a part of it. It is irrational and impractical to have everyone who wants to protect others to isolate themselves wholly via extra-community physical distance - we need hundreds of planet Earths in order to do that.

And because I am not a community of one, there are also others - like my octogenarian parents - that I need to take care of. They depend on me in ways I can only satisfy through being physically there for them, to physically assist them. And while I have vaccinated myself, I also depend on everyone else I come in contact with - frequently do to things for my parents that they cannot do themselves anymore - to be vaccinated and to mask up as well. To protect themselves as best as possible, to put the needs and lives of the community as a whole ahead of their own trivial inconveniences.

>You intentionally ignored the first section of authoritarians. If this is a slippery slope, how do authoritarians get their power of not through a slippery slope?

Your logical fallacy is: Circular Reasoning.

Apathy and learned helplessness explains the rise of most Authoritarians quite well just in of itself, no slippery slope needed.

>Argumentum ad populum (appeal to widespread belief, bandwagon argument, appeal to the majority, appeal to the people) – a proposition is claimed to be true or good solely because a majority or many people believe it to be so.

Concerning the effectiveness of vaccines or masking up? Sorry, not yours. The real-world scientific evidence has no counterpart that has survived the test of disproof.

>Appeal to consequences (argumentum ad consequentiam) – the conclusion is supported by a premise that asserts positive or negative consequences from some course of action in an attempt to distract from the initial discussion.

Concerning the effectiveness of vaccines or masking up? Sorry, not yours. The science has survived plenty of tests of disproof on this one.

>Fallacy of relative privation (also known as "appeal to worse problems" or "not as bad as") – dismissing an argument or complaint due to what are perceived to be more important problems. First World problems are a subset of this fallacy.

See: Polio. Spanish Flu. Smallpox. Rinderpest. Hepatitius B. Measles. Whooping Cough. The list goes on and on.

Or are historical facts not your concern?

Re:The Rise of Biodigital Surveillance by Vecr on Thursday October 27, 2022 @06:19PM (#33364787)
What are you even talking about? Do you have any models that so far have been consistent with reality to support the idea that current ideas of vaccination and surgical mask wearing would actually meaningfully protect octogenarians from getting a SARS-CoV-2 (virus that causes COVID-19) infection before they die? What people like Vincent Racaniello, Daniel Griffin, and Paul Offit say is that immune memory pretty much can't be formed to any protective extent in people that old, so the correct strategy is for immune compromised, old, and otherwise high-risk people to make plans with their doctors to immediately take Paxlovid after infection is first detected, or otherwise to be infused with Remdesivir (Veklury) if that's not possible. For people like this, repeated boosting is just one step forward, and (a couple months later) one step back. The immune memory and anamnestic response never becomes enough. As far as anyone can tell, current vaccination strategies can't halt transmission anywhere in the world in real-life conditions, and it's highly unethical to give someone a biologic when the risk of that biologic outweighs the risk of not getting that biologic, or getting a less risky alternative.