News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by TechBro8615 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:54PM (#33252168)
In fact it seems like a reasonable assumption that on many days at a BSL-3+ lab, we're trusting at least one hungover graduate student who is operating on two hours of sleep at 9 in the morning, not to commit human error while implementing biosafety protocols to protect against the accidental release of a synthetic pathogen to the local urban population.

Another comment in this thread suggested building these labs in a desert or some other extreme environment where scientists can be isolated for months at a time. This seems like an obviously necessary mitigation against the unknown risk of introducing synthetic pathogens that haven't been created in billions of years of evolution. And yet, the secretive groups funding and regulating this research instead choose to build their labs in urban centers. Why?

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by inkcapmushroom on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @04:05PM (#33253082)
An obvious answer is it's expensive to build and hard to staff and maintain labs in extreme environments.
Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by heavyset_go on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @06:38PM (#33255029)
Bioweapon labs have a history of being built on small islands for this reason.
Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by bayesian_horse on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:22AM (#33261066)
None of that is practical. In reality, biosafety procedures in those labs are extremely good at preventing any incidents. If you think it's easy to infect yourself as a BSL-3 researcher, you probably have that impression from watching a movie or TV show.

That's why isolating the researchers is not necessary. Also you underestimate the number of such labs and the amount and variety of work that such labs are doing. "Synthetic Pathogens" are not a thing. Synthetic viruses are hardly pathogenic at all.

Re:Lab-made Covid virus draws government scrutiny by TechBro8615 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @02:10PM (#33265830)
If it's not practical to mitigate against some risk, then the potential reward isn't high enough. Ignoring the risk and continuing without optimal mitigation is only a logical course of action if the potential reward outweighs the possible downside.

If research is sufficiently dangerous to necessitate a BSL-3+ lab, then it should have to meet a correspondingly high bar for demonstrating its potential reward. It's not clear to me that gain of function research could ever make such a justification.

In an ideal world, we could do this research with remote controlled robots in an orbiting space capsule. If we can't do that yet, then we could at least do it in a desert. Otherwise, shouldn't we be asking the local population to approve each research proposal that could lead to a local outbreak of a dangerous virus?