News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by subpixel on Friday October 14, 2022 @11:53PM (#33211577)
“More than 230 filmmakers signed a letter denouncing the documentary. A majority had not seen it.”

Just a reminder that the far ends of the political spectrum loop back and connect.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by 8f2ab37a-ed6c on Friday October 14, 2022 @11:58PM (#33211603)
This is all reminiscent of the 80s and 90s Christian right groups picketing outside of Rock and Roll concerts demanding that Marilyn Manson be forbidden from playing in their town because of his corrupting influence on the youth, that his music was going to lead to real physical harm. Same with dungeons and dragons before that. Had any of them ever listened to that music? Ever played a D&D session? Nope.

It's interesting how easy it was to ignore and ridicule those movements at the time, we'd go "ah, those silly fundies", how quaint. Remember Kevin Smith picketing with them outside of movie theaters at the Dogma premiere? We got a good chuckle out of it.

Yet look at how seriously the same people are taking the current flavor of moral panic.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by ericjung1982 on Saturday October 15, 2022 @12:12AM (#33211683)
It predates Marilyn Mason by many years. Black Sabbath in the 70s and Ozzy Osbourne (solo) in the early 80s come to mind.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by 8f2ab37a-ed6c on Saturday October 15, 2022 @12:13AM (#33211688)
Totally fair. The whole playing records backwards trolling for audio that might sound like satanic verses, whatever that means, comes to mind.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by Hoasi on Saturday October 15, 2022 @05:10AM (#33213148)
> The whole playing records backwards trolling for audio that might sound like satanic verses, whatever that means

On the other hand, these claims turned out to be excellent marketing for those records.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by edanm on Saturday October 15, 2022 @07:33AM (#33213891)
I don't remember where, but I heard a podcast with someone who did music promotion for some of these artists. They would call the newspapers and feed them stories about the terrible musicians who do things like "eat bats live on stage", to get outraged parents to boycott these concerts. This was a very successful promotional effort for them.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by 8f2ab37a-ed6c on Saturday October 15, 2022 @04:08PM (#33218158)
Trust Me, I'm Lying by Ryan Holiday talks a bunch about how much of outrage about movies and music has actually been intentionally manufactured by guerilla marketers in order to promote the product to edgy teens wanting to purchase a controversial product that their stuffy conservative parents hate.

I wouldn't be completely shocked if some of the initial outrage about Jihad Rehab was triggered by a shrewd marketer, similarly how marketers would tip off the Tucker Max movie screenings to feminist organizations around campuses in the hopes that they would call for a cancellation.

Doubt we'll ever see the evidence for that though.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by dudeinjapan on Saturday October 15, 2022 @01:59AM (#33212136)
Is there any metal album that you can play backward and it says "Praise Jesus, my lord and savior!" I wonder what the Christian groups would do with that?
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by the_only_law on Saturday October 15, 2022 @10:42AM (#33215249)
I got ones you can play forward that are basically that.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by rhinoceraptor on Saturday October 15, 2022 @12:51AM (#33211854)
Don't forget about the current identity politics war that the American right wing is currently engaged in, attempting to remove any mention of LGBT people in public schools, attempting to remove any serious engagement with past and present issues of slavery, segregation and racism.

The right wing moral panics are just as ludicrous today as they were then. For example, they are currently latched onto the hoax that schools are providing litter boxes for "self-identified furries".

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by AmericanChopper on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:50AM (#33212731)
> This is all reminiscent of the 80s and 90s Christian right groups picketing outside of Rock and Roll concerts

The PMRC was an absolutely bipartisan effort. Tipper Gore was a founding member, and probably the most prominent person amongst their leadership. Probably a good idea to try and project your biases onto history a little less.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by adaml_623 on Saturday October 15, 2022 @04:17AM (#33212877)
It's very unclear what you're saying. Are you saying the Tipper Gore is/was right wing? Are you saying that censoring music isn't something from the right wing of the political spectrum?
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by AmericanChopper on Saturday October 15, 2022 @04:26AM (#33212933)
It’s very clear what I’m saying. The PMRC (which was the most influential music censorship lobby in the 80s and 90s) was a bipartisan organisation. To claim the music censorship initiatives of that period were right wing is simply to project one’s own biases onto history, and is trivially falsifiable.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by adaml_623 on Saturday October 15, 2022 @09:26AM (#33214599)
Were the protests outside concerts also bi-partisan in nature or were they organised by Christian groups? I think the protests are different to the PMRC actions.

Edit: actually ignore me. I don't think we have matching definitions of left and right wing. And I definitely don't have knowledge of whether the US Democrats are left wing by any definition I'd use

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by AmericanChopper on Saturday October 15, 2022 @05:44PM (#33218939)
> Were the protests outside concerts also bi-partisan in nature or were they organised by Christian groups?

In the 80s and 90s, about 90% of US adults identified as Christian. So your question here doesn’t really make sense.

> I don't think we have matching definitions of left and right wing

I’m getting the impression that your idea of “right wing” is just all the things that you don’t like, such as Christianity. Irrespective of actual the histories of right and left wing politics…

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by adaml_623 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:43PM (#33268258)
I think you're jumping to conclusions about my opinions with very few data points. I'm not from your country so I'm also not sure what history we'd be looking out without a lot of 'true scotsman' arguments about definitions.

As for Christianity, I hope we can agree that the teachings of Jesus are quite to the left on the political spectrum.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by mellosouls on Saturday October 15, 2022 @11:02AM (#33215435)
Yes, McCarthyism and the censorship you highlight above were a poison of the right; modern cancel-culture is a poison of the left.

It is depressing how blind the left (my side!) are to it, you still see them denying it or - now that the mainstream has become aware of it and they are on the defensive - excusing it with nonsense about "accountability/call-out/consequence culture".

Shameful.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by slavik81 on Saturday October 15, 2022 @12:03PM (#33215943)
It continued all the way into the 2000s. A particularly stupid episode was the outcry around Mass Effect, which was thankfully short-lived due to Geoff Keighley's excellent response [1]. I'm not sure if it's a coincidence, but the moral panic around video games seemed to die down around the time Jack Thompson was disbarred.

[1]: https://youtu.be/PKzF173GqTU

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by brutusborn on Friday October 14, 2022 @11:58PM (#33211606)
Is this from another article or did you change the quote? The article says "...signed by over 200 filmmakers, many of whom had never seen the film"
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by cfeduke on Saturday October 15, 2022 @01:52AM (#33212114)
The original copy referencing 230 filmmakers appears in the NY Times in September.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by brutusborn on Saturday October 15, 2022 @04:04AM (#33212812)
I was more interested in "many" vs "majority". Those mean very different things.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by mmanfrin on Friday October 14, 2022 @11:57PM (#33211597)
Just a reminder that the horseshoe theory isn't fact.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by carabiner on Saturday October 15, 2022 @01:28AM (#33212017)
Though with the dirtbag left now flirting with being "trad cath" and softening towards racial realism, it does seem like it's approach the intellectual fascism of the nazis.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by MarkMarine on Saturday October 15, 2022 @02:11AM (#33212198)
This is incorrect in its facts and framing. I’m not going to get into a long political discussion, this doesn’t seem the place for it, but I would implore you to look further into this before you start throwing words like fascism and nazi around when you’re talking about people who basically want to give everyone free healthcare.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by 8f2ab37a-ed6c on Saturday October 15, 2022 @02:18AM (#33212234)
Is national socialism antithetical to free universal healthcare?
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by MarkMarine on Saturday October 15, 2022 @02:32AM (#33212322)
Yes, it is, unless by healthcare you mean deadly medical experiments that kill their subjects.

National “socialism” wasn’t socialist at all, it was just branding by some of the most extreme right forces that have ever held power. If you think that is socialism you’ve got a goldfish brain.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by nailer on Saturday October 15, 2022 @04:23AM (#33212913)
The nazis admitted they were inspired by socialism, nazism specifically had elements of class warfare. “goldfish brain” isn’t much of a response.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by goodpoint on Saturday October 15, 2022 @04:46AM (#33213041)
This is provably false. The nazi imprisoned and even exterminated socialists and communists as soon as they could.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by nailer on Saturday October 15, 2022 @05:46AM (#33213296)
I don’t follow your logic- my statement was that that the nazis openly considered themselves socialists and class warfare was a huge part of nazi ideology. Your state that’s probably false - but then don’t prove either of those statements false. It’s entirely possible to fight between factions of the same side of politics.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by rosnd on Saturday October 15, 2022 @09:53AM (#33214838)
Class warfare seems to be a standard part of far right ideology, from Trump crowd to European far right.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by nailer on Saturday October 15, 2022 @10:39AM (#33215229)
Trump isn't far right. If you think he is you likely vary have little knowledge of politics.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by rosnd on Saturday October 15, 2022 @01:40PM (#33216860)
Or perhaps you have very little knowledge of politics?

From a European perspective, Trump crowd is certainly far right. Shit, even most democrats would be right wing here.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by nailer on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:02PM (#33217587)
In Europe. Trumps not advocating for an ethno state, political violence or anything else we’d typically associate with the far right.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by rosnd on Saturday October 15, 2022 @04:57PM (#33218571)
Trump is not advocating for political violence? Huh. Well, I guess that's debatable.

I'd argue that his election related claims are exactly that, if the elections are fraudulent what alternatives are there to solve that but violence? What other alternative could there be if the other party has truly pulled off such a coup?

Trump also pushes extreme religious views, such as abortion bans (In fact, he claims the abortion ban to have been decided by God himself).

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by nailer on Saturday October 15, 2022 @06:12PM (#33219139)
By that novel standard anyone else with an equally ridiculous conspiracy is calling for violence. Think Trump got in by secretly collating with Putin? Call to violence. Neither situation is how the far right, eg the BNP or German neo nazi groups would operate.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by rosnd on Sunday October 16, 2022 @11:07AM (#33224138)
> Think Trump got in by secretly collating with Putin? Call to violence.

I don't understand that one. It's normal to collude with third parties to win elections.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by MarkMarine on Saturday October 15, 2022 @11:27AM (#33215643)
Ridiculous. Like I said, goldfish brained thinking. If you read just a little bit and used some critical thinking, you could figure this out yourself but it sounds like you prefer to think what you currently think because it supports your current ideology.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by nailer on Saturday October 15, 2022 @01:20PM (#33216664)
ok
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by goodpoint on Sunday October 16, 2022 @12:44PM (#33225023)
Both the fascists and the nazi never considered themselves socialists.

This is proven by numerous quotes from mussolini, hitler, various party members and verified by historians.

The fact that both fascists and nazi imprisoned, tortured and killed socialists and communists (again, widely proven by historians) is perfectly aligned with that.

Additionally, both fascists and nazi never implemented policies or took actions that would be aligned with socialism.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by nailer on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @04:23AM (#33244457)
> Both the fascists and the nazi never considered themselves socialists.

That’s provably incorrect, see the link posted by the other socialist in this same thread.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by heavyset_go on Saturday October 15, 2022 @07:04PM (#33219475)
Nazis piggybacked on the popularity of socialist movements at the time, but the Nazis were explicitly not Marxist-inspired socialists, they say so themselves. According to them, they re-appropriated the word to redefine it to something else, an ideology opposed to socialism that was meant to empower the Volk[1].

According to the Nazis, Marxism, socialism and communism were Jewish conspiracies to weaken the Volk. They chose to redefine the popular term so that it is explicitly divorced from its Marxist origins to mean something else entirely. Marxist socialism is explicitly about workers owning the means of production, while Nazism exalts the Volk and seeks to restore the domination of the German people/Volk.

[1] https://research.calvin.edu/german-propaganda-archive/haken3...

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by nailer on Saturday October 15, 2022 @10:46PM (#33220623)
> they re-appropriated the word to redefine it to something else, an ideology opposed to socialism that was meant to empower the Volk

I was referring to the exact writing you reference, and it does not support the point that nazism reappropriated the word to mean something else.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by heavyset_go on Saturday October 15, 2022 @06:53PM (#33219390)
Yes, the Nazi state existed for the Volk[1], the Nazis' economic policy was that of privatization[2] and Social Darwinism. Universal healthcare as implemented in Germany in the 1800's covered more groups than what the Nazis considered the Volk, depending on the implementation, free universal healthcare flies in the face of economic privatization, and Nazis' Social Darwinism said that the weak who can't take care of themselves should be culled.

[1] https://www.britannica.com/biography/Adolf-Hitler/Rise-to-po...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privatization#Etymology

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by bigDinosaur on Saturday October 15, 2022 @02:52AM (#33212441)
You can have authoritarian left and authoritarian right. That's not really related to healthcare. Authoritarians tend towards abuses of power - I kind of don't find it terribly relevant if millions were killed or imprisoned because of the differences in their ideals, which is what the horseshoe theory speaks to. What it speaks to is mainly that the methods - e.g. unconstrained power of an executive or government, become more similar than not as extremism increases. It's not really saying that the ideology necessarily comes to match, only that the ideology matters less than whatever horrible things are coming your way, beliefs be damned.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by nailer on Saturday October 15, 2022 @04:22AM (#33212906)
In the UK it’s the far left (Labour after it was taken over by Momentum) who’ve had major issues with antisemitism and ignored it for years until they were forced to take action. Thirty years ago it would have been the far right.

So yes.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by dontlaugh on Saturday October 15, 2022 @06:57AM (#33213652)
Momentum isn’t far left, the Communist Party of Britain is. Labour wasn’t taken over by Momentum, people that liked Corbyn joined Labour. And finally, antisemitism accusations were used cynically by the right of Labour for years, trying to equate anti-Zionism with antisemitism. Have a look at the Labour Files at least.

So not even a little.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by nailer on Saturday October 15, 2022 @10:44AM (#33215270)
> Momentum isn’t far left, the Communist Party of Britain is.

If you support terror groups - and I mean in the strictest sense, as in people that attack civilians - you're on the far edge of politics. Before you shout that Corbyn was 'reaching out' to terrorists by saying they're his friends, that punishing people that killed innocent people in Brighton was a show trial, or laying wreaths at their funerals: everyone involved in Northern Ireland or the Middle East peace processes claims that Corbyn, a Labour back bencher at the time, had nothing to do with either of the Northern Ireland or the Middle East peace process.

> People that liked Corbyn joined Labour

Because of a Momentum campaign that cynically exploited a brief moment allowing anyone to join the Labour party for 5 pounds.

> antisemitism accusations were used cynically by the right of Labour for years

And obviously the far left is still denying them even after the party's own investigation found they had substance.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by MarkMarine on Saturday October 15, 2022 @01:46PM (#33216923)
This is hacker news not Facebook. If you want to argue politics go there.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by nailer on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:04PM (#33217604)
Political discussion is allowed by the HN guidelines and I’m responding to something you brought up, newcomer.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by MarkMarine on Sunday October 16, 2022 @03:50PM (#33226651)
You’re just spitting out agitprop with no underlying point except “left bad.” It’s not well thought out or discussed with room to agree or disagree, or even based in fact, you’re basically just shouting into the void about something you don’t like. That brings down the level of discourse here, and belongs on Facebook where you can share memes with a bunch of smooth brained people that agree with you.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by nailer on Sunday October 16, 2022 @06:32PM (#33227755)
> it’s not even based on fact

Pardon? What specifically of the very specific, widely accepted points of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33215270 was not based in fact?

If you think my points are issues with the mainstream left rather than the far left I don’t think you’ve been reading the posts you keep writing replies to.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by MarkMarine on Sunday October 16, 2022 @09:00PM (#33228745)
I’m not going to put effort into describing where and why you’re wrong, I don’t think talking to you is worth the effort. You’ll never change your beliefs.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by nailer on Monday October 17, 2022 @09:36AM (#33233266)
Fair enough. I’ll point out as that as the person complaining about the level of discourse you’re the only person in this conversation that has resorted to insults and refused to address reasonable questions.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by aaronbrethorst on Saturday October 15, 2022 @02:22AM (#33212250)
The Bruenigs are assholes but that doesn't make them "approach the intellectual fascism of the nazis"
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by Grimburger on Saturday October 15, 2022 @01:55AM (#33212125)
By definition it can't be, but neither can the general theory of relativity.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by dudeinjapan on Saturday October 15, 2022 @02:00AM (#33212143)
Close only counts in horseshoes and hand grenades.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by albertop on Saturday October 15, 2022 @02:32AM (#33212325)
Not surprising. They would have been cancelled if they did not. Nowadays if you not actively against it you are obviously guilty.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by anonair on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:20AM (#33212584)
One doesn't need seeing the film to notice the racism in the title. The title could be "terrorist rehab", but it now looks like jihad is bad per se, while jihad for Muslims can mean anything from "struggle against self ego" to "defend country from invasion". All Muslim scholars denounce terrorism and yet she chose "jihad" in the title.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by aaplok on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:46AM (#33212709)
The article mentions that "jihad rehab" is the name of the Saudi program the subjects of the documentary are enrolled in. She didn't chose "jihad", she chose "jihad rehab".

"Terrorist rehab" would be quite an ill-suited name. There is no indication that the men in the documentary ever were terrorists, aside from one of them.

You could have suggested "Guantanamo rehab". That would have better qualified the men in the film than "terrorists". Even then I think it's unfair to call racist her decision to name the film after that Saudi program.

Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by anonair on Saturday October 15, 2022 @04:39PM (#33218398)
No, article mentions _her_ statement about the name. If you have a more reputable source for that, I will retract
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by molotovh on Saturday October 15, 2022 @02:04PM (#33217087)
If your issue is that you find the title racist, then your issue is with the Saudi Arabian government, not Ms. Smaker. The filmmaker accurately named her documentary after the subject of the film, which was a Saudi government program. If you read the article instead of immediately having a knee-jerk reaction to perceived "wrongspeak", you could easily have ascertained that information.
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by anonair on Saturday October 15, 2022 @04:41PM (#33218424)
I read the article, and only saw her account of the name. If you have more reputable source for that I will retract
Re:The Shameful Cancellation of Jihad Rehab by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Saturday October 15, 2022 @05:03AM (#33213120)
Famously, after Pasternak's Doctor Zhivago was awarded the Nobel Prize in literature, a flood of derogatory letters were published in Soviet newspapers, each beginning with "I have not read the novel..." As a result, Pasternak was forced to decline the Nobel Prize.