News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by clint on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:22PM (#33249831)
Which is simulating what could and probably will happen in nature, before it really happens
Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by JamesBarney on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:45PM (#33250257)
Or could cause it to happen. There's still a decent chance the original covid wouldn't have happened if people weren't doing this type of research.
Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by bayesian_horse on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:50PM (#33251278)
There is zero indication of the Virus having originated in a lab. Some hand-waving, no actual evidence. No genomic signature. No merging of known lineages (which would happen). No plausible mechanism (to those who know the subject).

Much more likely: This Virus originated just like the thousands before it. From ordinary Human-to-animal contact. Virus particles pass from animals to Humans trillions of times a year. Most of the time exactly nothing happens at all. Even rarer are actual transmissions. Still rarer are chains of transmission that allow the Virus to evolve into an actual threat.

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by buscoquadnary on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @03:17PM (#33252476)
I love how everyone involved always jumps on the most extreme version of the lab leak hypothesis "Chinese government made COVID super weapon" and then use that to discount everything else instead of admitting the much more nuanced reality of the situation.

The lab leak hypothesis has a range from "This virus was created and released by the Chinese government as a bio-weapon against the US and to kill off their own aging population" at the extreme. To the "The virus was being studied at the Wuhan Virology Institute and someone one got lax on safety protocols got exposed accidentally and then took the train home."

Most people that seem to argue against lab leak, seem to assume everyone ascribes to the first position, whereas the majority of the people that believe in the lab leak subscribe to the later position, including myself.

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by throwawayxxcf on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @07:36PM (#33255545)
The conflation and smearing that happens whenever an accidental lab leak is brought up, makes me suspicious. As an example, I used to edit Wikipedia articles in the area, but I gave up, because some editors made a concerted effort to discredit it as a "conspiracy theory" and had boundless energy to shut it down.

It seems to be the opposite to the much vaunted "fearless scientific transparency" that's sold to the public as a hallmark of science.

I guess that in a generation or two, when vested interests move on, there may be more willingness to explore this.

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by autoexec on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:08PM (#33255777)
> The lab leak hypothesis has a range from "This virus was created and released by the Chinese government as a bio-weapon against the US and to kill off their own aging population" at the extreme. To the "The virus was being studied at the Wuhan Virology Institute and someone one got lax on safety protocols got exposed accidentally and then took the train home."

And people on either end of that spectrum should be expected to have substantial evidence to support their position since the far simpler and common scenario is that it wasn't leaked from the lab at all. "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence" applies much more to the government bio-weapon crowd, but it still absolutely applies to the 'employee mistake' theory too.

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by LawTalkingGuy on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:45PM (#33257363)
There are two indicators, one simply how close it was to a virus lab doing similar studies, and two how immediately and blindly people denied that they could be any connection.

They'd have had to investigate before making a claim, and had not, so obviously they're lying.

A concerted conspiracy to deny an option is some evidence for that option being true.

I don't claim it did come from a lab, but that anyone stating categorically that it did not is lying.

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by JamesBarney on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:07AM (#33257969)
Why is

- a virus unusually adapted to being transmitted between people

- which was released next to one of a handful of labs on earth that studied it

- that the Chinese government and several American scientists tried to cover up

- normally found a thousand of miles away

- that we can't find an origin for unlike SARS and MERS (with far more looking)

isn't also an at least equally extraordinary claim?

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by mistermann on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:15PM (#33257150)
> I love how everyone involved always jumps on the most extreme version of the lab leak hypothesis "Chinese government made COVID super weapon" and then use that to discount everything else instead of admitting the much more nuanced reality of the situation.

I think a decent argument could be made that this phenomenon (in its abstract form, not specifically this variation of it) is more dangerous than covid, or even a virus much more dealy. Who knows how much damage this does to the world considering how widely it exists?

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by bayesian_horse on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:36AM (#33261216)
"Gain of Function" research is brought up very often in this context.

A natural virus would first need to get into the lab in order to escape from it. I'd argue it's a lot harder and less probably for a bat Virus - which isn't adapted to Humans yet - to be collected by a lab, then infect a researcher, then continue the chain in Humans, rather than the same virus making it from the Jungle to a Human population without involving some researchers. Even more likely, Sars-Cov-2 widely circulated in the intermediary hosts and had thousands of contacts with Humans until one lineage "stuck" because it finally matched.

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by JamesBarney on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @04:26PM (#33253392)
How would we know if there would be a genomic signature if the database of viruses Wuhan worked with wasn't opened up?

There is not plausible mechanism for anyone from the Wuhan laboratory to get sick with a virus they are studying? This happened several times, and happens 100's of times a year (not Wuhan specifically but labs).

There is some circumstantial evidence it was a lab leak. Like the virus doesn't naturally occur in the Wuhan district, and the Wuhan Institute of Virology is one of the few in the world that study coronaviruses and do gain of function research. Unlike SARS and MERS where we discovered the origins quickly, we still don't know the origins of covid-19. I don't know how you leap to the conclusion it was of natural origins when we don't even know what those natural origins are.

We don't know if it's a lab leak or not, but they do happen and they've fairly common. (10's-100's per year)

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by bayesian_horse on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:42AM (#33261280)
The Virus has been sequenced to death. Gene editing technology leaves traces. Hard to explain, but it's partly because of the technology and partly because evolution erodes statistical anomalies in a certain way.

There is no plausible way to "gain of function" your way into a pandemic Virus. Researchers can make a Virus gain a function. Usually by making it lose a few others. There is also no plausible way that an unmodified Virus collected from labs just happens to be the next hot shit on the pandemic scene. If there is a Virus with that potential, you wouldn't need researchers and a leak from a BSL-3 lab to make it go viral, it would just happen on its own.

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by dTal on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:47PM (#33250285)
Except it's not a simulation, it is causing it to "really happen". The only difference hinges on the ability of human institutions to keep it contained, which at the very least we have reason to be concerned about.
Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by bayesian_horse on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:04PM (#33250574)
A pandemic virus circulating in the wild is an incredibly fine-tuned machine. Just mashing together integral parts from two quite different genomes is not going to result in a Variant that is tuned enough. In order to make a Virus virulent and transmissive, it needs to evolve through multiple, probably dozens of hosts, and only if that is on a broad scale, like thousands of such lineages, does it have a chance of success.

Even one lab leak isn't enough. The Virus would most likely die out on its own, if not it would get outcompeted by naturally developing variants. The risk of a lab leaking a variant in a way that it would outcompete natural strains is so miniscule compared to natural variants arising and doing the same, it's not worth mentioning.

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by d0mine on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:29PM (#33250954)
Do we have definite proof that the original SARS-CoV-2 hasn't escaped the lab?
Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by bayesian_horse on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:00PM (#33251429)
To what standard? It's the same game with climate change. When only 1% of the scientists dissent, that gives certain people enough confidence to believe the opposite of what the 99% believe.
Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by xupybd on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @04:12PM (#33253193)
I'm always skeptical when people say x% of scientists agree or disagree with a given hypothesis. Most of the time these numbers are flat out wrong or misleading. Most scientists have very complex views on their own domain. Those complexities lead to a very nuanced understanding of topics that we lay people don't fully understand. Most have subtle disagreements on most topics.
Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by InitialLastName on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:16PM (#33255825)
You can have even substantial disagreements with other people in your field without negating the possibility that the bulk of your field is in directional alignment with respect to the core of the matter.

Climate change is a perfect example: 99% of people who study climate likely agree that a) the Earth is getting warmer on average, b) the warming is substantially exacerbated by human-derived emissions, and c) the medium- and long-term destabilization due to that warming has meaningful potential to have catastrophic effects any biomes, including those inhabited by humans. They likely disagree amongst themselves on a) how much warmer and over what timeline, b) how much of the warming is caused by humans, and c) what the specifics and timeline of the catastrophic effects are likely to be.

In situations like the above, attempts to paint disagreement over magnitude as disagreement over direction are misleading at best and disingenuous at worst.

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by xupybd on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:40PM (#33257319)
You are totally correct. The problem goes both ways. One camp will say there is significant disagreement on this issue therefore we need to act in a certain way. While the other side will say the scientists all agree so we have to act another way. But you have to be very specific about the claims you're make when you say scientists agree or disagree on a matter. You also cannot extrapolate even slightly when you do.

For example you have made some very specific claims about the climate change consensus. But people often simply say X% of scientists agree on climate change, without defining what they mean about climate change.

All of this is also done to support a given course of action. Those courses of action only make sense with a very specific model of climate change. Often a model that is not totally accurate or agreed upon. Then they often incorrectly quote the scientist. Such as Al Gore's famous prediction “Some of the models suggest to Dr Maslowski that there is a 75% chance that the entire north polar ice cap during some of the summer months could be completely ice-free within the next five to seven years.” When Dr Maslawski was not predicting anything as dramatic. In the other camp you have appeals to Freeman Dyson. But he does agree that man has altered the climate. He simply doesn't think drastic action is required, and that we will be able to counter its impact. Not surprising from the guy that came up with the ideas to harvest the entire energy output of the sun.

The details matter and the appeal to authority that all the scientists agree with me is not as good as an argument on the facts.

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by bayesian_horse on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @10:18AM (#33262567)
You can't handle the facts.

Seriously. If you don't want to believe what 99% of the experts say, and don't know shit about the actual science - which takes years to understand - it's a pretty good bet you're wrong. Lot's of things can't be broken down to a level non-experts can understand.

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by xupybd on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @04:06PM (#33267325)
Of course, I'm sorry I forgot you are the source of all truth and all who disagree with you don't know anything about actual science. I thank you for my chastisement. I will commence with the self flagellation immediately.
Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by d0mine on Thursday October 27, 2022 @03:39PM (#33362930)
An Analysis of the Origins of the Covid-19 Pandemic: Interim Report [pdf] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33360216
Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by reuben_scratton on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @05:44PM (#33254456)
You must know that virologists routinely "serial passage" viruses through animal hosts? Evolving a candidate virus "through multiple, probably dozens of hosts" is what virology labs do.

And lab leaks happen All The Time. SARS-1 escaped labs on six separate occasions.

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by bayesian_horse on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:27AM (#33261132)
Serial passage actually weakens a Virus because this kind of evolution selects for properties that aren't useful for transmission outside the lab. And virulence usually decreases as well. Animal studies of this nature just don't have the numerical power to modify such properties intentionally.
Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by peyton on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @07:47PM (#33255620)
We have one other piece of evidence: Ecohealth Alliance will not share lab notebooks from Wuhan. As a Bayesian horse, you’ll know this “explains away” the natural origin hypothesis. The belief in a natural origin actually goes down.
Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by bayesian_horse on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:30AM (#33261158)
Bullshit. Absence of information means the uncertainty is not reduced...
Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by TechBro8615 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:54PM (#33252168)
In fact it seems like a reasonable assumption that on many days at a BSL-3+ lab, we're trusting at least one hungover graduate student who is operating on two hours of sleep at 9 in the morning, not to commit human error while implementing biosafety protocols to protect against the accidental release of a synthetic pathogen to the local urban population.

Another comment in this thread suggested building these labs in a desert or some other extreme environment where scientists can be isolated for months at a time. This seems like an obviously necessary mitigation against the unknown risk of introducing synthetic pathogens that haven't been created in billions of years of evolution. And yet, the secretive groups funding and regulating this research instead choose to build their labs in urban centers. Why?

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by inkcapmushroom on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @04:05PM (#33253082)
An obvious answer is it's expensive to build and hard to staff and maintain labs in extreme environments.
Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by heavyset_go on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @06:38PM (#33255029)
Bioweapon labs have a history of being built on small islands for this reason.
Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by bayesian_horse on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:22AM (#33261066)
None of that is practical. In reality, biosafety procedures in those labs are extremely good at preventing any incidents. If you think it's easy to infect yourself as a BSL-3 researcher, you probably have that impression from watching a movie or TV show.

That's why isolating the researchers is not necessary. Also you underestimate the number of such labs and the amount and variety of work that such labs are doing. "Synthetic Pathogens" are not a thing. Synthetic viruses are hardly pathogenic at all.

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by TechBro8615 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @02:10PM (#33265830)
If it's not practical to mitigate against some risk, then the potential reward isn't high enough. Ignoring the risk and continuing without optimal mitigation is only a logical course of action if the potential reward outweighs the possible downside.

If research is sufficiently dangerous to necessitate a BSL-3+ lab, then it should have to meet a correspondingly high bar for demonstrating its potential reward. It's not clear to me that gain of function research could ever make such a justification.

In an ideal world, we could do this research with remote controlled robots in an orbiting space capsule. If we can't do that yet, then we could at least do it in a desert. Otherwise, shouldn't we be asking the local population to approve each research proposal that could lead to a local outbreak of a dangerous virus?