News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by hutzlibu on Sunday October 02, 2022 @02:07PM (#33058573)
"And after your opponent overshoots--you just lost a ton of energy--and energy is everything in aerial combat. "

The idea is, to be able to make the kill, after you are now behind. Then it does not matter, if you are too slow.

But wikipedia indeed says, this manoever has never been confirmed in real air combat, so yes, its usefullness is quite limited.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by twawaaay on Sunday October 02, 2022 @02:29PM (#33058767)
The problem is, you are now not only behind but also much slower than your opponent. And as parent poster mentioned, energy is everything.

I would also point out both aircraft are in straight and level flight, basically in formation, with the pilot composed and prepared. This is not how a dogfight looks like.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by Sightline on Sunday October 02, 2022 @10:26PM (#33062818)
"you are now not only behind but also much slower than your opponent."

That's what HMD's are for: (ignore the shit music) https://youtu.be/-D9ZhmFxz3M?t=194

Re:Cobra Maneuver by meheleventyone on Sunday October 02, 2022 @03:48PM (#33059501)
> The idea is, to be able to make the kill, after you are now behind. Then it does not matter, if you are too slow.

Air combat is rarely 1vs1 so being slow means you get killed by someone else.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by MikeBVaughn on Sunday October 02, 2022 @04:39PM (#33060005)
Based on what I've read from people vastly more informed than me, this absolutely 100% seems to be the case.

Even beyond that, the general impression I get w.r.t stuff like supermaneuverability is that it's a much better use of money to ensure that most fights never even make it to the point where the stuff like the cobra seems like a good idea. Given the choice between 1) "marginally improving survivability in comparatively low-energy corner-case states" and 2) "increasing the odds that the fight never makes it to the merge," #2 seems like a much better choice in terms of money spent and pilots kept alive. (Though a counterpoint, I guess, based my my casual understanding, would be that making the judgment too heavily in favor of #2 was part of what hampered the USAF and Navy's air-to-air combat capabilities in Vietnam)

Re:Cobra Maneuver by onlyrealcuzzo on Sunday October 02, 2022 @03:29PM (#33059326)
Dumb question - why can't planes shoot in reverse? It seems like this would be useful for these situations.

I get that it would be hard to aim - but can't computers do that?

Re:Cobra Maneuver by jleahy on Sunday October 02, 2022 @03:32PM (#33059357)
Energy. If you fire a missile to your rear then it needs to first accelerate to your original speed just to be staying still, only then can it accelerate towards the target.

An AIM-9X can do this, but the kill probability drops rapidly as you move off boresight.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by tengwar2 on Sunday October 02, 2022 @05:35PM (#33060526)
This was addressed by the Pye Wacket missile (http://astronautix.com/p/pyewacket.html) which was to be developed for the B-70 bomber. It was to be a 500lb circular (lenticular) missile which could be launched with its thrust vector pointing in any direction relative to the direction of flight.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by leeoniya on Sunday October 02, 2022 @03:38PM (#33059418)
> only then can it accelerate towards the target

but in a dogfight (where this move is presumably useful) the target is not stationary, it's moving towards the missile. if all the missile does is accelerate to stay still, it will still hit the target at 700mph

Re:Cobra Maneuver by pishpash on Sunday October 02, 2022 @03:56PM (#33059565)
In a vacuum. The aerodynamics aren't possibly the same.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by Karellen on Sunday October 02, 2022 @06:32PM (#33061025)
Surely the aerodynamics are better for firing a missile backwards.

If you fire it forwards, the missile has to accelerate through whatever air resistance you're both already experiencing through even more air resistance to get to the target. That's hard.

If you fire backwards, the missile uses air resistance to accelerate towards (i.e. slow down) towards the target. Even when it goes through 0mph relative to the air and continues to accelerate, the resistance will be much less as it approaches an even higher closing velocity in a shorter period of time.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by fakethenews2022 on Sunday October 02, 2022 @10:06PM (#33062683)
Modern fighters are all about sensing and targeting the enemy first since missiles are so deadly. The missiles are much faster than the planes so which way the missile is pointed at matters less and most of the time it is better to be pointed forward.

So the optimizations and tradeoffs are in sensing and targeting further away or being able to rotate a sensor to target an enemy off bore.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by usefulcat on Sunday October 02, 2022 @11:56PM (#33063313)
If you fire it backwards, when it first launches it will be traveling backwards relative to the airflow. So you would have to make a missile that can fly forwards or backwards. Probably not impossible but it must add some difficulty.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by leeoniya on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:43AM (#33064215)
hmm, yeah that sounds challenging, but spacex does it when landing the first stage :)
Re:Cobra Maneuver by mumblemumble on Sunday October 02, 2022 @08:38PM (#33062023)
I would guess that the speed at which air moves over the missile's control surfaces has a large effect on its ability to steer to meet the target.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by mizzao on Sunday October 02, 2022 @10:37PM (#33062897)
But, missiles can't maneuver at 0mph airspeed even if traveling at 600mph in the frame of reference of a plane.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by bornfreddy on Sunday October 02, 2022 @03:39PM (#33059425)
What about guns? Relative speed against the enemy is the same no matter if you shoot forward or backward. Or am I missing something?
Re:Cobra Maneuver by avereveard on Sunday October 02, 2022 @04:28PM (#33059894)
You need a backward facing radar for modern fire control targeting calculating a solution. These are heavy and large and will interfere with engine placement.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by Maursault on Sunday October 02, 2022 @03:47PM (#33059490)
Bullets don't move at the speed of light.[1] Shoot a bullet backwards off a bullet train, that bullet's ground speed is less than if shot from the ground while stationary. Similarly, shoot a bullet forward off a bullet train, that bullet's ground speed is more than if shot from the ground from a stationary position. Shoot bullets backwards off a jet moving Mach 3 (just sayin') those 1700mph bullets will still be moving in the forward direction of the jet at 600mph relative to the ground.

[1] They should use rear-facing lasers!

Re:Cobra Maneuver by leereeves on Sunday October 02, 2022 @03:58PM (#33059595)
That's true in the ground's frame of reference.

But in the plane's frame, where both planes are roughly stationary and the wind is moving 100s of mph backwards, bullets fired backwards move faster.

And for aerial combat I would argue the plane's frame is the important one.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by jasamer on Sunday October 02, 2022 @03:57PM (#33059587)
But the bullet will still hit the plane following you at roughly 1700mph (you could say, the plane will crash into the bullet at that speed, but it‘s the same result), because it‘s also moving at Mach 3.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by hef19898 on Monday October 03, 2022 @05:57AM (#33065388)
Good luck trying a Cobra with a Blavkbird, a plane that needs a third of the US to make a 180 turn at full speed.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by ozim on Sunday October 02, 2022 @04:01PM (#33059623)
But the guy that is pursuing you will still be going after you in around Mach 3 so he will go through your bullets like they would be traveling his direction at 600mph.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by malloci on Sunday October 02, 2022 @04:38PM (#33060001)
This really only applies if shooting at a target behind you that is either stationary or moving much slower than you.

If the target is moving at (or nearly at) the same speed as you then those velocities effectively cancel out

Re:Cobra Maneuver by jawarner on Sunday October 02, 2022 @04:06PM (#33059674)
Yeah but your enemy is also moving forward because they’re trailing you.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by dingaling on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:56AM (#33064685)
R-73 and AGM-88 can also launch 'over the shoulder'
Re:Cobra Maneuver by rafale on Sunday October 02, 2022 @05:19PM (#33060395)
In theory it's possible to build such system. But dogfights are gonna be extremely rare in the future. The US Air Force believes more in stealth and beyond visual range (BVR) engagements. And so far, given the lead they have in those areas, they are unmatched in the skies.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by cm2187 on Sunday October 02, 2022 @04:25PM (#33059866)
I would imagine you need to install a second cannon. I think these days dogfights are fairly unlikely, jet fighters are more likely to shoot each others beyond the horizon with the advantage to the side with the missiles with the longest range. A second cannon is a lot of weight for a very remote use case.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by onlyrealcuzzo on Sunday October 02, 2022 @08:28PM (#33061939)
But when you're in a disadvantage with conventional guns... if you had guns that could shoot from any direction - wouldn't you not be in a disadvantage anymore?
Re:Cobra Maneuver by TylerE on Sunday October 02, 2022 @04:58PM (#33060200)
Fighter guns are fixed. You aim by pointing the whole airframe.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by ninkendo on Sunday October 02, 2022 @05:33PM (#33060507)
I think the operative question is, why must the guns be fixed? Wouldn’t it be useful for guns to be on turrets that can aim in other directions?

We do it with helicopters (complete with automated aiming), and we used do it with bombers in WW2, after all.

I’m sure the answer has to do with aerodynamics, and the general rarity of close-range dogfighting in the first place, that make such a design impractical.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by giantrobot on Sunday October 02, 2022 @06:49PM (#33061194)
> I’m sure the answer has to do with aerodynamics

It's both aerodynamics and mass. The main guns on most western fighters is the M61 Vulcan which is a 20mm rotary gun. The F-35 mounts a 25mm GAU-12 rotary gun. These are both pretty big guns and are typically mounted internally on the jet. Trying to fit one in a turret would not be practical, it would have tons of drag. In order to be able to rotate and elevate the gun it would need a lot of heavy duty motors to be able to actuate at fighter jet speeds.

Even if such a thing nominally worked, that space and mass could go to missiles. Missiles are far more likely to be used than some gun turret. A bore sight mounted canon is far more useful since the pilot is already going to be pointing the whole plane.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by justsomehnguy on Sunday October 02, 2022 @07:08PM (#33061318)
> I’m sure the answer has to do with aerodynamics

The need for the fighters to have a good aerodynamic. Non-fighters and multi-role fighters have the gun pods.

https://www.weaponsystems.net/system/1049-HH13%20-%20SPPU-22

https://www.weaponsystems.net/system/567-SPPU-6

Re:Cobra Maneuver by NovemberWhiskey on Monday October 03, 2022 @12:03PM (#33069368)
https://www.flickr.com/photos/13476480@N07/38271566385

The 20mm cannon on an F-16 is the entire assembly labeled as items 63, 72, 73 and the ammunition is 78.

How do you envisage this as other than a fixed installation?

Re:Cobra Maneuver by TylerE on Monday October 03, 2022 @01:57PM (#33071212)
Yeah. The guns in a typical WW2 bomber were M2 brownings...which are less than 100lbs.

It's the square-cube law in action (twice over). Going from a 12.7mm to a 20-25mm bullet... twice the diameter, four times the crosssection, eight times the mass.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by bolasanibk on Sunday October 02, 2022 @03:35PM (#33059390)
Some have: B-29 tail turret https://media.defense.gov/2010/Jun/14/2000352211/-1/-1/0/100...

I am guessing mostly space and weight are at a premium in an airplane.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by trevorishere on Sunday October 02, 2022 @05:20PM (#33060399)
B-52 was the last USAF bomber to have a rear-ward facing guns. During the Gulf War, one of two theories that a rear-ward facing gunner turned on his defensive fire control system and was hit by friendly fire after an F4 released anti-radiation (HARM) missile in the blind. The AGM-88 locked on to the DFCS and blew off the rear section of the BUFF -- which was then nicknamed "In HARM's Way".

https://theaviationgeekclub.com/exclusive-former-buff-gunner...

Re:Cobra Maneuver by usrusr on Sunday October 02, 2022 @04:44PM (#33060066)
The correct tense is had. In the age of air to air missiles, a chasing plane would never bother getting into range. (but that does make me wonder if anti missile point defense might ever come to flying carriers. A part of me wants to joke that those would likely make the B-52 reach its bicentennial)