This product is being used to maximize revenue in specific markets, by telling landlords to hold apartments vacant by listing them at higher than market prices. By doing that across the market, they artificially increase scarcity, which forces people to rent those apartments at inflated prices. That's collusion by proxy, because you have a single actor that's coordinating actions.
It's collusion because all of these companies are sharing their private pricing data with a central entity, who's using that private data to provide coordinated actions.
> By doing that across the market, they artificially increase scarcity, which forces people to rent those apartments at inflated prices.
Yes, this is how the product works, it tells the price that will maximize the revenue.
>That's collusion by proxy
There is no such thing. If the agreement on prices exists then it's just collusion, if it does not - there is no collusion. Price fixing, which I suppose you mean by collusion is outlawed. Following market trends is not. The agreement on prices is the key element, without it there is no collusion. Nobody is coordinating anything, there is no agreement to set prices according to the marketing data. This is why stock advisors, appraisers, reports and any other pricing sources are not "collusion by proxy" since they are missing the collusion per se.
The national average is going to be lower than cities with housing crisis, because the country is large, and it's skewed by areas that are effectively ghost towns. My friends in New Orleans have had a 100% occupancy rate since the last major hurricane.
> There is no such thing. If the agreement on prices exists then it's just collusion, if it does not - there is no collusion. Price fixing, which I suppose you mean by collusion is outlawed. Following market trends is not. The agreement on prices is the key element, without it there is no collusion. Nobody is coordinating anything, there is no agreement to set prices according to the marketing data. This is why stock advisors, appraisers, reports and any other pricing sources are not "collusion by proxy" since they are missing the collusion per se.
I'm assuming you don't have a real estate license, because there are specific national laws (and often stricter state-level laws) related to collusion, and they differ and are considerably stricter than price fixing laws.
How do you know the unnamed company in the article is in a city witch such a crisis? To me it appears there was not enough demand so it had to discount its rents by a lot to get to the target 97%-98% occupancy and thus lost revenue.
And yes, I don't have a real estate license in Louisiana, so can you please name the specific laws you had in mind?
This quote is specifically from a company that had 50k units, normally ran with 100% occupancy, did some trials with the pricing company, which showed they could increase revenue by running at an occupancy of 98%, and has now pushed that lower to 95%. By lowering their occupancy rate, they're increasing housing pressure, which forces renters to accept their higher rates.
> And yes, I don't have a real estate license in Louisiana, so can you please name the specific laws you had in mind?
You don't have one at all, or you'd know the laws. Based on your responses I can tell you didn't read the article, and aren't debating in good faith, so I don't plan on continuing this.
> Can you define the "long period" or point somewhere in the article or other source where this is described?
The article mentions that landlords are using the software to run at lower occupancy rates to increase revenue. One specific landlord was mentioning an occupancy rate as low as 95% on 50,000 units (which is quite low). Landlords don't base occupancy rates on short-term vacancies.
> I probably did not read the same text books you read.
The article describes a service that takes private pricing data from numerous competitors, then gives all the competitors pricing and occupancy recommendations as a means of maximizing revenue. There's a good quote in the article about replacing the word algorithm, with a "guy named Bob". If a person was doing this, it would obviously be collusion, because it's a practice that is already illegal, essentially everywhere.
In real estate school, they were pretty explicit about not even walking the edges of collusion; for instance, simply saying "we only price our commissions at 3%" in a room with other brokers could be considered collusion.
> Do the house sellers who hire the same appraiser also collude in your text book? What about people who use Zillow's or Redfin estimates?
An appraiser sets prices based on factors like recent sales in the neighborhood of similar properties and property sizes, age/condition of the house, etc. Everyone can use the same appraiser because that appraiser isn't doing any coordination across the sellers. Two different appraisers, for the most point, should be setting very similar prices.
It could very well be collusion is every broker was using Zillow or Redfins estimate's, especially if they were giving recommendations on holding properties off the market in a coordinated way to maximize profits.