News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Visited Bucha Today by downvoteme1 on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:39PM (#33030231)
Well if Ukraine did not have the American made weapons, they would have folded in less than a month. The United States has spent close to 100B in aid for Ukraine in the last 6 months and other amounts of money by the EU as aid. All told it is about 5-10x Russia’s yearly military budget.

All in all, Russia is a very weak country with less than 1.5T GDP. As a result, any infusion of huge sum on money by external actors will tilt the balance in the favor of the party that gets the money .

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by wahern on Thursday September 29, 2022 @11:00PM (#33030373)
> As a result, any infusion of huge sum on money by external actors will tilt the balance in the favor of the party that gets the money.

Counterpoint: Afghanistan. Money and matériel are surprisingly ineffective without the people and institutions capable of leveraging them.

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by mcv on Friday September 30, 2022 @04:45AM (#33032519)
Exactly. The reason it's worth it to send those weapons, is because Ukrainians themselves are so eager to fight for their country. That is the massive difference between Ukraine on one hand, and Afghanistan and Iraq on the other; Ukrainians know exactly what they're fighting for, and what they're fighting against. I don't think it's possible to break their fighting spirit.

All that spin about NATO fighting Russia to the last Ukrainian is wrong. It's the Ukrainians themselves who want to fight for their country, with or without outside help. The outside help just makes it easier, but they would have fought either way.

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by foverzar on Friday September 30, 2022 @09:01AM (#33034281)
Why imply that Ukrainians motivation somehow excludes NATO from the equation?

NATO provides intelligence, training, counsel and supplies. You can't just pretend it's not involved and that at some point this war didn't become Russia's proxy war with NATO.

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by mcv on Friday September 30, 2022 @09:28AM (#33034561)
Russia may see it as a proxy war, but Ukrainians don't. To them, it's entirely about the future and freedom of Ukraine.

You've got to understand that while the current generation of Ukrainians grew up in relative freedom, their parents and grandparents grew up in the Soviet Union. And now with Putin trying to subjugate Ukraine, they fear that their children may grow up in a similar situation, and possibly worse, with all the Russian talk of genocide.

So that's why they're fighting so hard. They're fighting for their lives, their freedom, and that of their children and grandchildren. That's an incredibly powerful motivator, and I'm absolutely convinced that they'd fight just as hard without foreign support. But that support does give them a better fighting chance, enabling them to fight Russia on equal footing, instead of relying mostly on partisan/guerilla warfare, which is actually what NATO expected to happen.

With or without support, I don't think this is a war that Russia could possibly win; there's just too much at stake for Ukraine, and not enough for Russia. People are generally eager to fight for their own lives and freedom, but not to subjugate others. Especially not a brother nation, as Ukrainians and Russians used to see each other before this.

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by foverzar on Friday September 30, 2022 @10:54AM (#33035721)
IMO, these bitter-sweet kind of "freedom fighting" narratives just too rarely represent real life, and the iceberg of this conflict is surely huge.

There is too much "nothing happened at Tienanmen Square" kind of stuff for "long-sought freedom" kind of scenarios to be believable.

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by mcv on Friday September 30, 2022 @01:45PM (#33038118)
I don't deny that it's rare, but this is a pretty clear and blatant case of it.

That the people of China don't fight for freedom like this is a completely different issue, though maybe not as different as the reason Russian don't. For Ukraine, the situation is quite different, though: they have tasted freedom for 30 years, and there's a clear external party who undeniably wants to take it away from them. Can't get much clearer than that.

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by foverzar on Saturday October 01, 2022 @07:31AM (#33045778)
It's only that clear and blatant, when you cozily watch it on TV. A nice captivating narrative with clear morals, "good", "bad" and all the other storybook stuff that literally never happens in real life.

I'm sorry, but I just feel like your impressions of it are naive, as you reason in categories that don't have weight for real actual individuals in real actual life.

"Fighting for freedom after tasting it for 30 years" is something that only exists in storybooks. In reality it's always powerful people making the decisions and then agitating other people into submission.

Real individuals are preoccupied with much more mundane things, like providing for their families and so on. Ukrainians, Russians, Chinese, whatever. Denying them this is a very typical dehumanization and manipulation tactics, commonly found in western supremacist culture, i.e. "why don't they fight for freedom" tropes.

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by mcv on Saturday October 01, 2022 @07:17PM (#33051086)
I suggest you read and watch a bit more about how Ukrainians themselves feel about this situation. Their fighting spirit is higher than I've ever seen in a war. And it makes total sense if you think about why.

Yes, powerful people make the decisions, but those decisions are meaningless if nobody obeys them. You see that in Russia without hundreds of thousands of people fleeing the country in order to avoid conscription. They have no faith whatsoever in Putin's war, and don't want to fight in it. Ukraine, on the other hand, doesn't just have much of its own population willing to do what they can, they also have many foreign volunteers who believe sufficiently in their cause to help them. That is not something that happens when the decision only comes from the top. This is a massive difference between Russia and Ukraine, and it's visible in the vastly different morale of the soldiers on the ground.

> Real individuals are preoccupied with much more mundane things, like providing for their families and so on.

Yes, but how are you going to do that when your country is being invaded by someone who wants you dead? This is exactly why Ukrainians are so eager to fight and Russians are not: the effect the war has on them personally.

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by supergirl on Friday September 30, 2022 @05:07PM (#33040820)
it's silly to compare Ukraine with Afghanistan. Ukraine was an important part of USSR. so they were once the nr. 2 super power in the world. morale helps but it's far from the deciding factor. they were preparing for some time, it's easier to defend, they get huge help from tens of countries. Russia went it too weak. they assembled a force equal in size to Ukraine but you need much more if you're the attacker.
Re:I Visited Bucha Today by riku_iki on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:58PM (#33030353)
I think you are heavily making things up. US heavy weapons started arriving like 3 months from when invasion started, US aid is very far from 100B.
Re:I Visited Bucha Today by dprice1 on Thursday September 29, 2022 @11:10PM (#33030430)
I was curious about these competing claims, so I googled for the answer.

https://www.defense.gov/News/Releases/Release/Article/317337...

Dated Sept. 28, 2022

"In total, the United States has now committed approximately $16.9 billion in security assistance to Ukraine since January 2021. Since 2014, the United States has committed approximately $19 billion in security assistance to Ukraine more than $16.2 billion since the beginning of Russia’s unprovoked and brutal invasion on February 24."

I'm not sure that all of the money/material has yet reached Ukraine. But that is what is said to be committed.

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by nosuchthing on Friday September 30, 2022 @02:17AM (#33031587)
Most of the weapons given to Ukraine have been lost and unaccounted for.

CBS published this report on the missing weapons stolen by corrupt groups operating within Ukraine. Shortly afterwards they were forced to amend a statement that someone is trying to track the newer shipments, without explaining any sort of actual plan for accountability.

War is racketeering. https://youtube.com/watch?v=ZWzxbS8eUKc

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by _kbh_ on Friday September 30, 2022 @02:31AM (#33031654)
This story was retracted by CBS because it turned out to be hugely misleading and is no where near the truth about the situation today. Trying to pass it off as such is at best misleading and at worst actively malicious.

But even going down that path of thinking, it’s amazing Ukraine has decimated the Russian armed forces with only a fraction of the weapons they were supplied with!. /s.

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by nosuchthing on Friday September 30, 2022 @03:17AM (#33031937)
The story was not retracted by CBS, they only removed a quote.

You seem motivated to hide corruption lol

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corruption_in_Ukraine

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukrainian_mafia

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by qaq on Friday September 30, 2022 @04:44AM (#33032511)
This is the funniest angle that Russian propoganda stopped pushing like a month ago because they realized how bad it makes their army look.
Re:I Visited Bucha Today by _kbh_ on Friday September 30, 2022 @03:33AM (#33032044)
I’m motivated to refute Russian propaganda. Something you seem motivated to spread. The quote was the only part that talked any solid numbers about aid to Ukraine, so how can you even make and analysis.

You also never mentioned the quote is from the very start of the war and how the situation of supplies is very different now.

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by nosuchthing on Friday September 30, 2022 @04:07AM (#33032265)
CBS is America, not Russian? The history of Ukrainian political corruption predates the war from Russia.

Russia is a corrupt aggressor, but that does not mean Ukrainian abuses should be ignored. Zelensky is not allowing Ukrainian citizens the freedom to leave the country for safety.

How is it different now?

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by _kbh_ on Friday September 30, 2022 @08:39AM (#33034048)
> CBS is America, not Russian? The history of Ukrainian political corruption predates the war from Russia.

CBS is American but this idea that the majority of weapons aren’t being in Ukraine cause they are being sold or stolen or lost _is propaganda_. Nothing supports this idea for the current phase of the war and people have generally moved on from this narrative.

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by qaq on Friday September 30, 2022 @06:40AM (#33033194)
What does limiting who can leave the country during war time have to do with corruption? The narrative of Ukraine loosing most western weapons was started by Russia and then they dropped it since UA advance was clearly showing them to be total BS.
Re:I Visited Bucha Today by nosuchthing on Friday September 30, 2022 @08:10AM (#33033804)
Zelensky gets more money the longer the war drags on. If Ukrainians are allowed freedom to exit to safety, then Zelensky and the oligarchs will not reep as much donations.

Interpol chief is Russian??

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jun/02/ukraine-weapon...

lol you have no idea what you’re talking about.

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by Anthony-G on Friday September 30, 2022 @09:16AM (#33034445)
> lol you have no idea what you’re talking about

You have added some useful links to this discussion but this is the second time you’ve undermined your own argument by laughing at the person you’re responding to. Please be aware of the Hacker News Guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

> Be kind. Don't be snarky. Have curious conversation; don't cross-examine. Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community.

Re:I Visited Bucha Today by qaq on Friday September 30, 2022 @08:15AM (#33033848)
You obviously do. Yes Ukraine should just surrender and no you are not spreading Russia propaganda
Re:I Visited Bucha Today by agapon on Friday September 30, 2022 @11:35AM (#33036284)
Note how the Interpol chief used the future tense. Why did he talk about the future with such certainty? It would be unthinkable that he was "influence" to make such claims for a certain purpose.
Re:I Visited Bucha Today by qaq on Friday September 30, 2022 @04:42AM (#33032501)
Also important to remember a portion of funds is being allocated to "trade up" soviet equipment in NATO countries to modern US variants. E.g. US gives modern US tanks to say Poland and Poland gives soviet tanks to Ukraine. Also some equipment has limited shelf life so if not used it would have being replaced in the next few years anyway.
Re:I Visited Bucha Today by justsomehnguy on Friday September 30, 2022 @07:19PM (#33041960)
Yeah, yah, these were just chronoported to Feb 28: https://www.militaryimages.net/threads/ukrainian-military.59...