Yes, ISA's matter, to a point. And yes, ARM64 and RISC-V are much closer to 'best practice' ISA design than x86 with all its legacy baggage. But enough better to make AMD&Intel throw away the x86 market and their position in that as explained in the parent comment? No effing way.
It doesn't seem like ARM and maybe RISC-V will have the same issues, at leatin terms of magnitude so I don't really see why it matters.
I think long term they risk ending up like Canon/Nikon in the DSLR market when Sony came along with the new fangled mirrorless technology - sometimes you gotta disrupt yourself and skate to where the pick is going.
Problem is that the endpoint is much less attractive (for them) than where they are now and the transition will be very, very messy. At a time when the business is under strain for other reasons it's a risky move.
Should have done it a few years ago - when they had process lead - but hindsight is a wonderful thing!
Ruthless, yes. But mistake?
My point is that it doesn't matter how good the architecture is or if a few firms follow you - you need it to be successful in the market.
If you think Itanium was a cunning plan to take a few competitors out of the market only to abandon a few years later then we'll have to disagree.
It was not necessarily the plan to abandon the architecture, but once it was won, it also wasn't terribly important to keep going. Much like most corporate takeovers to this day.
Intel would have been happy to keep the market segmented for a few more years, but what happened instead was that the market vacuum was filled by Linux and x86 instead. That would likely have happened sooner or later anyway, but there you go.
ARM was meaningless during those days.
If Itanium continued to implode with no other alternatives, PowerPC would have been the most likely to pick up the slack. The main reason why it more or less failed was from a lack of volume to pay for leading edge R&D for the process side. Without AMD64, Intel's Itanium obsession combined with the mid aughts dennard scaling wall catching everyone with their pants down would have given a nice bit of breathing room for PowerPC to exceed x86-32.
https://www.itprotoday.com/windows-78/windows-nt-powerpc-no-...
They also literally were shipping an NT derived kernel for Xbox 360 into the 2010s.
And that small bit doesn't address the core of what I'm saying, that PowerPC support would have seen even more support if the two options were that and Itanium.
Which doesn't matter which of us is right, because AMD created AMD64 and killed Itaninum in the process.
Surely they are not doing that again. Well ...
Had it not been the case, and everyone would be using Itanium no matter what.
That's quite a strong statement.
Take it or leave it, and with Wintel going Itanium, that would be it.
Mobile phones and tablets are mostly consumer devices, Apple's ARM laptops are only relevant for about 10% of the desktop market.
Outside embedded devices and electronic appliances, every other CPU is a rounding error in what concerns the general public.
People not just gone use really bad processors because they have no other options.
Apparently people didn't have any problem using the bad 80x86 architecture like so many complain around here.
People would rather run server workloads on Unix rather then using windows with shitty expensive processors.
People that are unwilling to move to Unix very likely just stick around on 32bit instead.
We were running Windows 2000 in production, alongside Aix, HP-UX and Solaris workloads across all our customers back in 1999 - 2003, before we got hit in the first .com startup crysis.
At some point the x86 companies will either have to respond or see more and more people migrate to either Apple or other arm laptops (serious alternatives are not here yet, but a few producers are starting to experiment)
Every release AMD has done lately has two sides: side A is for the same compute as previously, you use less watts; side B is for the same watts, you get more compute; the third side is often oh yeah, you can pump a lot more watts (Zen4 almost doubled TDP on the high end parts, to compete with Intel's raised TDPs).
If you want an energy efficient AMD machine, you just have to limit the wattage. It may or may not get all the way to M1/M2 level of efficiency, but it's decent. Of course, lots of people are going to prefer performance, and it makes sense for AMD to allow that if system design can handle the power supply and cooling requirements. Apple gets to design their CPUs around an assumption that clock speed won't need to scale because cooling will not be sufficient for astronomical clocks, but Intel and AMD are in a competitive market where clock speed sells chips, so everything needs to scale. Arm's more relaxed memory model helps Apple as well.
This chip shows why Intel would like RISC-V. The core ISA is RISC-V, but every other piece of the chip is proprietary and patented Intel stuff. They are far ahead of almost everyone in these areas, so they don't have much to fear in their current markets from the ISA itself.
Few companies have the ability, desire, or connections to spend billions designing a next-gen chip. China has thoroughly proved this. They have designed for x86, Alpha, MIPS, ARM, RISC-V, etc, but none of their designs were particularly good. For example, they recently released their Phytium D2000 chip. It was basically a clone of A72 with improvements, but chips and cheese analysis[0] showed that the supposed improvements actually resulted in a worse design.
If designing a good high-performance chip was down to just ISA, then everyone would be doing it.
Meanwhile, x86 patents for SSE2 and before have expired (with SSE3 expiring in 2023-4). Analysis of real-world code shows that only a couple percent use something beyond SSE3 and pretty much all of that has fallbacks for SSE2. There's already not much left to keep companies from designing x86-compatible chips (Apple's Rosetta x86 compatibility tracks this expiration exactly).
At the same time, x86 is incapable of competing in MCU and DSP markets and Intel's phone offerings were flatly rejected and only competitive when they had the huge advantage of being a couple fabrication nodes ahead of their competitors. Intel paid billions trying to make it happen, but never had many sales outside of the lemonade they made in the embedded market.
Intel and AMD would far rather have a non-proprietary solution like RISC-V win than a proprietary one like ARM.
[0] https://chipsandcheese.com/2022/09/29/chinas-phytium-d2000-b...
Also, they tried to move to other ISAs they owned. Trying to move from their position to 3rd party or open ISAs would make even less sense.
They use RISC-V to compete in markets other then where x86 is dominant. That seems pretty clear.
The important x86 patents are all expiring. Nothing would prevent a third party from recreating AVX using different instruction designs that would avoid those patents too.
The non-commodity stuff is all the interconnects, memory controllers, caches, etc. Having access to the Athlon XP or Pentium 4 cache, interconnect, or MC designs simply doesn't matter. Intel has these bits locked down already.
As the ISA is commodity, the only parts that matter are efficiency, compatibility, extensibility, and cost.
RISC-V allows them to penetrate new markets where x86 either can't compete or people don't believe it could compete because it is much more efficient at the low end. On the high-end, simplifying stuff in one area means you have the ability to increase the complexity and performance somewhere else.
On the compatibility front, Apple has already forced their hand by being compatible enough to offer a path to ARM.
x86 is not so extensible at this point. Lots of the best instruction encodings are wasted on stuff like BCD and even x86_64 has lots of legacy and extensibility issues. RISC-V not only solves this problem, but Intel is big enough to exert a lot of pressure on future standards.
Cost is a problem that isn't to be underestimated. ARM charges 1-3% per chip. That's something like 8-10% of gross margins. RISC-V means Intel can get a new ISA that is already being picked up by everyone (rather than spending billions on forcing a new one only to fail as they've already done).
In short, there are a lot of advantages and very few downsides to Intel making the switch.
A modern foundry is expected to have a suite of hard IP blocks to drop on a design to cover PPA sensitive blocks like VPUs someone would want, and blocks with analog bits like PHYs. Best way to ameliorate people's concerns is to have shipped a chip that runs with those blocks.
What are the three? I can only think of two: IA64 and i960, but those weren't departures.
I worked on Itanium (and McKinely, and Madison). They were never intended for desktops. (In fact, back then there was still this notion of Desktop and Workstation, which is essentially dead today.)
The i960 was a fantastic CPU and I only know the wikipedia version of what happened to it, since it was before my time (well, they were producing it when I worked there, but I was ignorant of the climate). However, it was never a "move away from x86" product, it had great # of embedded customers. Again, never for desktops.
I think it's fair to say though it was intended to be a move away from the main PC microprocessor line (which you can argue traced a path through 8080 to 8086 and beyond ) and ultimately replace it at the high end - so in spirit similar to Itanium even if not an 'x86 replacement'.
8008 was almost a full decade before the launch of the iAPX 432.
The roots of x86 were in one of the first major ISAs ever created (and something like the 2nd or 3rd microprocessor architecture) which is pretty remarkable when you think about it.
I think there was a good amount of ecosystem issues there. Android x86 phones shipped and were ok, but too many apps shipped native code without an x86 flavor; I don't remember if Google had per-arch builds on Play Store yet, but those also cause issues because people pull those builds and host them on apkg sites, then users have problems when installing them on wrong arch phones.
Intel canceled the atom for phones lines days before Microsoft demoed Continuum, which would have been an obvious outlet for an x86 phone. Of course, Microsoft threw in the towel on WM10 before launch too, so maybe Intel wasn't willing to stick it out because they saw Microsoft was going to mess it up. In an alternate reality, the Lumia 950 would be a phone in your pocket and an x86 desktop running real apps on your desk, instead of stuck running app store apps and (pre-chromium) Edge only.
Short of that, I expect ARM or RISC-V to become the dominant ISA on server and clients come 3-7 years and where do they go from there? Become the next PPC?
i.e. what if the M1 peo/ultra had x86 cores in addition to ARM? Woud that have made the transition easier from a SW perspective? Could Intel have implemented a translation layer better than Apple owing to IP constraints?
impossible.
rosetta 2 is for a relatively short transition period, not something companies like apple/intel would pour huge amount of $ into it. with such limited funding & expected life expectancy in mind, it is fair to say that rosetta 2 is already close to be perfect.
also, intel has a track record for producing software with horrible quality. it is vastly different from apple which is doing very good in a long list of software projects for decades. just look at the negative comments regarding Intel's most recent ARC video card software -
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k6WDvK41fms
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I8pdXvbW71E
let's be crystal clear - Intel and Apple are not operating on the same level here, their market cap has a 20x gap for a very very good reason. we are talking about the resting & vesting company that pushed for about 5% per annual performance increase for their desktop products for like 8-10 years in a row.
Second, Intel and AMD's x86 and AMD64 are the dominant platform on server and desktop market today. ARM instruction set architecture (ISA) dominates the mobile platform and is only now competing with Intel and AMD on the desktop and server market. If Intel or AMD drop support for x86 and AMD64, and migrate to ARM, it will make ARM the dominant ISA on which all IoT, mobile, desktop and server softwares run. This is obviously not in Intel or AMD's interest. Migrating to RISC-V would mean they have to help promote a completely new ISA and help developers migrate their software to it. Doing so will also kill the x86 and AMD64 platform.
So unless RISC-V ISA actually offers some real technical advantage (like drastically lowering the power requirement and boosting computing performance) it really makes no sense for Intel and AMD to shift to it.
Note that the news here is not that Intel and SiFive have built a RISC-V chip but how SiFive (who have ventured into making RISC-V chips) has partnered with Intel Foundry Service to make the chips in Intel's fab. This is Intel diversifying to also make chips for others in its foundry like, Samsung and TSMC already do.
SiFive don't make RISC-V chips, except in small volumes as a demonstration. Their business is licensing CPU cores to companies that do make chips.
"Horse Creek", as its naming style suggests, is an Intel product that uses licensed SiFive CPU cores. SiFive will use the chip to make high priced dev boards. We don't know yet who else will use it.
The apparent success of the project is likely to get other SiFive customers to, as you say, use Intel Foundry Services instead of the traditional TSMC or Samsung.
I don't know whether Intel is designing high performance RISC-V cores of their own. It's not unlikely. But there are also others announced to be providing cores to Intel Foundry Services including Rivos who are developing an M1-class RISC-V core (they have a number of Apple's core designers, including some of the founders of PA Semi who Apple bought to establish their CPU design team in the first place)
Intel wants to keep the ability to serve the Chinese market, that means in the long terms having RISC-V offerings, hence the investment in SiFive.
Unlike Ottelini, Gelsinger is not a bean-counter who sold off StrongARM/XScale to Marvell and thus made Intel irrelevant to the ARM market, and by extension to mobile computing.
Firstly, adopting Arm would mean giving their blessing to an architecture that is now competing with x86 head on in key markets. That would only accelerate the demise of x86. So unless they have absolutely world beating products available on day 1, I don't think that's going to happen.
Secondly, adopting either architecture means that they would remove a key part of the 'x86 moat' and open up competition from anyone else with deep pockets who can put together a top quality silicon design team.
So I think it's likely that ultimately - whatever ISA they adopt - they will look for any way they can to distinguish themselves from the competition and avoid the commoditisation of their products.
Finally, just to add that supporting RISC-V - which is clearly competing successfully with Arm at the low end at the moment - helps to weaken a competitor so might be seen as a shrewd commercial move irrespective of any longer term plans.