News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by romankolpak on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:30AM (#33164541)
Related personal anecdote:

I am experimenting with Tinder subscription at the moment, and it feels incredibly exploitative. When you make a profile, matches are frequent and you can tell that you show up for people. However it gradually falls down with time, and the only predictable and obvious way to get back up is to pay for Boosts and/or Priority Likes.

Right now my 6-month old profile gets ZERO likes outside of the time it's Boosted ($3 a pop or something). I get plenty once I'm boosted, so the profile attractiveness doesn't seem to be a factor.

It feels like the app's algorithms are rigged to gradually push you towards paid subscription options. There must be a huge invisible market of Tinder whales given how exploitative it is, gambling addiction, loneliness, and desperation for dates are correlated traits and I would absolutely bet on Tinder exploiting this heavily.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by Cloudef on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:38AM (#33164678)
Dating apps are really ethiically questionable. Forget the apps, meet people in real life like you are meant to be.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by Carrok on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:44AM (#33164753)
> meet people in real life like you are meant to be

Keep this gatekeeping nonsense to yourself. I met my wife of many years on a dating app. We probably never would have met by chance.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by mensetmanusman on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:51AM (#33164867)
Realizing there is survivorship bias might help people appreciate the complexities this topic.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by Cloudef on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:45AM (#33164781)
Good for you. Doesnt change the fact they are shady and made to mainly exploit people's weakness for money.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by denton-scratch on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:00PM (#33164988)
How is wanting to meet a partner "weakness"?
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by Cloudef on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:04PM (#33165052)
Loneliness can make people do dumb things, like waste money on scammy dating apps that artificially block you out unless you fetch the money.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by skyyler on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:18PM (#33165252)
Calling loneliness a "weakness" says a lot more about you than dating apps.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by SketchySeaBeast on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:54AM (#33164910)
> exploit people's weakness for money

Weakness?

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by Cloudef on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:57AM (#33164954)
Loneliness
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by SketchySeaBeast on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:14PM (#33165200)
I feel like that's just being human, not a weakness. Thy are exploiting humanities desire to form relationships.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by kzrdude on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:44PM (#33165557)
I'm sure you have some vulnerability in your humanity
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by SketchySeaBeast on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:56PM (#33165730)
For sure, the spirit is willing but the flesh is spongy and bruised. But in this case our ability and desire to form attachments is also a strength, I find it funny to be called a weakness.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by mikepurvis on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:49AM (#33164836)
If you've already graduated university, aren't part of a religious community, and don't want to do the bar/club scene, what does that leave? Friends of friends, or family introductions? Activity groups like sports/dance? Your workplace, or the gym? Neighbours?

Most of these are extremely hit and miss, and a lot of people have no interest in being hit on while trying to do their job or work out.

Dating sites/apps absolutely fill a need— you can argue that that need only exists because of systemic issues in how modern society works, but it's possible to tackle that in parallel to adopting a non-judgmental attitude toward those using the best tools available within the system we do currently have.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by Cloudef on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:55AM (#33164928)
Dating apps do not work because you are not actually present. You have the attention of hundreds of people at the same time, so unless you decide to meet up right away, the other party immediately loses interest. Most of the people are just looking for sex or something less serious, and the apps heavily paywall males. They are cancer.

Meeting through friends is probably the safest, as that at least gives you some safety that you arent meeting up with someone completely nuts.

Personally I met my date through a bar though.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by ketzo on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:41PM (#33165533)
I mean -- I've had multiple medium-to-long term, fulfilling relationships that started on dating apps. They do work sometimes.

Yeah, it's a shitty environment, and it's very much a numbers game (especially for hetero guys), but again -- you're coming from an extremely judgmental place.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by mattmaroon on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @01:27PM (#33166132)
The number of men with the attitude that the problem couldn’t possibly be the way they use the apps is astounding.

A female friend of mine took some very expensive online dating class run by a former data scientist from one of these apps and she started her own side business fixing mens profiles. I was very skeptical at first but I have several friends who’ve used her. Each of them went from basically no success at all to getting dates every week.

The good news is while there’s probably nothing you can do to make it a truly enjoyable experience, online dating can work quite well largely because the competition is so poor. Ever watch a female friend swipe? It’s amazing how bad most men are at this.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by edude03 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @02:00PM (#33166639)
Was it Logan Ury? If so I think that’s part of a much more complicated and nuanced discussion on self worth, self reflection, knowing what you want etc more than anything specific to “apps”
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by mattmaroon on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @03:21PM (#33167962)
I think the teacher of the class was female but I’m not certain! Honestly I’ve seen some of the profile transformations she’s done and they’re good. They got great results. And there’s nothing magical about them, just some good insights.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by mikepurvis on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @04:00PM (#33168499)
I can't claim to be any kind of expert, but there are a number of TikTok accounts that get into this kind of thing, like Eric Explains. One of the biggest principles is that many women come to an environment like a dating app with a lot of preconceived notions about the men they're going to find there— that they're all going to be sleazes, pathetic, desperate, bland, immature, out of shape, whatever.

So your #1 goal with a profile is to use the pictures to tell a story that challenges these preconceptions. For example:

- Overall, favour photos that other people took of you over selfies (communication: I have good people in my life and am not looking for a support system)

- A picture of you being domestic, like cuddling your pet, cooking, or even cleaning (communication: I have my shit together, can take care of myself, and am not looking for a substitute mom)

- A picture of you doing something active that you love (communication: I already have interesting passions and will have worthwhile things to talk about)

- A picture of you giving a presentation (communication: I'm a leader, people listen to me when I speak)

- A picture of you in a suit at an event (communication: I clean up nice, I get invited to fancy parties)

- A picture of you in an exotic location (communication: I travel and have varied experiences)

But the main thing is that the pictures tell a story far more than the words do, so use the pictures. Don't make the words a bland list of assertions about your personality, instead use that space to tell a joke or give a conversation prompt.

And then there's a few sort of obvious turn-offs to avoid, like the shirtless bathroom selfie, the fish pic, the pic with your ex, the joke that you're willing to lie about how you met. All of that just makes you blend in with the crowd rather than stand out.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by imiric on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:34PM (#33165441)
> Dating apps do not work

> unless you decide to meet up right away, the other party immediately loses interest.

I think you're contradicting yourself, and making an objective statement from your subjective experience.

Dating apps are best used to setup actual physical dates. They're the digital equivalent of making eye contact at a bar or party, and giving a stranger your contact information. All the while eliminating the uncertainty of whether the other person is even interested, based on initial physical appearance and whatever they decided to share in their profile.

> Meeting through friends is probably the safest

Sure, but that's always been the case. It's always been risky going on a date with a stranger, or a blind date. Dating apps make the blind date a bit safer, while substantially opening up the possible dating pool to beyond just via friends.

Are they predatory, full of dark patterns and exploit lonely men? Absolutely. But I'd still argue they're better than meeting a random person at the bar, evidenced by many people who do find suitable short or even long-term partners on them.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by Cloudef on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:44PM (#33165558)
Yes, I agree I have bit of biased view here. I do find it very unnatural to go to blind date with person I barely know. Compared to something lets say bar, it's less unnatural because you both just happened to be there, maybe you both came with some other friends and just happened to start talking to each other. To be honest, I've had better experiences meeting people through non dating online communities than from dating apps, because you already have kind of an idea how the person you are meeting is like.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by mikepurvis on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @01:03PM (#33165819)
> non dating online communities

How does the geographical aspect work? Are you mobile enough that you don't mind meeting a person that's a flight away? Or is it primarily online communities that are already geo-bound, like discords/reddits for particular cities?

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by Cloudef on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @01:16PM (#33165971)
In my case, there were both cases. Meeting people far away, but also locally. Sometimes we would gather somewhere as a group.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by blfr on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:13PM (#33165176)
> unless you decide to meet up right away, the other party immediately loses interest

Well, yeah. You should meet up right away. What else you gonna do? Flirt over text for weeks?

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by hahamrfunnyguy on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:40PM (#33165512)
This is how it's supposed to be done, after all the other person wants to meet you too. Typically, I make a suggestion of somewhere to meet during the first text conversation. Never had anyone decline the offer.

Most of my first dates have been enjoyable, even if I didn't see the person again. It's just pleasant casual conversation with a stranger.

I've only ever had one really bad first date, but now the story is quite entertaining. I had her meet me at a concert I was attending with friends. She spent the evening alternately hitting on my friends and crying in the corner. To be fair, I didn't have high expectations for that date anyway which is why I tried to fold it into something I was already doing.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by Cloudef on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:16PM (#33165230)
Actually get to known each other before we go over for a drink or lunch, instead of hurrying it up just to have an awkward time?
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by blfr on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:18PM (#33165253)
You can get to know each other in person. Why would it be any more awkward than over text.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by Cloudef on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:21PM (#33165276)
I don't know about you, but I don't usually meet up with someone just together that I don't know at all. It would be nice to talk at least for a while. It's different when you meet someone already in a social situation.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by throwaway289943 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:23PM (#33165305)
Another big reason why dating apps suck, is that people don't go on dates. People meet their partners in groups of friends of friends, at parties. Before dating apps, nobody would ask a stranger out for a date, and nobody wants to do that now either, so the apps is enabling something that people don't actually want.

It should be focused on getting together groups of friends of friends for parties instead.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by Cloudef on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:25PM (#33165330)
Even if you do, it usually feels very unnatural as you don't really know each other yet. I agree that meeting in a group works better.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by slater on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:53PM (#33165686)
Personals ads in newspapers have been a thing since forever
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by CapricornNoble on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @08:09PM (#33170977)
>>>Before dating apps, nobody would ask a stranger out for a date, and nobody wants to do that now either, so the apps is enabling something that people don't actually want.

Huh? Before dating apps, you would do things like go to the mall, and look for cute girls in the food court to start a conversation with. We were absolutely approaching strangers to ask out. Did you not date in the late 90s?

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by mikepurvis on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:19PM (#33165260)
> Most of the people are just looking for sex or something less serious...

Not in my limited experience browsing the 30-40 range in my area. There are a handful of profiles where it's clearly an ENM couple looking for playmates, but almost all the rest have the exhausted-sounding language of "serious only please", "no hookups/nsa", "please don't be a weirdo/cheater", "please have your shit together", etc.

> ... and the apps heavily paywall males. They are cancer.

Yes, absolutely. The current state of affairs sucks for everyone. But I'm not sure if meeting people at a bar is necessarily any guarantee of finding someone who isn't "completely nuts".

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by lmm on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @09:07PM (#33171441)
> almost all the rest have the exhausted-sounding language of "serious only please", "no hookups/nsa"

Which is notoriously one of the strongest indicators of a woman who's looking for hookups/nsa.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by c7DJTLrn on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @01:10PM (#33165904)
I'm pretty much in that position and still don't use the apps. It's like saying there's nothing to eat and settling for grass. For average males they'll provide a fleeting moment of hope only to utterly destroy self confidence after a few weeks. Better off not using them at all.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by kashunstva on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:56AM (#33164953)
> meet people in real life like you are meant to be.

Meant by whom - you? The form of this argument could be extended in any number of equally ludicrous directions where things were previously one way and now they are another, e.g. “Forget airplanes, walk like you are meant to.”

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by skyyler on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @01:37PM (#33166277)
I kind of agree with you, but expand "real life" to include "group chats local to your geographic location and/or hobby and/or interests"

Furries have been doing it like this for years and it works very well. I met my wife in a chatroom dedicated to making fun of people that misinterpret Hegel.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by mikepurvis on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:44AM (#33164765)
Agreed. It also seems extremely gross that you're initially pushed to buy Tinder Gold, but then only afterward realise there are still features locked behind Tinder Platinum, and even after that you'll probably spend still more buying packs of boosts and super-likes.

I know they're far from the only game in town, but this really feels like the behaviour of a monopoly entity that knows it can do basically whatever.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by nerdponx on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:14PM (#33165199)
If I were an unethical data scientist working at Tinder, I would actually reserve the best matches until later in the period, after the initial flurry of "visibility" subsides a bit. That way you are less likely to immediately find a good date or two in the first few matches, helping to ensure that you will not just unsubscribe next month, while providing you with enough tantalizing options that you think it makes sense to keep going. "Great matches started coming up, I had better renew so I don't lose out!"

It's like a slot machine that actively adjusts the odds as you play, in order to keep you hooked as long as possible.

I'm pretty solidly mediocre when it comes to "algorithm design" tasks like this one, so I thought of it you can bet for sure that someone at Tinder did too.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by idealmedtech on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @10:30PM (#33172047)
There's certainly no doubt in my mind that they save your "top" match, based on your swipe history and whether or not they've already matched you, to show up right after you use your last free swipe. Wait 12h and hope they show up again? Maybe, or maybe I'll spend the $2 to get that super like. Very scummy.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by orta on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @05:22AM (#33174633)
One of the protagonists in the book Version Control works in customer service in a role a lot like you're describing, it's a great read for anyone into sci-fi https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/25733442-version-control
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by mikepurvis on Thursday October 13, 2022 @11:03AM (#33191998)
Thanks for the recommendation! I have a long flight coming up so I'll check this out for sure.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by somedude895 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:48AM (#33164820)
Back when I was on Tinder I'd delete my profile and make a new one once every three months or so, seemed to do the trick.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by opportune on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @01:31PM (#33166189)
I am pretty sure they also boost you when you start using the app again after a period of inactivity, but not sure if the implementation/magnitude is different from the new-user bonus
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by no_time on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @03:15PM (#33167869)
I'm very suprised they are not using face tracking and/or device fingerprinting to thwart this.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by flutas on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:51PM (#33169694)
It's all speculation, but they _seem_ to track a large amount of data to try and check for "new profiles" that are old users starting a new account, supposedly for 3 months after you delete your account. These are the ones I've seen commonly talked about.

- Phone Number

- IP

- Device IDs

- Email

- Photo hashes

- Photo exif

- Facial recognition

- Linked Facebook, Instagram, Spotify accounts

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by welshwelsh on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:51AM (#33164859)
Honestly, I am ok with this system. Paying a couple dollars for a matchmaking service isn't a big deal. If you go to bars instead you will pay way more. An introduction to a potential partner is worth at least $50 in my opinion, if anything Tinder is too cheap.

There are too many guys on tinder and most of them are not serious, mindlessly swiping as a way of wasting time. If you filter out the free users and only match guys who pay for boost with girls, it's a much better ratio for those guys and a better experience for the women since guys who buy boost are more invested and more likely to follow through.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by hahamrfunnyguy on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:21PM (#33165286)
I don't mind paying something, but their goal of selling boosts, super-likes, etc runs counter to the goal of the customer which is to meet a compatible person IRL and then (presumably) stop using the site.

My experience with boosts is that they were counter-productive. While the boosts yield likes, but a lot of them would be profiles I'd already left-swiped on, should have been excluded by my filters, or just low-effort profiles. The same profiles would keep showing up in my feed too after I had swiped.

As for your second point, I think women do exactly the same thing. There's just more guys on the site so women are just getting a higher ratio low-effort likes. I'd say a good 50% of the profiles don't have anything written in them except a series of emojis or statements like "I don't know what to write here." or other really low effort content. Even the gold profiles sending messages would initiate a conversation with the dreaded "Hi." These interactions were always a complete waste of time, I just stopped responding to them after a while.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by michaelchisari on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:21PM (#33165287)
I agree, but a honest model has a flat subscription fee instead of promising matches for free and upselling through nudging and manipulation.

I haven't online dated in a long time, but if I ever do again, I'll go with a service that has a transparent pricing model with no free plan.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by blfr on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:10PM (#33165144)
I've made a similar comment before[1] but this is exactly right. The price-to-benefit ratio for Tinder is incredible. You can literally fill your calendar with dates for months on a budget that would last a couple of decent drinks.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30485955

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:32PM (#33165418)
Only if you've hit the genetic jackpot.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by notch656a on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:37PM (#33165470)
I've always wondered if online dating selects HARD (relatively to in-person invites) for looks. I don't look very pretty but when I was on the dating scene I could get probably half the women I talked to out on a date if I really tried. Being fairly ugly I tried tender and OkCupid for a year or two and was lucky to have someone accept once every few months and I had a 100% no-show rate where the counterparty backed out. Online dating seriously hurt my self esteem until a few months after I stopped.

I gave up and married someone meeting them the old fashioned way.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @01:56PM (#33166567)
For men it selects hard for height. Looks are secondary if you pass the magic threshold.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by alfnor on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @04:36PM (#33168909)
False. Women see your face before your height on dating apps, but vice versa IRL.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by valarauko on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @02:07PM (#33166761)
> I've always wondered if online dating selects HARD (relatively to in-person invites) for looks.

I think it does, since it's the primary determinant of selection. I also find that in-person personality can be more attractive, unlike profiles where you have fewer dimensions to go on. Likewise, I do think certain types of people do better online and some do better offline.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by Firmwarrior on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @05:43PM (#33169614)
I'm not the prettiest dude in the world, but I'm not really particularly ugly.. I look like a brown Matt Damon IRL.

I had absolutely zero luck with online dating back when I tried it around 2008. I think I just got downranked into oblivion by not gaming the system, since those dating sites use a ranking algorithm internally to gauge how attractive you are. If you click the "like" button on any woman you'd be willing to go on a coffee date with, it assumes you're a loser and hides you away.

Fortunately, you can network your way into a relationship the same way you can get a job.. just put out the word among friends, family, family friends, etc that you're looking for a girlfriend. Chances are you're within a couple of hops of hundreds or thousands of people. This isn't good for finding hookups or for incel jerks, but if you're ready to settle down it's the best method IMO.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by louissan on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:06PM (#33165084)
Well I'd rather go to a bar/pub anyway. Social, human beings, brawling to order a beer at the zinc, contact and all that? Not to mention you at least get the tipsiness/(more: drunk) if/when all else fails... 8>
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by throwaway289943 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:12PM (#33165159)
Same here, I can look at, meet, and chat with 5-10 girls in one evening in a bar, and get a pretty good impression of them. Takes months to do the same on a dating app, with heaps of added toxic behaviour/people that you don't get in a bar. Gave it up a long time ago..
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by nerdponx on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:15PM (#33165217)
Maybe I'm just socially inept, but I have never once managed to meet someone at a bar that wasn't already part of some bigger group that I was with.

Edit: that's actually untrue, there are exactly 2 instances where it happened in my life. They were in the kinds of bars that I would usually avoid (too many drunk people shouting over loud music), in areas far from where I lived, that had pretty strong "going out" cultures.

Edit 2: now that I think about it, I'm not exactly dashing handsome. I've historically done a lot better in "house party" type of settings, but again that's with people who are already friends of friends.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by briga on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @06:11PM (#33169909)
Have you tried to meet someone at a bar that wasn’t a part of your group?
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by Shugarl on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @12:43AM (#33172947)
I know that works to make friends, when you drunkenly, randomly start to talk to other people, or jump into conversations. But how does it work for meeting the opposite sex ? Being drunk for these kinds of things usually isn't good
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by throwaway289943 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:08PM (#33165108)
It's dishonest though, it should be clear that you get downgraded over time as well, and not just marketed as a "boost".
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by maerF0x0 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @04:00PM (#33168486)
IMO if the business model is to pay for impressions, I wish they'd be up front and just state and charge price per mille (or hundred or whatever). Instead you get an ambiguous "boost" with no accountability/metrics about what even happened? They could literally show you to no one and say "Oops, guess your profile sucks!"

The match rate thing is also kind of a lark because you don't care about matches. You care about matches with people you want to match with... in fact that kinda understates the ultimate goal -- you care about matches with someone who would be good for you (and you for them)... everything else is just vanity.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by jrnichols on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @06:33PM (#33170118)
unfortunately Tinder has become a lot less useful, and a rising number of OnlyFans creators are using it as a vehicle for advertising. They'll match with a guy, chat like normal, and then start dropping hints about their "spicy site."

it's really kind of depressing, honestly. Guys on dating sites are viewed as transactions. Tinder isn't alone with this - they're on multiple sites doing the same thing.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by hahamrfunnyguy on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @12:01PM (#33165003)
I am sure that is the case, their goal is to keep you swiping as much as possible and buying their upgrades. I had a Gold membership for about a year or so. Boosts didn't work for me, I found that the boots only yielded a lot of low-quality likes (ie: profiles, that my filters should have rejected). I also continuously had profiles showing up that didn't meet my filter criteria and that I'd already swiped left on just days before.

I ended up emailing support and making the case that the site wasn't working as advertised or even as support said it was supposed to be working. I ended up getting a full refund.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by LtWorf on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @01:17PM (#33165986)
2-3 years ago you could use a GPS faker, stay somewhere random a week and then return and you'd have many matches again.

I experimented a lot with it because I used to work at a different online dating company (where I was also doing scummy things).

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by onetimeusename on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @02:04PM (#33166701)
ya. I pay about $100 per month over a few apps and if you read the sales pages it's clear they deliberately disable useful features if you don't pay so you are paying to have an "enhanced experience". That alone should suggest they don't really have a value proposition for your life. Maybe that's because they don't want to be sued by promising to sell relationship success. But they keep user statistics secret and I suspect that is because the statistics would tell the truth about what they sell. I have had a bad experience but I don't think HN is the the place to talk about it.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by btbuildem on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @03:21PM (#33167973)
It IS exploitative, by design. If you don't have the paid service, they'll never show the people who liked you in your normal stack. But once you pay, they've identified you as willing to pay, so the incentives are at extreme odds (any time you get a match, it's a risk for Tinder that you won't pay again)
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by cryptonector on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @04:46PM (#33169015)
I wonder if for younger people now the best way to meet dates is off-line. Well, I suspect it's always been so, but the question is whether the culture for young people will be decidedly on the off-line side.
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by jesterson on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @10:52AM (#33177847)
> It feels like the app's algorithms are rigged to gradually push you towards paid subscription options

I'd be extremely surprised if it happened to be otherwise.

Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by mock-possum on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @08:22PM (#33185610)
I've only ever used ok cupid back in the day, not tinder, but - why do likes matter? Can't you still use the search function to find people you're interested, and begin interacting my messaging them?
Re:Why you should never pay for online dating (OkCupid) (2010) by OkGoDoIt on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:50AM (#33201138)
No, not anymore. OkCupid is just a stack of people you swipe right or left on now, just like Tinder.