This is the answer to most pop-Econ articles. It’s amazing how hard people want to believe that something else is to blame or that traditional economics doesn’t apply for some reason. Algorithms are a popular outrage-bait right now, so I’m not too surprised to see “the algorithm” blamed for high rents now, too.
But in this case, it's also the algorithm -- the article has multiple quotes where "empathy" is seen as a problem and that getting humans out of the loop is a boon to profit. The algorithm itself isn't the problem, it's the bloody-minded profit-seeking where capitalists leverage trust in the algorithm to extract maximum rents by leaving properties vacant in the midst of a housing crunch.
I guess what I’m saying is that the incentives are aligned here: property managers want to see units occupied, and so does everyone else.
Will they lower prices until 100% occupancy? No, there needs to be some unoccupied units or there would be no liquidity in the market (if there are no houses to rent and you want to move to a city, how could you move?).
It sounds like you're using the intuition of a person who hasn't captured a major portion of the rental market. You're going so far as telling me that property managers wouldn't do what the people involved with the company say they're doing. Needless to say, I'm not convinced.
Oh yes. Media often lament people radicalizing online supposedly because of them. But nobody is forced to follow recommendations, which are moreover labelled as such. People stay logged-in and indulge on them, and that's it.
The ridiculously low cost of holding assets are making it too cheap to hold and do nothing. Tax policy is a big part of this, but won’t change for many years.
All this is doing is bringing it to smaller apartments and single family rentals.
I still feel that if you correctly account for costs and back out appreciation, being a single family home landlord ain’t worth it.
If you rent it out, there will be wear and tear (ie. after 5 years it'll need a full refurb), and you run the risk of having tenants stuck in your property if laws change and suddenly you aren't allowed to evict them.
Often the capital appreciation is so much greater in value than the rental income (after management, maintenance, etc) that it isn't worth risking the capital income for a tiny bit of rental income.
In other words, building more properties isn't the main problem here.
Cashflow is the lifeblood of a business. The era of cheap money is over. If a company wants to sit on their real estate while other companies are building and filling up their units, they can do so at their own peril. If you haven't noticed with the markets' movements, unrealized gains aren't worth anything.
The issue here is that there are units being held as vacant for long periods of time, in a saturated market, to drive prices up, and a central algorithm is being used by a large percentage of the market, that allows them to do this in a coordinated manner.
This is effectively textbook collusion, obfuscated by technology. People should be losing their real estate licenses over this, and honestly, folks should be reporting any company using this service to the real estate commission in their state for collusion, because this is normally something real estate commissions take seriously.
Can you define the "long period" or point somewhere in the article or other source where this is described?
>This is effectively textbook collusion, obfuscated by technology.
I probably did not read the same text books you read. Do the house sellers who hire the same appraiser also collude in your text book? What about people who use Zillow's or Redfin estimates?
> Can you define the "long period" or point somewhere in the article or other source where this is described?
The article mentions that landlords are using the software to run at lower occupancy rates to increase revenue. One specific landlord was mentioning an occupancy rate as low as 95% on 50,000 units (which is quite low). Landlords don't base occupancy rates on short-term vacancies.
> I probably did not read the same text books you read.
The article describes a service that takes private pricing data from numerous competitors, then gives all the competitors pricing and occupancy recommendations as a means of maximizing revenue. There's a good quote in the article about replacing the word algorithm, with a "guy named Bob". If a person was doing this, it would obviously be collusion, because it's a practice that is already illegal, essentially everywhere.
In real estate school, they were pretty explicit about not even walking the edges of collusion; for instance, simply saying "we only price our commissions at 3%" in a room with other brokers could be considered collusion.
> Do the house sellers who hire the same appraiser also collude in your text book? What about people who use Zillow's or Redfin estimates?
An appraiser sets prices based on factors like recent sales in the neighborhood of similar properties and property sizes, age/condition of the house, etc. Everyone can use the same appraiser because that appraiser isn't doing any coordination across the sellers. Two different appraisers, for the most point, should be setting very similar prices.
It could very well be collusion is every broker was using Zillow or Redfins estimate's, especially if they were giving recommendations on holding properties off the market in a coordinated way to maximize profits.
This product is being used to maximize revenue in specific markets, by telling landlords to hold apartments vacant by listing them at higher than market prices. By doing that across the market, they artificially increase scarcity, which forces people to rent those apartments at inflated prices. That's collusion by proxy, because you have a single actor that's coordinating actions.
It's collusion because all of these companies are sharing their private pricing data with a central entity, who's using that private data to provide coordinated actions.
> By doing that across the market, they artificially increase scarcity, which forces people to rent those apartments at inflated prices.
Yes, this is how the product works, it tells the price that will maximize the revenue.
>That's collusion by proxy
There is no such thing. If the agreement on prices exists then it's just collusion, if it does not - there is no collusion. Price fixing, which I suppose you mean by collusion is outlawed. Following market trends is not. The agreement on prices is the key element, without it there is no collusion. Nobody is coordinating anything, there is no agreement to set prices according to the marketing data. This is why stock advisors, appraisers, reports and any other pricing sources are not "collusion by proxy" since they are missing the collusion per se.
The national average is going to be lower than cities with housing crisis, because the country is large, and it's skewed by areas that are effectively ghost towns. My friends in New Orleans have had a 100% occupancy rate since the last major hurricane.
> There is no such thing. If the agreement on prices exists then it's just collusion, if it does not - there is no collusion. Price fixing, which I suppose you mean by collusion is outlawed. Following market trends is not. The agreement on prices is the key element, without it there is no collusion. Nobody is coordinating anything, there is no agreement to set prices according to the marketing data. This is why stock advisors, appraisers, reports and any other pricing sources are not "collusion by proxy" since they are missing the collusion per se.
I'm assuming you don't have a real estate license, because there are specific national laws (and often stricter state-level laws) related to collusion, and they differ and are considerably stricter than price fixing laws.
How do you know the unnamed company in the article is in a city witch such a crisis? To me it appears there was not enough demand so it had to discount its rents by a lot to get to the target 97%-98% occupancy and thus lost revenue.
And yes, I don't have a real estate license in Louisiana, so can you please name the specific laws you had in mind?
This quote is specifically from a company that had 50k units, normally ran with 100% occupancy, did some trials with the pricing company, which showed they could increase revenue by running at an occupancy of 98%, and has now pushed that lower to 95%. By lowering their occupancy rate, they're increasing housing pressure, which forces renters to accept their higher rates.
> And yes, I don't have a real estate license in Louisiana, so can you please name the specific laws you had in mind?
You don't have one at all, or you'd know the laws. Based on your responses I can tell you didn't read the article, and aren't debating in good faith, so I don't plan on continuing this.
I hear this a lot from certain quarters
How long will looser regulations help until we're back to the same problem?
Perhaps we should dig deeper.
Why have we organized our society in a way that encourages and almost enforces high population density?
The fact is that our current way of living is unsustainable. The housing situation is just one symptom of that.
Unless your proposed plan is like living off grid or something, making it easy for people to move to cities seems logical.
Once you account for maintenance items owning becomes decently more expensive than a simple “mortgage + utilities + insurance + taxes” calculation shows. A $10k furnace every 25 years adds something like $40 a month and that’s only one of the many wear items there are.
There are other non-tangible benefits to ownership, of course.
Right, but remember that if you are a renter, the landlord is passing those $40 to you bundled in the rent (along with all other future maintenance projections). There's no free ride, the renter is paying for all of it plus profit margin to the landlord.
You can sometimes get lucky as a renter by finding a small-time incompetent landlord who doesn't price these future maintanence costs into the rent, but that's not the norm.
If an investment house was a business, it often takes a decade to see substantial returns, sometimes after many years of hard slog and even losses. Would you accept that from the businesses that hacker news dreams of?
I think the fundamental issue is that the whole renting market is buying long and selling short (buy a dwelling for a long period, rent it for short periods) and that causes issues on one or another direction (either you rent for what appears "too much" because you need to build reserves, or you rent for what appears "fair" and the first major expense kills the landlord).
Answering your question with another question. Why stop there? What you are ultimately arguing for is population-growth control. Turns out very few people are interested in the government deciding how many children they can have.
What do you mean here, and how does it relate to total population levels?
California legislature is passing some housing good laws, but the state's attorney is not enforcing them. The non-profit CaRLA is doing the enforcement and having success [1]. Their wins in court have set precedent and unblocked a lot of building permits.
A city needs to upgrade multiple infrastructural elements simultaneously if it wants to make a successful leap into higher densities. In a democratic culture this means getting enough parties on board to accept a big jump in taxes for huge civic works projects like subways. To make all of this coherent this will take a massive and sustained political momentum which can exercise eminent domain in a very big way.
How much more revenue do you believe the city needs?
By all means allow people to build parking if they want to, but there’s no need for parking minimums.
I don’t see how more central planning could help. Our central planners love to block housing unless it meets 100 different conflicting requirements they make up on the spot. Just let people build!
There's an analogy in the article to airplane seat pricing. The solution there was to tell the airlines they couldn't collude with each other, not to say "The real problem is the lack of flight supply."
But I don't see any actual evidence that collusion is happening. Collusion is difficult to pull off! It requires each owner to restrict their supply so that all owners benefit through higher prices. The incentive for an individual owner is to "defect" by renting out their whole supply. Collusion generally requires participants to be able to monitor and enforce each other's behavior.
To the extent that owners are increasing prices slightly to benefit themselves, that's not collusion, that's just the market clearing.
Not if the company keeps apartments empty as mentioned in the article. With such an arrangement between landlords you can increase rent not matter the supply&demand.
There could be an Elysium scenario where the super-rich will pay anything to live in a high-demand area, so the prices go so high almost all properties end up empty. That doesn’t seem beneficial to society, the environment or anyone.
If there were strong vacancy taxes the situation would change. Vancouver has a 3% empty homes tax. Let’s keep raising a tax like that until managing empty properties becomes untenable. If we want people to have more affordable homes to buy we should incentivize people living in them over managing them for optimal profit.
So maybe not everyone who wants to live there gets to.
Again, not from out that familiar with the area so maybe I’m off the mark here.
So instead of SF continuing to expand to engulf all of California, other cities in other areas would begin to grow. Somewhat this has happened - Redmond near Seattle, etc, but we haven't really had any "ground up" new cities that I can recall, they're all offshoots/suburbs of existing ones.
I put algorithm in quotes, because it's clearly just a facade in front of good ol' fashioned price collusion.
As the example in the article points out, replace the word "algorithm" with "a guy named Bob" and suddenly it doesn't sound so innocent to say: The companies controlling 90% of apartments in a neighborhood give all their data to Bob, and then Bob tells each one what to price their apartments. It's price collusion by proxy, pure and simple.
We shouldn't just ignore it because it's not the biggest cause of the price increases. Yes, we absolutely need to tackle the housing supply problem, but at the same time we need to stop companies like this from exploiting the crisis and driving prices up even further.
If you stop "this one company" you'll just have someone else making profits and still have people homeless.
Do you honestly think any other property owner would touch companies like this if this one popped like that?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racketeer_Influenced_and_Corru...
> If you stop "this one company" you'll just have someone else making profits and still have people homeless.
And this new homes will be bought by ordinary people who for years paid inflated rents and have no real liquidity or corporations/landlords who have profited by renting and have more than enough cash to absorb any new properties that would become available on the market? Because grabbing them allows for a virtual monopoly on home ownership so people are forced to rent. And we have another cycle of capitalism.
> RealPage claims its software will increase revenue and decrease vacancies. But at times the company has appeared to urge apartment owners and managers to reduce supply while increasing price.
“Oh no, someone is clearly doing something illegal, if only we could do anything about it”.
Also we could legislate that apartments must target >80% occupancy in dense areas or face penalties for overpricing.
And there's your gig-workforce and companies like Uber that figured out that replacing blatantly illegal stuff with "AlgOriThMS" somehow takes governments long times to untwine and figure out that they're illegal shills.
But the in-person businesses can't do such tactics. But some venture capital financed outlet can dump hundreds of scooters on public areas, and socialize their costs and privatize their gains.
And yes, the article shows that this is collusion through a third party. I don't give a shit if it's an 'algorithm', Bob, or a tarot reading. It's collusion, and anyone involved needs to suffer.. up to and including being awarded the apartment/house.
But, we know the worst that'll happen is some lawyers will get millions, and the plebes will get a check for $100 off their rent at participating renters.
Does supply and demand affect housing prices? Yes, and the fact that supply has been constrained is affecting prices.
Is it the only factor? Probably not.
Even basic economics classes will teach that there are several ways that supply and demand breaks down.
For one, if there are imbalanced implications for both the supply and demand parties. For a landlord, rent is a purely economic transaction. Not taking a tenant means losing money. For a renter, not having a place to live is far more damaging. You lose shelter, safety, social standing, etc. The article touches on leaving an apartment empty for a couple months to find a tenant that will pay what you’re asking. But would anyone really go homeless for a couple months to save on rent? Not only that, but peoples lives revolves around where they live, and it’s not easy for a lot of people just to pick up and move to a different market.
Another way supply and demand might break down is if there is price collusion between parties on the supply side. This is relevant especially in this case because if there is a single party setting prices (eg the algorithm) and there is a constrained enough market, then you can in fact force people more than what typical supply and demand would imply.
We’ve outlawed construction. Any other factor besides this is far far behind.
Ok based on what? Like I think there are supply problems, but there are plenty of examples where the demand isn’t increasing much or is even decreasing but housing is still getting more expensive.
I get so tired of watching people declare things with an air of authority that are absolutely not true if you apply a modicum of thought to it.
The issue here is the collusion in place of competition.
I largely agree with the many angles here but I don't see it as a single "build it and they will come" issue.
I don't think it is there yet but are their rules about how much of the market can be owned by a single entity?
I know of a farmer who sold his farm and invested into housing. He had a big party when he got to 100. That was 20 years ago. Are there more of these "super investors" in the market?
After all, money is infinite, but land in the world is limited.
But the underlying problem here is the supply & demand! Rentals are competitive, an algorithm can't force people to pay more than an comparable rental property is charging.
It's the lack of housing supply in areas like SF is responsible for rents being a multiple of what they could be.
Developers want to build apartments, but are prevented from doing so by local regulations. So we need to change those regulations or, as is increasingly happening in the last couple of California's legislative sessions, take control away from local authorities (e.g. SF Board of Supervisors).